“Do you believe in absolution?”
It had been a quiet afternoon, which had turned into a quiet evening, and as the last hour of Confession approached, Sebastian was looking forward to being released from his duty and driving home. He hadn’t heard the creak of the bench, only the question from the other side.
It was December 26th and so cold outside that the chill seemed to seep through the chapel’s stained-glass windows and into Sebastian’s bones.
“Of course.” He leaned towards the perforated wooden pane that separated him from the shadowed figure. “God’s mercy is infinite to those who seek forgiveness.”
The silence from the other side stretched for so long that Sebastian began to suspect that the person— a man, from the pitch of their voice— had left as stealthily as he’d approached.
Reluctance wasn’t uncommon. Despite the anonymity of it all, some parishioners rarely came to confession out of guilt or shame— as if they thought the priest was going to be remembering every word, tracking them down by voice alone, and pronouncing their sins for the whole church to hear. Sebastian, personally, had better things to do with his time.
Finally, there was a low and weary sigh, pushed out like a candle-snuffing breeze. “In the Name of the Father, and of the Son, and of the Holy Spirit. Amen.”
“May God, who has enlightened every heart, help you to know your sins and trust in His Mercy.”
“Bless me, Father, for I have sinned. This is my first true confession.”
It had been three years since Sebastian made his vows, yet still, the thought of first confessions made him grimace slightly. It was a daunting thought to know all a stranger’s worst wrongdoings, their secrets, their failings in one sitting. Sebastian found it hard not to judge. He knew it was wrong; a venial sin, even.
“When I was a child, I killed my family’s dog,” the man said. “I lied about it to my parents. It didn’t like me. So, one day, I opened the gate and let it into the yard. It ran into the street and got hit by a car.”
Some inappropriate emotion was trying to claw its way onto Sebastian’s face. He pursed his lips, then shakily and quietly exhaled, forcing his expression to stay neutral. He had heard similar stories before. He had experienced something similar. It still unsettled him, to this day.
Any child could leave the gate open. It was a matter of intent.
At times it was difficult not to construct a monster on the other side of the box. Perhaps it was his inexperience; perhaps it was some form of arrogance. He chastised himself for it but fell into the habit all the same.
“I would dream about it every night. After-”
If Sebastian closed his eyes hard enough, he could hear the screech of tires on asphalt and the crunch of bones. A screaming yelp that had curled around his gut like a serpent: coiled, constricting. The dog’s name was…what had been the dog’s name? He brushed it away with a shake of his head. The man was still talking, and he had missed a few words, caught up in his fantasy.
“-o my desires. I was able to trap a rat. I intentionally hurt the rat before placing it in a bucket. I filled the bucket with water.”
“Rats are pests,” Sebastian said before he could stop himself.
The man’s laugh was at odds with his voice. For while he spoke in a manner that was low, smooth and measured, his laugh (more of a cackle) shattered air like broken glass. He didn’t sound amused. “I took pleasure in torturing an innocent animal. A rat is no less valuable than any other of God’s creations.”
Sebastian flushed at the admonishment. As a priest, his role was to be a (mostly) silent observer, until the time came to deliver penance. He did not apologize. He instead prayed for self-control. Clearly, he needed it, between his wandering mind and loose tongue.
The man continued with the confession, “When I was thirteen, I rejected the doctrine of the Catholic Church and denied God’s existence. Subsequently, I engaged in blasphemous activities, saying the Lord’s name in vain, and actively searching for media that made a mockery of Christianity. I found a fascination in the occult and paganistic rituals.”
There was a certain human curiosity that Sebastian was sure that all people experienced, from the moment that Eve first set eyes on the Tree in the Garden. He knew of the occult and its dealings. He had used a ouija board a time or two (or three), in his youth as well. If anything, he would argue it was human nature to seek out power, to try to take power for themselves. This didn’t mean it wasn’t wrong.
He wondered what the man had tried to do. What had he tried to achieve, who had he tried to summon? How many times had he pricked his finger and let the bead of blood drop? How many animals had he sacrificed, ripped the hearts and lungs out of small brown birds, how many hours had he spent in the back of the city library with a book that would surely be forbidden in his home pouring over Latin texts, his straw-colored (straw-colored? Maybe he was dark-haired. Perhaps balding. Sebastian would never know) hair clenched in his fists.
