Pairing: Eli Michaelson x f!Reader || Nobel Son
Warning: dry humping, clothed
˚₊⊹ masterlist: Cramped ✧ Tumblr | Ao3 ˚ ₊⊹
word count: 1k
"We can't fit in here together,"
"Oh, thank you for telling me. I was blissfully unaware until you said it," growled Eli as he tried to keep the lab supply cupboard's door shut. He yanked it hard until it clicked, shutting. His shoulders felt the pressure of the door against them, and he tried to roll them slightly to get more comfortable, which was hard.
Especially considering how large he was already.
He was a chemistry fellow, but physics and mathematics, although not his favourite, didn't escape him. Albeit it didn't take a genius to observe that, with you inside too, it was quite physically and mathematically impossible to fit in comfortably. Or to fit in, in general, for that matter.
"Why are you always acting like a dick? Is that really necessary?"
Eli scoffed, his hips rolling up against you. Had this been anyone else, you could've called it an accident, but this was Eli at the end of the day. Whatever he did, you'd better know it was intentional. He growled slightly, feeling the tightness of his trousers acutely frustrating as it kept him trapped. But better than nothing, right? Friction like this would at least provide him some pleasure. So he rolled his hips up into you again, managing to ride up against your butt.
Great how you got trapped in there back to him. Absolutely incredible. How you got to feel his boner squished against your butt, and his hands roughly grappling to make room to catch your hips.
"Shut it. You know I don't like it when you give me an attitude."
"You don't like anything."
"Listen to me, you cheeky girl-"
You rolled your eyes, pushing your butt back, forcing even more pressure against his boner, and he grunted. He couldn't do anything to put you in your place when this cupboard restrained you both. But to your advantage, you could always shut him up like this. Not that it didn't have repercussions. He buried his fingers into your skin roughly and pushed forward into you, his hips gaining a sort of motion that was making him twitch. Oh, he wasn't letting you come out of here without finishing off, even if it cost him the trousers. A stain was a stain, replaceable.
How will he explain it?
That was something he'd concern himself with after he made the most of this.
"I hate you,"
"You hate that you can't boss me around. I am not some stupid schoolboy. Besides, it doesn't sound or feel like you hate this. Or me."
"I do hate you,"
"Of course you do, and still you want to get that A+, don't you?"
Eli continued to grind up against your ass, his belly pressing into you from behind. There was no room, and the cupboard was starting to make some sounds that made it clear it wasn't fixed to the flooring. At least not properly. Moreover, his shoulder was pressing into the door, making it creak, so close to busting open.
Not that the door was the only one about to bust.
"Don't be like this! We both know you never get generous with scores even if I-"
"Even if you what? Go down on me? Take me like a good little slut?"
Eli taunted with a low growl against the back of your shoulder, his movements rougher. Sharper. Causing the cupboard to creak and screech. Your face pressed against one of its inside walls, and it sent a jolt through you from how cold and sterile it felt. It smelt of weird substances, and for a second your mind thought of the possibility that drugs could be snuck somewhere in here. But Eli's erection pressed into your arse snapped you back into sense.
He grunted by your ear. Eli licked the shell before he laughed mockingly. Yet the laugh was not fully amused. It was sprinkled with needy groans.
"You little slut, fuck. The things I do for you…"
"For me?"
"For you, yeah. Not my fucking idea to be trapped in here."
Eli gasped, growing closer with each rocking motion of his hips.
"Not mine either."
"You said the office bored you-"
"Because it does? A fucking hotel would've been much nicer."
"Oh, don't get greedy with me. Enjoy the change of scenery. After this, we're back in the office."
Eli gasped again, his breathing coming back shallower, his chest pressed hard into you, almost as if he was attempting to make you one with the back wall of the cupboard.
"You're not any fun…"
"I'm trying to fuck you, not make you entertained."
"You're fucking yourself more than me."
Eli snapped at that, his hand slithering angrily to your front, between your legs, shoving itself roughly forward. It slithered between your thighs and cupped your cunt impatiently before he started to blindly tease you with his ring and middle finger over your trousers.
"Come on, you little slut. You want to tease me? Fine, there you have it. See how you manage to keep standing in this fucking cupboard with your legs weak."
Eli grunted with frustration, latching onto his tone, fingers teasing you. His hips kept rocking, but this time, yours jerked too with the jolting spark of pleasure caused by his fingers. You tried to reach back and hold onto him, but the space was far too tight, and all you could do was squirm. Eli didn't let you try to break loose, humping you energetically whilst using his fingers to bring you closer to.
"Come on, wanted to cum, hm? Come on. Do it. See how you come out of here on your own two feet then."
"Stop it, Eli. Fuck, stop it."
But Eli didn't stop.
He kept going, thrusting his hips into you until he came, twitching with his orgasm, his trousers stained irretrievably. But even so, he didn't stop until he felt you come undone too. Not because he cared that much to make you feel good, but because he wanted to see how you would manage to keep yourself upright after this, all by yourself.
"I am sure you'll be grateful to use the office from now on."
"I can't stand you, cocky bastard."
"I would keep the insults for when you're spread open on my desk."
Nobel Son | Eli Michaelson/OC (unnamed, first person POV)
Summary: Eli hasn't met his match - he's always known her. But he's an idiot, and she's unstable. When will they ever make it work?
Word Count: 12.3k
AN: In a bid to help @hollyjollyzora over her League of Legends addiction, I offered to write her a fic of her choice if she could quit League for a week. She did, and promptly went back to playing it after a week, so my plan didn't work very well but I made a promise and I'm seeing it through.
I also wanted to take the chance to experiment with something different, so I wrote it in a first person perspective without mentioning the MC's name, so it's kind of a mixture of OC and reader-insert.
Warning/Content: Childhood Friends to Lovers, Pregnancy, Abortion, Cheating, Pyromania, Smut, Obsessive Behavior, Toxic Relationship, Teacher-Student Relationship, Manipulative Behaviour, Extramarital Affairs, Acid Attack, Suicidal Thoughts, Drug Addiction. The MC is just a really bad person you guys and so is Eli
Bonus Feature: Playlist
Read now on Ao3 or WattPad or under the cut:
I've known Eli Michaelson my entire life.
Our moms met in the hospital, giving birth in neighbouring beds. Eli was born on April 20th, 1946 at 3.29pm; I was born on April 20th, 1946 at 5.53pm. He always did love reminding me that he's older.
Trauma bonding during labor made our moms friends, and they would visit each other to bring us on playdates, which my mom later told me mostly involved Eli trying to steal my toys from me and crying until his mom gave in and gave him something to placate him.
That pretty much sums up how Eli's mom always treated him. If he wanted something, he screamed until he got it.
As for his dad, nothing was ever good enough for that man. Mr M was a scientist whose work had been put on hold because of the war, and he never got those glorious pre-war days back, especially once he knocked up his girlfriend and had to marry her. He was bitter, and he expected Eli to make up for his own regrets.
If you didn't know why Eli was so obsessed with winning the Nobel Prize, now you do: it was all his dad. Even after Mr M died, Eli was still determined to prove himself by winning the prize daddy had missed out on.
While Eli was being pushed into science before he could even spell it — I'm surprised he can spell it now, actually, his spelling is atrocious — I was trying my best to get myself killed. Anything stupid or dangerous, I loved it and wanted more. I guess that's what I saw in Eli.
As soon as Eli was old enough to sneak into his dad's lab, he would steal stuff from in there to create the most chaotic mixture he could for me. At first we'd "play experiments," as we called it, in the kitchen. That got too messy, so we moved into the garden. Then, when we decided to take it a step further and blow stuff up, we ended up at the park.
I couldn't tell you the amount of times I got grounded because of some stupid shit Eli and I got up to. My parents tried to ban me from hanging out with him anymore, which of course made me want to hang out with him even more, which led to sneaking out of my bedroom window to go and see him.
All this was completely innocent, by the way. We were just kids, we had no idea about sex or kissing. We knew about marriage, because that was what our parents did, but neither of us were interested in that. We just wanted to blow shit up.
We went to elementary school together, but when it came time for middle school, we got split up. Then along came high school, and he went to some smart ass high school for smart asses, and I went to normal high school for normal people.
It didn't stop us hanging out, though. As we got older, we got busier and even got other friends, so we didn't see each other as much. We always saw each other on our birthday, though, and it was on our 15th birthday that we had our first kiss.
It wasn't romantic, or sexy. It was quite bad, actually. We were both nervous — though Eli would tell you he'd never been nervous ever in his life — and it was less of a kiss than it was us awkwardly pushing our faces against each other and wondering what the hell we were supposed to do.
Still, it was a kiss, and Eli had just hit puberty a few months earlier so he was suddenly much hotter to me than he had been before, and he was growing like a beanstalk. The little chemistry nerd I'd grown up with was becoming a handsome man, and we were both overwhelmed with the new, confusing feelings that came with raging hormones.
We were seventeen when we had sex for the first time. His friend from Nerd High was having a house party, and Eli dragged me along. We got drunk and ended up making out behind a bush, which led to him fingering me behind a bush, which led to him sticking his dick in me behind a bush.
I was young and drunk and a little bit in love, and did I mention I loved doing stupid and dangerous shit? Because losing my virginity to Eli Michaelson behind a bush at some guy's house party was definitely in the top 5 stupidest and most dangerous things I'd ever done by that point. I think there was some poison ivy in that bush with us, because I had a rash on my ass for days after that.
Something changed in Eli after that. I think we all know he's a sex addict, and he'd just taken his first hit of the drug that'd be his vice for the rest of his life.
He wanted it all. the. time.
Thank God this was long before cell phones, because otherwise I would have been hit with a "u up?" text every night. He couldn't call the house phone, because my parents still didn't want me hanging out with him, so he'd climb into the back yard and throw stones at my window instead.
I'd try to tell him to go away when I was studying, but somehow my resolve was never as strong as his, and he'd end up sneaking in through my window. Looking at him now, you'd think he'd never be able to stealthily climb into a second-floor window, but the durability of the young mixed with the hormones of a teenage boy made him what the kids today might call a master of parkour.
First he'd climb onto the dumpster. Then, he'd lift himself up onto the garage roof, and finally, through my bedroom window and very quickly into my bed.
That bed was tiny, by the way. It was a single, and I was growing out of it myself, let alone trying to squeeze Eli in there, who was just a few inches off the full 6'1 he'd end up hitting. But I didn't care, because our bodies were so intertwined we hardly needed the space anyway.
Keeping quiet was the hardest part. Eli's always been vocal, and he often had to clamp his hand over his mouth to muffle his groans when he finished. Fortunately my parents were the kind of old people who needed the TV on full volume to hear anything, and still managed to fall asleep on the couch with it blaring, so I could often hear Bill Cullen's voice much clearer than Eli's, even with Eli right on top of me.
Eli's vice was sex, and mine was danger; so having sex with the risk of getting caught was addictive for both of us. Sometimes the TV would be switched off, and we knew we only had a couple of minutes at best before my parents would start coming up the stairs to go to bed. My bed was pressed up against the wall, and on the other side of that wall was the bathroom; sometimes I could literally hear my dad taking a shit, and Eli would still be inside me. I'm pretty sure the only reason we were never caught was because my parents were so very, very deaf.
If ever I found myself home alone for a few hours, I'd be straight on the phone to Eli. Well, that wasn't quite true — since we weren't supposed to be seeing each other, I couldn't call, because Mrs M always picked up. Instead, I'd call one of Eli's friends, who'd call and ask for Eli on the pretense of having some homework problem, then he'd tell Eli I was home alone. Eli would tell his parents he had to go and help a friend with homework, and then I'd relish being able to let him in through the front door, and we'd have sex on whatever surface of the house we decided we were going to taint that day.
We had our first argument when I got pregnant. "How could you let this happen?" he asked me, as if it wasn't him that had been sticking his dick in me at every possible moment. Abortions are pretty scandalous now, but they were even worse back then. My parents died years later with no idea I'd ever been pregnant, let alone what I'd done about it.
The recovery period was pretty bad for me. I was bleeding a lot, and I did my best to hide it, but I think my mom figured enough out to think that I just had a really heavy period.
Naturally, I didn't want to have sex for a few weeks. Not only was I bleeding, but I wasn't keen on going through all that again, so sex lost its appeal to me for a while.
This, apparently, was too long for Eli. He was the hottest guy in school — which wasn't hard at Nerd High — and he had a long list of girls he could turn to for a quickie in the locker room.
I found out on our 18th birthday. His parents let him throw a house party, and I snuck out to go — only to find him shamelessly sucking on some girl's face when I arrived. And somehow, I was the bad guy for making a scene at his birthday party.
I found a lot of things out that night. Not only had he been happily filling the void I left by taking a few weeks to recover from a secret abortion, but apparently, because we'd never been on a date or talked about a relationship, everything we'd done was just a bit of fun and we were never boyfriend and girlfriend.
I also discovered that the couch he'd been face-sucking on was flammable. As was the rug underneath it. Also, drunk teenagers are really bad at putting out flames before they spread.
And a few days later, I discovered that my college fund was just about enough to bail me out and to pay for the damage, so Eli's parents didn't press charges.
I graduated high school with no criminal record, no college fund and parents who were really, really mad at me. Eli, of course, had all the sympathy for being "attacked" (I threw the lighter at the couch after he'd stood up) by his "crazy ex-girlfriend" (I thought I wasn't his girlfriend?), and all his college fund could be spent on accommodation and food and partying because he was the chemistry genius daddy always wanted him to be, and he got a full scholarship.
