Definitely Not Casual
Shane Mccutcheon x fem reader
Description: You and your friend Shane had quite a bit in common. You loved to flirt, sleep around, break hearts, that was your thing. You two were even known for it in LA. So when one of your friends ask if you would ever sleep together, it shouldn't have surprised you.
Warnings: 18+, reader is more girly, use of y/n, smut, cursing, uhhh lmk if I missed anything
Word count: 6.5k
Part 2
_______________________________________________
You and the girls walked into the bar, finally in your element again. Well you AND Shane's to be exact.
You did what you always did.
Sit at a table or at the bar with a nice drink, talk with the girls for a minute, then venture off elsewhere to find something or…someone fun. You usually didn't have to do much to find someone though, they always came to you, so that made it so much easier.
Today you chose the bar to hang at.
“Leave the blonde one over there for me, will you?” You ask Shane as you already see a girl approaching you.
Shane looks over to her “Do I get something in return?” Shane asks, leaning closer to be able to hear you, and so you can hear her better.
“A little smooch from the one and only?” You say flirtatiously girly as you can, twirling your hair with a head tilt, and your famous look. Your voice going deeper in that way that always had girls going crazy.
Shane smirked, letting out a low chuckle, leaning closer to your ear “Is that a promise?” She asked so deliciously, causing chills to go down your spine.
You step back a bit, faces close as you look up at her “That's a promise.” You say, a slow grin growing on your lips.
“Blonde is all yours then.” Shane tells you before the girl on your arm pulls you away.
Shane watched you two walk away, shaking her head with a smirk.
Then she took one last sip of her drink before heading off to do something similar.
“Mhm, I think you're super pretty. Like-” you lean down closer to her “I think most girls here don't compare.”
The woman giggles and hits your arm “You're one to talk, gorgeous, but I bet you tell all your women that, hm?” The woman tells you, obviously deep under your charm spell.
You squint your eyes playfully “No I speak the truth only. But if you should know, I treat all my women equally as well and you wouldn't be an exception.”
“Oh, I'm your woman now?” The woman asks, like as soon as you saw her you didn't already know she was going home with you.
“Do you wanna be?” You ask, moving hair from her face with that look.
You look past her and you see someone familiar. It distracts you so much that you don't even hear what the girl says next.
It was…
Jenny??
She was sitting alone, by herself looking absolutely miserable. Probably because of no other than Marina. Dammit you had to do something…
You couldn't let the poor girl sit there like that.
“Uh excuse me for a second, yeah?” You told the woman you were with. She nodded, you think but you didn't really look as you left.
You walked over to Jenny's table, and you surprise her as she looks up.
“Yo Jen, what're you doing here?” You ask, taking a sip of your drink
“Ooo you know just…hanging…” She says awkwardly
“With?? I don't see anyone.” You say blatantly
“Ouch, you didn't have to call me out like that.” Jenny says half laughing
“Sorry…you want some company? We can spice up the night or whatever.” You offer, swinging your hips playfully.
“Depends on what your definition of spice it up means.” Jenny says with a shy smile
It's almost like she already knew how the night would end. Back at your place where she would have the absolute night of her life. It was the least you could do for her with everything going on with Marina.
She even thanked you afterwards. Yeah she really needed that you suppose…
The woman you left at the bar completely slipped your mind, but you knew you'd see her again and you would make up an excuse that she would accept if you laid on enough charm.
The next morning you went to The Planet like you always did, looking like you just came from a fashion shoot, even though you were just up all night with a woman.
“Well if it isn't Y/N, looking beautiful as always.” Alice complimented as you walked to the table, sitting at your spot next to Shane per usual.
“Morning everybody!” You say cheerfully
“So energetic for this time of morning.” Dana half complained, leaning on her elbow.
“Especially for what we saw last night…leaving with Jenny, hm??” Bette points out
“Yeah, what happened there??” Tina asks curiously
You shrugged as everyone listened intently, wanting to know “She was lonely, so I helped her out, that's all.” You say casually
Shane found this amusing while everyone else talked over each other.
“Seriously Y/N?? Do you need to sleep with everyone who has a pulse??” Dana asks, her question cutting through the chaos.