Sebastian shuffled in his chair to dispel the sudden tingle of discomfort. He had been sitting most of the day, and now he was starting to feel pins and needles. It was that and nothing more. He checked his watch. It was five minutes from the top of the hour. Had it already been that long?
As if he knew that Sebastian was checking the time, the man said, “Father, I must admit I need to leave at six. My boss keeps me on a rather tight leash, he’ll be upset if I’m late.”
“Something like that.” It sounded as if the man was smiling. “I have finished confessing today. These are my sins.”
“For your penance, you should say four Hail Marys and three Our Fathers.” He placed his hand on the wooden panel that separated them. “Please say the Act of Contrition.”
There was no response. Perhaps this man was older, hard of hearing. Sebastian repeated his words louder.
He rose from his seat and exited the confessional. He barely heard the toll of the bells signifying it was 6 pm over the sudden high-pitched, ringing in his ears.
Sebastian didn’t hate his room. It was a sin to hate. It was not a sin to strongly dislike.
The walls were the color yellow-gold color of white wine and the furniture probably hadn’t been replaced since the 1960s. Including the short, wooden-framed bed, the sheets still mussed from the nightmare Sebastian had woken from that morning. The only decoration was a crucifix affixed above the door and a plain-looking poster with the Commandments and the Beatitudes hanging over his desk. The sole thing he had added was a portrait of his martyred namesake, St. Sebastian, next to his mirror.
But, his room was the one site of privacy that he had these days, living amongst five other priests in a rectory. Even then, it seemed privacy was a rare commodity. His clunky old laptop sat in the center of his desk. A hastily scrawled sticky note had been left on its cover.
Used your laptop to print my homily. Thanks.
“Fuuuhh…” Sebastian bit his tongue before he could finish that curse as he opened his laptop. He should have never told Piero his password, but Piero had needed it that one time and Sebastian had foolishly forgotten to change it. It was common knowledge that the Italian priest couldn’t keep a secret unless he was sworn to oath.
The browser history had been cleared, all his tabs closed. He couldn’t even remember what he had last been looking at. Frustrated, Sebastian pinched the bridge of his nose and sighed. He went to find Vernon, fully intent on (politely) giving him a piece of his mind.
“Vernon! Vern-” As he rounded the corner, his yell caught in his throat. Vernon, Piero, and Ezra were at the dinner table, mid-meal. It took a moment for Sebastian to place what exactly was most wrong with this scene, though. Vernon— his gently wrinkled face still and serious— wasn’t smiling. He always smiled.
It was enough to take the wind from Sebastian’s sails and replace it with a gentle chill instead.
“You, uh, need something, Sebastian?”
“Sorry to interrupt. I saw your note.” The silence was so painfully heavy it was smothering him. He had to clear his throat to get his next words out, but his voice still cracked all the same. “Is… everything okay?”
Vernon shrugged a shoulder and twisted his mouth into a fragile grin. It was the smile a lamb that had strayed too far from the flock gave to a wolf: tinged with fear at the edges, a hint of pleading, and regret. So much regret. “My laptop gave up the ghost last night. I hope it’s not a problem that I used yours. I just needed to print.”
“I see. No problem,” Sebastian lied.
Commandment Eight: Thou Shalt Not Bear False Witness Against Thy Neighbor.
As he walked away, he heard someone whisper, “If you’re sure of what you saw, we should tell the Pastor.”
The confessional was dim and cold and it was all too easy to doze off.
One would think that after Christmas, the confessionals would have more activity. Instead, people waited until the New Year and made it their resolution to come to church more often. That was ultimately how he had ended up re-entering the Catholic Church after he had graduated from college, drawn to the sense of community and the promise of repentance. When he was younger, the shame of his actions had burned hot in his belly and he had spent weeks if not months wondering how he could ever be worthy in the eyes of the Almighty. The priesthood had shown him a new way to serve, both himself and his God. Now, he was more than willing to be a leader for his flock and bring them to salvation.
But, today was one of those long and trying days that made him pray for strength and faith. He had spent the first few hours of his day trying to work on his homily, a task that proved near impossible with the little sleep he had gotten. He had taken an impromptu break, and stopped by the offering box, fingers skimming over the meager offerings before he closed the tithing box again. Then, just when he had settled down again, he had been called to an emergency at the hospital for Extreme Unction. He would surely have to perform a funeral in the coming days.
Sebastian jerked awake. “Peace be with you,” he reflexively spluttered, blinking sleep from his eyes.
