[through gritted teeth] the dark path was such a fun read guys
↑ other things i find interesting: the first two as a doctor/master parallel + the third included because despite his declaration that he is no longer koschei but the master, the book continues to refer to him as koschei.
Using the Doctor Who EU to show how Gallifrey survived the Chibnall era - 2026 Edition
So way back in 2024, I published my first essay on here, about how Gallifrey was not destroyed in the Thirteenth Doctor era, despite appearances. I am incredibly proud of that essay, but I have changed how I write essays in the year-and-a-half since then. Also since then, we have gotten more information about the supposed destruction of Gallifrey that I want to address. So I have my original essay replicated in full here, with some additions and a little bit of extra commentary from now. I don't know if this is gonna be of interest to anyone else but me, but I hope you enjoy!
Oh and if you want, the original essay still exists here
So. I'm actually a big fan of the Chibnall era of Doctor Who. That being said, I still don't like some of it's plot points, and so, consequentially, I have a handful of headcanons that use the Doctor Who expanded universe to address those, and I feel like they are worth sharing. We're gonna start with Gallifrey's destruction at the hands of the Spy Master. I don't like it for a number of reasons, but I think the biggest one is, like, how did the Master even do that? How did he destroy Gallifrey so completely while also leaving enough bodies behind to make the CyberMasters?
Well, let's find out. Buckle up, because this is gonna get complicated.
Okay, ground rules first. Anything seen on tv, happened. I can recontextualize as much as I want (and I'm gonna do that, believe me) but it still has to fit with everything we see onscreen. I also have to use all of an EU source if I use it. No picking and choosing bits.
Aww, me explaining my basic thought processes like that. That's adorable. I kind of take this stuff as read at this point.
With that out of the way, let's meet the stories that are our players:
Ascension of the Cybermen / The Timeless Children: the tv episodes that gave us the most details about the Master destroying Gallifrey. I'm gonna assume if you're reading this, you're familiar with.
Hell Bent: the other big Gallifrey episode of the new series. I'm assuming familiarity with it, too.
The Time of the Doctor: The only other tv episode I'm going to reference, again for Gallifrey reasons.
Down the Middle: a prose short story collection first released in 2020, and the crux of all the arguments I will be making here. While not licensed by the BBC, it does feature licensed use of prose companion Chris Cwej (among many other things) making it a valid part of the expanded universe. The first installment of the Cwej series. I will be talking about pretty heavy spoilers for Down the Middle here, so go away if you don't wanna see that.
The Dark Path: a book featuring the Second Doctor and, notably, the Master, released in 1997.
Alien Bodies: a book featuring the Eighth Doctor, released in 1997.
The Taking of Planet 5: a book featuring the Eighth Doctor, released in 1999.
The Book of the War: a... book (it's hard to define) that is styled as an in-universe guide to the world of Faction Paradox. If you're not familiar with, Faction Paradox is a sci-fi series that spun out of elements of Doctor Who books. It contains nothing owned by the BBC, but does contain elements and characters from Doctor Who books (specifically the Eighth Doctor Adventures book series), making it also a part of the expanded universe.
The Clockwise War: a comic serialized in Doctor Who magazine, and later released in a collection of the same name. Features the Twelfth Doctor and Bill Potts.
And Today, You: an installment of the Cwej series released in 2023. Set some time after Down the Middle from the perspective of Chris Cwej and the Time Lords.
I don't really do story lists like this anymore - it turned into something that was more effort than it felt like it was worth. But if you're keeping track, I'm gonna bring Wish World / The Reality War, the short story Time's Frey, and the Virgin New Adventures Cat's Cradle: Time's Crucible and Lungbarrow into this essay.
I've taken to dividing my longer essays into chapters, so: Chapter One - Context
Okay. Let's get started. Because of copyright restrictions, different parts of the expanded universe use different terms for concepts, events, and characters that are or could be interpreted to be the same. I'm going to go through some of the books I just mentioned and define how they approach these terms and the lore/worldbuilding they establish, so when I actually start making arguments, I can refer to these concepts in a consistent manner.
The only thing The Dark Path brings into this is that it established that Koschei was a name the Master used before calling himself the Master. That book does a lot of other great stuff, but that's the only thing relevant to this discussion.
