Buzzfeed Unsolved AU: fans of either guy are Dustbunnies and Sinners respectively. Lucas is much more on board with True Crime and absolutely dismisses Dustin’s frankly absurd conspiracy theories. There’s a huge portion of the fandom on board with Max, since the camera will often pan to her just sighing. A big joke is that Lucas turned Max gay but she dismisses that on Twitter, saying that Lucas is the only man she was ever attracted to and that he’s a great guy, she’s just REALLY gay.
dustin’s fave is obviously supernatural. he loves the episode where they look for bigfoot bc he gets lucas to do the mating call even though lucas is 100% convinced that it’s bullshit. but he’s so in love it literally doesn’t matter dustin can pretty much get him to do it….. eventually. even after much resistance. you should see his face when dustin pulls out the ouija board one episode though.
@max_mayfield (verified) - to answer everyone’s questions, lucas is the one (1) man i have ever been attracted to and i love my gf. moving on.