So off Eli went to college, and I stayed back in our hometown. I got the odd job here and there, but nothing resembling a career. I couldn't stay in one place for too long. I got restless, I got bored, and whenever I was restless and bored, I was liable to destruction.
I stole from cash registers just for the thrill. I broke men's hearts because I could. And every now and then, for no discernable reason, I took the long way home and drove past Eli's house.
He never came back for the summer while he was at college. I heard from a friend of a friend that he had his own place in Stanford so he didn't bother coming back. His mom went to see him every now and then, but as far as I know, he never saw his dad again until his mom's funeral.
That was when he saw me again too. He was midway through his masters by then, fast on the way to being 'Dr Eli Michaelson'. I, meanwhile, had a success of my own to brag about: I'd managed to stay an entire year in a job without getting fired or ragequitting.
I've heard it said that people get horny after a funeral because all the talk of death makes them want to celebrate life. I don't know if that's true, but what I do know is that Eli fucking me in a janitor's closet at his mom's wake was the biggest thrill I'd felt in years.
How could I have resisted? He looked unbelievably hot in his black mourning suit, and he looked even hotter in it afterwards, when he was doing the social rounds with mourners telling him how sorry they were for his loss, and he'd thank them for their kind words, then casually slip his hand into his left pocket, where I'd watched him stuff my stolen panties just minutes earlier.
Five years later, I missed his dad's funeral because I was in jail for six months — doesn't matter why — and only found out he'd died when I got out.
My parents had no interest in trying to rein me in once I had a prison sentence behind me, so when I got released from prison with nothing to my name except the clothes on my back and a Greyhound ticket, I figured I'd find somewhere new — but I had no idea where to go.
I was at the bus station, looking at the destinations on offer. I was seriously considering Vegas, figuring I could find work there easily, until a college kid walked past me with a Stanford sweater on, and suddenly I knew where I was heading.
What I was actually gonna do when I got there, I had no idea. All I knew was that fate was drawing me to Stanford. The last I'd heard of Eli, he had his doctorate and had gone from postdoc to assistant professor, and he was still thriving at Stanford.
The funny thing about college campuses in the 70s? No security whatsoever. You can just walk in. I don't know why students spend thousands on enrolling when they can just walk into class any time they like. Any rando can just get off the bus, walk over to campus, follow the signs to the chemistry department, and find the door that says 'Dr Eli Michaelson, PhD, Assistant Professor of Chemistry'.
I must have looked a mess. There are hardly any mirrors in jail, and there are none on Greyhounds, so I had no idea how I looked, but I must have been recognisable because Eli looked as if he'd seen a ghost when he looked up from grading papers to see, not a student walking in, but the crazy ex-girlfriend who'd set fire to his couch all those years ago.
"I thought you were in jail," was the first thing the love of my life said to me after several years apart.
"Got let out. How'd you know? Been keeping tabs on me?"
"Gossip spreads fast. What're you doing here?"
I put my hands in my pockets and shrugged. "They gave me a bus ticket. Can't go home, mom and dad don't want anything to do with me, can you believe that? So I… came here."
Eli sat back in his chair and smirked. "Nowhere else to go but to me, huh?"
"I dunno. I guess."
I looked around the room curiously. It was full of Eli. Framed photos showed him shaking hands with people I figure must have been important. His doctorate certificate hung proudly on the wall directly behind him, so if someone sat across from him, they couldn't miss it.
"Doctor Eli Michaelson," I read out as I looked up at the certificate. "I always knew you'd get there. You always get what you want."
"That I do."
Eli grabbed me by the waist and, before I even realised what was happening, he had me sat side-saddle on his lap.
"Y'know, it's funny… I was just thinking about you last night."
My heart leapt at that.
"Oh yeah? What was I doing in your thoughts?"
"Taking your clothes off, mostly — and here you are."
He flexed his fingers over my thigh, as if trying to resist grabbing me.
"You expect me to get my kit off for you here?"
"You'll get your kit off for me anywhere."
He had me there. And he took me there too, right on top of the papers he was grading. Some poor sap was gonna get their paper back all crumpled up, and they'd have no idea why.
If he didn't have to go and teach a class, Eli might have fucked me on that desk all day. But alas, obligations called, and Eli left me with an address, the key to his front door, cash for a cab and a burning between my thighs that couldn't be satiated.
I had some hours to kill at his place before he came back, and said place was a mess — clearly he didn't have a girlfriend, because no woman in her right mind would let a man live like this. There were pizza boxes strewn about, expired milk in the fridge, and stains on the couch I suspected weren't from anything edible.
I did my best to clean some of it up, if not for his sake then for mine — something smelled funky, and I couldn't just sit there for hours breathing it in. By the time he came back, it was semi-habitable, and I managed to forget about the weird smell pervading the air as soon as Eli stuck his hand down my pants.
It must have been past 10pm by the time Eli lit up a cigarette, one arm around my shoulders as I held him, resting my head on his soft body and savouring the feeling of finally holding him like this again after so long.
"So what's your plan?" Eli asked casually after taking a long drag of his cigarette.
"Don't have one," I mumbled against his belly. "Never did. Probably never will. Can I crash here for a bit? Just 'til I can get a job and get my own place."
"You keep riding my dick like that, sweetheart, you can stay as long as you like."
I looked up at him, eyes wide. "Wait, for real? You want me stay?"
Eli shrugged. "Sure, why not?"
I grinned, and Eli reckons I squealed like an excited teenage girl, but that's not how I remember it. We definitely both agree that I kissed him all over, and the cigarette ended up discarded in an ashtray so Eli could give me his undivided attention.
The two years that followed were, and still are, the greatest period of my life. Because I didn't have to pay rent, I didn't have to work much — just a few hours a week, enough to not be reliant on Eli for day-to-day living — and I even managed to hold down one job the entire time.
I transformed Eli's hazardous bachelor pad into a habitable living space, and I always made sure there was food waiting on the table when he got home. I loved waking up next to him in the morning, and obviously I loved having sex with him at night, but by far the best moment of every day was when he'd come home from college, often grumbling about how freshmen seemed to be getting dumber every year, and his face would light up when I greeted him with a kiss and a plate of hot, delicious food.
I didn't even know how to cook properly before then, but for Eli I learned, and by the time Thanksgiving came around, I was confident enough that I cooked Thanksgiving dinner for the two of us, and Eli must have been satisfied because he unbuckled his belt and burped loudly, which always meant that he'd had a good meal.
It wasn't all sunshine and rainbows, of course. We had a few arguments. One time I saw that he'd packed a suitcase, and I got upset because I thought he was trying to get away from me, but it turned out he was just going to some chemistry conference.
When I got pregnant again, we argued again, because this time I wanted to keep it, but Eli refused — he wasn't ready to have a kid, he wouldn't have the time, he couldn't afford it, and he wanted to spare me the shame of having a kid outside marriage. "Why don't we just get married then?" I suggested, but Eli didn't want to ever get married, though he promised that if he had to marry someone, it would be me.
So to the clinic I went, and while I was there the doctor suggested I start taking birth control so I didn't get pregnant by surprise again. The pill was a fairly new thing back then, and I've never really paid attention to the news so I didn't even know about it. A tiny pill I could take every day and never get pregnant, and if I wanted to get pregnant I could just stop taking it? It seemed like a miracle, and I jumped at the chance.
All good things come to an end, and in 1979, we had our biggest argument yet. While looking through Eli's drawers — doesn't matter why — I found a checkbook that was nearly at its end. I flicked through the stubs and saw the same name, the same amount, over and over again. Glynnis James. Who the fuck was Glynnis James?
It took a lot of interrogating for me to find out, but eventually Eli caved: Glynnis James was the wife of his best friend, Harriman James. (I thought I was his best friend, but okay.) Five years earlier, he'd killed himself while she was pregnant, leaving her penniless. Eli, apparently, had been helping her out financially since then.
I wanted to believe him, but it didn't make sense. He'd convinced me to have an abortion because he didn't have the money to raise a kid, and yet he was sending checks to his dead second best friend's wife — what, out of the goodness of his heart?
Yeah, no. I wasn't having it. Anyone who knows Eli knows he would never do something like that out of the goodness of his own heart. He's the tightest asshole known to man, why would he send maintenance checks for some kid that wasn't even his?
And that was when it clicked. He was sending maintenance checks because the kid was his!
Needless to say, I was pissed. I'd had two abortions for him, and yet when he knocked up his second best friend's wife, he apparently had no problem with her carrying the kid to term.
I don't remember much of what happened after that. I do remember Eli calling me a "psycho" — how could I not remember that? You'd remember it too if the love of your life looked at you with nothing but fear and hate in his eyes and called you every variant of "crazy" he could think of. I was angry at him for a long time after that, but I forgave him eventually — I guess I can see how he would think it was my fault, given past experience and that he found me right outside Glynnis James' house as it burned down. But I still don't remember doing anything that would result in a fire — the last thing I remember is realising he had a kid, and the next thing I knew, I was standing on the side of some street I'd never been to before, watching a house burn down.
I couldn't stand to be near him after that. It was too confusing. I was angry at him for what he'd said to me, and I was kind of embarassed too. It sure looked like the fire was my fault, and I'd clearly found her address and gone to her house. So naturally I did the healthy thing and moved 3,000 miles away.
I just about managed to hitch-hike my way to New York without getting murdered or raped, and I settled in to my new life as a bum on the streets of New York City.
I actually really loved New York. It was loud and messy and chaotic, just like me. Drugs were ridiculously easy to come across. I worked for a while at a music bar, partly because the loud music was soothing to me, but honestly also because the guy who ran it kind of looked like Eli. Plus he was married, and I always loved ruining marriages, but he wasn't interested and I hate the chase — it's hard to break a man's heart when he's not that invested — so I quit and definitely wasn't fired for shooting up in the kitchen.
It's a blur after that, and honestly, we're not here to talk about the darkest period of my life, so let's skip forward to the next time I saw Eli.
Protip: if you ever find yourself a homeless drug addict, don't bother abiding by the law. Cops just move you on, or maybe throw you in a cell for the night. But as soon as you commit a crime and end up in prison, suddenly you've got tax dollars paying for therapy and a roof over your head, and you're forced into rehabilitation by going cold turkey.
I was three years into my sentence when a guard told me I had a visitor. I thought she must have been joking at first, because I hadn't seen my parents since my last stint in prison, and I'd lost touch with anyone I could call a friend years ago.
Imagine my surprise when I walked into the visiting room and saw him.
"You look tired," I said as I sat down, and it was true. There were dark circles under his eyes, and though he'd shaved his moustache, he had a shadow of stubble around his jaw that I had a very strong urge to shove between my legs.
"You look like shit," Eli replied, and it was probably true too. Again, prison, very few mirrors, and the commissary didn't offer a very wide variety of beauty products.
"How'd you find me?"
"I can always find you," Eli said mysteriously, and I decided to let it remain mysterious — I didn't want to ruin the image in my mind of Eli dedicating the last seven years to finding the only woman he'd ever loved.
His hands were folded over each other on the table. I glanced down, trying to resist taking his hands in mine — and I saw a glitter of gold.
I frowned.
"What the fuck is that?"
Eli quickly pulled his hands back and placed them on his lap.
"Nothing."
"Fuck off was that nothing. Was that a wedding ring?"
Eli didn't answer, which told me everything.
"Whatever happened to 'I don't wanna get married'? What happened to 'If I had to marry someone, it'd be you'?"
"That was before you tried to kill my son."
"I did not try to kill your son!" I protested a little too loud, eliciting nervous glances from other tables, and a nearby guard straightened up, paying close attention to me.
I threw my hands up and sat back to show I wasn't about to jump across the table and strangle him, as much as I wanted to.
"Why are you here, Eli?"
"Because someone had to tell you that your dad died."
Surprised? Yes. Sad? Not really.
"And it had to be you, did it?"
"Your mom's in a home, and I don't think anyone else gives a shit about you, to be honest."
My heart leapt then.
"So you do still give a shit about me."
Eli sighed. "Dammit, why do you have to be…"
"Gorgeous? Funny? Witty?"
"Why, out of all the women I've fucked, do you have to be the one I can't get out of my damn mind?"
I blinked, taken aback. "What's that supposed to mean?"
"It means," Eli hissed, "you're the only one who's thrown a lighter at me. The only one who burned down a house with my son inside. And still you're the only one I've ever given a shit about. Why? Am I cursed? Do you have some kind of spell on me that makes me fucking obsessed with you?"
My heart felt like it was about to burst out of my chest. He loved me! He loved me just as much as I loved him! Obsessed, he said. He was obsessed with me, he couldn't stop thinking about me, he probably thought about me when he was fucking his wife!
"You know exactly why, Eli," I grinned. "Same reason I'm obssessed with you. We're meant to be together. We were even born together! Which does beg the question of why the hell you married someone else when you made it pretty clear you didn't wanna get married, and if you ever did, it'd be to me."
Eli folded his arms defensively, glancing aside.
"It was… the right thing to do."
I stared at him.
"I'm sorry, what? Since when do you care about doing the right thing?"
"I got her pregnant, okay?" Eli hissed. "I knocked her up, her parents are old-fashioned, so I had to marry her."
I kept staring at him. Eli glanced at me nervously, probably wondering if I was about to set something on fire again.
"You got her pregnant."
"That's what I said, ain't it?"
"What, you hit your lifetime limit on abortions or something?"
"Don't be ridiculous —"
"No, shut up. Why is it, every time I get pregnant, I have to have an abortion, but if it's anyone else, she either gets a lifetime of maintenance checks or a fucking ring on her finger?"