Alien Bodies was the first book to introduce an arc about a future War (called the War in Heaven) across time between the Time Lords and some unnamed Enemy. While the Gallifrey of the Doctor's present was not yet a part of the War, they were aware of the war and trying to prepare themselves for it. This thread gets continued throughout the series of the Eighth Doctor Adventures book series, with Gallifrey becoming more militant and dangerous in preparation for the War.
So, uh... this sound familiar to anybody?
Legally speaking from the perspective of copyright, the War in Heaven as introduced in Alien Bodies and the Last Great Time War of Doctor Who's new series cannot be confirmed to be the same conflict. That being said, I totally think they're the same thing. Mostly just because "a massive war in space and time that was after the start of the Eighth Doctor but before the Ninth Doctor in which Gallifrey and the Time Lords went from a passive people to warmongering maniacs and the universe was nearly destroyed in the process" is a description that fits both the War in Heaven and the Last Great Time War and, like, the fact that the show and the expanded universe never references there being two conflicts like that. Not everything works perfectly together, but that seems reasonable in a War that heavily involves changing time and history. I'll hopefully do another big post like this weaving all of the War in Heaven stuff with Last Great Time War stuff together a bit more seamlessly, but for now, I'm going to take it as stated that the conflicts are the same.
Yeah I still need to make that essay. It's a longtime ambition.
That tangent aside, one of the books that was seeding Alien Bodies' upcoming War in Heaven was The Taking of Planet 5, which notably introduced the idea of the Nine Gallifreys. More specifically, the idea was that the Time Lords had made at least nine identical copies of Gallifrey to be used as decoys in the war - and that it was possible that multiple Gallifreys thought they were the original.
If you're thinking "oh, so the Master destroyed a copy of Gallifrey, not the original," then, well, yeah. So did the guy who came up with the idea of the Nine Gallifreys in the first place. And that is where this is going. But that actually doesn't answer how the Master was able to raze a Gallifrey. We've still got a lot more digging to do.
The Book of the War was the first release of the Faction Paradox series, and it took the War in Heaven idea and divorced it from Doctor Who. It still had the same players and was explicitly set in the same continuity as the Eighth Doctor Adventures books it had launched from - just with some things renamed to avoid having to get license from the BBC. The Time Lords became the Great Houses, Gallifrey became the Homeworld, and so on and so forth. But this is still the same War in Heaven, and so I consider it still an account of the Last Great Time War.
Chapter Two - the Cwej War
One thing The Book of the War introduced was the Cwejen. To make a long story very short, the Time Lords spliced the timeline of one of their agents, Chris Cwej (former companion of the Seventh Doctor, although that's not actually relevant to anything happening here). By doing so, they were able to start manufacturing time-clones (look. I'm doing a lot of simplifying here) which were then considered a new species called the Cwejen. The Cwejen were used as agents and as foot solders during the War. (This is basically Doctor Who's equivalent to Star Wars's Clone Troopers.)
Okay, now we're ready for Down the Middle. This is where things get really fun.
Down the Middle is set after the conclusion to the War in Heaven, which I am claiming was the Last Great Time War. Thus, from Gallifrey's perspective, it is set after Gallifrey returns to the universe, as shown in Hell Bent. It features the Time Lords, or, well, the Superiors. Much like Faction Paradox, the Cwej series can't explicitly say things like "Time Lords" or "Gallifrey" without getting copyright struck by the BBC, so they say "The Superiors" and "The Base of Operations." I'm gonna stick with the BBC terms for sake of consistency though.
Down the Middle follows Chris Cwej, still as an agent of the Time Lords, as he does missions for them. It also spends a lot of time looking into the Cwejen and what their life was like after the end of the War. The first like 80% of the book is very good but also not relevant to what I'm doing here, but towards the end of the book, the High Council of the Time Lords decides to execute Chris for... reasons (look I'm trying to not spoil stuff). However, Chris proves harder to kill then expected, and he guns down the Time Lord President before escaping. This would be bad already, but the Time Lords decided to broadcast Chris's execution to all the Cwejen to make an example of him or something.
This backfires. Badly.
