Paragon, Renegade, Pilot Chapter 1
A NSFW Mass Effect fic | Joker/Kaidan/f!Shepard | Read it on AO3
Shepard and Kaidan are a gorgeous couple.
Like, propaganda poster gorgeous â  if you ignore the fact that sheâs his commanding officer, and their entire semi-secret relationship is technically Alliance Unsanctionedâ˘, which everyone does because hello. And that suits Joker just fine. Or not fine, fine, you know? But fine, alright? Itâs fine. Itâs expected. And heâd look ludicrous on either of their arms. Never been good at that whole looking aggressively chiseled while brooding at a vague middle-distance thing. And Joker is a realist. Heâd mourned and buried his inability to look like a badass when he was about twelve.
(Joker has precisely two looks. Smug asshole and irritating goofball, and he likes to zip between the two lightning fast. You know, for funsies.)
But in the dead of night, when itâs just darkness and the soft sounds of a ship half asleep, and a hand â his own, duh â on his cock; he imagines. (Also for funsies.) Because apparently, his type is the Allianceâs best and brightest, and way way way out of his league. But Joker keeps his grip firm, wishing abstractly that he had callouses because heâs seen Kaidanâs big and blunt-fingered hands, and though heâs never been close enough to Shepardâs bare hands to tell, the Commander has never done anything soft in the whole of her life. And so, tug tug tug in the dark with a grip thatâs a titch too hard and demanding to be comfortable, but it makes the bones of his hips feel like theyâre made of warm syrup.
Maybe he ought to feel guilty about it; jerking off to his Commander and/or Staff Lieutenant â and letâs be honest, itâs mostly and â but Jokers had a life full of hopeless crushes and needing to look someone square in the eye and fly a ship less than five minutes after rubbing one out, and practice makes perfect, after all. So his hand doesnât still or stutter, it surges up and down his length, like he owns it â well. Like they own it.
It takes all of not very fucking long. One hand braced against the panel of the shower stall, keeping him upright, the other standing in for Shepardâs mouth and Kaidanâs hands, which is why itâs all so quick and bright. Just a handful of strokes and he is gone.
Joker turns the shower on right after he pulls himself back together enough to manage the taps, weak-kneed, trembling, and breathing like heâd just run a mile.Â
He never masturbates in Normandyâs cockpit. He does practically everything else in that chair and heâs not about to risk getting it sticky. Some things in this world are sacrosanct, and Normandyâs flight chair is one of them.
So he stands in the shower letting the water run down his neck and and his back and all the places heâd imagined being touched. He doesnât get long to savor the post-orgasmic bliss. The waterâs always hot â the whole shipâs practically one continuous loop of energyâ but Alliance rationing being what it is, itâs on a timer, and if he lingers too long itâll switch out to subsonic pulses of air that kinda vibrate the dirty right off of you. Itâs the blue-balls of hygiene; deeply unsatisfying on every level, which is not how he likes to end a good wank.
(Or a not-so-good wank, which is rare, wanks being what they are.)
(Never pass up a good â or not-so-good â wank.)
So, confession time. Joker watches porn. Not like a lot, a lot. But just. Space is big and mostly empty, and the thrill of piloting still leaves ample free time, and he is a goddamn full-grown adult.
He's into your basic kinks. Threesomes. Anal. Asari in wet tshirts. But the extranet is big and weird and he's wandered into some stuff that he'd never have willingly searched for, like that drell-hanar porno with some really, really unnecessarily complex plot; 100% of all Elcor porn heâs seen; and that one-time he accidentally found Inspectreing the Booty, a porn parody about Commander Shepard steadily banging her way through the Normandy crew.
And that one was weird. Like super, terribly, irredeemably weird. But Jokerâs curiosity can easily be described as morbid, so itâs not entirely his fault that several hours after finding the series heâs blown through every single episode.
Figuratively speaking.
Slightly more literally with the one that paired the Commander with her dark-haired, dark-eyed, burly, biotic Staff Lieutenant.
What there isnât, is an episode where Shepard bangs her abrasive yet irresistibly charming pilot. Which is a littleâŚÂ yeah. You know. Even Wrex gets laid.
Somehow, even just in fantasy, the world knows Jokerâs not meant to be with Shepard.
And thatâs okay. It is.
Kaidan and Shepard have each other. Joker has the Normandy. And they have a goddamn galaxy to save.
***
Shepard starts visiting Normandyâs cockpit early on.
Not many commanding officers do that. They have the bridge for The Doing Of The Important Stuff, and thatâs where heâs used to being summoned for any face-to-face conversations.Â
The first time sheâd done it he was pretty sure sheâd only come to reassure herself that a pilot with Vrolickâs Syndrome wasnât going to be a liability. Heâd had that happen on nearly every ship heâd served â no matter that he'd had to take all the Allianceâs physical fitness assessments just to get his wings in the first place.
