🔥
And now for something completely different, featuring outing myself as a former member of a shit fandom
I was gonna use the sloppy metafiction as a cardinal sin as a way to segue into salting about Homestuck but then I figured fuck it, poorly executed metafiction is one of the least of Homestuck’s problems.
The biggest problem with Homestuck, in my eyes after doing a lot of thinking is that the last chunk of it (everything post Game Over) was utterly unplanned or just poorly planned. Everything was slapdash preparation for the climax, almost everything in the Game Over timeline is just left as a loose end. And its replaced by a fucking saccharine show of characters that we barely know anything about.
And then people will try to argue that this is good writing because Homestuck is about a video game and you lose lives in a video game and shut the fuck up you goddamn moron. If you’d honestly sit through a five hour movie of a guy getting his teeth kicked in by some The Nameless King and actually pay to do so then I’ll concede that you’re beyond help and offer to put you out of your misery myself but if you can make something like that a commercial success that still adheres to professional standards then I’ll concede that maybe I was wrong about how certain parts of one medium cannot be translated into another medium and then I’ll spend the rest of my life quoting Professor Farnsworth whenever anyone asks me how I am.
But yeah, back on track, Homestuck in its final arcs feels rushed. Like Hussie somehow forgot that He needed to write an ending to it until after Game Over. The entire Game Over timeline is just left hanging with next to no closure and John’s retcon powers are promptly forgotten about (which is honestly for the better because they killed the comic enough in their brief tenure)
I could have used this to bitch at length about my absolute loathing for Post retcon Vriska, who holds the position of my least favourite fictional character ever (long story short, everything that’s awful about Scathach and Manaka is present in this iteration of Vriska in particular) but it’s not worth it. I can laugh at Sieg getting his shit pushed in by Karna after all his spotlight stealing and Scathach getting mauled by BerserCu in America and I’ll smile at Arthur killing Manaka but there’s no catharsis for Vriska. She’s a Creator’s Pet and she’ll never get that cathartic moment that fills my salt for those other three with enthusiasm. Homestuck, in brief, is a great set of concepts, brought down by overly ambitious and poor writing.
Now, if you’ll excuse, I’m going invent inter-dimensional the get to to the timeline where Wildbow wrote Homestuck. And I’ll show the people of that Timeline Worm. Also, you all should read Worm
















