WTNR NRHLGD'R SNGM OA RAKEPLZ, SA SEWTMP, VTNKT WTEY WLCMRW IPES SM.
THIS ISLAND’S _IN_ __ S____A_, __ __TH__, _HI_H TH__ TA__ST ____ __.
THIS ISLAND’S _IN_ __ S____A_, __ __TH__, WHICH TH__ TA__ST ____ __.
THIS ISLAND’S _IN_ __ S_C__A_, __ __TH___, WHICH TH__ TA__ST ____ __.
THIS ISLAND’S _IN_ _Y SYC__A_, _Y __TH__, WHICH TH__ TA__ST ____ __.
THIS ISLAND’S MIN_ _Y SYC__A_, MY M_TH__, WHICH TH__ TA__ST ____ M_.
THIS ISLAND’S MINE _Y SYC__A_, MY M_THE_, WHICH TH__ TA_EST ____ ME.
THIS ISLAND’S MINE BY SYC__A_, MY M_THE_, WHICH TH__ TAKEST ____ ME.
THIS ISLAND’S MINE BY SYCORA_, MY MOTHER, WHICH THOU TAKEST FROM ME.
Alright, you’ve got me on this one. What the hell is the last letter? Nothing else fits so it’s got to be some weird obscure reference like Tolstoy or something Becks would read.