The Cwejen, outraged and inspired, rise up against the Time Lords. The Time Lords are completely blindsided by this, and by the time they get their act together the rebellion is too big to be stopped. Chris Cwej, exhausted from the events of... previous stories in the book... and not wanting to be in a second war following his survival of the War in Heaven, takes a stasis pod to an empty planet and puts himself into stasis without any real intention of ever coming out of it. In Chris's absence, a Cwej named Thomas Mackeray becomes the leader of the Cwejen Uprising.
This brings us to the last story in Down the Middle, Rebel Rebel.
The plot of Rebel Rebel is as follows: The Cwejen uprising has been raging for fifty years. A Cwejen named Tina visits the ruins of Gallifrey's Capitol and finds the head of a cyborg - in the first edition, it was a Cyberon and in the second edition it was a Cryptopyre (I'm gonna circle back around to this) - and uses it to access the data from the cyborg's hive mind. This data contains the resting place of Chris Cwej. Tina and her girlfriend Frey use this information to travel to Chris Cwej's resting place, where they dig him up and revive him. Tina and Frey want to escape the warzone raging between the Time Lords and Cwejen, so they take Chris Cwej to Thomas Mackeray, hoping Mackeray will grant them safe passage from the war in return for Chris giving official support to Mackeray's rebellion.
The problem is that Mackeray is a bloodthirsty tyrant who has become no better then the Time Lords. He's currently held up on a former Time Lord structure called simply the Tower. The Tower has the power to change history, and Mackeray wants to use it to destroy Gallifrey from before its natives became the Time Lords to wipe the Time Lords from history (It's implied that some Time Lords are still around, although they are fighting a loosing battle against the Uprising). Mackeray can't use the tower himself, but Tina and Chris both could. When Chris refuses to give Mackeray support, Mackeray throws Chris down to the bottom of the Tower. Frey is able to save him from falling to his death, but in doing so, she uses up much of her life energy and is left near death and also at the bottom of the tower. Chris and a dying Frey explore the bottom of the tower, and they find there is actually a Time Lord down there. He seems to be imprisoned. He claims Mackeray has no idea he's down there. And he's only identified as Koschei.
Oh and btw the copyright page of Down the Middle says that the character of Koschei is copyright to the person who wrote The Dark Path (David A. McIntee). Chris and Frey just discovered the Master.
The Master tells Chris that he can save Frey's life and give both Chris and Frey safe passage to the top of the tower if Chris promises to listen to the Master's words at a time of the Master's choosing. Chris is aware that it's a trap, but it's Frey's only hope, so he agrees. The Master heals Frey, then hypnotizes Chris. Chris blacks out. When he wakes, the Master is gone, but he is able to get back to the top of the tower.
It's not specified which incarnation of the Master this is, but the dialogue fluctuates rapidly from polite conversation to unhinged mania in a way that feels very Spy Master. He goes on a rant about how he wants to painfully murder all the Time Lords, then tries to pass it off as a joke. He also claims to have been locked in the Tower after trying revolt against the Time Lords, but also claims he would rather them in power over Mackeray. Visually, he is described as being blurry and painful to look at, which is explicitly a result of being in the core of the Tower with all the intense time energy being thrown around. I don't have conclusive proof that this is the Spy Master, but I think it fits.
In any case, Chris and Frey return to the top of the Tower, where Chris confronts and defeats Mackeray and accidentally begins the Tower's destruction. He then tries to use the the Tower to change history to remove the Cwejen Uprising and the bloodshed it has caused from history, but the Master takes telepathic control of Frey and uses her to stop him from doing the job properly - and the Tower fully destructs before he can get another chance. The universe is left as a combination of how it was before the Cwejen Uprising and how it was after that.
