When J.D. dabbed his mouth with his napkin and did that dramatic, overly-posh little impression, she let out a soft laugh. The playful showmanship was so him, that side he only ever shows when it's just the two of them. For a moment, she admired him, eyes bright, amusement lingering. As if she was trying to memorize it to keep the moment in her mental treasure box of memories.
But then she noticed how J.D. took a second too long before answering her question about Preston. It wasn't a whole pause, just that tiny delay, the kind that made her brain start turning automatically. "Is it because the topic is sensitive?", she wondered, although that also didnāt really sound like something he'd struggle with in the first place. J.D. always had opinions, always had something to say. He wasn't the type to go quiet from discomfort. At least not around her. Still, his long reply filled the space again, and she listened as he talked, even if yet again a part of her kept waiting for the exact thing he wasn't saying.
It wasn't unlike him to ramble like that, at least not in the way that mattered. But a part of Veronica hadn't expected him to say so much about this. He doesn't care about the popular students at Westerberg, and for very understandable reasons, if you ask her. But thing is, he did raise points that landed. Her safety at parties. The way things could go wrong so fast. The fact that someone had been killed at one of them like it was just another night of beer and uncomprehesible tumult. It had been pure luck she was able to skip that one thanks to her sleepover with Martha.
She didn't hate parties entirely. Actually, she liked people-watching, the music, dancing, pretending everything was fine and in harmony for once. Yet she also knew a part of her was on a constant cycle of "sucking it up" while at them. There was always something that soured the night. Preston being one of those "somethings" before he met his end.
It seemed reasonable, if not logical to Veronica. Maybe she'd take a step back from the party crowd for a bit. At least until things cooled down. Until Heather made it impossible for her to decline without turning it into a whole thing.
It was then J.D. said, "Hang with me instead at night-it certainly would be safer for you." Veronica paused. Not fully, but her brain snapped to attention with that particular kind of recognition it always did when she was sure J.D. must be implying something else through his words.
She stared, expression neutral at first, almost serious, like she was steadying her tone before the punchline. "I'm sorry, what? 'Hang out with you instead at night,' you say?" Her gaze sharpened with playful suspicion as she tilted her head. "Oh, okay. I know what this is really about."
She took one of her fries, and pointed at him with it. Wobbling it in circles like it was evidence, she let the words stretch out with theatrical confidence. "You are just looking for ways to convince me to keep paying you visits at night." Her eyes narrowed, but she was smiling again, clearly entertained. "Well, I hate to break it to you, Mr. J.D., but as I told you earlier today, that will not be happening."
She threw the fry into her mouth and chewed, cutting herself off for half a second with a muffled mumble, as she covered her mouth with her palm. "We have to give it sometime, until Clover forgets about... everything."
After listening to his reply, she lowered her hand and went back to listening, because she couldn't deny his sincerity, and some of what he said was unexpectedly empathetic. Veronica had expected him to brush Preston's death off, or at least treat it like another detail in Westerberg's drama spiral. J.D. had plenty of reasons to dislike the popular crowd, plenty of reasons to see Preston as "deserving" in whatever twisted way he framed things when it suited him.
Yet he wasn't doing that. He was talking about grief, impact, and her safety. It made her think, and feel a little uneasy in a different way. When he asked that question, when he looked at her like there was still something he needed to know, her confidence faltered.
Veronica hesitated before speaking, and she hated that her first instinct was to calculate what would happen if she told him the truth. She'd never even considered telling him the specific kind of uncomfortable details she'd lived through with Preston or any other guy at parties. Not to J.D. Not in this version of their world where he was her comfort and certainty, even when he was hiding pieces.
She remembers telling Heather once how she couldn't stand the idea of lying to J.D. Because trust is important, and she doesn't want their relationship to be built on lies. Yet this wasn't just "keeping a secret." It was repeating the same mistake she made with Martha all over again. Lying and hiding things is like a crack at the bottom of the ocean. Unnoticeable, but catastrophic in its nature.
So she decided to be honest. She told herself she'd be brief, careful, and not get wrapped in too much details. She took a breath, let her words start neutral, then struggled, as if they were heavier than she expected.
"Uuuuuh... Not much, really." Her voice stayed was on its higher pitch side, a litle awkward, and her eyes didn't quite meet his the way they normally did. "You know how all popular guys are. Like Ram, Henry, Kurt; huge dicks. Preston was the same."
As she continued, she hadn't realized it, but she had stopped eating. Her hands folded tighter, arms eventually crossing against herself, back pressing against the booth's backrest like she needed the support. Her voice turned more serious. "I just had some uncomfortable encounters with him at parties is all. I always managed to move past him and he'd go away."
It felt wrong, talking about the person's worst sides when he was gone, especially so recently. But it was also true, and she couldn't pretend truth was something you could just erase because it made other people uncomfortable. Her voice did remain a lower tone now, not wanting anyone around them to overhear. "Feels wrong to talk like this about someone who passed away so recently," she admitted, the initial plan to be brief now forgotten. "But it's who he was. People are trying to make it seem like he was this innocent, perfect guy. They only focus in the bright future he could've had but not the reality of what he did while alive."
Veronica's expression turned more serious as she exhaled through her nose, her annoyance mixing with something angrier underneath. "They're all idiots." She leaned back and let the words land with weight. "Two things can be true: Preston Sullivan was no angel, but he also didn't deserve to die like that; nobody does. He was still a human being who had room to grow."