“I did her a favor. Poor girl needed it after everything.” You reason, not finding it as big of a deal as everyone else.
Marina walks over with your usual order, never having to ask anymore.
“Who's this poor girl we're talking about?” Marina asks, as she hands you your muffin and coffee
It seemed no one wanted to tell Marina about anything to do with Jenny so you answered.
“Jenny.” You say, taking a sip of your coffee after.
“What about her??” Marina asks further
“Y/N went home with her last night…” Alice answers carefully.
…
“Oh. Did she now?” Marina answers
“Hey, don't worry about it. I was just helping her out, that's all.” You say, trying to settle Marina's undeniable nerves.
Marina shakes her head with a chuckle “It's funny though.”
Hm?
“What's funny?” Tina asks
“It's like how do you sleep with Jenny of all people before Shane??” Marina asks, revealing the reason behind her laughter
…
Then suddenly everyone starts talking over each other again, like the quiet part was finally said out loud. Like they could finally get this off their chest.
“Exactly!” Alice agrees
“That's what I've been wondering.” Bette also agrees
“Thank you!” Dana says, exaggeratedly throwing her arms ups, like the fact itself annoys her
“You have a point.” Tina adds
You raise an eyebrow at this sudden change in conversation. What the hell are they talking about??
You look over to Shane next to you, and she looks just as confused, but you can't deny she looks like she's having fun.
“Woah woah guys, explain whatever the hell this is please.” You ask, really wanting to know what they're getting at.
Everyone starts talking at once.
“One at a time, Jesus..." You ask
Alice takes over “I would think it's obvious. You two are like the biggest heartbreakers of LA, and you also happen to be close friends.”
You half nod, not all the way getting it yet, so they further explain.
“I mean come on, the two of you already flirt with each other like crazy.” Alice goes on further
“Aaaand I know I've caught you two making out at parties before. Like you don't even try to hide it.” Dana adds
“Okay, but that's just good fun. You know how we are.” You explain, really not getting it
You look over to Shane again, wanting some back up.
She shrugs, “That's just how we've always been.” Shane finally says, arms crossed.
“Exactly, that's our dynamic, it's never NOT been that way.” You agree
Alice actually backs you up here…well kinda. “Okay while that's truue, it's still surprising you have never gone past lip touching to…well touching lips.”
You roll your eyes as hard as you probably ever have. "Never say that again, first of all, second, it's really not surprising. I mean Shane is my friend, is it that hard to believe we've never hooked up??”
“That's not my thing, I don't sleep with friends.” Shane adds as a matter of fact
You agree with Shane there, nodding along.
“Okay that's great and all…but question.” Tina steps in
Everyone looks to Tina, awaiting what she wanted to ask.
“Would you two ever hookup?? Just to do it. Like everyone said you two are super close, flirty and all that stuff. You've slept with every other girl in LA, why not with each other??” Besides being friends. Like if you two weren't friends, we'll put it that way.”
…
The two of you thought about it. Like really thought about it. It was true you two were very close, you did make out from time to time, you flirted, and well…you did find each other attractive…but everyone in LA found you two to be also, so it wasn't a big deal.
When you finally had your answer, you spoke up. Everyone at the table anticipated what you two had to say.
“Yeah, I would.” You say honestly
…
Shane looks over to you, a look of surprise on her face, but she was intrigued too.
You look over to Shane next to you “I would, but not casually…if that makes sense.” You go on
“What do you mean?” Bette asks, tilting her head a bit
“Like if I were to sleep with Shane, it would have to mean something because Shane means something to me, you know? I couldn't sleep with her casually.” You say genuinely
Shane is absolutely fucking stunned at your answer, she just sits there looking at you, mouth ajar slightly. She didn't expect you to have such a thought out answer. She was bout to bullshit with something, but she felt she couldn't now.
In fact, she thinks she would have the exact same answer if she really thought about it.
Everyone was silent, feeling the answer was more interesting than anything.