Chapter Three - What Happened to Gallifrey
Before I proceed, I need to circle back around to a few things. I totally believe that the Master was imprisoned by the Time Lords after a failed revolt - a revolt he started after stumbling across the secret of the Timeless Child in the Matrix. I think he's trying to play the Cwejen and the Time Lords against each other, and his telepathic gambit at the end was an attempt to leave both destroyed or subdued. Also, I promised I'd circle back to the Cyberon and the Cryptopyre. The Cyberon are an imitation Cyberman owned by BBV. When Down the Middle was first published, BBV and Arcbeatle Press (Down the Middle's publisher) were working together and sharing IPs. Since then, BBV has come under controversy for shady behavior, and Arcbeatle has cut ties with BBV - hence changing the Cyberons to the Cryptopyres. Arcbeatle plans to publish more stories with the Cryptopyres in the future, but with the information we currently have, I am going to consider the Cryptopyres to be a subset/offshoot of the Cybermen, much like the Cyberons are implied to be related to the Cybermen (or as strongly implied as BBV can get away with without being sued).
So, how did the Master destroy Gallifrey? The Cwejen uprising destroyed the place (while leaving enough bodies for the Master to use later), possibly with the Master's help. Then he used Chris Cwej to wipe the Cwejen Uprising from history, ensuring that the army that had ransacked Gallifrey couldn't turn against him without rewriting the destruction of Gallifrey itself, He would later bring the Cybermen to Gallifrey's ruins, leading to there being broken Cybermen on Gallifrey (after the events of The Timeless Children), and Tina would later find a Cyber-head on Gallifrey to lead her to Chris.
There's one small problem with this though. I still haven't recapped the final scene of Rebel Rebel (oh and btw I have actually managed to avoid spoiling some of it so if this sounds good please please check out Down the Middle I love it so much). After this whole mess, Chris is contacted by the Time Lords. They survived after all. The Time Lord who contacts Chris (who is strongly implied to be Romana, by the way) tells him that Gallifrey exists again and is really angry at him, but also can't do anything about it because they don't want to kick-start the Uprising all over again. Romana and Chris come to a basic agreement that Chris will work to help repair the residual damage left by the Uprising, and Romana agrees that Chris will no longer work for the Time Lords directly.
So... how did that happen? Well, do you remember what I said about the Nine Gallifreys Project? An earlier story in Down the Middle sates that even after the War, the Time Lords still have the technology to create Gallifreyan cloneworlds. So I believe that when the universe was setting itself into the new timeline that Chris was trying to create (and that the Master hijacked), the Time Lords were able use that technology to mean that in the resultant timeline of the universe, there were Gallifreys at the same time. One where it was destroyed by the Cwejen, and one where the Cwejen Uprising never happened, with the latter hidden somewhere and the former where you would expect Gallifrey to be. The Master was completely ignorant of this, discovered the destroyed Gallifrey, and concluded his plan had worked.
I have a couple pieces of outside evidence to support this. In Hell Bent, Ashildr/Me is seen in the ruins of Gallifrey right before the end of time with the implication that she had been brought to Gallifrey by the Time Lords; if the Time Lords had been wiped out by the Cwejen (or the Master, or whatever) then it wouldn't make sense for her to have survived. To paraphrase the Doctor, she's immortal. Not indestructible. Similarly, in And Today, You (set after the events of Down the Middle), Chris is aware of the appearance of the Fourteenth Doctor and the events of the Flux. It's possible that the Time Lords could have looked into the Doctor's future, but the general expanded universe consensus is they don't do things like that, so I take this as more evidence that Gallifrey and Chris survived through the Thirteenth Doctor's era.
Chapter Four - the Rani
The Rani's account in Wish World / The Reality War complicates this slightly. She gives a few details about what actually happened in the razing of Gallifrey: she claims that she "saw it coming. The genetic explosion. I had a split-second, flipped my DNA, made a biological side-step. Survived the carnage." She also claims that the "genetic explosion didn’t kill us. But it roasted us. And sterilised us. Extinction is taking a bit longer, that’s all."
The Rani appears to be implying that the Master released a fast-acting genetically activated... something on Gallifrey. However, the lack of details she gives about this does give a decent amount of wiggle room, especially since the Master is not explicitly mentioned anywhere in Wish World / The Reality War. The ruins we see of Gallifrey in The Timeless Children clearly show that something physical happened in the Capitol - the Capitol we see is visibly damaged, making it less likely that the Master released some sort of plague or something. So, if we continue working off of the assumption I established from the Cwej series, what does that mean for the Rani's account? We know from the Cwej series - I'm thinking of the short story Time's Frey - that the Cwej have instinctual reactions to anyone with Time Lord biodata. Assuming a connection between biodata and genetic data seems reasonable, meaning that if the Rani was able to hack her own biodata and genetic data, that would allow her to go unnoticed by the Cwejen long enough to escape. (Heck, her hacking her own biodata would also explain why she bigenerated). Of course, then given that the timeline in which the Cwej burnt Gallifrey was destroyed, it makes sense for the Rani to have only a loose understanding of what actually happened, and thus been out of the loop for the con Gallifrey was pulling and unable to give a detailed account of what happened.
