"You're frustrated. If you want help, I'm here. If you just need to vent… leave a message."
Chase says this to House in S4E3: 97 Seconds, and, well, he really holds up to it for a while, I think!
For example, in S4E12: Don't Ever Change, Chase explains that he can't convince the patient, Roz, to undergo exploratory surgery before sunset, as House had wanted. The interaction goes:
ROBERT CHASE. I had a Rabbi call. She's adamant.
GREGORY HOUSE. She's not a masochist. She's suicidal. Nice job, Chase.
ROBERT CHASE. Yeah. I should have had twin Rabbis call. Can I go now?
Chase starts walking out.
GREGORY HOUSE. We need you.
Chase pauses.
GREGORY HOUSE. So, instead of a few days, we now have a few hours to figure this out. Nice work, Chase.
ROBERT CHASE. Why do you need me?
GREGORY HOUSE. Saying, "nice work, Chase" when you're not here is pointless.
Chase smiles and continues walking out.
GREGORY HOUSE. Seriously, we need you.
Chase leaves.
(I recorded this scene, and the others I'm going to reference, but I'm only able to upload one video per post. Does anybody know any way to circumvent this? It feels as though I might be misleading when I choose what actions/expressions I choose to write out, but it also feels like leaving out important context when I don't add them in.)
When Chase thinks House legitimately wants his input and assistance, he waits, but as soon as he finds out House is simply aiming his frustrations at him, he walks out, demonstrating how Chase is now willing to set boundaries with House. Of course, he does come back a few moments later with a solution to House's problem, but he doesn't stick around to be belittled for no reason.
That's a stark contrast to how Chase interacts with House earlier in the series. Take S1E19: Kids. After House discovers that Chase ratted him out to Vogler, he punishes him by making him research every possible cause of neck pain, an endless errand.
GREGORY HOUSE. What letter are you up to?
ROBERT CHASE. A.
GREGORY HOUSE. Torture combing through all that stuff, ain't it? Real dull. Awful.
ROBERT CHASE. It's no problem.
GREGORY HOUSE. Well, thank goodness. A lot of people would resent having to do this.
Instead of refusing to partake in an obviously pointless assignment, Chase simply bows his head and does it, completely willing to endure House's treatment.
Sure, House is Chase's boss, but we know that he doesn't actually want or respect mindless obedience from his employees. In S4E11: Frozen, House says as much directly to his new team. He tells them, "Do not play games with me. Number one, you're going to lose, you're just not ready. Number two, the game was to force you to stop playing games. I need you to stand up to me. Challenge me. I need you to stop worrying about getting fired." House doesn't want people who shut up and take whatever he dishes out, he wants them to be willing to argue, fight, and callenge him... something Chase just didn't do. By Season 4, though, he's learned the difference between helping House and enabling him. He'll stay if House actually needs him, but if House just wants someone to kick around... he can leave a message.
What's ESPECIALLY interesting to me is that, when Cameron and Chase's relationship takes a tumultuous turn after Dibala, he seems to backslide. In S6E8: Teamwork, we see the boundary he set begin to blur:
GREGORY HOUSE. I owe you an apology. I was wr-rr-r... I was wrr-r-rr...
ROBERT CHASE. What were you wrong about?
GREGORY HOUSE. You spent weeks elaborately concealing the fact that you... crashed daddy's car. And then you just confessed. Seemed idiotic. Certain to end in disaster. Instead you're riding off into the sunset together. Any theories on why?
ROBERT CHASE. I assume you've already dismissed the "she loves me" theory?
GREGORY HOUSE. Well, it's possible. It would require the presupposition that everything she's done for the last six years has been completely inconsistent with her character, but yeah, it's possible.
ROBERT CHASE. And as we've already established, it's also possible that you're wrong.
GREGORY HOUSE. Or there's another explanation. Since you don't have one, I’m gonna keep looking for you.
Chase doesn't act like he might've back in Season 1--yieldingly putting accepting House's accusations entirely--but he doesn't walk away either as he suggested he'd do in Season 4.
What's important here is that House isn't actually trying to help Chase. Throughout the episode, his interest in Cameron and Chase's relationship appears to be motivated less by concern for Chase and more by his own desire to keep them both at PPTH. House does not want to lose two members of his team, and he seems determined to prevent that outcome, evidenced by his saying "four for four" when Cameron walks into his office, implying that he sees her return as another success in keeping the team together. Earlier in the episode, when he tells Chase, "Cameron thinks you're my personal sock puppet. If you don't stay, it's gonna be hard to prove you're not," he's pushing on an insecurity because he wants Chase to make the choice that benefits him.
A Season 4 or 5 Chase might have recognized that House's comments were less about him and more about House getting what he wants, and he might have disengaged. Yet, here, Chase challenges him and allows the conversation to continue, gives House room to continue probing at his insecurities.
The real tragic part about this is that Chase's initial growth in Season 4 and his regression in Teamwork are driven by the same desire: to not be defined by House. Chase walks away in Season 4 because, guess what, House's opinions don't matter as much to him, he doesn't have to do whatever House wants! But in Teamwork, that same need for independence becomes his flaw. House telling Chase that Cameron sees him as "House's personal sock puppet" threatens the distance Chase has been building. He doesn't want to be seen as someone who simply follows House, so when House suggests that leaving PPTH would only confirm Cameron's suspicions, Chase engages instead of walking away.
And so, the fact that Chase is left taking up House's mantle in the finale is bittersweet to me, not triumphant. Chase wanted to distance himself from House, yet he ends up unable to escape his shadow.