“And also with you.” The faint rustle of fabric on the other side suggested the confessioner was doing the Sign of the Cross. Sebastian echoed the action and leaned against the back wall, checking his watch while mumbling the traditional words of response that had been seared into his brain. It was five twenty-seven.
“Have you been here long?”
“I have,” was the reply.
“I’m so, so, sorry.” He would get into serious trouble if the Pastor heard about this. Thomas was such a stickler for the rules. “It’s been a long day-”
“I know.” Sebastian turned his gaze to the perforation. Interrupting someone was not a sin, but it was still rude. “My apologies, Father. I left before my penance.” The man from yesterday. Had he come solely to ask about his penance? Sebastian’s question was answered before he had the opportunity to ask. “I come with more to confess.”
“In college, I over-indulged in alcohol. Alcohol bought with stolen money, nonetheless. Then, I helped a friend commit mortal sins.”
“Which sin?”
“Infidelity and premarital fornication. I drove him to a bar, knowing he would engage in sexual activity despite being in a relationship. He made advances on a drunk girl.”
College had been a wild time for Sebastian. He remembered very little of it. Before he had gone to seminary and had begun his training to become a priest, he had partied a lot. It wasn’t really the man’s fault. He had been trying to be a good friend. The friend had been— probably— drunk, so if anything the man was doing them all a favor by keeping a drunk driver off the streets. He’d saved lives that night, even. If it came to murder (of a human) or lust, surely lust had to be the lesser sin.
“I remember being…so jealous. Jealous that my friend was able to enjoy what I could not. So, I purchased and viewed pornographic content. I willfully entertained and even encouraged impure thoughts. I masturbated to images of…” the man sighed heavily, the east wind that parted the Red Sea. Sebastian imagined he was disappointed in himself. Disgusted, maybe. Or maybe the priest was projecting.
He didn’t need the details, Sebastian wanted to object aloud. His stomach began to churn.
“I kept the pictures and put them on my personal computer. I’m in my early thirties. Tell me Father— why do I still look? Why do I still desire?”
There was something cold moving through Sebastian’s gut, slithering up his ribs. The serpent had wrapped around his heart.
Sebastian woke up when the bells began to ring.
The confessional was empty, the curtain swaying gently as if it had just been disturbed.
He tried not to think about the man from the confessional the next day. He had no idea how much of his encounter had been a dream. Mass had been an overall uneventful affair. Attendance had been low, but that was expected for a Monday night. He had been preoccupied with a lurking shadow that didn’t exist, and his homily had gone for too long.
His chest still felt tight.
He dismissed one of his altar servers with a soft word of gratitude and made his way down the steps before the altar. He turned to bow. A flash of movement in his periphery nearly had him jumping out of his skin and he whirled around half expecting it to be Father Thomas, his face flat with disappointment.
It was not Thomas. The words came from a smiling woman with too-blonde, blonde hair in a flower-print dress. Her forehead was a little too big, her eyes just a little too small.
“Thank you.” Sebastian calmed his racing heart with a smile that he hoped didn’t look like a grimace.
“I’m Margaret Nemoto. This is my husband, Yuto.” Sebastian shook hands with the man, squarish and East Asian with short, dark hair streaked with grey. Yuto looked disgruntled. It had clearly not been his idea to approach Sebastian. Was he, perhaps, the man from the confessional?
“Pleasure to meet you, Father.”
With that simple sentence, he was not. The voice was all wrong.
“And our kids Robert and Rachel.” Robert was around fourteen, maybe. His eyes were glued to the screen of his phone, fingers tapping away. Rachel looked about a year older, though she was small and short, inky black hair pulled back in a ponytail. Her features were soft, her eyes a dark brown that reminded Sebastian of the wood of the pews. She met Sebastian’s gaze and smiled shyly.
“We’re new to the parish and just overjoyed-”
Margaret sounded like she had a ball of phlegm lodged in her throat, just begging to be freed by a cough. It was all too easy for Sebastian to tune her out. He found his thoughts drifting back to the man from the confessional, despite everything. He was a priest, one who spoke and commanded the word of God. Why was he so cowed by a layperson, one from his community nonetheless? The sins that the man had admitted to were human flaws, things that anybody could do.
Things that Sebastian could do.
He tore himself from his thoughts, looking back to Margaret. He had no idea what she wanted from him. “My apologies. It’s so nice to meet you and your family. I was just thinking about the programs we have here for young Catholics.” He glanced at the pair of children. They both seemed so young. “Has your son ever been an altar server before?”