“Aweeee that was actually kinda sweet, Y/N.” Alice says finding it adorable
“Pretty romantic actually.” Bette says, hiding her smile behind her cup
“Very.” Tina agrees
“I don't think a woman has ever said anything so romantic to me before.” Dana adds
God they're so dramatic…
“Shane, isn't that romantic??” Alice asks theatrically
“I think it's a good answer, and I think I'd answer the exact same to be honest. I'd sleep with her but definitely not for fun. That's a big step from kissing afterall.”
“Really?? That answer is a bit believable for Y/N but not you. That's like your whole thing, it's not supposed to mean anything.” Dana claims
“But it's different because it's Y/N, that's what I mean. Me and Y/N have a different relationship than most so I have a different answer…I don't know. It isn't that deep.” Shane explains, also not finding this all that crazy.
“See, we're on the same wavelength.” You note, nudging Shane's shoulder, with a chuckle, then leaning your head on her with affection.
“No SEE you guys are basically a couple!” Alice claims dramatically
You're starting to find this more fun than annoying so you lean into it.
“Couple?? No never!” You retort then turn your head to Shane.
“You still want that kiss I promised, Shane??” You then ask playfully
Shane chuckled, and if you were paying attention you'd see the slight blush on her cheeks. “Yeah, I'm down.” She answers with her signature smirk.
“Hey, what're you-” Alice starts
You turn Shane's face to meet yours and kiss her in front of the girls, all their jaws dropping knowing you were playing in their faces.
You didn't just give her a little smooch like you said, you really kissed her like you were the only two there. Shane softly hummed into the kiss and you softly chuckled, knowing the girls were flipping.
Bette shook her head with a laugh, finding this ridiculous, Tina rolling her eyes also finding this ridiculous. Alice feels like she's being baited HARD, quite wickedly, especially since she's secretly been their biggest shipper.
And Dana…
Dana just felt lonely.
When you finally pulled back your lips were shiny with saliva. You gently wiped the saliva from Shane's with a playful smile.
“Definitely not a couple, and DEFINITELY not sleeping together.” You say casually, obviously teasing all of them
“Definitely not taking her home tonight.” Shane adds to the teasing
“Definitely not going to my bedroom.” You add
“And DEFINITELY no lip touching.” Shane finishes
Everyone rolls their eyes annoyed “Yeah whatever…” Alice says
They seemed to lay off of you both after you leaned into it, thankfully. While the conversation went back to normal, Shane was still thinking about it though. Which was weird because these kinds of things didn't usually linger. Shane would get those thoughts about you, then they'd go.
They didn't stay…
But this time you stayed on her mind.
The way you kissed her even though you've kissed before.
The way you gave that answer about her, and how surprisingly thoughtful it was. Unfortunately the table was right…it was a bit romantic.
Even the way you laid your head on her shoulder.
That warm feeling in her stomach.
She meant something to you. And you meant something to her.
But maybe you meant more than you should. Maybe just maybe…Shane felt more for you than a friend…
Fuck. She was so fucked…
Shane was knocked out of her thoughts when you started absentmindedly playing with her rings on her fingers. You always did that, but now it made butterflies fill her stomach…which she rarely felt on a day to day basis in general. She didn't get nervous with girls…
Jesus what the hell is wrong with her?? She was fine just the other day…was she just like every other girl in LA that fell to your feet now??
Stupid stupid stupid feelings.
“Hey you okay Shane?” You ask from beside her, moving her bang from her face with care. While you were flirty with Shane, you were also a sweetheart with her more than anything.
“Yeah, just…thinking.” Shane says
“Uh oh, anything but that.” You tease light-heartedly
“You could uh…say that again.” Shane says trying to force a laugh
“Wanna trade rings?” You ask her
“Yeah but I still need that chunky silver one you stole from me.” Shane reminds you
“Ughhh fine, okay. It's on my dresser at home, but I'm not bringing it to you.” You tell her, being petty.
“So I have to come over?? For a ring? Seriously??” Shane asks
“Yep.”
“Fine.”
Eventually you had to get to work so you left, leaving everyone with goodbyes, and Shane with a ruffle of her hair, a hug to her backside. Which once again, you always did but somehow made her heart skip this time.
