Cricut Machine Comparison Guide for DIY Projects 2025
If you are still thinking about buying a Cricut but aren’t sure which one to choose, you’re not alone! With several models available, it’s easy to feel overwhelmed. That’s why, in this guide, we will compare popular options like the Cricut Maker, Explore, and Joy to help you make the right choice.
I understand how confusing it can be when each machine comes with its own features, price point, and purpose. The best Cricut machine for you depends on the kind of projects you enjoy most, whether it’s crafting cards, customizing t-shirts, or creating large-scale designs. To simplify things, we have put together this easy Cricut machine comparison guide to explain the key differences between the models.
Whether you are a total beginner or a pro crafter, this guide will help you choose the perfect Cricut that matches your style, budget, and DIY needs. Your ideal crafting machine is just a few scrolls away – so let’s break it all down in the easiest way possible!
Cricut Maker 3 vs Maker 4: Main Differences & Features
The Maker 4 is an upgrade to the Maker 3. While both machines support a wide range of tools and materials, including Smart Materials, the Maker 4 has a faster cutting speed and potentially a slightly quieter operation. They have the same dimensions and weight (22.1 in x 7 in x 5.9 in and 11.1 lbs). Both support a wide range of Cricut tools (13+) and can handle cutting with or without a mat with Smart Materials.
These are the top-of-the-line machines, offering the most versatility and power. They can cut various materials, including fabric (even without backing), wood, leather, and more, thanks to their adaptive tool system and stronger motor.
The Maker 4 is much faster than the Maker 3, especially when using Smart Materials. The Maker 4 can cut at up to 14.1 inches per second, while the Maker 3 cuts at 11.3 inches per second.
The Maker 3 is primarily available in light blue color, while the Maker 4 comes in seashell and sage colors.
The Maker 4 features a 36-watt power supply, while the Maker 3 offers a 50-watt power supply.
The Maker 4 is often more expensive than the Maker 3, especially when purchasing bundles.
Important: Both machines are compatible with the same tools and accessories and offer identical features and functionality.
Cricut Explore 3 vs Explore Air 2: Which One to Buy?
When making a Cricut machine comparison, the two options that often show up are the Explore 3 and the Explore Air 2. While they look similar, many key differences can impact your crafting experience.
The Explore Air 2 is best for beginners. It cuts over 100 materials like paper, vinyl, iron-on, and cardstock. It uses mats for every project and connects via Bluetooth or USB. It’s budget-friendly and gets the job done for most casual crafters.
The Explore 3 is the upgraded version of the Explore Air 2. It can cut Smart Materials without a mat, helping you work faster and with more ease. It also cuts twice as fast as the Explore Air 2 and allows you to perform longer cuts, up to 12 feet in one go. This machine is ideal for bulk projects or large designs. Explore 3 also supports the new roll holder and has better software integration.
In short, if you’re just starting out your journey with Cricut and want something affordable, go for the Explore Air 2. But if speed, matless cutting, and longer designs matter, Explore 3 is worth the upgrade.
Cricut Joy and Joy Xtra Comparison
The Joy and Joy Xtra are both compact cutting machines, but the Xtra offers a larger cut size and the ability to print and cut, while the original Joy is more limited in those areas.
Let’s compare them in detail so you can choose the best fit.
Cricut Joy
The maximum cut size is 4.5 inches wide and 4 feet long.
More compact and lightweight, which makes it highly portable.
Works with different types of materials, including vinyl, iron-on, and cardstock.
The machine can cut, write, draw, and foil.
Suitable for label making, creating greeting cards, small-scale home decor, and personalized gifts.
Important Note: It does not support Print Then Cut functionality.
Cricut Joy Xtra
Supports a wider cut size of 8.5 inches wide and 4 feet long.
Includes a Print Then Cut sensor, allowing users to print full-color stickers and other printable with an inkjet printer and then cut them.
It is larger and heavier than the Joy but is still considered small and easy to carry.
Compatible with various materials, including cardstock, vinyl, iron-on, and printable materials.
This machine can cut, write, draw, and foil, too.
Suitable for all projects the Joy machine can handle, as well as larger projects and Print Then Cut projects, such as stickers and custom cards.
Helpful Tip: If you need a compact and portable machine primarily for basic cutting, writing, and drawing, and don’t require Print Then Cut functionality, the Cricut Joy is a good choice. If you want the flexibility of larger projects, Print Then Cut capabilities, and don’t mind a slightly larger machine, the Cricut Joy Xtra is a better choice.
Key Factors to Consider Before Buying a Cricut Machine
Now that you’ve done a Cricut machine comparison of various models, you have to make sure about the following key points before you hit the Buy button:
Budget: Machines range in price, so determine your spending limit.
Cutting needs: Different machines can handle various materials, from paper and vinyl to fabric and thicker materials like balsa wood. If you plan to work with thicker materials, you’ll need a machine compatible with tools like a knife or rotary blade.
Project size: Consider the size of projects you plan to create.
Speed vs. Control: Some machines prioritize speed for faster cutting, while others offer more precision and control for intricate designs.
Portability: If you need to move your machine easily, consider its size and weight. Smaller machines, such as the Cricut Joy, are more portable than larger ones.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
What is the main difference between Cricut Maker and Maker 3?
The key difference between Maker and Maker 3 lies in their ability to work with Smart Materials, resulting in faster and more accurate cutting capability. The Maker 3 can cut Smart Materials (vinyl, iron-on, sticker, cardstock, etc.) up to 12 feet long without a mat, offering convenience and potentially faster project completion. It cuts up to twice as fast as the original Maker. Another main difference is their price; Maker 3 is more expensive than the original Maker.
Do all Cricut machines work with Design Space?
Yes, all current Cricut cutting machines (Joy, Explore, and Maker series) are compatible with the Design Space app. It is a free app for desktop (Windows/Mac) and mobile (iOS/Android) devices. It is the software that controls these machines and allows users to design, personalize, and send projects to their cutting machines. Older models, such as the Expression cutting machine, are not compatible with the Design Space software.
Is Cricut Joy worth it for small projects?
Yes, Cricut Joy is considered a worthwhile investment for small crafting projects, particularly for beginners or those who mainly work with vinyl, iron-on, and cardstock. Its compact size, user-friendliness, and ability to handle popular project types, such as labels, cards, and small decals. These features make it a convenient choice for users with limited space or simpler crafting needs.
Source: https://cricutnewmachine.com/cricut-machine-comparison-guide-for-diy-projects-2025/