(Heâd passed, but the Alliance had still ordered additional scans for him to ensure that he hadnât broken anything from the stress of the tests. You know, just in case. And though no oneâs actually said it out loud aside from that one flight instructor he got court-martialed; heâs well aware the Alliance doesnât really want to employ a pilot with brittle bones. Even one whoâd set every flight simulator record with every class of ship heâs licensed to fly â and a few he isnât.)
But Shepard had just wanted to talk. And though the conversation had been somewhat impersonal and brief, Joker had sweated through his shirt because humanityâs first and only Spectre was intimidating up close, and way, way prettier than she had any right to be.
Sheâd kept coming back though, and their conversations had stretched. Meandered from professional, to casual, and then into personal territory.
She asks him about his time in flight school, and he tells her that the academy wouldnât let him sit for certification on ships he hadnât been formally trained to fly, so he broke into the simulator room and beat all the flight sim records on all available ship classes and models. Then he got stubborn and wouldnât take the formal certifications, but the Alliance pretty much let him fly whatever he wanted after that anyway.
She asks him about his home base, and he tells her he always thinks of his ship as home, but that heâs got a tiny place on the Citadel because, although the Alliance wants their officers to be all-in all the time, they donât want them to be so obvious about it.
She asks him if heâs got anyone waiting for him, and he lies through his teeth and says heâs got a girl in every port, and at least one desperately heartbroken Krogan out there somewhere. She laughs at that, the sound surprisingly light and bright and he is fuuuuucked. He is so fucked.
Stupid hopeless crush.
Some days she doesnât ask him anything. She just settles into the copilotâs seat, folds her long legs up to her chin, and just talks. To him. Baffling.
Today sheâs folded up like a pretzel, idly tapping through the Normandyâs feeds on a flight screen, which Joker kinda hates â he doesnât go into her quarters and put his hands all over her guns after all â but not enough to shoo her away.
âYou know,â Shepard says, âyouâre the only one of my crew whose academy dissertation was classified by the Alliance. Even I didnât have access to read it until they made me a Spectre.â
Joker chokes on a laugh. âYou actually read those? I donât even think my instructor read them. Did you read everyone's? Did Kaidan write about Canada? Or bacon? Or, wait, wait. Canadian bacon?âÂ
âNo,â Shepardâs mouth does that weird thing like sheâs trying not to smile. âHe wrote about the biomechanical half-life of L2 biotic implants and why the Alliance shouldnât upgrade them in active military personnel, as was the plan at the time.â
âO f course he did.â
âAnd youâ"
âA Proposed Redesign of Sanitary Stations on Alliance F-Class Vessels Based on the Traditionally Varying Role of Toilet Paper in Council Species.â Joker tips the brim of his hat at her and flashes a quick grin. âXenobiology, baby.â
Shepard blinks.
âUm,â Joker clears his throat quickly. âThatâsâ xenobiology, baby Maâam . Damn, thatâs worse. Commander. Maâam. Shepard. Sir.â
Shepard bites her lower lip.
Oh no, thatâs hot.
âUhâŚâ He wipes sweaty palms against his jumpsuit, blundering on. âI mean the research got real interesting at one point. I even added some non-council species for extra credit. Did you know that Krogansââ
âYeah. I read it. â Shepardâs smile finally breaks through, and Joker legit stares because holy shit .
He can probably count on one hand the number of times Shepard has smiled â honest to God smiled, not just a smirk or that twisty grin thatâs all sharp teeth and danger â and she is transformed.
And well⌠Thereâs nothing more terrifying than popping a boner in Shepardâs presence because she has a sixth sense about the world around her and Joker is just a thousand and twelve percent certain she knows.
(And speaking of percentages: it turns out if Shepard smiles thereâs an eighty-seven percent chance heâs gonna get hard.)
(Give or take thirteen.)
And yep. There it goes.
Awesome.
Humanityâs first Spectre has dimples.
And Joker is completely screwed.
***
This is the part of the job Joker hates the most.Â
Well, no.
He hates writing flight reports. Trying to reduce instinct and awesomeness into a neatly rational and easily defendable set of decisions is impossible at best. All the navy should need at the end of the day is crew safe, ship intact, and half the time heâs not even sure why he does the things he does.
He hates the way his dress blues always bunch up around his balls. He hates his dress blues, in general, but he hates them specifically where they are ball-adjacent. The constriction is always particularly nefarious whenever he has to stand around while some top brass does the sort of tiresome things that top brass always doesâ like passing out medals or giving great pilots crap for stealing a ship.
And he hates whenever some aeronautical engineering nerd slash twat suggests that navy pilots are a dying breed, and how the future of spaceflight is AI, and how [insert any installation request heâs ever made] is really a waste of valuable Alliance time and resources because heâll be obsolete in a few years and something something something, Joker doesnât listen to idiots.
