Part two of this ficlet because it’s Billy’s birthday and he deserves something nice, and also because everyone was begging me to write a part two lmao. here you go :)
There’s a note in his locker the next day.
Quarry after school? – Steve
Billy crumples it up and tosses it.
A tiny part of him twinges at the thought of Steve waiting for him there all night, but the rest of him is pleased by it. He kind of wants Steve to suffer a bit after the hours Billy stayed up crying last night. He also wants Steve to be that desperate to see him.
He avoids Steve all day. Doesn’t look at him in practice. Sticks close to Hagan, because the guy repels Steve like the plague these days.
Steve never did tell him why that is. Guess now he’ll never know.
Steve keeps leaving little notes. Billy wonders, idly, what Steve’s friends think about that. If they’ve ever caught him slipping a piece of paper into Billy’s locker and asked questions. Thinks Steve’s way too good a liar to be worried about it, anyway.
Billy reads all the notes. Then trashes them. Can’t bear to stick them in his pocket. Refuses to carry around a piece of Steve after he hurt him.
The notes get longer. They go from quarry? to talk to me to Billy, please just let me explain, I didn’t realize how it sounded and then one day they stop altogether.
It makes Billy almost wish he’d said something to show he was reading the notes, just to get Steve’s hopes up. To make him keep leaving them in increasing desperation.
Billy doesn’t ever want to be alone with him again, but he wants to hurt him. So it’s a shame when that method disappears.
Billy kind of misses it, also. Proof that maybe Steve still cared. Ever cared at all.
He’s not sure how much anger is towards Steve for hurting him and how much is for himself for not being able to get over it already.
About a week after the notes stop, the worst happens. Steve actually manages to catch Billy unawares and alone.
The moment Billy realizes what’s happening – that they’re in the locker room, and they’re alone, and Billy fucked up and didn’t notice until it’s too late – he gets so angry he can barely breathe.
They’re both dressed by now, thank god, but Steve’s approaching him with his mouth already open a bit and Billy sees red.
He doesn’t want to hear it.
So he lunges and slams Steve back against the locker and tells him exactly that.
“I don’t wanna hear it, Harrington,” he snarls, his forearm pressed hard against Steve’s chest, keeping him shoved back without having to touch him with his hands. “Fuck off.”
“Woah,” Steve says, like he’s actually surprised, like he didn’t expect Billy to get this angry. Fucking idiot. “I just – ”
Billy slams his hand into the locker right by Steve’s head. Steve flinches but he doesn’t move. Doesn’t stop talking, either.
He cocks his fist back. Steve doesn’t even have the decency to look scared. He just stares at Billy, his wide doe eyes never glancing at the raised fist. Like he doesn’t believe Billy will hurt him.
Maybe he’s right, because Billy actually gives him another chance.
“Get out,” he says, slowly. Really emphasizes every sound.
“There is no other guy,” Steve blurts. “I lied.”
Billy’s lip curls back. Steve’s gaze finally flicks over to his raised fist.
Apparently Steve takes that as his cue to keep talking, because he’s an actual idiot. Maybe he figures this is his last chance to get it all out and know Billy heard him, which is kinda fair. Billy still hates it.
“It’s just, every time I go out with a girl you just let me go, so I thought maybe it would be different,” he says, rambling fast. “I wanted to see if you’d get jealous at all because I really like you, Billy, and I needed proof that you actually wanted me?”
Billy stares at him. He’s sort of lowered his fist, awkwardly, though he’s still keeping Steve pinned.
Billy must sound as incredulous and confused and pissed as he feels, because Steve cringes and barrels on.
“I thought if you got mad about me maybe going out with a guy, that would prove you wanted to go out with me.” Steve sounds kind of sheepish. His voice is quiet. Embarrassed, maybe. “I didn’t think at all about how it would sound, I… I really like you.”
Billy stares at him for another long moment. Slowly releases him from against the locker.
“You lied,” he scoffs. “Jesus fucking Christ, I knew it.”
Steve’s nose wrinkles up. It’s his turn to be confused. “What?”
“The moment you said it was the last time, I knew you lied.” Billy shakes his head. “I knew it, and I let you talk me into thinking you weren’t full of shit.”
Billy taps his foot. “You’re an idiot.”
“I’m an idiot,” Steve agrees.
“No, I wanna hear that one,” Billy says, folding his arms over his chest. “You’re an asshole.”
Steve makes a sound suspiciously close to a laugh. “I’m an asshole.”
“Glad we’re finally on the same page,” Billy replies. He looks at Steve consideringly. “I still kind of want to punch you.”
“That’s fair,” Steve says. “You probably should be angry.”
“Don’t tell me what I should do,” Billy snaps.
Steve does that breathless huff of a laugh again. “Yeah, okay, Billy.”
Billy licks his teeth. Stares at Steve. “If I punch you, will you still go out with me?”
Steve frowns, but like he’s thinking, not like he’s mad. “Not the face,” he bargains.
“Yeah.” Steve’s got a little pink on his cheeks, now, which is weird, because Billy’s talking about punching him. “I wanna look nice for our date.”
Billy’s still kind of pissed but he doesn’t really want to punch him anymore. Damn Harrington.
“Alright, fine,” Billy says, like it’s a huge burden not to punch Steve, actually. Like he’s really letting him off easy.
And then Steve’s biting his lip like he’s trying to keep from smiling, and that won’t do at all. So Billy kisses him, coaxing his lip out from between his teeth. He keeps kissing Steve, quick little chaste presses until Steve is huffing a laugh against his mouth like what’re you doing, idiot and yeah. That’s good. That’s really good.
Steve laughs again, and opens his mouth, maybe to say something, but Billy doesn’t give him the chance, pressing into his open mouth.
Steve still manages to giggle, and wraps his arms around Billy’s neck like he missed him.