Shane thought she wouldn't see you again the rest of the day but fate decided to fuck with her. Apparently you happened to be working on the same set as her today, you doing your clothing styling, Shane doing hair of course.
“Shaaaane ahhh!” You exclaim excitedly, jumping onto her with a hug “I didn't know we'd get to work on the same set today! This is so exciting!” You tell her as you pull back
“Shit, we're bout to make this the best damn music video ever.” Shane claims
“Hell yeah!” You respond enthusiastic as can be
This was the first time Shane officially got to see you work on a set and you ran that shit like you owned it. People listened to you and your charm flowed through the whole place, putting a smile on everyone with ease.
Unfortunately Shane was no longer immune to it, but she'd sure try to act like she was for as long as she could…
Luckily this girl named Carmen showed and kept her distracted for a bit. Mostly…
When Shane caught you getting too touchy with the star of the video, she felt this weird feeling inside her that she really didn't like. Once again…you were always flirting with people so that shouldn't have bothered her.
The set went smooth besides that and Shane met someone new who she actually really liked. After the set, you found her before she did.
“Hey handsome! Looks like you did pretty great today. Everyone's hair looked amazing of course, thanks to you.” You compliment
“Nahhh I wasn't the only hairstylist, you're the one who did your big one today with the lead. That outfit was killer. No wonder you're always on these sets.” Shane replies, pushing the compliments to you instead.
“Oh stop, it's about time your talents were taken seriously, and you know it.” You say genuinely
“Thanks Y/N…” Shane appreciates
A warm smile graced Shane's face as she looked down and you were always lucky enough to get to see it so often up close. It was so distracting that you forgot you had something for her.
“Hold on, I have something to show you actually.” You reveal
You pulled Shane to a secluded area which just ended up being one of the fancy dressing rooms.
“What are we doing??” Shane asks, chuckling at this ridiculous situation.
“Shhh just wait.” You hush, as you pull something out of your oversized purse
You pull out a slim leather designer jacket with these golden buttons, a golden intricate design around the collar.
“Y/N…you did not-” Shane starts
“I may have snatched this off the rack without telling anybody…” You reveal
…
“Y/N.” Shane warns
“I KNOW! I just thought you'd look super cool and hot in this, it reminded me of you so I grabbed it without thinking.” You explain
“Hot?” Shane questions slyly
“Even hotter than you already are, of course.” You say playfully. “Will you try it on though? For me??” You slightly flirt with charm
“Whatever you want.” Shane concedes, taking the cool looking jacket, that if she was being honest was exactly her style. You knew her too well.
“Can we even be in here?” Shane asks as she takes her shirt off
Oh…
You turn away shyly even though youve seen her multiple times naked. It stopped meaning anything to both of you after a bit, you were just that close.
You weren't sure why, but the way she so casually got undressed in front of you. It made your face burn up…
Shane noticed your energy and it definitely fed her ego, made her a little…bold
“You can look, you know?” Shane gives permission, a smirk on her face
“Do you want me to?” You ask, despite your shyness, deciding you'd challenge her instead with your own flirtation.
And yes…you look. And maybe you enjoy it??
God she's so fine, it's crazy…
Shane looks back at you as she puts on the jacket, making eye contact that could kill even a straight man.
You didn't waver as she buttoned the jacket up. And Christ she looked exactly how you thought she would. Hot as fuck.
“You like it? Cuz I do.” You say, laying your charm on sweetly
Shane chuckles. Oh you weren't gonna win this.
“Yeah I do like it. You think l look good?” Shane asks
“Super sexy. Makes me wanna take it right back off of you.” You flirt hard, voice slightly sultry, knowing how to play this game with her.
Shane's smirk grew to a full grin. Fuck you were doing a number on her…
“Come take it off of me sweetheart.” Shane challenged
…
How the hell are you supposed to respond to that?? Fuck, she might've won this.
“Why don't you come here then??” You tell her
Shane hesitates.
You were still going…she guessed they'd have to keep going until one of you tapped out…both of you too prideful to stop
She walks over to you, stopping within a few inches. So close, her beautiful natural scent filled your nose almost intrudingly. A welcomed intruder?? And the fact you had to look up at her…
Maybe you could just fuck your best friend and think nothing of it….maybe, but like you said it would have to mean something for you. An actual expression of both of your affection.