"It's not like that!" Eli insisted. "Glynnis wanted to keep it, I couldn't exactly drag her down the clinic, and Sarah's dad already knew —"
"I wanted to keep it! I wanted to keep our baby! But you didn't, and I respected that, so I got rid of it. How fucking ironic, huh? I love you enough to have an abortion for you, twice, and the bitches who don't love you get to keep theirs!"
"Hey!" shouted one of the prison guards, striding towards our table with her hand on her taser. I glanced around, realising suddenly that I was standing up. When had I stood up?
I threw my hands in the air innocently. "It's alright, I'm not gonna do anything."
"Yeah, she doesn't have a lighter," Eli scoffed.
My fist was hardly in the air before the guard was grabbing me by both arms to restrain me.
"I was right about you," Eli sneered as he stood up to leave. "You're a fucking psycho. You really think I'd wanna marry you?"
I had no words to describe how I felt in that moment, so instead I just screamed, and as the guard dragged me out of the visitation room, all I saw was the love of my life walking out the other door, back to his white pickett fence with his wife and his child and the life that would never be mine.
Two years later, I was out. I once again found myself with nothing but a Greyhound ticket and the clothes on my back, but this time, there really was nowhere for me to go. Mom had died, and that cow had left all her worldly belongings to some stupid charity for stupid kids with stupid behavioural problems. That was her to a tee — she'd walk to the ends of the earth to fix someone else's broken kid before she even glanced at her own.
And then there was Eli. I desperately wanted to go and find him. Every part of me, my mind, my body, my soul, it yearned for him. I wanted to go back to the way it used to be, when we were just kids playing experiments in the park.
But that part of my life was over. We'd never be kids again, and we'd never be what we were. And as much as I wanted to find him, to prove to him that I was the one he was meant to be with, I remembered what the prison therapist told me.
Retribution may feel good in the moment, but it doesn't solve the problem. Real solutions are hard, and they take a long time, but their impact lasts longer than any short-term solution ever could.
I knew, if I wanted to win Eli back, it would take time. I had to make him see that his life and mine were so interconnected that resistance would be futile, so he would eventually give in to fate and accept that we were meant to be together.
I used my bus ticket to get as far away from New York as possible. I ended up in Colorado, found a shelter to stay at, and got a job in a strip club. Yeah, not classy, I know, but it paid well, and I managed to get my own place eventually. Well, I say my own place, it was a shared house, but at least it wasn't a homeless shelter.
Every month, I went to the store and bought the latest copies of every science-related magazine I could get my hands on. I pored through every one of them, trying to find any hint of Eli in the pages. Where was he? What was he doing? Was he still married? Perhaps unsurprisingly, the science magazines didn't have gossip columns, so I didn't get much, though I did see the occasional mention of Stanford.
Eventually, I saw his name — he'd written an article for Chemistry Monthly. I read that article over and over again, desperate for any part of him I could find between the lines.
He wrote more, and I read them all, and somewhere along the way, I started actually reading the other articles too. Most of them didn't make any sense to me, but I wanted them to, and that was how I ended up enrolled in community college.
In my fourth year, we were encouraged to take trips out to visit colleges we might want to apply for to do a bachelor's. And just to prove me right about fate, my chemistry course arranged a trip to California to visit Stanford.
It was 1991 by that point. Seven years since I'd last seen Eli walking out on me, and seven years since he'd last seen me freaking out about him marrying the wrong person.
Over time, I hadn't forgotten about him, but I had other stuff going on. Community college helped me focus my mind, and it was chaotic enough to keep me distracted. I got free therapy from the psych students, and those that couldn't handle me learned pretty quick that they weren't cut out for the field. I avoided drugs — mostly — and didn't set a single fire (small accidental chemical fires do not count).
All in all, I was feeling pretty well-rounded. I was a far cry from the "psycho" Eli had labelled me seven years ago.
And when I saw him again, it was like everything fell into place.
He had volunteered — or been volunteered — to give a short talk to the visitors from the Colorado community college about studying at Stanford. We gathered in a lecture hall, and he sauntered in with all the arrogance and swagger that I'd always adored in him. He knew how to play to a crowd, and his charming smile and witty remarks had everyone hooked and sold on applying to Stanford.
Then he saw me, and he froze in his tracks.
I honestly wasn't trying to be seen. I wanted to talk to him afterwards. I was at the back of the group, wearing a baggy hoodie, hoping to keep a low profile. But just as Eli had said to me nine years ago, he could always find me, and he found me. He was talking about demanding engagement in his classes, and to prove his point he came around the back of the group and targeted me, pulling down my hood as he spoke.
He stopped mid-sentence. His face changed quickly from a witty smile to wide-eyed shock as he stared at me, and probably every person there wondered why the hell Dr Eli Michaelson was staring at me like he'd just seen a ghost.
He cleared his throat, turned away, and sped through the rest of his talk to quickly dismiss us.
As my group began to talk amongst themselves as they got ready to go to the next part of the tour, I tried to speak to Eli, but he was already out the door.
I followed him. For half a moment, I considered not following him, but then I shook that stupid thought away and followed him.
A few steps down the hallway, I was suddenly grabbed by the elbow and pulled into what turned out to be a janitor's closet.
"What the fuck are you doing here?!" Eli hissed once he'd closed the door behind him.
"College tour. Nice to see you too."
"And what the fuck is this?"
Eli grabbed at my hoodie.
"If you're gonna show up out of the blue, at least do me the courtesy of letting me see you properly."
He pulled the hoodie over my head, and groaned when he saw the V-neck t-shirt I was wearing underneath.
"Fuck," was all he had to say before he was kissing me with wet, open-mouth kisses, hands grasping at my chest like a starving man whose only sustainance was me.
It wasn't the greeting I was expecting, but it was exactly what I wanted.
He fucked me against the wall, one leg wrapped around his waist, and he came inside me with a long groan after less than a minute.
"Sorry that was quick," Eli mumbled in my ear as he came down from his high, nuzzling his nose in my hair as he released his grip on the leg around his waist. "I really, really needed that."
"Your wife not putting out any more?"
Eli shook his head as he pulled out of me and took a step back. "You don't know the half of it." He reached for some blue roll from the janitor's supplies and tore some off to wipe me down between my thighs, where his seed was already overflowing down my leg. "I haven't had sex in six months. You know what that does to a man? She's always busy, or tired, or not in the mood, or Barkley's still awake and he'll hear, or all of the above. And whenever I get frustrated… you appear. In my head, in my dreams. Haunting me. Just last week, I was thinking about tracking you down… and here you tracked me down. Community college, huh?"
"Yep."
"In Colorado?"
"Furthest I could get from New York without bumping into you."
"Yet here you are."
Eli screwed up the blue roll that was now soaked in jizz and shoved it in his jacket pocket.
"My chem class were taking a trip to Stanford. How could I resist?"
Eli looked at me curiously. "You're taking chemistry?"
"Surprised? You know I love blowing shit up."
"You always were the most unstable molecule in my life."
I laughed. "What?"
Eli shook his head. "Nothing. How long you in town for?"
"We're at a hotel tonight, then we're on the bus back tomorrow."
"Fuck that. Sarah's out of town on conference. You're staying with me."
I stayed all weekend. He palmed the kid off with his grandparents — "they made me keep him, they can damn well have him" — and we had the place to ourselves for three glorious nights.
"I'm glad you're doing okay," Eli murmured against the top of my head. He was sitting up on the bed, back propped up against the pillows, and I was sat in front of him between his legs, leaning back against him while we watched some trash on TV that I wasn't really paying attention to.
"Awh, were you worried?"
"Course I was. Can you blame me?"
I shrugged. "Most people don't give a shit about me."
"Yeah, well, I ain't most people, sweetheart. I give a shit about you more than anyone."
"Don't let your wife hear you say that."
Eli leant his head back against the headboard with a sigh.
"I wanted to marry you, you know."
"Then why didn't you?"
"Kinetic persistence."
I laughed. "The chemistry metaphors aren't sexy, you know."
"Yes, they are."
I laughed and turned around in his lap to face him.
"Go on, then. Explain how kinetic persistence stopped you marrying me."
Eli pushed a stray hair behind my ear and smiled with a mixture of adoration and amusement.
"You could never overcome the high energy barrier to transition to a more stable state."
"…You mean I was too crazy and you expect a wife to be stable?"
"Something like that."
"And that's what Sarah is? Stable?"
"Mostly. She has her moments."
"Not a psycho, then."
"…No. Not a psycho." He kissed me on the forehead. "And neither are you. Who can blame you for being obsessed with me, huh? I'd be obsessed with me too."
"Pfft. You are obsessed with you."
Eli grinned cheekily, and seeing him smile again, seeing him happy because of me, it reminded me of why I could never shake him.
"Eli… I can't live without you. My life has been nothing but chaos, and the only time it makes sense is when I'm with you. You can't tell me you don't feel the same."
"Sweetheart, if I'm the order in your life, I hate to think what the rest has been like, because you're nothing but the chaos in mine. When you're not around, life is…"
"Boring?"
Eli laughed. "Yeah. Yeah, it's boring in comparison. I'm always trying to find a way to fill the you-shaped hole."
"Well, maybe… maybe there doesn't need to be a me-shaped hole. How would you feel if I came to Stanford?"
"You come to Stanford? You'd have to get in first."
I frowned. "Hey!"
"No offence, sweetheart. There's a big difference between Colorado community college and Stanford U."
"Earlier you were telling us we could all get in!"
"Yeah, 'cus that's what the Dean told me to say. Look, prove me wrong, please. I'd love to see you get in. Having you there on campus whenever I need a good fuck?" He squeezed my thigh and bit his lip with restraint. "Fuck. What I wouldn't do to have you there on Monday."
"I'll get in," I promised him, and I meant it. "I'll do whatever it takes. Suck whoever's dick I have to —"
"No you will not, unless it's mine."
"I'll get in. I promise you. We can be together, Eli, just like we were always meant to be."
Eli was right. The admissions process was brutal. And the worst of it was, I did get offered a place — but at full tuition. I wasn't good enough for any scholarships, so they'd let me in only if I had $25,000 a year to spare. Believe it or not, as an ex-con turned stripper turned community college student whose inheritance got handed over to some charity, I did not in fact have $25,000 a year.
When I told Eli, I thought he'd be disappointed, and he was — disappointed that he'd be down the best part of 100k over the next few years.
He loved me. He wanted me around. No matter what anyone else might say to me later, my belief in that truth was unwaverable, because Eli doesn't like spending money on anyone, not even his own kid, and yet he didn't even hesitate to cover my tuition.
The catch? Private "tuition" with him three times a week. And by tuition, I mean fucking. And by private, I mean on every spot on campus we possibly could without getting caught, although we lived dangerously close to the edge sometimes.
I wasn't actually taking any of Eli's classes, which was a good thing really, because we would have both distracted each other, and Eli really did take his work seriously. And believe it or not, I took mine seriously too.
That worked in our favour, actually. I was interested in chemistry, I told my roommates, but didn't have room for any chem classes in my curriculum, so I was paying Dr Michaelson for some private tuition. Nobody knew that he was paying my actual tuition, nor that the "tuition" I had with him was in fact just us fucking our way around campus.
It still shocks me to this day that his wife believed his story that he was privately tutoring someone, and I think even Eli was surprised when she suggested he invite me over for Thanksgiving dinner when he apparently mentioned that I didn't have any family to spend the holiday with.
"That is a bad idea, Eli," I said when he suggested it while he was tucking his dick back inside his pants.
"Yeah, believe me, I know. But I got no excuse."
"Eli. I know I have no morals, and neither do you."
He looked at me expectantly.
"But there is no way I am sneaking off to fuck you at Thanksgiving dinner when your ten year old son is at the table."
"Hey, I never suggested sneaking off to fuck!" Eli protested, throwing his hands up innocently, though I'm pretty sure that was exactly what he was envisioning.
"I'm serious, Eli. That's where I draw the line."
Eli sat up in his chair, looking at me with a frown while I tried to find where I'd thrown my t-shirt earlier.
"Let me get this straight. You'll burn down a house with a kid inside, but if Barkley might hear some adult noises, that's where you draw the line?"
I stood up straight, frowning at him furiously.
"I never burnt down a house with a kid inside!"
"Glynnis would disagree."
"Glynnis can go fuck herself. How is your illegitimate son, by the way?"
"Spectacular. Gone to college in Ohio, I think. Or was it Wisconsin? Somewhere ordinary. Your shirt's on Jake, by the way."
"Jake" was the bust of Jacobus Henricus van't Hoff that watched over the office from the far corner. Apparently in life he was the first person to win the Nobel Prize in Chemistry, and now as a bust he was relegated to watching Eli fuck me over his desk. It must have been a relief for him when my discarded t-shirt landed over his head, because at least he didn't have to watch this time.
"I would really like it if you came to Thanksgiving dinner," Eli said as I retrieved my t-shirt back from Jake.
I turned back to him, surprised at how serious he sounded.
"How much does Sarah know about me?"
"She knows we grew up together. She knows you had a rough time of it and you're only just starting college now."
"A rough time of it, huh?"
Eli shrugged. "Not my place to tell her any more. She didn't push."
"She doesn't know about the fires?"
"Nope."
"Does she know about Theodore?"
"Thaddeus. No."
"She doesn't know you already have a kid?"
"Nope."
"Where does she think those maintenance checks go?"
"She doesn't see them, I have my own account."
"Of course you do. How does your wife know nothing about you?"
"She knows what she needs to know."
"Sounds like I know you better than she does."
"You know me better than anyone does."
My heart leapt, and I smiled.
"Damn right I do. Okay, fine, I'll come to Thanksgiving. I'll even make mac and cheese."