None of this actually explains the genetic sterility thing. Time Lords being genetically sterile had been a concept for a while, however. The book Cat's Cradle: Time's Crucible established that Time Lords had been sterilized by Pythia's Curse in their ancient history, and had been using Looming Engines to reproduce ever since, and the book Lungbarrow features the ultimate removal of Pythia's Curse in the modern (pre-War) era. The Book of the War and other Faction Paradox stories reference Time Lords no longer being sterile post-Lungbarrow, although Looms are still commonly used.
However, in Wish World / The Reality War, the Rani and the Doctor both claim to be sterile again. Why? My best guess comes with the context of Pythia's Curse. The end of that curse happens well after both the Doctor and the Rani were Loomed, so while we know formerly infertile Time Lords gained the ability to sexually reproduce, their fertility could, theoretically somewhat dependent on their connection to Gallifrey. We know from other sources (including The Book of the War) that Time Lords maintain some sort of connection to their home planet. So since the Doctor and the Rani were totally disconnected from Gallifrey, they both lost their "cure" to Pythia's Curse, rendering them both sterile once again.
Chapter Five - Some Final Context
Okay the last thing I want to do is talk about why the Time Lords handled this situation in the way they did. Why let the Master think Gallifrey was dead? Why let the Doctor? If the Time Lords know about the Fourteenth Doctor, then they would also presumably know that the Doctor thought Gallifrey dead. It does come up a lot in the back half of the Thirteenth Doctor's era.
I think the answer comes in Hell Bent. The Doctor shows up on Gallifrey, and then immediately leads a military coup that exiles the Time Lord government. Shortly afterwards, he shoots down General Kenossium, one of his biggest supporters, because Kenossium was trying to prevent the Doctor from breaking the laws of time. The Doctor is a hero to Gallifrey, sure. But he's also incredibly dangerous to it. Whatever government put itself together in the aftermath of Hell Bent has an excellent reason to fear the Doctor returning, because he could tear anything they do to shreds. And they know he would, because he has. Not too long after that, in The Clockwise War, Gallifrey is nearly brought to its knees by an entity known as the Absence. At the start of Down the Middle, an off-worlder manages to assassinate the Time Lord president. It was stated in The Time of the Doctor and Hell Bent that Gallifrey needed to hide from its many enemies, and it was clearly doing a pretty bad job of it.
At the same time, the Cwej series shows that the Time Lords are actively trying to rebuild their powerbase after the War. They don't want to just run and hide, they want to hide while climbing back up to their former glory. And the best way to keep Gallifrey safe was to fake its death. Now the whole universe thinks Gallifrey is dead and gone - including its two most dangerous renegades. So long as the Doctor thinks Gallifrey is dead, he can't confront Gallifrey's underhanded power grabs. So long as the Master thinks Gallifrey is dead, he can't ever threaten it again. So long as the universe thinks Gallifrey is dead, they won't try to destroy it. Gallifrey is safe to rebuild its powerbase.
And while I doubt the Rani was in any way the intended target for this con in the same way the Doctor and the Master were, but I don't think Gallifrey minds her loss either. While she had been invited back to Gallifrey during the War (she gets alluded to being on Gallifrey again in The Taking of Planet 5), given how she was kicked off the planet for being a loose cannon in the first place, it makes a lot of sense that Gallifrey would be very willing to roll with her thinking of them as dead.
If you have any thoughts on my theory, please do let me know! And I'm hoping to be posting more in-depth headcanons like this tagged under "heartshaven's headcanons" so keep an eye out for that if you enjoyed this. I really enjoyed typing all this out, so thank you for reading!
Why do you call the Master "Koschei"? And what made you start using that name?