You definitely were feeling something right now though. Particularly between your legs…fuck, your lack of self control when it came to sleeping with women…
Shane smirked down at you, moving hair behind your ear.
“What happened? All talk??” Shane asks
Oh hell no.
Your hand ran up her stomach, past her chest, then you started unbuttoning the top. It seemed both of you were too far to stop, too big of egos to admit the other out flirted them.
Maybe you should out fuck her, and she'll shut up.
Shane chuckled as her nose nudged yours. She finally kissed you and once her lips hit yours, you started unbuttoning the top faster. God she's such a good kisser but you were too, so it just all felt right.
Unfortunately your dumbass breaks one of the buttons. Fucking embarrassing…now you just look super eager…
“Fuck- sorry.” You murmur against her lips
Before Shane could say anything, someone started messing with the doorknob to the room.
“Shit.” You whisper
“Looks like you're bout to get in trouble.” She whispers back with a playful smirk
“ME?? You're the one wearing the stolen designer piece.” You whisper yell, now trying to get the top off of her.
“Hey, you're the one who took it. I guess we'll both get kicked off the set and blacklisted.” Shane says casually, the mystery person still trying to get into the room
You have to forcefully unbutton the rest because Shane wants to play around instead, and of course she teases you.
“No date first?” Shane jokes
“Oh shut up, we know dates aren't even your thing. I'll at least go on one…” You say as you peel the top from her to the best of your abilities
Shane laughed at your comment as the person at the door finally found their keys and unlocked it, revealing…
“Carmen?” Shane questions as she turns and sees her. Her bare back facing her l
“Woah, I didn't know you were in here…getting frisky…” Carmen says truly surprised
“No, we weren't…I was just uh..doing a quick fitting, that's all.” You lie
“Oh…okay. Cool.” Carmen says, definitely not believing it.
You quickly go to grab Shane's shirt from the floor and hand it to her. God this is so awkward…
“You’ve met Carmen, Y/N?” Shane asks as she puts her shirt back on
You shake your head.
“Carmen, this is my close friend, Y/N. Y/N, this is Carmen…uh my new friend??”
“Oh so you're like that with all your friends?” Carmen asks with a hint of judgment
…
What the hell is she talking about???
“Okay, that's not fair.” Shane claims
So Shane has been messing around on set…Judging by that comment, they've already done something together, which is crazy because all you got on set today was the number from the star of the video, and some casual flirting. This really shouldn't surprise you…but you felt something biting at the back of your mind.
Jealousy??
No it couldn't be…jealousy wasn't your thing, never was. And with Shane?? You both bring girls home pretty much every night like clockwork, neither of you questioning the other or feeling anyway about it.
So what changed? Was it that dumb question at The Planet earlier??
“Uhh, I'm gonna go. It was nice to meet you though.” You leave them with that before heading out. You didn't care to stick around any longer. You needed to clear your head.
If Carmen never walked in…you might have hooked up with your best friend, when literally that same morning you said you'd only sleep with her if it meant something. You're so pathetic, your reasoning goes right out the door when you want a good fuck…
And you know she would have delivered that, same with you. That's why it kind of bugs you. The sex would be so good, probably amazing. But you weren't going to mess up your relationship with Shane just because you're horny…
Your abrupt absence was felt in the room, especially by Shane. She weirdly felt the need to apologize, but she wasn't sure what for. She just hoped you two were okay after this…
That night, Shane tossed and turned, thoughts of fucking up everything special she had with you ran through her mind. This weird sexual tension that you two had today, the jealousy felt, the way you were all over each other before Carmen interrupted.
It was all different, and Shane wasn't sure what would happen from here. She was…scared.
You weren't much different.
Shane was all you thought about that night. That stupid smirk she always smirked. How she shifted her hair from her face. Like fuck…you felt like all the other girls in LA who fell at Shane's feet. You were immune before…
Now you are just the same…
The question was, what would you two do about this from here?
