The First Hunt
A Themorea Story: Ari, Part 1
Lycan!Ari x [mystery]!Reader
This is a direct continuation of "The Company We Keep". Lots of plot here, but this is Ari's story—it is very, very NSFW.
Word Count: 6,775
Author's Note: I know book length won the poll, but to be inclusive I'm going to break up these stories into chunks and post them close together. You won't be left waiting long and I'll try to keep the links updated. Please bear with me while I figure this out.
Themorea now has a masterlist
A special thank you to the very talented @cafekitsune for the divider. Go check them out!
The Council meeting broke apart like a tide receding. Chairs were tucked back in, notes gathered, seconds filing back to their lords’ sides. The plan for the mortal front was settled, at least in broad strokes.
Andy was the first to rise, Sunshine’s hand tucked securely into his. Conversation hushed for a beat as the two said their goodbyes and slipped out the door.
Lloyd leaned back in his chair with a lazy grin. “Might wanna leave those two alone for several days to celebrate.” His tone was light, but the implication was clear.
Jake barked a laugh. “Gotta respect the man’s stamina.”
Yelena rolled her eyes so hard the sound practically echoed. “Ugh.”
Lloyd just winked at her.
Maria ignored the bait, gathering her notes into a neat stack. “Jokes aside, we need a first outing. The company won’t mean anything until it has an actual footprint.”
Jake tilted his head. “We’ve got a name, a logo, and we’re starting official holdings. It’ll take a little effort on the other side to age it up a bit, but it won’t be a problem. What we don’t have is street cred.”
Maria blinked. “I thought all we had was street cred? Isn’t that what started this—Andy’s rumored infamy?”
“Yeah, but that’s just with Pronge, and he’s keeping his investigation close to the chest. I think he’s hoping to join up or deepen the relationship more than he’s looking to blackmail or turn in evidence.” Jake shrugged. “We need something to confirm some of his ideas and rule out others, mold his expectations. An outside confirmation will help—which is why I think we should start with Rogg.”
Steve frowned. “Jon Rogg? From your list, Maria?”
“Yeah.” Jake leaned against the back of his chair. “Runs in the same circles as Pronge. Smug bastard with his hands in everything—smuggling, blackmail, side hustles. I’m pretty sure he also does murder-for-hire. He’s good, too, with a small crew and solid connections. Get him onside, and we get our in.”
Maria’s brow arched. “Onside? We noted him as a player to keep tabs on, not recruit. He doesn’t sound like someone we want onside.”
“Not in any official or public way, no,” Jake agreed. “But we’d like an open channel. Understand his connections, keep Pronge in check. ELARA can set up a meeting with Rogg acting as an information broker. Personally, I’d like to know more about Pronge’s illegal side hustles. I get the feeling he’s darker than we know. Could be fronting, though. He seems like a coward, but Rogg would know. That’s why I chose him.”
Steve’s jaw flexed. “It has to be clean. No blood.”
Jake’s grin widened. “Relax. We’ll smile, exchange details, and shake hands. But if someone blinks wrong—”
“Jake.” Steve’s voice cracked like a whip.
Jake held up his hands. “Okay, okay. Clean. I can do clean.”
Lloyd clapped him on the shoulder as he moved past. “I’ll talk. You’ll grin. And the wolf will lurk in the corner. Everything will be perfectly civilized.”
Nick snorted from where he stood at Maria’s side. “You do realize I was joking when I said Ari should babysit, right?”
Ari had been quiet through most of the exchange, broad shoulders relaxed but steady. He finally spoke, voice low and even. “I think it’s a good plan, but there are a lot of variables. Having quiet backup is necessary—but I won’t be babysitting.” A faint smirk curved his mouth. “Besides, if someone blinks wrong, it’ll be me that ruins their day, not Jake or Lloyd.”
Bucky laughed, and Jake grinned. “Dad mode activated.”
Lloyd smirked, sharp as a knife. “Every good field trip needs a chaperone.”