Eli groaned as if he'd jizzed his pants at just the thought of mac and cheese.
"God, your mac and cheese. Please."
I'm embarassed to say how long I spent choosing what to wear to Thanksgiving, so I won't. All that matters is I looked damn good in a black ankle-length skirt and a purple V-neck sweater, just sexy enough to show up Eli's wife without being inappropriate for a family dinner.
Eli opened the door, and his eyes lit up when he saw me — or maybe it was when he saw the massive tub of mac and cheese in my hands.
I had to resist kissing him hello, keeping a respectful distance as he showed me in and introduced me to his wife.
I'll admit she was pretty. She had curly brown hair and a heavy side parting, and I don't remember what she was wearing but it was probably plain and boring. She was nice, too, I suppose. Okay, fine, I'll admit she made a good first impression. There wasn't much I could judge her for at the time.
She definitely didn't seem to suspect anything. She tried to call Barkley down to come and say hello, but got no response.
"Probably playing with his Lego again," Eli said with a roll of his eyes. "I swear, that boy spends more time playing with those damn bricks than he does on his homework."
"He's ten, Eli, he should be spending more time on Lego than homework," Sarah contradicted him. "Why don't you go upstairs and say hello?"
"He won't be very talkative," Eli warned me as he led me up the stairs. "When he's playing with those bricks, the rest of the world doesn't exist."
He opened his son's bedroom door without knocking. "Barkley! Put those things down and come and say hello."
"Hello," Barkley mumbled, hardly raising his eyes from the Lego set he was laser focused on.
Deciding to take matters into my own hands, I knelt down opposite Barkley and introduced myself.
"Oh, wow, is that Lego?" I gasped, pretending I'd never seen Lego before.
"Uh-huh," Barkley replied poetically.
"That's so cool! I always wanted Lego but my dad never let me have any. You think you could spare a couple bricks so I could give it a try?"
"I'm making the Enterprise," Barkley told me. "You can make this one."
He reached under his bed and pulled out another Lego set for the Millennium Falcon from Star Wars. Barkley really liked spaceships, apparently.
"Wow, thanks, Barkley! That's so nice of you. Hey, but this one's still sealed. You don't wanna open it?"
"It's okay, you can open it."
As I opened the box, I glanced up at Eli. He was leaning against the doorframe, his arms folded, watching me with an amused smirk.
"Having fun?"
"I got Lego, of course I'm having fun. By the end of the day, Barkley's gonna have a whole fleet of starships, then he can send them all to attack Dad when he's grumpy."
Barkley laughed. "Dad's always grumpy."
"Is he now?" Eli said with a raised eyebrow.
"He's always grumpy at college, you're saying he's grumpy at home too?" I said to Barkley, ignoring Eli for the moment.
"Uh-huh."
"Maybe if he had more Lego, he'd be less grumpy."
"Dad doesn't wanna play with Lego. He says it's a stupid toy."
Just then, Sarah called up the stairs for Barkley to come and help her set the table. Barkley jumped up, completely disregarding his precious spaceship, and practically ran down to help his mom.
"Wow, he hardly looks at you, but Mom calls and he goes running."
Eli shrugged. "Whatever. One of us has to be the bad guy, and she coddles him too much."
He put his hand out to help me to my feet, and as soon as I was standing, he pulled me close and wrapped an arm around my waist.
"Eli —"
"What?" he murmured, his breath hot on my ear. "They're busy setting the table. Go on, just a quick kiss."
What can I say? I've never been able to say no to him. If he'd asked me for a blowjob right there and then, I'd probably have given it to him.
He pushed me up against the wall, hands grabbing at my ass as he ate my face. I knew something like this might happen, so I hadn't worn any makeup in case it got smeared on his face and gave us away.
"Eli —" I gasped when he started kissing my neck.
He grunted in response.
"You wanna go to dinner with a hard-on?"
"What I want is to fuck you, right here and right now," Eli growled. "I wanna fuck you on every surface of this house, 'til I can't move without looking at something I fucked you on." He took my earlobe between his teeth and tugged, which he knew drove me crazy — then let me go and stepped back.
"Another day," he said casually, as if it were no big deal.
I glanced down at his pants. It wasn't glaringly obvious, but if you looked for it, you'd see the proof of his arousal, and I relished the idea of him trying to hide it from Sarah.
"It'll go soon enough," Eli shrugged, fully aware of where I was looking. "I just need to look at Sarah and it'll deflate."
Maybe any other day, but today I was there, and I was determined to make him suffer through dinner.
We sat two by two at the table. I was next to Barkley and opposite Eli, which was ideal, because it meant I could stretch my leg out and brush my foot against Eli's leg without anyone noticing. He pretended he didn't notice either, but I saw his jaw tighten, and I wriggled my toes under the hem of his pants to brush against his bare skin while forcing myself to engage Sarah in conversation about her work just for the thrill of having her attention on me while I was playing footsie with her husband under the table.
I wasn't going to drink more than a glass or two of wine, as I had to drive home, but Eli altruistically offered to drive me home instead so I could have a couple more drinks. Sarah seemed surprised at the generous offer, but still her suspicion levels were low. Dumbass.
I'd made as much mac and cheese as I physically could to account for Eli's appetite, and still he made sure there was none left by the end of the night, leaving me with an empty tub to take home. I was just saying my polite goodbyes to Sarah when Barkley came running down the stairs, raced up to me and silently handed me a box.
"Oh, Barkley, I don't need to keep that!" I said, realising he was handing me the Millennium Falcon I'd hardly made a start on. "That's yours, sweetie."
Barkley shook his head and pushed it towards me insistently. I didn't really care for Lego or starships, but I wanted the kid to like me, so I took it grratefully with the thought of returning it after a few days on the pretense I'd finished it.
I placed the empty tub and the Lego box on the rear seat of Eli's car and got into the passenger seat. We sat chastely side-by-side until Eli pulled up to an empty parking lot behind an abandoned mall, and the engine was hardly off before I was climbing over the gears and bunching my skirt up to straddle his lap.
That was the start of our ten-year affair. I became a regular visitor to the Michaelson household and often babysat for Barkley, which started off as playing Lego with him and putting him to bed, and as he became a teenager it mostly became sitting downstairs working on my coursework while he locked himself in his room to play video games and telling Eli and Sarah that he'd gone to bed at 11 o'clock even when I'd let him stay up late.
They had dinner parties often too, and I was invited to those — the busier the better, because Eli and I could sneak off for a quickie while Sarah was distracted by entertaining the guests. We could hear people's chatter and laughter downstairs, sometimes spilling out into the garden too, and Eli would clamp his hand over my mouth to keep me quiet while he fucked me on his wife's dresser.
I graduated in 1996 and got a job in Sacramento. It was about two hours away, which seriously limited how often I could see Eli, but when you graduate from college at the age of 50 and have a criminal record, you can't afford to be picky with graduate jobs.
Just outside of Sacramento, the University of California had a campus for its science department — and Eli, altruistic as he was, began volunteering there twice a month, teaching chemistry at the weekends to less fortunate students.
At least, that was what he told Sarah. What he was actually doing was railing me the whole weekend.
You might think, now that we were in our 50s, our appetites for each other would calm down. You would be wrong.
Don't get me wrong; it wasn't all sex. Sometimes we even went out on dates. This was before social media, of course, so it wasn't likely that we'd be recognised — still, it was a possibility, and that was enough to keep the thrill going.
I still visited them sometimes. Barkley stopped needing a babysitter at age 14, but there were still the dinner parties, and I was invited to family events like Barkley's graduation and, in 2002, Barkley's wedding.
Some people will tell you that I cried at Barkley's wedding. Those people are liars. He got married outside in the summer and I have allergies, okay? I coincidentally got hit by a particularly strong gust of wind carrying a lot of pollen at the exact same moment that I looked at the seating chart and saw that Barkley had put me up at the head table next to Eli and Sarah because I had been, he said in his speech, just as much of a parent to him as they were since he was ten years old.
Bullshit, if you ask me. I was his babysitter. All I did was look after him and put him to bed and encourage his interests and help him with his homework and — okay, I see it now. I did more for him than Eli did. Just because I'm in love with Eli, it doesn't mean I don't see his flaws, and I know he was a disinterested father at best and a mean one at worst.
I wish Barkley had warned me he was gonna say that, because now I felt kinda guilty. He saw me as part of the family, he thought I was nice to him because I cared. What would that do to him when he eventually found out I'd only been nice to him because I wanted his dad to leave his mom for me?
Eli kept promising me it would happen. First he wanted to wait until Barkley had grown up, then he wanted to wait until Barkley had finished college. Divorce was expensive, and he couldn't afford both Barkley's tuiton and lawyer fees.
I believed him. Like an idiot, I believed him.
In October 2002, Sarah was away at a conference and Barkley had moved out to live with his wife. I was planning to visit Eli for the weekend, driving down after work on Friday. Instead, I took the day off and drove down on Friday morning to surprise him on campus.
I knew he didn't have classes on Friday mornings. I expected him to be in his office, and he was. With his pants around his ankles. Balls-deep inside some bitch not much older than his son.
They were so preoccupied, they didn't even notice me opening the door and closing it again.
I just stood there, my world spinning. I could still hear them. The desk was rattling, the same desk he'd fucked me on three times a week when I was a student.
How many times a week had he fucked a student on it after I graduated?
I could hear his voice through the door.
"Yeah, that's it. Fucking take it. Take your professor's cock. You want an A, huh? You want it bad?"
"Yes, Dr Michaelson, please, I want it bad, I want it so, so bad!"
"You know the rules. You get an A when you take my cum."
"I'll take it! I'll take your cum, sir, please! Cum inside me, sir, please…"
"I'll fucking fill you up… ugh, you're so fucking hot… fuck!"
As if the muffled sound of his orgasm was what I'd been waiting for, I turned and left.
There are no gaps in my memory this time. I know exactly what I did.
It was almost too easy. I only had to wait outside for her to come out, legs wobbling and hair a mess, and follow her to her car.
I didn't know a lot about chemistry. But I knew enough to know where Eli kept the sulphuric acid in his lab.
I wasn't aiming for her face, honestly. I was aiming for her car. But then she turned around, and her face got in the way.
I ran back into the building before her screams could attract anyone's attention. The parking lot was far enough away from Eli's office that I couldn't hear her screams anymore once I reached his door, and he was glad to see me when I walked in.
When he heard the news, he must have suspected me. Acid wasn't that far off fire, and I would have had a motive… if I knew about her. But I didn't, as far as he knew.
I parked on the street and came in through the back entrance, I told him (true). I hadn't been anywhere near the parking lot that day (false).
Completely separately, I swore, I decided I wanted to end the affair. Either file divorce papers tomorrow, or it was over.
It was over.
I relapsed pretty quickly after that. I almost lost my job because I went on a bender, and it was sheer luck and a lot of begging that kept me hanging on by a thread when I came to my senses.
I kept in touch with Barkley. When his wife filed for divorce, I let him crash on my couch in Sacramento for a while until Sarah convinced Eli to let him move back home.
Barkley told me Meredith had left him because he couldn't get it up. The problem must have been with her, because he had no problem getting it up for me, although it was much smaller than his dad's.
Oh, don't acted so shocked. He needed a rebound and I was still pissed at Eli. What's a little revenge pity fuck between friends?
I guess he was embarassed about what had happened, because we didn't keep in touch anymore after that.
The next time I saw Eli's stupid smug face, it was splashed across the front cover of Chemistry Monthly. I didn't subscribe to it anymore, but I saw it on the shelf at the store, and I got jumpscared by Eli's face appearing announcing he'd won the Nobel Prize for Chemistry.
I didn't believe for a second he'd really done whatever he'd apparently done to win the Nobel. How could he possibly have time for all that work between fucking every pretty student that enrolled in his class?
The next time I saw his stupid face was on TV. He was on the news, looking uncharacteristically sad. I stopped channel surfing for a moment out of curiosity.
Barkley had been kidnapped.
Barkley? Kidnapped? Why on earth would anybody want to kidnap Barkley? He didn't have any money. Eli had some, but nothing worth kidnapping over. Unless he'd recently come into —
Then it clicked. The Nobel Prize. Didn't it also come with some huge cash prize? That must have been what the kidnapper was after.
"Well, Barkley's dead," I said to my cat. (Yeah, I became a crazy cat lady, so what?)
I knew Eli would never part with that much money for Barkley. He wouldn't even part with the cost of a divorce lawyer for me, the only person he'd ever loved almost as much as he loved himself.
I was genuinely worried for Barkley. The news was reporting that the kidnapper wanted $2 million. If I had that lying around, I might have considered paying it, but I was behind on my own bills, so that was out of the question.
Barkley showed up after a few days anyway, so it was all a lot of hooplah for nothing.
A few months later, I saw Eli on the cover of Chemistry Monthly again, and this time I bought it, because I absolutely had to read the article about Dr Eli Michaelson's Nobel Prize being stripped from him because evidence had come to light that he'd stolen most of the work from some guy called Harriman James who'd died in the 70s.
Harriman James… the name sounded familiar. I was sure Eli had mentioned him before.
Then it clicked. One of the biggest arguments we'd ever had was after I found out he had an illegitimate son with the wife of his dead second best friend, Harriman James.
The article also told me that Dr Michaelson's wife had recently filed for divorce.
At first, I laughed at the karma of it all. I laughed a lot. For a long time.
Then, the damndest thing happened.
My doorbell rang.
I ignored it. I wasn't expecting anyone, so it was probably just Mormons.
Then it rang again, and again, and again.
