“For Israel To Exist, Palestine Could Not.”
“When Zionist paramilitaries ethnically cleansed 750,000 Palestinians from their homes during the Nakba, the Bund demanded the right of return for those refugees. Israel, of course, would do no such thing. Bundists and Zionists hated each other from the start.”
@mollycrabapple speaks at the 2025 Conference on the Jewish Left, organized by BU’s Institute on Culture, Religion and World Affairs ( @cura_bostonuniversity ) about the history of the Bund, and the alternative vision for Jewish safety and liberation that Bundists proposed as an alternative to Zionism. She states:
“The Bund was a sometimes clandestine political party whose tenants were humane, socialist, secular, and defiantly Jewish. Bundists fought the Czar, battled pogroms, educated shtetls, and ultimately helped lead the Warsaw Ghetto uprising.
“Though the Bund celebrated Jews as a nation, they irreconcilably opposed the creation of a Jewish state in Palestine.
“The Bund coined a word for this stubborn insistence on staying - ‘Dokheit’ hereness, as opposed to the there of Palestine.
“Bundists would fight for freedom and safety in the places where they lived, in defiance of everyone who wanted them dead. One can see in this Yiddish term a precursor echo of the Palestinian concept of ‘Sumud’, the steadfast determination to stay on their land despite the predations of the Israeli state.
“To the Bund, Zionism was submission to the same bigots who wanted to kick Jews out of their homes in Eastern Europe.
“Zionists and European racists agreed on one thing: Jews to Palestine. All of this filled the bund with disgust. Henrik Ehrlich wrote, “The Zionists regard themselves as second class citizens in Poland and their aim is to be first class citizens in Palestine and make Arabs second class citizens.”
The many Jews across the world fighting for liberation and safety where we live, and fighting for Palestinian freedom, embody the values of the Bund today.