So this is really the thing he hates fourth most.
He hates listening to the comms when Shepard and Kaidan are planetside getting shot up all to hell while he keeps his hands on Normandyâs flight controls ready to evac their asses back to safety ââ but he hates the silence more.
(Fifth most? Whatever, heâs losing count.)
The team in the sky follows the team on the ground through a number of feeds: tiny blips and biometrics and bursts of data â but Joker has a direct, active comm link. But when the signal is blocked; or too scratchy to make out, even when Normandyâs computers run them through noise filters and decryption cycles; or when theyâre just plain silent and thereâs just dead air and tension and waiting and really unpleasant what ifs floating around inside his head. God, he hates that shit.
Itâs strangely comforting when theyâre actually fighting. The first spatter of gunfire always makes his heart leap, but over the months heâs learned to read the sounds of the firefight. All the Alliance soldiers carry the same base assault rifle, but Shepardâs got hers modded halfway to hell, and it has this pop to it, where every round sounds almost bouncy. Kaidanâs heavy pistol has this distinct thundering sound, kinda slow and measured and broad. Joker's even learned to identify the soft fizzy static of Kaidanâs biotics, which he tends not to use unless he needs to. But as long as they're shooting and flinging little blue fireballs, they're alive; and he can breathe a little.
But now, right now, Joker sits in the silence with a weight on his chest, hands gliding over the ship's controls restlessly, imagining all the terrible reasons it might be so damn quiet.
And it's quiet for so long.
Too long, maybe.
Too too long. Fuck, this is his second least favorite for sure.
So when Shepardâs voice finally comes through with a burst of static and gunfire, Jokerâs relief is so profound he almost misses when she says.
ââus up. And make sure Chakwas is ready.â
âDr Chakwas?â Shit. His hands are already flying over the controls. âRoger that, Commander. Bringing the Normandy in. Evac, three minutes five.â
Worry spikes through the relief, though Shepardâs voice was steady enough. Of course that doesnât mean that someone hasnât lost a leg, or anywhere between one to three livers.
Wrex was with them today, so if he's down three, heâll still have one to spare. The others, not so much.
Joker doesnât like the atmosphere of this particular planet. Itâs too slippery. The Normandy handles like itâs coated in oil. Heâd rather a sluggish stick than one that slides around unpredictably, but he gets the Normandy down at speed and manages not to clip the side of the Cerberus research facility in the process.
The video feed switches to the hangar doors, letting in a cloud of smoke pierced with a scatter of laser fire as they open. He feels the tremble of rockets bouncing off the Normandyâs shields and resists the urge to belly-flop the ship directly on top of the Cerberus troops because how fucking dare. Â
âHurry it up Commander, theyâre targeting the Normandy! Thereâs only so many rockets up the backside a lady should be required to take!â
He knows from the crackle of the comms switching to internal channels that theyâre on a moment before the VI notification.
âCrew onboard .â
âSweet,â Joker lifts away from the planet immediately, taking care to make sure Normandyâs burners are running extra hot, cuz fuck those guys. He hopes he melts every last one to the tarmac.Â
As soon as they are out of the atmosphere and are moving into deeper space, Joker passes the Normandy off to one of the on-duty flight crew, barely waiting to be formally relieved. He dashes to the stairs â though it probably doesnât look like dashing â and then has to force himself to take it slow. A tumble down the stairs would be the stupidest way to end his military career.
He meets the ground crew coming up from the cargo hold. The smell of a firefight hits him first. Smoke and that peculiar electric burn of spent thermal rounds are nearly eclipsed by the sharper reek of human blood and Krogan sweat.
Shepard and Kaidan are both wounded.
Sheâs walking easily enough, but sheâs got an arm slung over Kaidanâs shoulders, and a long, vicious-looking scorch mark down her flank and across her back. As they pass, she smiles at Joker with such an easy, sharp grin that it should make him feel better about the whole thing, except that Kaidan shoots him a dark look over the top of Shepardâs head. Or at least he tries to. Joker canât see any obvious wound but half of Kaidanâs face is awash with blood, the eye beneath, squeezed tightly shut.Â
âDodged a rocket,â Shepard explains. Her eyes are wild and a little bloodshot. Green irises eerily ringed with red.
Joker frowns.Â
âWell, mostly,â Wrex says, coming up from behind them with Shepardâs helmet and assault rifle in hand. He chuckles, low and gravelly. âDidnât dodge the explosive crate it hit, though.â
âStill counts,â Shepard mutters.
Joker frowns harder and follows them into the medbay where Dr Chakwas is waiting.
âCommander Shepard, thatâs a nasty-looking burn.â Dr Chakwas pats one of the medical beds. âHop up. Wrex, is any of that blood yours?â
âNo,â Wrex snickers.