Robert’s face scrunched with disgust and Margaret shot him a disapproving look. Sebastian huffed, amused. He remembered a time when that would have been his exact reaction to such a question.
“And if something like that doesn’t interest you,” he continued before the boy could be properly chastised, “both your children are welcome to join us at Wednesday’s youth group. Pamphlets with more information are near the font.”
It was three days before Sebastian went to the confessional again. He had traded shifts with Ezra twice, and then Wednesday had been youth group. He told himself he hadn’t been avoiding the confessional. Rationally, it didn’t make sense for the man to return. Ezra would
have given him his absolution. Just in time for the new year, as well.
And yet. Sebastian had sat in white-knuckled trepidation for hours.
The bench groaned. “I broke my vow,” the man said without preamble.
“What?” Sebastian’s voice was a mere whisper. He felt a wave of dizziness rush over him and had to grind the heels of his palms into his knees to settle himself.
“My wedding vows. I cheated. I use my position of authority and power to take advantage of the women around me. On Monday, I spotted a young woman with hair like ink and eyes the color of oak wood. I knew I had to have her.”
Why was the man here? Why?
“I called her to my office under false pretenses, and when we were alone, I began to make advances I knew she could not refuse. It started out small. A brush of the fingers, my hand on her thigh, as I provided her comfort.”
“Stop.” He felt like he was choking.
“She cried as I fucked her-”
“Stop!” There was something in his throat, crawling up inch by inch.
“I bent her over my desk and told her it wasn’t a sin, since I was a man of God. She was sixteen. I made her praise me, say my name. Sebastian.”
It was a perfect mimicry. The hiss echoed through his head, and for one moment, he could see Rachel, her face wet with tears, eyes open wide as she cried out. His heart pounded in his chest, a fierce anger burning in his belly as he rushed to deny the claim.
“I didn’t…” Sebastian stammered. His hands flew to his temples, tugging his blond hair. “You’re a liar.”
The man laughed, brittle bones and ash and salt. “I do not lie.”
Sebastian forced his heaving breaths to slow to a rasp. He needed to calm down. It must have been Vernon or one of the other priests on the other side. They must have found his diary, or spied on him, or something. “No one will believe you. Get out of my church.”
“Your church? Oh, Sebastian. It hasn’t been your church in a long time. I’ve recited the most grievous of sins that you’ve ever committed. You sat here and absolved me of them as if you have that power. As if you have that authority.”
The last word cut into Sebastian, a sword sharper than any needle he pricked himself with. He needed to run. Run while he still could.
He tore out of the confessional, shoes slapping against the smooth marble of the floor.
“Silently judging me, shamelessly making excuses for each one, knowing deep down inside it would be the only way you could live with yourself.” The voice followed him, hung over him like a noose. It roared in his pounding ears and threatened to overpower him, a windy storm.
Out of breath, Sebastian fell to his knees in the middle of the aisle, cowering, beseeching for mercy he did not deserve.
The voice just laughed. “You don’t believe in absolution, or surely you would have sought it.”
“Who are you?” he managed through ragged, heaving, coughs. He could see nothing in the church but stained glass windows of judging saints and empty pews, stretching for eternity. “What are you?”
Sebastian felt himself go pale. He turned his gaze heavenward, panting.
Blessed Michael, archangel, defend us in the hour of conflict.
He couldn’t move, trapped under the piercing stare of hundreds and hundreds of eyes burning with holy light.
Be our safeguard against the wickedness and snares of the devil
may God rebuke him, we humbly pray:
The figure in the mass of eyes was indecipherable, though the impression of a flaming sword and a scale inexplicably pounded at the back of the priest’s head.
and do thou, O Prince of the heavenly host,
by the power of God thrust Satan down to hell
The coughing was worsening— he could scarcely catch his breath.
and with him those other wicked spirits
who wander through the world for the ruin of souls.
Blinding pain gripped him as his jaw cracked. Cold, and smooth, and wriggling, something was coming out. Scales slick with blood, the serpent emerged head-first, forced from his throat inch by inch.
Sebastian was found the next morning by Piero. By then, his body, slumped in the confessional, had grown stiff with rigor mortis. A single white feather was pried from the fist of his right hand. His left held open a book of prayers. The Prayer of Saint Michael.
His watch had stopped at 6:00.