Steve didn’t look convinced, but he didn’t argue further. Maria gave Ari the faintest nod, trusting his judgment.
One by one, the Circle and their seconds filed out, voices echoing off the stone as they stepped out the main doors and vanished into the agora.
Ari lingered only long enough to register the thought: he hadn’t been back to the mortal realm since Themorea was created. The idea didn’t unnerve him. If anything, it sparked a flicker of anticipation he hadn’t expected.
The apartment was spacious, modern, and too polished for three men who hadn’t slept under a mortal roof in years. Floor-to-ceiling windows framed the skyline, lights glittering against the night.
Ari prowled the perimeter first, checking doors and sightlines before he set his bag down. “I still don’t see why we’re staying here. We could portal back each night. Safer. More comfortable.”
Jake had already flopped onto the sofa, stretching out like he owned the place. “Because we need an address. Paperwork, bills, the illusion of normalcy. Nothing says legit like a lease.” He tipped his head back, grinning. “Besides, ELARA’s already wired the utilities. We even have cable.”
Lloyd drifted through the living room, running a hand along the sleek counter. “I, for one, intend to enjoy it. I haven’t had to bother with a glamor this solid in ages, and I’d like to stretch my legs.”
Ari’s mouth flattened. “Doesn’t mean I have to like it.”
Jake smirked. “Relax. No one’s going to bite you.”
Lloyd’s eyes glinted. “Unless you ask nicely.”
Ari ignored them both, crossing to the window. “So tomorrow’s meeting. This club… explain.”
Jake sat up, resting his elbows on his knees. “Speaking of asking nicely—it’s a kink club. Exclusive, underground, and a common meeting ground for people like Rogg. He’s comfortable there. Means fewer surprises.”
Ari’s gaze sharpened. “Is it neutral ground? Any rules we should know about?”
“Not that we know of, but that’s why you’ll be outside the room,” Lloyd said smoothly, fiddling with his shoelaces. “You listen, you watch, you glower. I’ll handle the talking, Jake will nod at the right moments, and Rogg will feel very important.”
Jake grinned. “It’s all theater. He thinks he’s the star, but really we’re just getting him on record. I want to see what he’ll volunteer once he thinks we’re hooked.”
“Or what he slips,” Lloyd added. “Men like Rogg always slip.”
Ari leaned against the window frame, arms folded. “And if it goes wrong?”
Jake spread his hands. “Then we walk. No bodies. Not on the first night, anyway. I’d hate for Steve to think we didn’t even try to keep it clean.”
Ari wasn’t convinced, but he didn’t push. They’d chosen their ground, and his role was clear. Still, as he looked out at the sprawl of mortal lights, he felt that flicker of anticipation again. He couldn't help but feel something was on the horizon.
The club was exactly as you remembered it: low ceilings, shadowed corners, music that pulsed in the bones more than the ears. The smell of leather, sweat, and perfume tangled in the air. You paused at the threshold, inhaled once, and squared your shoulders.
You didn’t come here often anymore. Not because you were afraid or shy—you weren’t—but because too many nights had ended in disappointment. Partners who postured and preened, who thought control came from barked orders or a stinging slap, who recoiled when you bit back harder than they expected. You wanted more than performance. You wanted a fight.
You headed straight for the bar. Polished wood, bottles lit from below, and perched on her usual stool was the one domme you knew you could trust to speak plainly.
“Back again,” Topaz drawled without looking up from her glass. Her lipstick was dark, her expression darker. “What’d he do this time? Cry?”
“Don’t start,” you muttered, sliding onto the neighboring stool.
Topaz tipped her head, finally giving you a look—equal parts boredom and amusement. “So… complain about another failed scene, or sit there sulking until I drag it out of you?”
You scowled into the bar top. “He wanted the thrill of the chase, not the fight after. Sure, he caught me, but he hadn’t won yet. Five minutes in, he was sulking that I wouldn’t just roll over.”
