Truth’s Overrated || Closed
continuation [x]
Charlie stood there, staring at Josie, waiting for her to speak. Instead, she bit her lip and turned her back to him, fixating on a vase of what looked like dying flowers on the coffee table and attempted to tidy them up. Charlie watched her, perplexed, feeling his frustration start to rise. “Josie.” He frowned, taking a couple of steps towards her. How hard would it be to give him a simple reassuring answer? A laugh. Something Anything. The silence was making him feel uneasy. Making it seem like -A had been onto something after all. The way Josie didn’t just fall over laughing at how ridiculous the whole thing was. That he could ever be Emma’s father. It was worrying. Finally, Charlie could take it no longer. He reached out and removed the vase from the table, beyond irritated now. She shouldn’t play games like this, it wasn’t funny and Charlie had never taken her for the type. “Say something.” He snapped, frowning as he watched her look away and bite her lip again.
“She’s yours.” The reply, when it came, threw Charlie. Even though this weird, paranoid part of him had been expecting it almost... he felt like he’d just been kicked in the head by a horse. “Excuse me?” Josie’s gaze lifted to his face, her eyes sad as she raked her fingers through her blonde curls. Something about her expression made Charlie feel uneasy but then she was turning from him again with a heavy sigh and that was when she finally seemed to find her voice. Though, by this point, Charlie was actually beginning to wish that she’d kept quiet or he hadn’t come round in the first place. He wasn’t ready for any of this and he had no idea that -A had pretty much set this whole thing up for her to lie. Josie seemed so sincere, while she was telling the story, she seemed on the verge of tears, so apologetic. But he couldn’t quite believe it was true. That, years ago, he’d cheated on Jenna with Josie one night while he’d been so drunk that he couldn’t recall the incident now. Drunk? Charlie remembered the night itself, that his friend was talking about... but he couldn’t actually remember sleeping with her. To this day he swore he’d only had two glasses of wine. Josie insisted this wasn’t the case and... how could he say otherwise? It’s not like Charlie thought she would lie about any of this, it’s just that he hadn’t thought -A was right. He thought they were just messing with him or trying to cause a rift between him and Ruby somehow, or... just trying to make him hurt because of Sophie.
“I should have told you... but you didn’t remember - or didn’t want to - and... you were with Jenna. You had a family. Charlie, I’m sorry..” But Charlie wasn’t listening. She’d had plenty of chances since then. Hell, when Emma had figured it out, put it all together... was that not the right moment?! He was furious. At her. At himself. At -A. Everything. This couldn’t be happening. There was just... no way. Charlie couldn’t be Emma’s father. But Josie wouldn’t lie, Charlie trusted her. Once a cheater, always a cheater - right? And Sophie... he didn’t know how to handle any of this. What did he do? Try to form a relationship with Emma? Charlie didn’t know if he was ready for something like that. It suddenly felt very raw.
This kind of turned his whole world upside down and all she could say was sorry? He dropped the vase back on the table, probably tipping it sideways, and then turned and simply walked out of her house without so much as a backwards glance.