A fist banged on the door.
Mormons weren't that persistent. Bailiffs? No, I wasn't that far behind on my bills.
…Cops?
It couldn't be cops, surely. The cops had stopped trying to find the culprit behind the acid attack four years ago, and I was pretty sure I hadn't committed any more crimes since then.
"Come on, open the door, it's freezing out here!"
Eli?!
I opened the door but kept the screen closed.
"What are you doing here?"
"Freezing my balls off. Can I come in? Please?"
It was snowing and he didn't have a coat on, of course he was freezing his balls off. I thought about letting them freeze — maybe then he'd stop emptying them in every hole he saw — but I guess I got soft in my old age, and I let him in.
"Why aren't you wearing a coat?" I demanded, as if his lack of coat had personally offended me — which it had, really, because it meant I had to let him in.
"It's not snowing in LA."
My cat jumped on the back of the couch and hissed at him. Eli blinked, surprised at either the fact I had a cat or the fact it had hissed at him.
"That's Michi. Don't mind him, he hates men. Apart from freezing your balls off, why are you here, and what does the weather in LA have to do with anything?"
"When I left my apartment, it wasn't snowing." Eli helped himself to a blanket that I'd left draped over the armchair and dropped himself into the seat. "It got colder as I drove north."
"Rewind. Your apartment in Los Angeles?"
"Yeah. I live there now. Fancied a change of scene."
"You got fired for the Nobel Prize thing, didn't you?"
"Damn, I was hoping you hadn't heard about that."
I folded my arms and perched on the arm of the couch. "Yeah, I heard. And I heard about Barkley. And Sarah."
"Everything," Eli sighed, sitting back into the armchair. "I lost fucking everything."
"And, what, you thought I'd pity you?"
He looked up at me, frowning. "No. But you… you're the only thing I've got left. I thought, if I can salvage things with you… nothing else will matter. Not Sarah, not Barkley, not the Nobel Prize, not my tenure, fucking none of it. I don't care that I've lost it all, if I can still have you."
I barked a laugh, so loud it startled Michi.
"You're joking, right? What, you want me now? After forty fucking years, you've finally got no other options but me?"
Eli shook his head. "No. You were never an option. You were never a choice. You just… were. Constant. Inevitable. And then you… weren't. You left. I took you for granted, I took all of it for granted…"
He ran a palm down his face and sighed.
"Let me get you a drink," I said, reluctantly straightening up to head to the kitchen. "You want a bourbon?"
"Nah, I gotta drive back. Coffee's fine."
I hesitated for half a moment, then continued reaching for the bourbon in the cupboard.
"You're driving back in this?" I said to him through the doorway.
"I'll find a motel, then head back in the morning."
I couldn't believe it. He was being completely serious. He had driven a good five or six hours to see me, and he wasn't expecting to end up in my bed.
When I came back into the lounge, I handed him a glass of bourbon.
"I told you, I gotta drive —"
"No, you don't. Stay here tonight."
I sat down on the couch with my own glass and raised it to him.
"To kinetic persistence," I said.
Eli half-smiled and downed his drink in one go, then burped.
"You know," he said, "a molecule that interacts with other molecules has a much greater potential to luminesce."
"…What?"
He put his glass down on my coffee table carefully, as if he were choosing his words with great thought.
"What's your plan for the rest of your life? We've got, what, 20 or 30 years left, if we're lucky? What're you gonna do with them?"
I shrugged. "Got five years to retirement. Figure I'll stick it out 'til then, then probably go kill myself 'cus I can't afford to retire."
Eli stared at me.
"…You're serious, aren't you?"
"Well, depends if Michi's still around."
"Your cat. Whether or not you kill yourself in five years is dependent on your cat."
"I got nothing else, Eli. This place is a rental. I have no assets, I'm in debt. I have no family, no friends. All I got is a criminal record and a cat."
"You have me."
I scoffed.
"You do," Eli said seriously. "You have me. You've always had me."
"I haven't, though, have I? I've never had you. Not completely. I've only ever had the crumbs of love you leave behind when you're done with other women. Glynnis, Sarah, that girl from school — God knows how many others. Tell me, how many other side pieces did you have while you were married? Were we all at the same time? How many As did you give Laura Green in exchange for sex?"
"Laura —? I knew it! I fucking knew it was you! You threw acid over her, didn't you?"
"How many others were there?!"
"I don't know, I didn't keep count!"
"Did you fuck them all raw, or just her?"
"Don't you flip this! You threw acid on her! She's peramently blind now!"
"Did you get any of them pregnant?"
"No! Well — one. She didn't keep it."
"Oh, well, at least I'm not the only one."
Eli grabbed my arm, looming over me with his height. We were standing up, when did we stand up? I don't remember.
"Did you throw acid over Laura Green or not?"
"I was aiming for her car."
Eli released my arm from his grip. "I was right about you all along. You are a psycho."
"I'm not crazy!" I yelled. "I'm in love with you, and you drive me crazy! Do you even realise that everything — the shit that I've done, everything that happened this year — it all goes back to your philandering dick?"
"You didn't seem to have a problem with my philandering dick when it was you I was sticking it in."
"I begged you to get a divorce! I wanted you, Eli! All of you, all the time, but all you would give me was the crumbs!"
"I know! Alright? I know, I should have married you. We should have kept the baby — both of them. I fucked up both our lives, is that what you wanna hear? I'm sorry!"
The word hung in the air.
He'd never said it before. Not to me, probably not to anyone — not seriously, anyway.
"My whole life has been a series of mistakes," Eli continued, calmer now. "I broke your heart. Broke some others, too, but yours was the one I should never have broken. I'm sorry. I…"
He raised his hand, and I flinched, but he just stroked the side of my face softly.
"I love you."
He'd never said that before either.
Only in my head. Only ever in my head. So much of it was only ever in my head.
"You are the only person I have ever loved. Not Sarah, not Barkley. No one. Only you. And maybe you are crazy, but so am I. I don't know what happens after we die, sweetheart, but if there's a Hell, that's where I'm going. All I ask is to live the rest of this life with you."
I sniffed and placed my hand over his.
"If you're going to Hell, Eli, then I'm burning with you."
"It's already on fire, you'll fit right in."
I laughed and shoved his chest playfully.
"I love you too, by the way."
"I know."
For a few moments, we just stood there, hands intertwined and hearts finally aligned.
Summary: When the line between obsession and love blurs, Eli Michaelson begins to unravel—haunted by a past he refuses to name and a girl he swore he’d never need.
Pairing: Eli Michaelson × Fem! Reader
Warnings: Smut, Angst
First, Second, Third and Fourth part here.
Also read on Ao3
Eli suddenly pulled out of you without warning, dragging a broken sob from your throat as your body clenched around nothing, shaking, slick, undone. You barely had time to gasp before he hooked his arms under your thighs and lifted you—just lifted you like it cost him nothing, like you weighed less than a grudge.
You clung to him out of instinct, half-limp and overstimulated, your body a trembling mess, your hands fisting the collar of his shirt. His cock was still hard between you, thick and soaked with you, twitching against your thigh as he carried you up the driveway and through the front door like a man possessed.
He didn’t say a word.
Not when the hallway lights flicked on. Not when your head lolled against his shoulder and your lips brushed his neck. His jaw was set, nostrils flared, baritone breath hissing through clenched teeth like he was holding himself back by inches. By threads.
He carried you into the bedroom and set you down on the mattress—his bed, sharp and cold and immaculately made—and you sank into the sheets, boneless and dazed, your thighs still sticky, your heart still pounding.
But Eli didn’t climb on top of you. Not yet. Instead, he straightened, adjusted his shirt with one hand, and turned toward the door.
“Stay there,” he said—gravel-soft, voice like a warning shot muffled by velvet. “Don’t fucking move.”
You blinked, watching him disappear down the hallway. You heard the sound of the fridge. The hum of something opening. Running water.
When he returned, he had a bottle in one hand—glass, not plastic. Chilled. Condensation beaded across his fingers.
He handed it to you without comment.
You stared at it for a beat, confused, your breath still coming in shallow little gasps. “What is this?”
Eli arched a brow, his hazel eyes burning with a slow, mocking patience. “It’s water, sweetheart. Try not to look so offended.”
You took it with trembling hands, fingers brushing his. The bottle was cold—blessedly cold—and you took a long sip without thinking, the liquid soothing your dry throat, your fried nerves.
Eli sat on the edge of the bed.
He still hadn’t come. He was hard. You could see it, thick and angry between his open trousers. But he didn’t reach for you. Not yet. He watched you instead, his hooked nose casting a sharp line of shadow across his cheek, his lips parted just slightly, like he was cataloguing every twitch of your bare, ruined body.
“You’re flushed,” he murmured. “Pulse high. Still leaking.”
Your thighs clenched involuntarily.
He tilted his head, voice lowering to a dark purr. “I like you like this.”
You swallowed. “Like what?”
“Ruined,” Eli said, eyes raking over your body. “Fucked open. Full of me.”
You tried to shift, to close your legs, but his hand was already there—firm, warm, splaying across your inner thigh to keep you open.
“You begged for it,” he murmured. “You begged for my tongue. My cock. You screamed when I gave it to you.”
You whimpered softly. “I said stop.”
Eli’s expression flickered—just for a second.
“You said ‘stop leaving,’” he replied coldly. “There’s a difference.”
Your lips parted, but no sound came.
“And you said it with my cock halfway down your throat,” he added, cruelly calm. “So don’t rewrite the story now. You knew what you were doing.”
Silence.
Then, softer—quieter, with something almost like… restraint:
“I’m not done with you yet.”
You were about to speak—maybe protest, maybe surrender—when he reached out and took the bottle from your hands, setting it on the nightstand with a quiet clink.
“Lie back,” he said.
You did.
And when he climbed over you, the weight of him pressed into your chest like a verdict. His baritone voice was low, but not gentle.
“I want to feel you come around me again. Slow this time.”
His cock brushed your inner thigh, slick and hot. His nose nuzzled against your jaw, voice whispering like a secret too dangerous to speak aloud.
“And then I want to come inside you,” he breathed. “So deep it doesn’t leave for days.”
You didn’t answer. You didn’t have to. Your body already had.
An hour later, the room was quiet. Still. The sheets tangled at your waist, your skin flushed and glistening, your breath soft with sleep.
Eli sat on the edge of the bed, seminude, elbows resting on his knees, one hand running slowly through his disheveled hair. His back was tense—broad shoulders hunched, spine rigid with something restless and unspoken. He stared at the floor like it might offer an equation he could solve, something he could fix, categorize, dismiss.
But there was no solution here. Just the sound of your breathing. The faint imprint of your body on his sheets. The smell of sex still hanging in the air.
You were asleep.
He wasn’t. He couldn’t be. Not when his mind was churning like this—chaotic, volatile, embarrassing.
It shouldn’t be like this. You were supposed to be the toy. The subject. The willing object of his control, his money, his precision. The lab rat who signed her life away for a stipend and some tuition coverage.
He was supposed to be the master. Detached. Amused. Unreachable.
But here he was. Awake. Haunted.
The image of you moaning his name still vivid behind his eyes, raw and hungry and real. Too real. Your voice still echoing in his head. The way you clung to him. The way you looked up at him, even in anger—even when you said no, even when you said enough—like he was something that mattered.
It was infuriating.
He shouldn't be this affected. Shouldn’t care if you walked out. Shouldn’t care what you did after the contract ended. Who you fucked. Who you laughed with. Who you trusted instead of him.
But he did.
God, he did.
The thought of you with someone else—some eager little academic with soft eyes and cleaner hands, someone who smiled too much and said “good job” when you passed a test instead of ripping the paper apart with red ink—that thought made his stomach twist. Made his jaw lock. Made his hands tremble.
He didn’t get possessive. That wasn’t who he was. He didn’t want things. He used them. Controlled them. Discarded them.
Except you.
He couldn’t discard you. Not when your scent was still on his skin. Not when your voice still lingered in his ear like an echo carved into bone.
He ran a hand over his mouth, exhaling through his nose. His hazel eyes flicked toward you—still sleeping, still warm, curled half on your side like you belonged there. In his bed. In his world.
You didn’t even look scared anymore.
You looked safe.
And that scared the shit out of him.
He hated that you made him hesitate. That you made him reconsider. That you turned fucking into feeling, even when he swore he’d never be that weak.
It was supposed to be control. That’s what it had always been.
Power.
Not... whatever this was. This heat in his throat. This ache in his chest. This absurd desire to slide back into bed and wrap himself around you, to pull you close and stay.
He stared down at his hands, flexing his fingers slowly. He’d paid your bills. He’d erased your contract. He’d memorized your body, your laugh, the exact cadence of your moans when you were seconds from coming apart.
He didn't own you. But he'd carved his name into you anyway. And now? Now he couldn't bear the idea of anyone else touching you. Not academically, not emotionally, not physically.
He clenched his jaw, shaking his head once like that might dispel the thought. You should’ve just been a phase, he told himself. A mouth. A cunt. A warm body that obeyed when he said bend over.
But no.
You’d become something else. Something messier. Something dangerous.
And the worst part? You didn’t even know it.
You still believed he could let you go.
Eli turned slightly, looking back at you over his shoulder. His baritone voice broke the silence—low, quiet, like he didn’t mean to speak aloud.
“You think I’m ever letting you leave?”
He stared at you, chest tight. Then he reached for the blanket and pulled it up gently over your bare shoulders, smoothing it down with a hand that didn’t shake.
But his breath did.
And that was worse. He closed his fist and bit down on it hard, knuckles white, the sting sharp against his teeth.