Well…
Instead of talking about these feelings like normal individuals, you two created another unspoken competition between yourselves. Before it was whoever could flirt better, but now it was whoever could flirt enough to make the other more jealous…
*One night at the club*
You had on an extra tight top that really showed off your upper body shape and chest, your lace bra slightly sticking out under. Your skirt was small and flowy, hair curled and bouncy, something to really grab the women's attention tonight. And Shanes…
She definitely had her eyes glued to you for a good minute when she finally saw you, until that girl Carmen showed up and ruined everything. She just happened to be here when you all were.
You could tell Shane likes her too. She was still in her usual ways though because while you could tell she liked Carmen, she couldn't stop flirting with other women. So now BOTH you and Carmen were getting annoyed.
This is what Shane always did though, why should you think anything of it?? Why should you think what happened between you two would change anything for her??
That's when you saw her.
Shane's eyes caught yours from across the bar and once she confirmed you were staring, a sly smirk grew on her face. She had you right where she wanted.
She wanted you to look. To wish that woman beside her was you. How fucking dare she??
But 2 could play at that game.
If she likes Carmen so much, maybe you could use that.
You walk over to Carmen, maneuvering around the crowd of people to get to her. She was staring at Shane from across the bar, but you'd have her staring at you instead. At least for tonight.
You took one last look at Shane before officially making it to Carmen. When she looked up and saw you weren't in the spot you were before, but instead approaching Carmen, that smirk was wiped right off her face. One now on yours instead.
“Hey, you're Carmen right?” You ask
Carmen turns to you. “Oh yeah, that's me. Didn't know you guys would be here tonight.”
“Well I'm glad I caught you.”
“Yeah?” Carmen asks curiously, titling her head
“Mhm, I know you and Shane have something going on but I'd like to get to know you better myself. There's something interesting about you that I like.” You flirt out your absolute ass
“Yeah? I suppose that's already more effort than what Shane's done.” Carmen admits
You laugh genuinely.
“Mmmhm yeah, coming from someone who's known her forever, she's always been like that. She likes to stay…detached? You know, keep you close but at a distance.”
“Noted…does she do that with you?” Carmen asks
“No…I guess I see a different side of her.” You guess
“I can see that.” Carmen says
“Hm? What does that mean?” You ask curiously
“Oh sorry, I just observed some things. Sheee…she looks at you different. I don't know what it is. When I saw you two come in tonight I thought, damn I definitely do NOT have a chance.” Carmen explains
You tilt your head intrigued, a bit amused.
“Really?? That's so interesting because I've been told by my friends that me and Shane act like a couple but I honestly just don't see it.”
“Well there you go. What's there not to see?? Be honest with me though. Were you two not about to fuck in that dressing room?” Carmen inquires
“We-” You almost lie
“Be. Honest.”
…
“Okay, yeah we were about to, but I'm so glad you came into that room when you did.” You admit
“Yeah? Why??” Carmen asks
“I don't want our first time to be like that, if we were to…” You explain
“Do you not hear yourself? You don't want your first time to be like that…that's not normal for friends to think about, you know? Or do.” Carmen tries to reason
“Okay I understand that but Shane and I aren't normal friends.” You say
“Then what are you?” Carmen asks
…
“We're…you know, like I said friends. Just not normal.”
“I think there's more to that. I think you have feelings for each other.” Carmen concludes
“I think you're wrong.” You deny
“Then why does she keep looking over here?” Carmen questions
…
“She's staring at you.” You try to reason
“Maybe…or she's staring at you.” Carmen suggests
You dare look over to Shane and she doesn't even hide that she's looking at you. She seems annoyed, maybe even more than that with the way her jaw is clinched. The girl she was with looks bored now, all Shane's attention away from her.
She clearly disapproves of whatever was going on over here. This was what you wanted though. Her to be jealous. It didn't feel all that great though now.
You didn't want Shane to be upset, never that. You just wanted her to feel how you felt. You didn't want to admit it but what happened in that dressing room wasn't just some good fun. Not all of it.
You both felt something that day, you did. Something real, and for Shane to just go off to the next girl like you were a nobody was harsh, despite how you knew to expect that.