Topaz chuckled, low and dry. “Typical. They like the idea of fire until they get burned.” Topaz swirled her drink, unimpressed. “Maybe you should stop handing matches to boys who can’t light them.”
You sighed. “Who am I supposed to give them to? I know I’m not too much for the right person.”
“Finding 'The One' is a tall order. Have you considered adjusting your expectations?”
You snorted at that. “What, lie back and purr while someone pets me?” You shook your head. “The so-called alphas can’t handle a fight. The sadists just want someone pliant to work over. Nobody wants… this.” You gestured to yourself, sharp smile not quite masking the bitterness underneath.
For once, Topaz didn’t immediately skewer you. Her gaze softened—barely. “As much as it strokes my ego to be right, I don’t think anyone here can give you what you need.”
The words hit harder than expected. You stared down into your glass, throat tight. You wanted to argue, but how could you? Too many nights had proved it.
“Maybe. But I’m stubborn enough to keep looking.”
The bass throbbed steady, rattling low in Ari’s chest, the kind of rhythm designed to keep mortals moving, distracted. He’d claimed a small table set back from the bar where he had a good vantage of the room at large, the door to the side room where the meeting would take place, and another side door opposite the bar he assumed was a discreet exit. He leaned back comfortably, arms crossed, an earpiece ready to feed him every word from inside. He’d arrived first to scout out the place and not be seen with Jake and Lloyd, which is how he’d already clocked the brute attempting to do the same for Rogg.
Rogg entered through the discreet side door, confirming Ari’s suspicions that it was an exit, and went straight into the meeting room. Jake and Lloyd arrived through the main door a few moments later, ordered a couple drinks at the bar, and then joined Rogg.
“Gentlemen,” Rogg’s voice purred. “A pleasure. It’s nice to put some faces to the name.”
Lloyd’s reply came smooth, easy. “Oh, and what name is that?”
“The Morea Group. Andy Barber. Take your pick.” Rogg answered, matching Lloyd’s easy tone. “It’s not often I hear the things I do about your group without hearing certain other things as well. You all are very… elusive.”
Lloyd gave a small laugh. “Flatterer. I hope you weren’t expecting Mr. Barber to make an appearance. I’m Lloyd Hansen,” he said without pause.
They shook hands. “Not a disappointment at all.” He then shifted his attention to Jake, offering his hand.
“Jake.” There was the slightest hitch—then Jake blurted, “Jensen.” Too quick, too loud.
Ari could practically feel the stumble through the comm.
But Lloyd slid in before Rogg could question it. “Speaking of hearing things, we’d like to know more about a mutual acquaintance—”
The conversation continued, all business. Rogg liked to talk, voice full of smug satisfaction, but Lloyd was better—guiding, flattering, letting Rogg feel in control while giving nothing away. Jake peppered in the right questions, sometimes careless enough to sound genuine, always sharper than they seemed.
It was going well.
Ari swept the floor with his eyes, steady and methodical. It turned out Rogg had brought two lookouts. The big man he’d identified earlier stood near the column. Even if he hadn’t spotted him before, he would’ve now. The man tried too hard not to stare, his posture too stiff. The sharp-eyed woman might’ve blended in better if she hadn’t kept circling him, whispering constant reminders to relax.
He told himself to focus on the meeting, but his eyes disobeyed, drifting to the bar again and again.
A woman sat alone, posture casual but alive with something deeper. No nervous energy, completely comfortable as if the barstool was her throne for the evening. There were a lot of beautiful women in the club, many more scantily clad than this one—some had even approached him, so he wasn’t sure why his eyes kept finding her.
The comm crackled as someone clapped loudly. Ari heard Lloyd’s parting charm and Rogg’s smug laugh. The meeting was done. The door opened. Lloyd, Jake, and Rogg all stepped out looking satisfied. To a casual observer they’d appear to be old friends. They said their goodbyes and Jake and Lloyd exited the main door. Rogg looked pleased with himself until his sharp-eyed watcher caught his eye and gave a small nod toward the bar.
