Ahfkah ok now that I'm thinking about 3below and toby specifically I just remembered an old theory of mine
Back before 3below came out i hella headcannoned that if Jim was the Trollhunter and Claire could use the shadow staff (ie Wizard) then Toby probably fit in aliens.
Thinking about it, it actually kinda made sense? His parents died in a storm on a cruise they had won (x)
While it's possible, its highly unlikely. Kinda like how Krel and Aja's backstory of escaping a coup from Cantalopia is possible, but unlikely. We as the audience know that they are escaping a coup, but arent from Cantalopia. What if Toby's parents did die in a storm, but not on a cruise?
In addition, I wonder about the disguises. Stuart mentioned how his was a lower quality which resulted in his fat apperance. What if Toby was also using this antiquated technology? In the first episode Jim comments that Toby has been on a 14 year diet (and only 15 years old). Toby could simply be fat, but if someone dieted for that long maybe the reason he saw no change was because his physical form is more like a costume than a body? The same principle would apply to his teeth and explain why he has had braces for so long and expects to have them for about another decade (I wanna get these off before I'm 30 jimbo) because Toby was raised human and thinks his body will change accordingly
I no longer stand behind this head canon, but I do think there is an interesting amount of evidence to support alien!Toby