What you didn't expect was for her to purposely try to make you jealous. So yeah you played in her face right back…
Where exactly would this lead you both?
“What should I do?” You ask Carmen
“Talk to her, I think she'll listen.” Carmen says genuinely
“Then what?? Shane doesn't date, and she's my best friend. I can't imagine us taking that step.” You explain
“Well…you said it yourself. You aren't normal friends.” Carmen reminds
…
“Damn…you're good at this.” You compliment
“My pleasure. And hey don't worry about me and Shane, I think you two would work much better than we ever could.” Carmen assures
“Hot and mature. I see why Shane likes you.” You flirt, now really taking Carmen's appearance in blatantly.
Carmen giggles “Oh stop, don't start flirting with me, go flirt with Shane, you cutie.”
“Yeah whatever, had to try.” You shrug
You look up and realize Shane isn't where she was before. Where the hell did she go??
You leave Carmen to go off and find her. She couldn't have gone far. You sift through the crowd and check every face you run into. You ignore the smiles from obviously interested girls, and even some that were trying to spark conversation.
Suddenly you felt someone grab your wrist and before you can turn around and tell off whoever the hell just did that, you hear Shane's voice close by your ear.
“Come with me.” She says, chills running down your spine as her warm breath hit your ear
You obliged, following her to wherever she'd pull you, ready for whatever.
She pulled you into the bathroom?? Then into a stall.
“Shane, what the hell are yo-”
Shane pushes you against the stall divider, hands then blocking your head as she leans in so unbelievably close to your face.
“Can I kiss you?” She asks almost desperately, her breathing quicker
…
“Uh…yeah.” You nod
She doesn't wait much longer as her lips crash into yours. You immediately pulled her in close by her collar, a delicious moan slipping from her into your mouth.
The kiss picked up almost immediately, as Shane was already pulling at your clingy clothing, and you at her pants belt.
“God, fuck you. I fucking hate you.” Shane contradicted softly against your lips
Shane removed your hands from her belt roughly, pinning them to the wall behind you, causing a gasp to leave your mouth
“You drive me so crazy, Y/N.” Shane reveled
“Fuck-” Slipped from your lips
She kissed your neck, and for sure left her own marks there but you didn't care one bit. You moaned and gasped at the feeling, but that made Shane suddenly stop.
“Youre gonna have to be quiet for me if you want me to help you, okay?”
You nod quickly with understanding, then she continues.
She kisses you again, each kiss more hungry than the last.
Yes you and Shane had kissed before…
But never like this.
Never so consuming, so needy.
Shane quickly removed one of her hands from your wrists, and slipped her free hand down inside your lacy panties under your skirt.
“Oh fu-”
“You wear these panties just for me?” Shane asks cheekyly
“Mmmh, you like them?” you tease breathily, immediately riding her hand
“Id like them better off.” Shane admits
“I like you like this.” You giggle, then gasp as Shane pulls them off quickly and picks you up, pinning you against the wall. Your thighs wrapping around her waist.
“All this cuz I was talking to Carmen, hm?” You tease
“Shut up.” Shane bites back
Shane quickly unbuckles her belt and lowers her pants with her underwear. She then brings her fingers to her mouth, looking you in the eye knowing she's about to absolutely ruin you.
And ruin you she did.
She pound you into that stall wall so good you think you saw the light, and no not the annoying bright bathroom lights. You were supposed to be quiet but that quickly went out the window, and you think Shane actually loved how loud you were. Loved how your nails clawed at her and the walls around you.
“You're so pretty Shane. So pretty while you fuck me.” You whine
Shane grinned “Yeah? Like this?” Shane went even harder. You moaned out for her, head going back against the stall
“So so fucking wet for me, Christ-” Shane praises possessively
Your phone goes off
“Don't answer it.” Shane commands
So you don't.
Some time later though…a familiar voice was heard in the bathroom
“Shane…Y/N…you guys in here??”
Alice.
Well shit.
Shane quickly covers your mouth and slows down. Fuck you were so close…
At this point you couldn't give a fuck to not reveal what the both of you were doing in there but there was definitely a hint of excitement at the thought of having to keep it down to keep your sinful actions a secret from your friends.
