Hot Take: Narnian Hogwarts Houses
Except this time, we focus on what each character values and not just the traits they display!
Edmund Pevensie as a Hufflepuff
Everyone loves to judge Edmund's whole personality and values off of the Turkish delight incident, but hear me out. After reigning as a king of Narnia for many years, it is said that he became known as Edmund the Just. He was completely changed by what he learned through Aslan's sacrifice; he valued second chances (see The Horse and his Boy); he took great care to be loyal to those who had proven they cared for him (after TLTWTW, he never doubts Lucy).
Lucy Pevensie as a Gryffindor
If you've read the books, you know that Lucy not only gets courage from Aslan, she also is told by him that if she were any braver, she would be a lioness. Aslan puts Lucy through trials of bravery because he knows her love for him overrides any fear or doubt that she, or her siblings, may have. Yes, she's loyal, but she values courage. If it's a struggle for you, but you still are willing to try, then you value that trait.
I've also heard people say Lucy is a Hufflepuff because she found Narnia and Hufflepuffs are good finders, but one of the themes of the books is that you can't just go looking for Narnia and find it. Digory tells the children this when they come back the first time. You are able to go by being called there.
Peter Pevensie as a Hufflepuff (with Gryffindor tendencies?)
I feel like it's a little less clear what Peter actually values, but I say that he does value responsibility and honor. He is brave- Aslan didn't give Peter a choice of whether or not he was to become the High King of Narnia, it was just instantly a thing that Peter had to accept. That came with a lot of responsibilities, on top of the "oldest child looking after the younger ones" vibe he gives off. Still, under all that pressure, he makes himself rise to the occasion and sees Narnia through it's Golden Age, carrying himself and his responsibilities with dignity.
SPOILERS FOR THE LAST BATTLE BELOW!!
Susan Pevensie as... a squib.
I know everyone puts Susan in Ravenclaw because she is very practical and values logic. However, I think it's possible that if the siblings were in the magical world, Susan wouldn't have the ability or much of it. Because she was always so practical, she had a hard time believing what she saw even while they were in Narnia. In the last book, when the three other siblings go to be with Aslan in his country, Susan isn't there. They say that she basically stopped believing in Narnia and got caught up in her world- what made logical sense. That was what she wanted.