Get your head together, Michaelson. Get your fucking head together.
But he couldn’t. Not tonight.
Not with your scent still on his skin. Not with the taste of your still ghosting his mouth, sweet and salt and defiance. Not with your sleeping in his bed like she belonged there, like you’d carved out a place in his life that he never meant to give.
Eli shoved himself off the edge of the bed, pacing across the room like a caged thing, breath shallow, heartbeat thudding loud in his ears. He wanted to punch something. A wall. A mirror. His own fucking father’s smug face.
Frank.
That bastard.
He hadn’t seen Frank in person in two years, not since the last pathetic attempt at a family gathering—an awkward dinner where Frank tried to play father over roast chicken and Merlot, like decades of contempt could be erased with polite conversation and a plate of fucking carrots. Eli had made it thirty-seven minutes before snapping, calling him a sanctimonious bastard and storming out.
Frank kept trying, though. Kept calling. Kept sending books, tickets, awkward little gifts with too many commas in the card—“Just thought you might find this interesting, son.” As if that word still meant anything.
Eli didn’t answer. He never answered. Not after what that man had done. Not after he’d replaced everything Eli’s mother ever was with a child bride and a do-over kid.
Thomas. That boy.
Eli ran a hand through his hair, fingers tugging hard enough to hurt.
He hated Frank. Hated the way he’d softened in his old age, as if marrying that cheerful, oblivious woman had magically absolved him of a lifetime of being a cold, withholding, judgmental bastard. Hated the way Frank treated Thomas like some kind of fucking golden boy—soft pats on the head, school awards on the fridge, bedtime stories and father-son science kits.
Where the hell was that version of Frank when Eli was seven? Or fifteen? Or twenty?
Eli had never known a Frank who laughed. Or hugged. Or called just to check in.
All he got was expectations. Orders. And disappointment.
And when his mother died, that already-icy world turned to frost. The only softness in Eli’s life disappeared with a hospice breath and a white hospital sheet.
That was the moment, really.
The rupture.
The hole that opened and never closed.
Eli tried to fill it with drugs at first. Ecstasy. Coke. A few trips into darker corners of chemistry labs where supervision was light and ambition high. He got smart about it. Started making his own. Microdosing during lectures. Popping molly before oral exams. Conducting peer reviews with pupils like dinner plates.
Frank found out. Of course he did. Had him yanked out of his PhD program and shoved into some elite rehab clinic outside of Boston. Military connections. Clean linens. No privacy. Eli had screamed. Begged. Bartered. Nothing worked.
“You’ll thank me for this,” Frank had said at the door, not unkindly.
Eli had laughed in his face.
He got clean. Stayed clean. Got out. Moved to California, poured everything into his research, won awards, published papers.
Married Sarah. Slept with a dozen others. Got Sarah pregnant. Stayed married out of obligation and spite. Screwed his way through graduate assistants, conference attendees, the occasional colleague’s bored wife. Control. That’s what it gave him. If he couldn’t be loved the way he needed, he could be wanted. Owned. Obeyed.
Sex filled the gaps.
Briefly.
Until her.
Until the girl now tangled in his sheets like she might belong there, like she might stay.
And that was the real problem.
Eli closed his eyes and pressed his fist to his mouth again, harder this time.
Don’t be fucking stupid.
She was just another body. Another bright young thing who let him push her too far and came back for more. He paid her. She posed. She stayed. And she would leave. Eventually, they all did.
But this one? She made him hesitate.
And that hesitation—that crack in his armor—made everything else worse. Sharper. Uglier. It reopened every old wound. Every unmet need. Every bitter fucking memory of being the wrong son.
Thomas didn’t have to beg for approval. Thomas didn’t get told he was too much. Thomas didn’t get dragged out of a lab and locked away like a disgrace. Thomas got bedtime stories and field trips and a version of Frank Benson that Eli had never even imagined.
And yet…
God help him…
Eli liked the boy.
No.
He envied, loved him.
Couldn’t help it. Thomas called him “big brother” like it meant something. Drew him pictures. Asked him science questions. Told him he wanted to be “a cool genius like Eli” when he grew up.
It was impossible not to get attached.
And that made Eli hate Frank more.
Because it meant the bastard could have been that man all along. He just chose not to be. Not for Eli.
The rage surged again, and Eli grabbed a glass from the nightstand, flinging it against the far wall. It shattered, the sound sharp and immediate, waking the girl in the bed with a startled jolt.
“Eli?” you whispered, eyes wide.
He turned his back.
“Go back to sleep.”
You sat up, covers pulled to your chest, your voice shaking. “What happened?”
Eli said nothing. Not right away. Then, quietly, too quietly: “Wrong life. Wrong fucking life.”
You didn't ask what he meant; you held out your arms to him.
And Eli hesitated. He stood near the broken glass, baritone breath tight in his throat, his jaw clenched so hard you could see the muscle jumping along his cheek. The light from the hallway painted his naked back in pale, sharp lines—tension carved into every vertebra. He didn’t move. Didn’t speak.
But he didn’t walk away either.
Your voice was soft, hoarse with sleep. “Come here.”
Still, he didn’t turn. His hand twitched at his side, fingers curled like they were deciding whether to clench or reach. Logic screamed at him—Don’t. Don’t let yourself go soft now. Don’t fall for the warmth in your voice, the pity in your eyes. This wasn’t love. This was a trap. A soft little nest of feelings that would only leave him exposed. Dependent. Pathetic.
He went anyway.
Eli crossed the room in two strides, dropped to his knees by the bed, and let you wrap your arms around his shoulders.
You held him gently. Like he wasn’t the man who’d threatened you. Fucked you. Bought you. Like he wasn’t dangerous. Just tired. Just human.
“Are you hurt?” you asked softly, brushing your fingers through the hair at his temple. “Did you cut yourself on the glass?”
“No,” Eli grunted.
“Then why—?”
“I don’t want to talk.”
But you didn’t stop. You never did.
“Is it about earlier?” you whispered. “About what I said—about the breakup?”
His shoulders tensed beneath your hands. His breath caught.
“I’m still going to finish the contract, Eli. I said I would. I’m not going back on that.”
He pulled away—not violently, but fast enough to break your grip. Fast enough to sting. He stood, pacing, his hand dragging through his hair, tugging hard at the strands like they were guilty of something.
“What’s wrong?” you asked, sitting up fully now. “Talk to me. What is it?”
“Everything!” Eli snapped, spinning on you, eyes blazing. “Everything is wrong!”
You flinched at the volume—more from the rawness than the rage. His voice cracked halfway through the sentence, baritone unraveling like a string pulled too tight.
He ran both hands down his face, then turned from you, talking too fast, too loud, like something inside him had finally come unhinged.
“Since the beginning, alright? Since the goddamn beginning. Since the day my mother died and that bastard of a father turned me into a fucking cadet!” His voice shook, rough and splintered. “Treated me like I was a project. A soldier. A fucking experiment.”
You didn’t speak. You just watched.
He paced again, bare feet crunching softly near the shards of the glass he’d thrown.
“And now look at him,” Eli spat. “Look at Frank. Smiling in every photo like he didn’t choke the life out of his first kid. Father of the year. Model citizen. And Thomas—”
He stopped, a ragged sound tearing out of his throat. He looked up at the ceiling like he might find the words carved into it.
“I love that kid,” Eli said, quieter now, but the fury hadn’t left his voice—it just folded in on itself, tighter. “And I hate that I love him. Because he gets everything I didn’t. Everything I should have had. And it’s not his fault. He’s just a kid. But I still want to scream every time he calls me big brother like it’s some fucking badge of honor.”
He turned toward you again, eyes dark and wild. “And then there’s Barkley.”
You blinked. “Your son?”
“My thieving, lying son,” Eli snapped. “Ran off with half my fucking money. I gave that boy my name, my blood, my legacy, and he pissed on all of it. And now, when I look at him, I don’t see a son—I see every single mistake I ever made shoved into a leather jacket and a smug grin.”
He shook his head, pacing again, hands clenching. “And now you—” he stopped, staring at you like you’d started this fire in his chest, “—you think you’re going to walk away? For what? For that scarf-wearing, open-mic-night philosophy major? Jordan?”
You opened your mouth.
“Don’t lie to me!” he shouted. “I see the way you look at him. Like he’s your salvation. Like he’s going to love you gently and say all the right things and touch you like you’re made of glass.”
He stepped forward, pointing, breath sharp.
“But he doesn’t know you. Not like I do. He didn’t see you beg. Didn’t see you scream. He didn’t drag the truth out of you like splinters. He didn’t pay your fucking bills.”
You stood too, hands shaking. “That’s not love, Eli. That’s control.”
“I don’t know how to love!” he bellowed, and the silence that followed was devastating.
Eli stared at you, chest heaving.
“I don’t know how,” he repeated, quieter now. “I only know how to keep people. How to own them. Protect them. Pay for them. Fuck them. Ruin them.”
His voice cracked again. “Because every time I loved something, it got taken. Or left. Or died.”
You took a step toward him. “I’m not—”
“Don’t,” he warned, voice hoarse. “Don’t make promises you can’t keep.”
The air between you hung heavy with something unspoken. Something broken.
Then, softer, like a confession he hadn’t meant to give: “If you leave, I don’t think I’ll know who the hell I am anymore.”
You exhaled.
And despite everything—every awful word, every ugly truth—you held out your arms again.
Eli looked at them. Looked at you. And this time, when he came to you, it wasn’t with hunger. It wasn’t with control.
It was with grief.
And need.
And something dangerously close to love.
The two of you didn’t talk about that night. Not about the bed. Not about the glass. Not about the confession that cracked open like a wound under your ribs and spilled something too fragile for either of you to name.
Eli stopped calling. He didn’t cancel your contract. Didn’t cut off your funds. He simply… stopped being there. The apartment was quiet. No more sharp baritone echoing through the halls, no more “Fix your goddamn posture” mid-study session, no more smirking commands to sit on the desk, to arch your back, to “earn your rent.”
And you didn’t go after him.
Not because you didn’t want to. But because you were tired. Because your final exams were looming, your hands were shaking every morning from too much coffee and not enough sleep, and every time you picked up your phone to text him—Are you okay?—you remembered the way he’d shouted, I don’t know how to love.
So you gave him space. Weeks passed like molasses. You studied. You worked. You kept your head down and your mouth shut. No more Playboy. No more photo shoots. Just you and your books and the deafening silence where Eli used to be.
And then, one afternoon, everything changed.
It was a Thursday. Warm. Early summer. The air outside still held the ghost of pollen, and your backpack was too heavy, and you were running on three hours of sleep and two Red Bulls. The exam had gone better than expected. You’d even smiled on the way out.
And Jordan was waiting at the curb.
He leaned against his motorcycle, helmet tucked under one arm, his scarf flapping in the breeze like a flag of hipster rebellion. He grinned when he saw you—wide and unguarded—and you couldn’t help it. You smiled back.
Eli saw it happen. He was crossing the lot, briefcase in one hand, car keys in the other, heading for his battered Mercedes like it owed him a favor. He wasn’t even looking for you. Not consciously.
But he looked up. And froze.
You were laughing—laughing—as Jordan handed you a helmet and gestured for you to climb on. He was helping you fasten the strap under your chin, his knuckles brushing your throat, his voice soft, close.
Eli’s breath caught. He didn’t move. Just stood there, half-shadowed under the curve of the building, hazel eyes locked on the image in front of him like he couldn’t quite process it.
You climbed on behind Jordan, wrapped your arms around his waist, and held tight.
And Eli—
He felt something snap. Not a loud break, not a scream. Just a quiet, internal fracture, like a glass vial under pressure finally giving way. His hands clenched at his sides; his breath came sharply through his nose.
The motorcycle roared to life.
Jordan laughed.
You pressed your cheek to his back, grinning, hair whipped by the wind.
And Eli Michaelson, Nobel laureate, academic tyrant, expert in quantum chemistry and the systematic disassembly of human emotion, stood in a parking lot watching the only person who had ever understood him ride away on a fucking motorcycle with a boy who wore scarves in June.
He didn’t say a word. Didn’t move. But his keys dug so hard into his palm, they drew blood.
And his baritone voice, when he finally spoke hours later into the hollow quiet of his kitchen, was so quiet it felt like a funeral.
“She wants him.”
He didn’t say it with anger. He said it like a sentence. Like a fact of the universe. Like gravity.
And somewhere deep inside—past the pride, past the genius, past the carefully constructed shell of control—Eli Michaelson finally felt fear.
Eli, the stupid fucking idiot Eli, found himself at a bar. Not a fancy one—not some sleek rooftop lounge where Nobel laureates went to be admired in dim lighting over overpriced whiskey. No. This was a dive. Sticky floors. Flickering TV mounted in the corner. One of the barstools had duct tape wrapped around the seat like a tumor. Eli took it anyway.
He was on his third scotch.
Maybe fourth. The bartender had stopped counting.
He felt ridiculous. Humiliated. Bitter.
Suffering. Over a girl. A girl.
He laughed—quiet and mirthless, more air than sound—and rubbed a hand over his face. His baritone rasped out low and sharp: “Christ, you’re pathetic.” He ordered another.
How ironic the world was. How small. How cruel.
He shouldn't have bought that Playboy magazine. He shouldn’t have picked it up in the first place—shouldn’t have flipped through the pages like some pervert. But he had. Like a fucking idiot.
He shouldn’t have chased you. Shouldn’t have dragged you against his car and shoved his mouth between your thighs like an addict licking the spoon. Shouldn’t have begged you to stay.
Idiot, idiot, idiot.
