the 'screw everyone else why didn't you tell ME' line always gets me because how could he not tell her that is the real betrayal. its not that he can kill someone its that he didn't trust her enough to TELL her that he could, trusted her as much as he trusted everyone else and she told him everything always bc she loves and trusts him more than anyone and that's what hurts the most, that he didn't let her share in his pain and be there for him so he wouldn't be alone and help
No. No no no. *enters ramble mode because my brain is a total mess right now, wheeee*
Itâs not that he didnât trust her. Remember, this is John âforever a martyr because heâs a self punishing asshatâ Young weâre talking about here. He was truly scared she would hate him, which is why he never told her. Because eventually the question would be asked âWell, how do you know you can kill⊠have you ever killed someone?â and that was just TOO close to the truth about what really happened to Roger. Letâs be serious here.Â
John only told that story about Roger âlooking for the ârefugeââ to collect people and keep them safe. He never actually expected that Roger would come back. He was 100% sure Roger was dead until Stephen was like âI TALKED TO MY DAD. WE HAVE TO FIND HIS BODYâ.  John really was having a rough fucking couple of episodes there tbh.
And letâs be honest, in the Pilot, John apparently had no idea what file he picked up from the hospitalâ one of those things I squint at because he was literally rifling through doors and had no idea who he was looking for? Originally in the first script, it was John who was like âGuess who I found.â and Cara is the one who is like âIt canât be!â which in retrospect would actually make less, yet more, sense than what they did.Â
I just find it hard to believe John didnât read the name off the file and someone just managed to pluck the file of his previously thought dead mentorâs son who he totally promised to protect 6 years previously.
But less sense, because why would John want to let this kid in? Other than Rogerâs promise and all that, everyone should have known that Stephen would want to find out what really happened to his father. Everyone sorta oopsied and forgot to tell Stephen Jed was his uncle, while weâre at it. I mean, Iâm sure they didnât expect the fact he was gonna bail out, despite the rule of they have to stay for a few days and think it over before they are allowed to leave (John you knew what a little shit Roger was! Did you think his son wasnât going to be the same way?!)
No but John trusted Cara. He loved her. He just was really scared, because everything in his world depended on that one lie not being revealed.
I mean All Tomorrowâs Parties 1x05
and then⊠The Citadel. 1x11? (PS I ALSO WENT AND MADE THIS GIF WHICH IS WHY I TOOK FOREVER REPLYING XD)
And then everything hit the fucking fan, not just the shit.