Rogg’s expression twisted, smugness cracking into raw irritation. His stride changed—shoulders tight, mouth set. Ari recognized it instantly: a man who felt denied, slighted.
He moved toward her.
Ari’s posture shifted, still casual to the crowd, but every muscle coiled, listening harder now than he had all night. Around them, the club kept moving, music pounding, bodies mingling—no one else noticing the scene unfolding by the bar.
“What are you doing here?” Rogg’s voice cut sharp.
The woman turned slightly, calm as ever yet not quite looking at him. “What do you mean?”
“I figured you were stepping back from play since you never got back to me about our next date.”
“But I did,” she said evenly. “I said, ‘no thank you.’”
“You can’t be serious.” Rogg’s laugh was incredulous. “With how well we matched? You loved my chase.”
“You didn’t love the struggle that followed.” Her words were quick as she side-eyed him.
Rogg’s face darkened, voice dropping. “You were supposed to submit.”
“And you were supposed to make me.” Her words came fast, gaze locking hard with his.
The silence that followed cut sharp enough to bleed.
Rogg leaned in, fury leaking through the mask. “I’m the best brat-tamer here. I’ll break you so good you’ll beg for my collar.”
Her smirk was knife-sharp. “Break me? Collar me? I don’t think so.”
Ari’s jaw set. He started to move without thinking, listening to every word, muscles taut and ready.
Rogg almost reached for her. Almost. But his eyes flicked sideways—and caught Ari approaching.
Disgust twisted his face. He jerked his chin to his crew. Together, they pushed past, Rogg’s shoulder brushing Ari’s deliberately on the way out.
Ari didn’t move further. Just watched them go.
When he looked back, she was watching him. Steady. Curious. Unshaken.
Her lips curved into the faintest smirk. “Were you coming to save me?”
Ari took the barstool next to hers, unhurried. “The thought crossed my mind. But you seemed to be handling it.”
“Do you have a thing for damsels in distress?” Her tone was mocking, coy.
One corner of his mouth tugged upward. “Is that what you are? A damsel in distress?”
That earned him a sharper smile, teeth flashing just enough to suggest bite. “No.”
“Good.” The word rumbled low, almost approving.
Your drink was nearly gone, but you weren’t in any rush to order another. Not with him there, watching you with that steady, unshakable calm.
Broad shoulders. Heavy frame. The kind of man who looked like he could carry a tree out of the woods without breaking stride. Jeans and boots, shirt stretched just a little too well across his chest. He didn’t look polished like most men here—no flashy leather or sleek lines. He looked like he’d walked straight out of the forest and sat down in a nightclub.
And damn if that didn’t hit all your buttons.
Most men who came to this place leaned hard on the act—clothes, posturing, tones of voice that collapsed the second you pushed back. He didn’t need any of that. He just sat there, steady, like he could take anything you threw at him and give it back twice as hard.
Your lips tugged into a sharper smile. Exactly your type.
You waved at the barkeep with the pretense of ordering water but gestured with your eyes toward the man. The barkeep caught your look and shrugged—clearly no help in identifying him. He must be new.
Which left you with only one option: ask for yourself. Or better yet, test him.
You tipped your head, letting the music wash over the pause between you. “I’m feeling…” your gaze swept down his frame and back up, deliberate, “…playful. Would you like to learn firsthand just how not distressed I am?”
Your lips curved as you let your gaze linger on him a second longer. He didn’t flinch. Didn’t shift. Just watched, steady as stone.
“I warn you though,” you said, voice low, playful but edged, “if we go upstairs, you’d better be ready to fight for it. I like it rough. Too many doms think they earn submission with a firm tone and a quick spank. Me? You’ll have to make me. Think you’re up to it?”
You leaned in, finger tracing an idle line along the rim of your glass before flicking your gaze back up at him. The thought slipped out before you could stop it, “God, I hope so,” half-whispered, as if it was meant to stay in your head.
His mouth curved, not quite a smile, but something darker. “You don’t even know my name, and you want me to take you to bed?”