He took another drink. At a nearby table, a woman had been watching him for the last twenty minutes. Pretty. Young. Too much makeup. The kind who liked her men older, tragic, and bleeding from the edges.
Eli glanced at her.
Then glanced again.
She smiled.
He raised his glass. Called the bartender. “Send her one of these.”
The man nodded, wiping his hands on a towel. Eli leaned back, glass dangling from his fingers, already seeing it—her in his bed, her knees spread, her mouth open, moaning his name like she’d known it forever.
Yes, he thought. That’s going to fix this. That’s going to make him forget you.
He was about to stand. About to walk over. About to slide back into the skin he wore best: charming, cruel, fuckable.
Then—
His phone buzzed. He frowned, dug it from his coat pocket, already preparing to ignore it.
Thomas.
He sighed. “Of course.”
He answered anyway.
“What is it, Thomas?” he muttered, pressing the phone to his ear. “You know these calls are expensive.”
The line crackled faintly. Then his brother’s voice came through, bright and unbothered.
“Hi, bro! Sorry, I just— I wanted to tell you—yesterday in school I did this project about chemical reactions, and I used vinegar and baking soda, and it exploded all over my shoes, and my teacher said I should be a scientist like you!”
Eli closed his eyes. Rubbed his temple. He didn’t respond.
Thomas kept going. “And I told her, I said, ‘My big brother’s a genius. He’s got awards and everything. He won a prize from Sweden!’ And she said—”
Eli cut in, voice sharp. “Tell Dad. He’s the one who cares. I’m sure he’d love to hear all about it. His favorite son. His beloved second chance.”
Thomas was quiet on the other end.
Too quiet.
Eli blinked, something in his gut twisting—but before he could say anything, the boy’s voice returned. Softer. Confused.
“…He always talks about you.”
Eli froze.
Thomas went on, his voice a little smaller now, but no less certain. “Dad has this album. He keeps it in the study. It’s full of newspaper clippings. Photos. Your name. Your speeches. Even the one where you looked really mad and your hair was all messed up.”
Eli didn’t breathe.
“He always says you’re the pride of the Benson family,” Thomas added. “That you were the first person to show the world what we could do. He says I’ll be like you one day.”
Silence.
The bar faded.
The woman disappeared.
Even the scotch in his hand felt weightless.
Thomas kept speaking, unaware of the thunder cracking inside Eli’s skull. “He says he was a bad dad to you. That he messed up. But he never stops talking about how smart you are. He brags about you all the time. It’s kind of annoying.”
Eli let out a breath. Just one. Shaky. Quiet.
He didn’t know what to say. So he said nothing.
And for the first time in a long time, that silence wasn’t filled with bitterness. It was filled with grief.
And something dangerously close to... relief. But he wasn’t ready. Not yet.
So he swallowed it. Like poison. Like medicine. Like everything he’d ever swallowed in his father’s house.
Then he cleared his throat and said, voice hoarse, “Go to school, Thomas.”
The boy hesitated. “…Okay. Good Morning, Eli.”
“Night.”
He hung up. The drink sat untouched in his hand. The woman across the bar was still watching. But Eli didn't move. He just sat there.
And for the first time in his life, he didn’t know who he was trying to forget. His father. Himself.
Or you.
There was a loud knock on your apartment door. Sharp. Repeated.
It was 2:11 in the morning.
You sat up fast, heart pounding, still dressed in the oversized shirt you wore to bed. No one should’ve been at your door. Not at this hour.
You grabbed the bat from under the side table—the old aluminum one you kept there for moments just like this—and padded silently to the door, bare feet cold against the tile. You peered through the peephole, every muscle in your body braced for a stranger, a threat, a face you didn’t know.
But it wasn’t a stranger.
It was Eli. Drunk. Disheveled. His white dress shirt wrinkled, the collar half-popped, and his dark coat askew over one shoulder like he couldn’t be bothered to fix it. His hazel eyes were glassy, bloodshot. His hooked nose looked sharper in the hallway light, his jaw tight, his expression unreadable.
You lowered the bat slowly.
Then you opened the door.
“Do you think my father loves me?” Eli slurred.
You blinked. “…What?”
He leaned against the doorframe, eyes not quite meeting yours. “You’re smarter than you look. What do you think? Is it love when someone makes you bleed and calls it discipline?”
You swallowed. “Eli, I don’t—I don’t even know your father—”
“Didn’t ask if you knew him,” he snapped, baritone thick and broken. “I asked if you think he loves me.”
Your mouth opened. Then closed. There was no right answer.
Before you could respond, he pushed off the frame and leaned toward you—too fast. His hand caught your shoulder, and then his mouth was on yours, rough and uninvited. He kissed you like a man falling off a ledge, desperate to take something down with him.
You pushed him back with both hands. “Eli, what the fuck—”
“I can’t—” He ran a hand through his hair, breath shaking. “I can’t do this. Not if you’re with him.”
“Who?”
“Jordan,” Eli spat the name like it burned. “That fucking… cardigan-wearing… golden retriever.”
You stared at him. “Are you seriously here, drunk, at two in the morning, because you’re jealous?”
He exhaled sharply. “I’m not jealous.”
You raised an eyebrow.
“I’m not,” he insisted, hazel eyes flashing. “Jealousy is wanting something someone else has. You’re not his. You’re mine.”
You sighed, the ache in your chest blooming again. “It’s not fair, Eli. You sleep with whoever you want. I’m not even allowed to talk to another guy without getting a lecture from you?”
“I haven’t,” he cut in.
You blinked. “What?”
His jaw clenched, the words slow and deliberate now—like they hurt. “I haven’t slept with anyone else. In months. Not since you.”
You stared at him, stunned.
“I tried,” he said, quieter. “Tonight. I tried. Bought a drink for someone. Took her home. She said yes.”
He looked away, jaw tight.
“But when I touched her… I felt nothing. Nothing. Like kissing the wrong ghost.”
You didn’t speak. Couldn’t.
Eli met your gaze finally, eyes darker now, his voice cracked and low.
“Do you have any idea what that means for me? I don’t do this. I don’t lose sleep. I don’t chase anyone. But you…” He trailed off, mouth twisting like the taste of your name was a confession.
You stood still, your fingers twitching at your side.
“I couldn’t fuck her,” he said finally, like it shamed him. “Because all I could think about was you. Your mouth. Your laugh. The way you never flinch when I’m cruel. You just stare back like you’re waiting for me to be human.”
You looked at him then, really looked. At the bloodshot eyes, the cracked knuckles, the tilt of his mouth like he was halfway between begging and breaking.
He took a step closer. “Don’t be with him,” he whispered. “Please.”
You swallowed hard. “Why? Because you can’t get it up for anyone else?”
“No.” His voice dropped. “Because I’m in love with you.”
Silence.
Then:
“Christ,” Eli muttered, dragging a hand down his face. “I actually said it.”
You didn’t move.
Neither did he. He just stood there in your doorway, every inch of arrogance stripped away, and waited to see if you’d slam the door in his face—or let him in.
And you…
You stepped aside.
Not because you forgave him. Not because it was simple. But because somewhere deep inside, under all the wreckage, you wanted to believe it.
Wanted to believe he meant it, even if he didn't know how.
Author's Note: Sorry for the delay again, all. I really enjoyed writing this one (not that I don't enjoy the others, lol), and hope you like some rare Eli from me!
Character(s): Eli Michaelson x Female Reader
Summary: Eli spies you playing volleyball across the beach. He offers a night in his motel room for an advantage next semester---and you're too desperate to refuse.
Warning(s)‼️: Smut. PIV Sex. Oral Sex. Abuse of Power/Power Dynamics. Student x Professor. Reader is a brat---but so is Eli.
Word Count: 1.7k
Read on AO3 or below the break:
Evening was settling in along the Los Angeles shoreline, the sun still flaming hot despite the late hour, though chemistry professor Eli Michaelson was unbothered by the heat. He was splayed out in a low-sitting beach chair in the shade of a grove of palm trees, lounge pants rolled mid-calf, loafers resting in the snow-white sand, pretending to read the latest publication from a physics journal folded in half in one hand.
His eyes had landed on a woman forty yards in front of him—spiking the ball in a volleyball match he hardly cared the score of—the oiled tan bodies and spaghetti-thin bikinis riding up the women’s limbs far more intriguing. He’d seen that girl in the halls in the last semester before term ended for the summer—he was certain. And Eli Michaelson was scarcely incorrect.
The players were disbanding, gritty sand sticking to sweaty thighs—thighs he imagined wrapped firmly around his middle, his groin stirring at the unsanctioned thought. The woman from his university was walking his way. He pulled the hem of his polo shirt down over his crotch, turning his journal page in an effort to play the part of the studious professor—the carefully curated image he wanted the student to maintain of himself. At least, for the moment.
“Fancy meeting you here, professor. On vacation?” He hadn’t expected his plan to work so well—perhaps she noticed him from afar before, or perhaps she recognized the manner in which he held himself while studying. It mattered not, for his tongue was suddenly tied—a rarity for an insatiable womanizer like himself.
“Something like that,” he muttered, wondering if the gravel in his voice that earned him spots on the lecture circuit and spots in students’ pants was taking effect.
“I’m sorry about your divorce.”
“I’m not.” It wasn’t the words he had been anticipating—perhaps her mind wasn’t as unfocused on sex as he had assumed.
“Was it the sleeping with your students, or the acting like a self-entitled prick?”
“I’m certain they weren’t mutually exclusive.” She snorted, nose upturned in disgust, eyes saying something entirely different that he was entirely happy to exploit.
“Here to read the same page of your journal for an hour, or couldn’t come up with a better cover to watch half-naked women by the sea?” He locked eyes with her, growing steadily more aroused when she failed to look away.
“The two aren’t necessarily mutually exclusive,” he purred, smirking. She wrinkled her nose.
“What a pervert.”
“And yet you’re still here, sweetheart,” he was enjoying her unrelenting supply of carefully crafted banter—it was so rare anyone but his ex-wife or sorry excuse for a son, bothered to argue. It was as intoxicating as any drug taking root in his veins.
“What do you want?” She asked, entirely mistrustful of him. He could hardly blame her.
“Oh, if you really want to know…” He tried to sound bored, tried to sound as if he were not currently attempting to disguise a raging hard-on poking against his trousers’ inseam.
“Call it a morbid fascination.”
“I’m looking for a pretty thing to take back to my motel and spend several hours fucking into my mattress, thanks for inquiring—or perhaps you’re volunteering?” He held his breath, wondering how long it would take for the hook to be set.
“Eww, I’d never—you’re too—”
“Old? Fat? I’m not asking for forever, sweetheart, just one night,” he snarled, watching her expression remain unchanged. “Maybe if I sweetened the deal? You’re in my class this term—perhaps I could ensure your grade is…passable,” he breathed, hoping to wheedle out the answer he desired. He had not anticipated such resistance.
“Fine, but no–no funny business,” she irritably spat, as his chest surged in triumph.
“Oh sweetheart, you forget…I’m neither a comedian nor a gentleman.”
“Two more minutes, or I’m joining you,” he grated out, and you could hear the eagerness that could not be tamped down in the low baritone voice. The idea of him in the shower with you was deeply…unappealing. You shuddered, hot water turned off, a towel tightly wrapped around your torso. Eli, as he had insisted you call him, had stolen the clothes you had laid out on the toilet. Bastard.
“Took you long enough,” he growled, standing fully clothed outside your door, hands folded across his broad chest, one silver brow arched in annoyance.
“You managed,” you retorted, satisfied by Eli’s eyeroll. “Going to fuck me in your loafers?”
“Yes,” he snapped, thin lips drawn in a scowl. “Have a problem with that? You’re certainly not here for my Adonis-like physique, you know—”
“I have standards—”
He snorted in disbelief.
“Right.”
“Perhaps I can—make it worth your while…” You dropped the towel lower, provocatively showing the top of your cleavage, watching Eli’s hazel eyes unashamedly boggle.
“Fine,” he sneered, as if he deemed this a distinct privilege—an act reserved for royalty. “But no bitching about my lack of abs.”
“Right,” you haughtily answered, dropping the wet towel to the stained brown carpet. Eli groaned, large hands open-palmed, hovering in mid-air near your chest. The crotch of his trousers began to fill. “Don’t,” you glanced at his hands meaningfully, rage heating his face.
“The hell I won’t,” he snarled, perfectly straight teeth bared.
“The trousers or the shirt off first,” you countered, tone perfectly even.
“Damn you.” He hissed, roughly unbuttoning the collar of his shirt, heaving the grey fabric over his head, angrily tossing it toward the hallway door. You eyed his now bared chest—pale as snow and slightly hairy, nipples puffy and stomach hanging low. Eli moved to his trousers, belly spilling out fully as he unzipped, letting them fall to his ankles. He kept his plaid boxers on, the outline of his lengthy cock clearly visible, as he stared at you in what could only be described as pure hatred. “Satisfied?”
“I don’t have your cock in me yet, do I?” You watched him almost smirk at your response before catching himself, instead choosing to frown at you down his hooked nose.
“Watch your cheek.”
“That a threat, professor?”
“Get on the damn bed and spread your legs—I intend to fuck the brattiness out of you tonight.”
“Then get on with it—so far you’re all talk.” Your uncharitable observation struck a nerve, Eli, lips white, unceremoniously depositing himself on the end of the bed with a grunt. You fought the urge to close your legs as he crawled between them, examining your pussy like it was the Nobel Prize sitting on his office desk—shiny, expensive, and undoubtedly earned by his own ingenuity.
