It was dangerous, how simple it was to revert to old habits. Synapses of the brain not yet re-wired, impulses persistent. Beyond ignoring. His hand was near her face, unmistakably tender in its extension. A remnant of happier times. Mattie melted into the ghosted ( not quite ) touch for a beat, then caught herself and reeled automatically back. âDonât,â she warned, eyes unmistakably sad as they skipped away from him. She tried to occupy herself by tracing the lines of her porch railing, the fresh coat of minty paint, the new swing sheâd had installed ( another dayâs distraction, the paint job and bench both ). Her voice was calm, quiet, but uncharacteristically firm. Not a quiver of doubt, despite the questions that still remained. The part of her that could never fully let go of him. After a breath, she continued: âI have to live my life. I canât keep waiting for you to decide whether or not you care about me. Held suspended in Foster Caldwell purgatory.â Perhaps it was harsh, but it captured precisely what their dynamic felt like. Him, keeping her loosely tethered, never able to choose whether or not he wanted to pull her close or release her. Shove her away.Â
              It was hard to decide which was more painful: the agony that was his indecision, or the loss of him entirely. âI know it hurts,â she agreed in that same serene, composed tone. âBelieve me, youâve got no idea. Iâve hurt over you for years. I canât do it anymore.â Her voice broke once, loudly, on years; a chink in her armor that rung through the relative silence. There was nothing to do but press on, fill the space between them with her explanation. She had her reasons, and it was only fair that she communicated them. He was half of the equation, regardless of his reluctance to commit. Mattie tucked a free tendril of hair behind her ear, then kept her hand occupied by twirling it methodically back and forth around her finger. Fidgeting.Â
              âI bet some would be totally alright with the arrangement. Iâm sure youâve got plenty of people willing to be your fuck-buddy.â A word foreign on Mattieâs tongue, not often one to swear. Synonyms evaded her; that was the only way she could accurately describe what theyâd been ( without falling into romanticizing again, without indulging in her fantasies ). Fuck-buddy. It was generic, impersonal even in the familiarity it suggested, and it helped Mattie considerably to embrace that label. As opposed to lovers. As opposed to childhood friends. As opposed to â as sheâd believed until recently â soulmates. Her words were somber, wistful in their honesty. That was the sappy, delusion Mattie; that was then, this was now. âIâm not one of those people. I thought I could be, but I was pretending.âÂ
              She was leaning against the door now, trying to put as much distance between herself and him as possible ( while the other instinct told her to move closer, allow him to touch her, sink into him ). Mattie was determined to remain strong, to fix herself into steeliness. Just the same, the guise had been slowly faltering. The tremor in her throat was indication of that. The way her wide eyes, paled by the daylight, shone wet up at him. Tinged with insuppressible moisture â sheâd always been weak, teary-eyed. A sensitive child with a tender heart. Nothing had changed. Nothing, expect for the fact that sheâd been enlightened to the dysfunction of them. How she gave everything, he as little as possible. âWeâre not good for one another. Maybe just right now, maybeâŠforever.â A thick swallow, tongue sandpaper-dry. âMaybe we never were.âÂ
A visible wince. A recoiled step back. Foster Caldwell purgatory. For a man who had impenetrable walls, who had heard plenty of insults thrown his way and simply deflected them or laughed them off, it wasnât often someone managed to say something that threw him off his guard. In the many years that heâd known Mattie, he couldnât trace back to a single time when sheâd said something that took the breath away from him. Mattie, the girl who built him up, gave him all the love and attention he wanted, had sent him crumbling down. Instantly, he felt his defensive side appear, the part that wanted to argue and defend and prove Mattie wrong. Years theyâd grown up together and learned the ins and outs of one another and here Mattie stood, trying to tell him that he didnât care. That heâd put her through hell. And perhaps he had done exactly that, but it wasnât something he could admit even to himself.
It kept building, the words she threw at him and pushed him farther and farther away. The tether between the two of them was fraying from the tension, Foster trying to cling to it desperately. He couldnât let go of Mattie. He couldnât let go of Mattie. Never had he imagined a life without Mattie right there. He couldnât even remember a time before Mattie. And look what had happened to him when sheâd gone off to the hospital. There was no doubt that Mattie was some sort of stability for Foster. However, it came at the price of all his instability being pushed upon Mattie. âStop,â Foster pleaded, eyes closed as he took another step back and had to avoid stepping off the porch. How had it come to this? Had this always been coming for them and Foster ignored it? Was obvious to it? Could he have fixed it before everything went wrong? This wasnât the end. Foster couldnât imagine it being the end. Mattie and Arch. Forever and always.
When he opened his eyes, she was so far away from him against the door. It was hard to not picture all the variations of Mattie that heâd come to know growing up beside her. All the faces of the two of them growing up through their troubles and their happy memories. It was a photo album in his mind, a flash of memories that only screamed at him not to let it go. Not to let her go. âNoâŠdonât say that,â Foster said desperately. âEverything youâve just been throwing at me, youâre wrong.â Words were failing him. For once in his life, Foster didnât know what to say that would bring Mattie back to him. âI care about you Mattie, thereâs no one else I care more about. For fuckâs sake, I put you even before my own sister. Every time someone said bullshit about you, I was right there to stand up for you even when you were away. I tried to come see you when you were in the hospital but my parents wouldnât let me. When youâre not around, I lose my fucking mind, Mattie. We are good for each other. Youâve always been the one person who keeps me sane, the one person who is always there when everyone else is fucking around.â
Foster was breathing harder, emotions on high. Heâd taken a small step closer to Mattie, eyes soft and begging for her to see the pain. âWhat do you want me to say? Iâm sorry? Hurting you wasnât my intention, Mattie. And Iâm sorry that I donât know what the fuck I want and to be honest with you, I donât know what I want. Iâve never known what the fuck I want. I feel like Iâm spiraling out of control and just floating around and trying to get back on the ground.â Another step closer, but Foster knew better than to get too close and take away that space from Mattie. But god, did he want to just slide a hand along her cheek, to let his thumb caress her cheekbone and look down into her eyes. Draw Mattie into him.
âYouâre the only thing thatâs always been certain. Mattie and Arch. You and me. Donât give up on me, Mattie⊠donât give up on us.â