A laugh bubbled out of you, sharp and unashamed. “So you are new.” You shrugged, unapologetic. “And what’s wrong with knowing what I want?”
Something about your candor—your lack of shame—hit him harder than it should have. He liked it. A lot. His cock was already half hard just from your teasing.
“It’s Ari,” he said, voice low, steady, already thickening with intent. “I want you to know what to scream later. Lead the way.”
You led him up the narrow stairs, past couples pressed together in alcoves, the bass from below thinning into a low thrum underfoot. Your pulse kicked harder with every step, not from nerves but from the heady anticipation sparking between you.
At the end of the hall, you pushed open the door to one of the soundproof playrooms, flipping its status to occupied. The room was dim, lit low: a wide bed dressed in crisp sheets, shelves stocked with the essentials—lube, condoms, wipes.
You turned to face him, leaning back against the door as it clicked shut. “Before we do this,” you said, voice even, “you should know how I play.”
His gaze never wavered. “Tell me.”
“I don’t have a single safeword,” you explained. “I use the light system. Red means stop. Yellow means slow down, take a breather. Green means good or keep going. Simple enough?”
“Simple. Smart,” Ari said, a faint approving rumble in his tone.
You smiled, sharp and teasing again. “Good. Because you’ll need it.”
Something flickered in his eyes—challenge accepted. He stepped closer, close enough for you to feel the heat rolling off him, but still giving you the space to pull away if you wanted.
“You're bold” he said, voice low, almost amused. “Show me if your fight lasts longer than your mouth. I’ll be disappointed if you’re all bark and no bite, like most people.”
“I’m not most people,” you shot back, eyes flashing. “I definitely bite. Can you actually handle me? I won’t just yield to anyone.”
Ari huffed a little laugh, “impertinent pup.” You shuddered at the endearment, liking it more than you should. Ari’s hand lifted then, slow and deliberate, brushing a lock of hair from your face. Not a question, not a demand. A promise.
“Then fight me for it,” he murmured.
The tension cracked—heat rushing up your spine as his mouth finally claimed yours in a kiss that was anything but polite or chaste. Teeth, tongue, breath stolen. You shoved back, biting, answering fire with fire.
The kiss broke, both of you breathing harder, and then he pushed you back until your shoulders hit the wall beside the door. His weight pressed close but not crushing, testing, gauging.
You snarled against his mouth, biting his lower lip hard enough to taste iron. He only growled in answer, hands sliding down your sides with deliberate control.
Your fingers fisted in his shirt, shoving, twisting—trying to force him back. He didn’t budge. If anything, the pressure of his body pinned you harder.
He caught your wrists, one in each hand, and slammed them above your head. The move was clean, practiced, absolute. You jerked, testing, but his grip didn’t falter.
“Color?” he asked, voice low, rumbling.
“Green,” you spat, chest heaving.
His smile was sharp. “Good.”
He bent, teeth scraping the top of your shoulder before biting down—not soft, not gentle. You gasped, startled, and for a moment you didn’t care if he drew blood. Your body arched into it before you could stop yourself.
“You bite,” he said against your skin, voice almost approving. “So do I.”
Your answering bite to his neck drew a groan from him, hips already pushing against you.
Your clothes tore and scattered. He spun you, pressing you face-first into the wall, his clothed body trapping your naked one.
“You really think you can hold me down?” you panted, straining against his grip.
“I don’t think,” Ari rasped into your ear. “I know.”
He kept you pinned with one hand holding both of your wrists while his other hand explored your body. Your neck, your shoulders, your back, your hips, then he palmed your ass and let out a low appreciative groan.
He twisted you around facing him again so he could palm at your breasts.
You shoved your knee upward, aiming for his thigh. He shifted just in time, letting the strike glance off, and then caged you even tighter with his weight. His erection was hard now, pressing firm against your hip, impossible to ignore.
You tried to twist free. In a single move that had you yelping in surprise, he threw you onto the bed.
The sheets were cool under your back, your breath catching at the suddenness of it. He followed immediately, a wall of muscle and heat, pinning you down.