âWell done you. Now, if youâd be so good as to take the Commanderâs guns away so theyâre not cluttering up my medbay, thank you. Kaidan, sit down. I want to take a look at that eye.â
âThereâs nothing wrong with my eye,â Kaidan protests.
âExcellent. Then itâll only take a moment.â
âButââ
âSit. Jeff, get the Commander out of her armor.â
âUhâŚâ Joker hesitates, feeling oddly caught out. His shoulders hunch up around his ears.
Dr Chakwas makes an exasperated noise. âShall I call Wrex back for assistance?â
âNot unless you want the Commanderâs arms to fall off,â Joker mutters grumpily, already reaching to help.
Modern ceramic plate armor is designed to be easy enough to get into and a bit of a bitch to get out of, and Kroganâs arenât well known for patience. The word gentle doesnât even translate properly in their native tongue. Wrexâs idea of assistance is likely to amount to pull real hard.
Joker steps closer to Shepard. Even Spectre quality gear follows the same basic design as all Human-Asari models. Joker runs his hands across the seam at her wrist until he finds and unhooks the interlocking clasp on her gauntlet. Thereâs no bare skin to be found, Shepard is clad in sleek black under-armor shot through with sensors to support haptic feedback during combat. He works his way up both arms, as Dr Chakwas tends to Kaidan, hesitating only when he gets to the plating on her torso.
The front plates are nearly undamaged bar some surface-level scuffing that would likely buff right out. But the back section is melted in spots, bubbled and cracked from both the heat and sheer impact of the explosion.
Years of piloting have stripped the uncertainty from his hands. Heâs as careful as can be, fingers slow and steady, but sure as he cracks her breastplate apart. This isnât at all like any of the times Joker has fantasized about undressing Shepard. Thereâs more medi-gel involved, for one thing. And for anotherâ
âYou have very pretty eyes, Joker.â
Joker snorts, startled, and canât quite brace himself for the nonsense his stomach does in response. âLook who's talking,â he mutters, ears flushing bright red.
âWeâre both talking,â Shepard says, and thereâs something in her voice that raises every hair on the back of his neck. She looks up at him but the green in her eyes is almost gone, swallowed by impossibly, unnaturally huge irises, and the whites of her eyes are red red.
âUh, Doctor? Off the record? It sorta looks like the Commander is tripping balls right now.â
âOh?â Dr Chakwasâ voice is even enough, but she looks alarmed rather than surprised.
âUm, yeah. Big Krogan ones, too. The whole quad at once.â
Kaidan tries to stand and join them, but Dr Chakwas shoots him a look of withering disappointment that has him retreating back to his corner. In another life, Karen Chakwas would have made an incredible Alliance Admiral. After all, sheâs the only person with the balls to bully Commander Shepard. She only does it in the tiny dominion of her medbay, but still. Thatâs some Gold Star Commendation for Bravery-level shit right there.
âI can feel all of my fingertips,â Shepard says, seriously.
Joker grimaces. âGood for you. So,â he asks, turning to Dr Chakwas.
âThe crate must have been near a cache of red sand,â Dr Chakwas takes a breath and shakes her head. âIt may surprise you to learn that Alliance ships are not stocked with anything that might readily prevent a narcotic overdose. I can fabricate something in a few hours, of course, butâŚâ
Joker feels something swoop in his gut, but he tries not to look too alarmed, for Kaidanâs sake. âThat's too long,â he says quietly, finishing her thought.
âI donât suppose the Alliance had anticipated the application of red sand via combat burn. Iâll have to author a medical paper â another one â on the extremely creative ways the Commander has tried to get herself killed,â Dr Chakwas makes a thoughtful noise. âThereâs no help for it I suppose. Joker, you wouldnât mind a detour to an old friend of mine, would you?â
âAny friend of yours, Doc.â
âFriend may be a bit of an exaggeration. So might acquaintance. But I donât think heâll shoot at us very much. At least, not unless he knows Garrus is on board. Not a big fan of C-Sec.â
âRelatable,â Joker activates the comm on his omnitool. âFlight, this is Joker. Incoming primary coordinates from Dr Chakwas. Anticipate mild to moderate hostility. Somebody tell Garrus to go hide in steerage. Somebody else tell Navigator Pressly heâs got command of the Normandy.â
***
It turns out Dr Chakwas was right, there was a limited amount of gunfire involved in their terminus-adjacent supply run.
There was some yelling, a handful of threats, and one truly superb volley of insults that almost made Joker wish heâd been there to see the ground crewâs expressions in person.
Not for the first time, Joker wonders where Dr Chakwas picks up black market contacts in a life spent as a prim and proper Alliance medic.
Her shore leave must be wild.
Shepard survives her trip. Kaidan keeps his eye. And Garrus is removed from time-out.
And Joker has to write a stupid flight report about it all.
