“Hellooo?? Don't tell me you guys left without telling us.” Alice calls out, walking deeper in the bathroom, getting closer to yours.
A sly grin grew on Shane's face.
She pounded you roughly into the wall, causing a sound to echo through the bathroom from the impact, and a barely contained whine to escape.
Alice pauses
Then Shane does it again, even harder this time making you throw your face into her neck to hide the undeniable sound of pleasure that escapes you.
“Uhhhh…” Alice laughs awkwardly “That you guys??”
Luckily the other people in the bathroom were able to drown some of your noise out. You weren't just going to let Shane get away with this though.
You suck and bite at her neck, purposely trying to pull the loudest, most delicious sounds out of her. And gosh did she sound like an angel trying to contain her soft whimpers. She even whined which you didn't know she could even do.
Apparently Alice managed to decipher who's whimpers it was despite how quiet she was trying to be because she directly called out Shanes name.
“Shane, Jesus you should've just told me you were with a girl.”
That's when Shane finally spoke, no reason pretending she wasn't there anymore.
“That's my bad.” Shane breathily got out
“Well just hurry up, someone needs to get Jenny home before she starts debating about how Astrology is an evil way to chain people inside predetermined boxes.”
You almost laughed at that, almost. But if you opened your mouth right now, you might just scream out Shane's name so you kept it tight shut.
“Yeah yeah, I'm almost done. Just don't let her get a mic in her hand please.”
Shane picked up the pace again, now no need to keep it down. God you couldn't do it, you couldn't. If Alice doesn't leave now, all of these attempts to keep quiet would've been pointless.
“Jesus, don't hurt the girl…” Alice murmurs as she fixes herself in the mirror
God, can she leave already??? You were getting close now and you weren't sure how much longer you could keep yourself in check.
Shane was grinning like a god damn cat as she saw how your legs started to shake around her and your composure starting to crumble.
“You're close sweetheart. You gonna cum for me, hm?”
“Fuck, fuck-” You softly let out into her neck. God you hope she doesn't recognize the voice…
“I'm gonna go find Y/N, you uh keep doing your thing.” Alice says awkwardly
You clung to Shane and softly moaned and whined into her neck. She was pounding you so hard it felt like she might fuck you through the stall itself. You honestly feel sorry for whoever is in the one next to you…
Alice stopped, thinking she recognized the voice but before she could think anymore about it, Tina rushed into the bathroom, telling Alice Jenny is indeed on the microphone.
They both quickly leave to stop Jenny from herself, finally leaving you to be as loud as you want.
It really only took one last good thrust into the stall wall to make you snap. You moaned so loud you think it's possible the people outside could hear. And God she didn't even stop afterwards, she kept going, her climax soon following. Breathy praises and words of possession into your ear making your legs feel even more like jelly than they already did.
She slowed down after a bit, both of you breathing each other in, her head on yours.
Christ, you two were an absolute mess…
Yes, Shane had to help you walk out, and yes your hair was everywhere but you did not regret a single thing.
And yes, days later she did go over to your home to “grab her ring” that you stole to use as an excuse to go down on you again. Of course she did.
So good that you wanted to buy her a different kind of ring. Yes that good.
And yes you did it multiple times over after that night.
It was good, great even. It was your little secret with Shane.
But…
You two hadn't had that conversation. The conversation where you both admitted you had deep feelings for each other and that the sex was anything but casual.
Sure maybe telling someone during sex to have your babies, that you love them, you can't live without them while tears run down your face could just be sex talk…
Maybe Shane looks at all the women she sleeps with deep into their eyes with sparkles and longing like everything in their lives led up to that moment.
Maybe you're too lesbian…
You weren't good with feelings, same with Shane but she was definitely worse than you.
So yes, you slept with Shane and it meant something for sure. It wasn't casual. But did it really mean anything if neither of you would admit it out loud??
_______________________________________________
AN: My first fic here ig. I had actually mentioned the idea for this one on my other account but never got around to finishing it so here, hope you guys like this. Don't be afraid to gimme ur ideas either : )


