I've read the Dark Path
Fan Fiction
Other members of the fandom
Old internet forums
I don't know
Other (please share!)
Voting ended onDec 24, 2024
With the sad passing of David A. McIntee, we're going to discuss his novel, "The Dark Path." However we would love to know how it is that the name Koschei spread so far through the fandom.
Please share how it was you came to know the Master by this name, we would love to hear from as many people as possible! Reblogging would also help so that we can reach others. (I'll be sure to credit/shout out anyone who's comments we happen to read out on the podcast)
I finished the Dark Path and that was really interesting.
So this book is just before Fury of the Deep. The Doctor, Jamie, and Victoria end up on a planet where a group of humans have managed to use a machine in conjunction with the connection to the time vortex by location, in attempt to make themselves immortal before trying to turn all life in existence human.
The story is interesting, and I am rather intrigued by it, but the overall plot wasn’t as interesting as the characters! We have Koschei, the Master, who is traveling with a woman named Allia. He and the Doctor both got dragged to the planet and are actually happy to see each other. The Doctor rushing forward to clasp his hands, introducing Koschei as his dear friend, you see a glimpse of what they were like once.
But we learn from Allia that the Time Lords see Koschei as unbalanced and concerning. They have appointed her to pretend to be a human and travel with him, reporting back to Gallifrey on him.
When she is killed by his own hand on accident (and he believes she is gone because she is human), we see him begin to unravel. He becomes so determined to bring her back that he actually helps the colony with their machine, wiping an entire planet and everything that lived on it out of existence in his efforts to keep the machine to bring her back. We don’t know how long they have traveled together or what they have been through together but it becomes apparent she is very important to him that he would do all this to get her back.
When he learns that she had been lying to him and spying on him; when he finds her alive with the Doctor; he assumes betrayal by both. He specifically says it is a betrayal by the two beings he cared about the most. Combined with the guilt and pain he’s already expressed in his efforts to bring his friend back only to learn it wasn’t necessary…it pushes him over the edge.
He decides to ‘bring order to the chaos of the universe’, expresses wanting to make it so no one will ever die again or act against instruction. And the scary part is we see the Doctor go through almost a similar thing with the Time Lord Victorious. The Doctor has become so overwhelmed, so hurt and pained by loss and loneliness that he decides to eradicate death, to take the laws of the universe into his own hands. And depending on which universe you accept (snapping out of it with Brooke in the tv show, or after killing the Kotturuh in the extended universe) he eventually realizes he has no place doing that and backs down. But not only does Koschei not do that, he leans into it. He wants power, strength, domination. He casts off his name, saying the one the Doctor knew growing up is now dead and that even the Doctor will call him their master.
We also see the Master deciding to have the Doctor assist in their plans. The Doctor and the Master are always clashing. The Master says about wanting to kill the Doctor, and does make many attempts to do so, but many times we see the Master being just as willing to take the Doctor captive and force them to work under them. These two have just become so entangled in each other’s existence that neither one can really live without the other.
The Doctor and the Master’s relationship in this book is really fascinating and takes the main focus of the book. It’s almost unfair too because Jamie and Victoria have such interesting scenes too. Victoria spending the majority of the book with the Master, being so sympathetic toward him, horrified by his actions and destruction, and deciding that she will leave the Doctor and Jamie at their next location because while she loves them dearly this is not the life for her.
Also the cleaver bit at the end where the Doctor is almost arrested by Allia and how Jamie and Victoria conveniently miss it, keeping the continuity of them not knowing that the Time Lords would want to arrest the Doctor was pretty cool.
The wind blows softly,
On the iron crimson dawn,
Telltaling the storm.
I managed to finish this chapter on time .....I’m the first one surprised! youhou \o/ So, here it is.
As for what’s next, things are going to change a little: we are finally entering the home stretch of the story. To spare you from any horrible cliffhangers, I’ve decided to take two months may be a little more to write the entire ending in one go. My goal is to be able to post the final chapters once a week, rather than making you wait a month between each one! So, don’t worry if you don’t hear from me next month; I’ll be hard at work to ensure I give you the best finale possible to close out this story.
Thank you for sharing this journey with me, dear readers. Next stop: Terminus!
