the audacity of vulnerability
When I was younger, I thought it was weird that people would respond to personal writing as “brave.” What was so brave and difficult about writing about yourself? Now I am starting to understand that openness as an act of great vulnerability--laying yourself bare for everyone to project upon you their anger and contempt and petty cruelty.
Last night, I was watching interviews with Japanese men who lived in internet cafes, generally men who didn’t have stable work and therefore enough money to get a more permanent residence. One of the men interviewed was older. He’d had a decent paying job, but he had to work upwards of 100 hours/week. Not surprisingly, he got really burned out and was diagnosed with depression. He took a month off to deal with the depression, and behind his back, his boss called him weak. Once he returned to work, his boss wouldn’t talk to him and eventually fired him.
While that’s on the extreme end, there’s a tendency in most if not all societies and cultures to view openness and honesty as weakness. That perspective is extremely prevalent in academic science, as I’ve discovered, and it’s really soul-crushing for someone who is frank by nature and yearns for a sense of community and understanding, someone who has diverse interests and dreams of doing something different.
The Japanese man in the interview said that being fired was such a relief for him, and now he dreams of being in a less judgmental society, traveling, maybe living in different countries for a few years at a time.
I turned to my boyfriend, and I said, “Do you see why suicide is so prevalent in East Asian cultures?” (It’s a frequent topic of my morbid jokes, and he hates it, but I can’t seem to stop myself.)
“He seems like the kind of person who would kill himself,” he said quietly.
“But he seems fine. He’s leaving his super oppressive culture.”
“Yes, at the time of the interview.”
I honestly didn’t think of that. I was so excited for this man at the end of the interview, for his grand ambitions that seem so similar to my own. But I should know better. Those dreams don’t matter when you’re in the throes of a deep depression. You don’t have dreams then. You don’t see possibility.
There’s a danger in being so optimistic, in dreaming so big--it leaves you that much more vulnerable to the crushing disappointment of reality, the shame of being so stupid as to let your guard down. I’m starting to see that vulnerability as a transgression, an act of defiance against a world that wants to beat you into conformity and submission. And sometimes, that world wins.