His hands restrained your knees, head leaning close to your slit before his eyes lifted to find yours—a wave of tenderness breaking through a sea of hazel—the moment brief, his eyes suddenly hardening. “Tell me to stop if you want, but the deal will be off.”
“I want you to fuck me, Eli—I want to sit in class next to all the other students knowing my grade’s safe because I pleased my old professor’s cock.”
“None of that mouth now—” He growled, looking strangely aroused, and yet his brows were drawn in pain. “The only sounds I want to hear from you are orgasmic screams or praise for my sexual prowess.”
You parted your lips to insult him, but the scorn never came—Eli’s tongue had dove straight between your folds—furiously lapping at your most sensitive places like a man on a mission. It had been ages since you’d had a boyfriend give you oral; it was almost tender. As if he had read your mind, Eli pulled away from your cunt, thin lips glistening, as he harshly retorted, “Don’t relax yourself too much, sweetheart. This isn’t for your comfort—it’s for mine.”
He was back to sucking and licking your clit with a vengeance—everything too fast, too rough, too unconcerned—yet your belly still tingled with the sensation of an impending orgasm, an orgasm about to hit you with the force of an entire speeding train. Your walls clenched in expectation, but the budding pressure never surfaced—all sensation disappeared.
You looked between your thighs, but Eli was gone—sitting upright at the foot of the bed, expression smug despite your slickness dribbling down his chin. He was oddly attractive in that moment, his stomach hanging over his boxers, knowing smirk daring you to defy—daring you to insult. And you were perfectly fine with taking the bait.
“Bastard,” you grumbled, feeling your arousal retreat deeper within your core. Eli grinned, like a coyote after a successful hunt.
“Tonight’s not about you, princess.” He stood up from the bed, tearing off his boxers in manly pride, your eyes comically widening in surprise. The loose pants and overflowing belly had somehow hidden the nine inches of meat stiffly swinging between his legs—three inches longer than any of the men you’d taken before. Icy fear entered your chest for the first time that evening.
“Like what you see, sweetheart? There’s a reason your peers keep coming back for more.”
He wasn’t wrong—that was the terrible thing. The rumors surrounding Eli Michaelson’s tendencies toward his female students had been active for nearly a decade, and one fact was always the same—the condescending man had a monster cock. And he wasn’t afraid to use it.
“Cat got your tongue? You aren’t the first student I’ve rendered speechless.” He straddled you, surprisingly gentle, pulsing prick hard against your stomach. “I didn’t even need to fuck you to tame the brat out of your system.”
“Asshole,” you retorted, cheeks scarlet at the truth lacing his words.
“Language, sweetheart.” You were back to despising his ego, despising the way he considered himself immortal among a world of plebians.
“Fuck me.”
“Try again, a little nicer if you would.” He was being unbearably smug, and you both knew you had to take it.
“Fuck me, please, professor.” You hated those words, hated the way you felt him twitch against your stomach.
“Certainly, sweetheart.” He pushed in, only pausing briefly when he noticed your pained grimace—sheathing himself fully when that pain passed into mere discomfort. His hands were gripping your hips so tight you were willing to bet fifty dollars they bruised, Eli’s grasp harsh as he began to ram himself in and out of your hole in earnest.
You had never felt so full before—his cock hitting your g-spot perfectly with every thrust. Arousal returned—the pulsing of an orgasm rising over the horizon settled deep within your lower belly. Eli panted above, his speed beginning to waver—his heavy balls failing to slam forcefully against you after every thrust. Sweat dribbled down his temple, one of your breasts clutched between his fingers—not tenderly, but admiringly—as if they were his to own–to claim–for the night.
“Faster,” you complained, his cock good, but your patience was limited—you wanted—needed, rather—something to get you over the edge. Eli’s hips stuttered, his lined face contorting with rage.
“I told you—before—” His thrusts had minutely increased in speed, though you knew better than to compliment a narcissist. “This—this—is—for—my—pleasure.” He came, fast and angrily and with an animalistic growl, not bothering to pull out, even after his quickly cooling cum started to leak out onto the cheap sheets. Your fingers found your clit—a few slow strokes along the head all you needed to see stars, Eli moaning in pleasure as your walls fluttered around him.
“Twenty minutes,” your future professor rumbled, grey head lazily reclining on the lumpy motel pillow, eyes softly closing shut.
“What?” You whimpered, unsure what exactly it was you felt lying next to him—his belly warm against your middle, his thumb absentmindedly tracing across your breast.
“I intend to fuck you again in twenty minutes—I thought you were smarter than that, girl.”
“Thirty.”
“Fine—no complaining this time. If you suck my cock I’ll make sure we come together.”
Pairing(s)/Character(s): Nobel Laureate Dr. Eli Michaelson (😂) x Fem!Reader
Summary: In where Eli gets jealous and reminds [Y/n] who she belongs to.
Tag(s)/Warning(s): Smut (p in v, student/teacher, facial (and not the one u get at a spa) )
A/N: Ah yes if it isn't Doctor Eli Michaelson Nobel Laureate 😂. Please enjoy this fun little smut piece for the world's Sexiest asshole. I swear I come up with the most unhinged things for this man I do not regret it.
There were a lot of things you quickly learned when you began your sordid affair with your Chemistry professor, soon after you had become his teaching assistant.
One, was that his pleasure came first when you two fucked around. Whether it be in the classroom right before a lesson started, or in his office when you were helping him grade papers, Eli came first.
Well not physically. Surprisingly, he always made sure you got off beforehand, granted that wasn't a very difficult task when he fucked you better than any other person you ever dated could. Him and his stupid large cock and knowing how to use it.
No, he made sure you knew he was in control of any, and all pleasure you received, and that what mattered most, was him getting to make a mess of you in whichever way he found sated his hunger for that moment.
It was a good thing for him that you were a bit of a sexual deviant, happy to be his toy if he wanted, considering it got you off as much as it did him. Maybe you ought to seek some professional help with that. You heard that the psychology department was taking volunteers for a cognitive trial for something or another. Maybe it would sort you out.
Another thing that you learned about him, was boy did he have an ego. Technically, you had learned that even before you were anywhere in his orbit. Considering he had a Noble Prize, it was easy to see why his head would be so far stuck in his ass.
Again though, only about a hundred or so people had earned that achievement in Chemistry, and him being one of them, surely did more for his ego than anything else could. Well, maybe also the way his students would throw themselves at him. Both because of his academic prowess and because of how good his cock was.
Look, you weren't naive, and you also weren't going to delude yourself that you were the only pussy his dick was finding a home in. Who cared? As long as was bending you over his desk every other day and making you come like no other man had, he could do whatever he wanted.
Shame you would lose such good dick after you graduated, but that was for future you to worry about. Present you, was having too much fun to care. And plus, he probably be more than happy to fuck an alumnus. It'd stroke his ego even more that you would come back after graduating.
Huh, maybe you should do your PhD here as well.
Oh yeah, and one last thing, for someone who like to fuck around a lot Eli Michaelson sure was a possessive asshole. That was something you found out more recently. Though, with the way he had an obsession with decorating your neck, and other areas of your body that people could see with bruises, you should have picked up on that earlier.
Again, it wasn't really a focus of yours when you were too busy trying to stay conscious and upright as he fucked you silly.
Kind of like…right now.
"F-fuck, fuck oh Eli!"
Your eyes, which you had no idea had fluttered closed as he railed you, shot back open as he slammed into you with a loud grunt. The tip of him pressing harshly against your cervix, causing hot ropes of pleasure to trail down your legs as they stiffened against his side. The burning engulfed your pussy in the most delicious way as you spread open even wider for him, one leg on each side of his thick thighs as he snapped his hips against yours with unbridled fury. The smacking of skin was loud, and very much obscene as your hands tried to claw at anything on the table, only causing the papers on his desk to fly off as you tried not to slide down from your position.
God thing he was fucking you so hard and at such a furious pace, that each thrust had you practically scooting back up on the desk.
Whatever had gotten into him, you didn't know but you sure did like it.
"Fucking!" -Thrust- "Little!" -Thrust- "Slut!" Each word was punctuated with him thrusting into you, and each time your back arched off the desk as a cry left your lips that still had the lingering taste of his cock on it.
"Didn't think I catch you rubbing up against that dumb as bricks grad student did you? Fluttering your little eyelashes with that stupid low cut shirt like you wanted him to see your tits!"
"Fuck Eli, ah! I was just, mmm fuck, just helping him! Oh god," you gasped, as he kept up his pace, cock dragging along your sensitive channel, "he was, shit aah, having trouble with gravimetric analysis!"
"Oh you were just helping huh? And how were you going to do that because he sure seemed more interested in what was under your shirt!" He snapped, as he grabbed at your hips, fingers digging into the soft skin as you squirmed helplessly against him. Unsure if you were trying to get away from him or get his dick deeper into you.
You were sure it was the latter though.
"Gonna suck his tiny dick and hope he learns by osmosis huh?"
Had you not been drunk on his cock, and your cunt not fluttering wildly at how deranged he was acting, you would have laughed. But alas that was for another time.
For someone who fucked around a lot, he sure was a hypocrite when someone else did the same. Not that you had any intention, or want to do that with that particular student.
"E-Eli Jesus, fuck!" You cried out as he leaned down on you, his body weight crushing you like a human-weighted blanket, and forcing himself deeper inside of you.
Your warm, velvety channel, was more than happy to accommodate the position, squeezing him, as he rolled his hips while mouthing at your exposed neck that was damp with sweat. "Unlike some people, I don't go fucking everyone that comes for help!"
"Well if I didn't, ngh, I'd be depriving you of the best dick you'll ever had wouldn't I be?"
He wasn't wrong there. But you didn't want to stroke his ego any more than you already were. Instead, you just opted to moan out your answer as he explored your body with a wandering hand. His hand moved up and down your tummy where he pawed at the skin, causing you to whine before he trailed himself up your front, wrapping a hand around one of your tits that bounced up and down each time he would force himself into you.
A little cry left your lips as he leaned down and bit at the perky nipple before his tongue soothed the ache, licking the swollen nub and sucking it causing your already sensitive body to tremble even more singling you were about ready to burst.
He seemed to feel it too as his thrusts began to speed up, hitting that spot in you harder, and faster. Your legs stiffened more and more as you let out whines that increased in volume, just like the sound of your wet cunt being fucked mercilessly.
You were sure your inner thighs were going to be bruised with how hard they were pressed against Eli, but it wouldn't be the first time, and it sure wasn't going to be the last.
With one more harsh thrust, your body seized, and your insides gripped Eli's cock, causing a shout of your name to leave his lips, as you shook underneath him while your orgasm washed over you.
"Eli oh Eli fuck, oh god," you whispered and sobbed over and over as your stomach twisted and knotted pleasurably. Your hips stilling rolling uncontrollably against his body.
Wave after wave of heat rolled in your stomach, and it took you a few moments to come down from your high. Only to find that the man above you was still hard and, that he hadn't come yet. Add to that your blurry thoughts and that wicked smirk that you barely registered on his face, and it was no surprise your foggy mind was confused.
"Wh-what are you- AH!"
Before you had time to finish your sentence, his cock was sliding out of your sensitive hole that tried to clench around him, and you wanted to whine about the sudden emptiness, but that was cut off too, as he dragged himself off of you, and dragged you to the ground unceremoniously.
You were about to protest as you got on your knees, but was quickly stopped by a hand on your shoulder. Looking up, you were greeted with the sight of his still erect cock, which was very angry looking and very wet from the both of you.
Had he not been holding you back, you would probably have dived right in and sucked him off. But it seemed like he had other plans as you watched him begin to jerk off in front of you.
"Fuckin' shit [Y/n]," he hissed the slick sounds of him pumping his cock now echoing in the room as you watched him with eyes still dark with lust.
A shock of thrill ran up your spine as you automatically stuck your tongue out ready to catch his seed, your hips already rocking back and forth as that familiar pressure began to grow again.
"Mmm yeah going swallow everything I give you aren't you? I bet you let me come all over your face too. Make you go to that useless piece of shit and show him that the only cock that's gonna use you is mine's."
God he was so possessive. Had it been anyone else, it be irritating, yet, by the way you clenched at nothing from his words, your body seemed to agree with him.
"Do it then, come on my face Eli," you purred as your hands found purchase on his thick thighs, and you lifted your face upwards towards his cock so he could make a mess of you. "Paint my face sir please, please, please want it all over me. Want you to mess me up please come sir please~!"
The wanton begging, paired with the way you licked your lips and humped the ground waiting for him to shoot his load on you, seemed to spur him into a frenzy.
He pumped himself faster, the grip on his cock tightening just as his balls did the same. Ready to empty everything on you, and before you both knew it, hot liquid began to spurt from the angry tip onto your face. It landed on your forehead, cheeks and some of the salty liquid landed on your tongue, which you savored as you watched his face twist in pleasure and a loud shout of your name left his lips as he emptied the sticky, hot seed on you.
"Tilt your head up," he gritted out, and while you didn't know why, you did what you were told, exposing your neck to him as he continued to spurt the last of his cum on you.
Hot stripes of liquid landed across your collarbone, and you let out a watery moan at the feeling of being made a mess of. God you probably looked insane right now with his cum all over you, but boy did it make your cunt want some more of him.
With that little show though, it seemed he had finally completely emptied himself as he let out a satisfied huff as he looked at you. A smirk crept onto his features as he took in his handy work, and you could only imagine what was going through his mind.
Probably something along the lines of doing it again or whatever. Not that you would protest. But what came out of his mouth next had you sputtering a bit with how out of pocket it was.
"Next time maybe if you show him that necklace I just got for you, he'll pay more attention to his work than thinking about fucking you."