(Context: our paladin worships a cheese-based deity and they double as a cheese vendor. Our sorcerer has a pet opossum who is secretly an Eldritch being. The opossum also loves cheese)
Paladin: Your opossum stole my cheese!
Sorcerer: Not my problem. You’ll have to fight him for it.
DM: Roll a contested strength check to get your cheese back from this opossum.
Paladin: Okay, that’s an 18. I’ll definitely get the cheese back.
DM, in disbelief: Welp, the opossum got a Nat 20. The opossum bites your finger, and swallows the rest of the cheese block whole. You take 1d4 piercing damage.