You clawed at his shirt, nails raking across fabric, and he answered by tearing it off himself, baring a chest that looked carved from stone. His skin was hot under your hands, scars and muscle shifting as he caught you by the throat—not squeezing, not yet, just holding you in place.
“Color?”
“Green,” you whispered, almost mocking.
His grip tightened. “Good.”
With one hand firmly on your throat, his other stroked your breasts trailing down to your belly stopping just above where you wanted him.
“Where’d your fight go, little one?” he growled, eyes burning into yours
Your eyes flashed. God, this man was dangerous.
You bucked, twisted, bit, scratched—every motion an attempt to throw him, to gain ground. But every time you thought you had him, he turned it, slammed you back into the mattress, bit you harder, kissed you rougher.
And with every clash, every growl, every breathless gasp, your body betrayed you more—heat coiling low, your fight fraying even as you clung to it.
You twisted under him, teeth bared, nails raking red down his back. He caught your wrists again and forced them above your head, pinning them to the sheets with one hand. The other slid down, rough and sure, holding your belly down, fingers splayed wide.
You bucked hard enough to nearly throw him, but he only laughed, low and dangerous. “Still fighting. Good.”
His mouth was everywhere—jaw, throat, collarbone—biting and sucking until your skin bloomed with heat. When his hand finally slipped between your thighs, you gasped, your body betraying you with how ready you already were.
“Color?” he asked, voice gravel low.
“Green,” you hissed, the word ripping out of you.
His fingers worked you mercilessly, rough and steady, until your body bowed tight against the bed. You tried to hold it, tried to deny him the victory, but it snapped out of you anyway—your orgasm tearing through, breaking your rhythm.
He grinned down at you, wolf-sharp. “So strong… yet you take it so well.”
You snarled, biting at his shoulder, but your fight had lost its teeth. You clawed at him again, trying to flip him, but your body trembled from the release. He pinned you back easily, claiming your mouth with another rough kiss.
“That was a half-hearted attempt,” he mocked, voice brushing your ear. He sat up in the bed now with his back against the headboard as he flipped you around, dragging you astride him. You had a brief moment in awe of how easily he manhandled you before you realized his cock was pressed against your soaking folds, rubbing your clit but not entering.
You keened.
“Color,” Ari asked, sounding as affected as you. It tore you out of your needy thoughts, realizing suddenly how very real and intense things had gotten.
“Yellow,” you whispered.
He immediately stilled, but didn’t move away. “What do you need?”
Your heart fluttered along with your pussy. You were gonna fuck his brains out.
You reached over to the table grabbing a condom. “Just this. Non-negotiable.”
You slid back so you could put the condom on Ari’s thick cock. You loved when a cock twitched like his. Shameless, hungry.
As you slid the condom down, you took as much of him in your mouth as you could.
Ari groaned, head banging back against the headboard. You worked his shaft with one hand, twisting and squeezing, as you tried to take more of him down your throat. “Fuck,” you thought, “I need to train more.”
Ari brushed your hair away from your face and tapped your cheek.
“As much as I love the sight of your pretty lips stretched around my cock as you struggle to take it, I want you up here,” Ari breathed.
You released him with a pop and surged forward to kiss him. He met you and positioned you over him, but left you the honors. You sank down on him slowly, taking him inch by inch. You both groaned as you eased down into him. You hadn’t bottomed out yet, but you started to bounce, working toward it.
“Good girl,” Ari kissed your temple. “Keep working yourself open on my cock.”
“I’m not that much of a good girl,” you answered breathless, rhythm becoming shaky. He was just so big you were struggling.
Ari grabbed your hips and slowly started to help. “Slowing down already, sweetheart?” He teased, purposefully stoking your fight. You growled and bit into his neck as you doubled your efforts.
His hands gripped your hips, slowing you, making you take every inch at his pace.
“And you said you’re not a good girl,” Ari huffed. “You want to be a good girl for me so badly, don’t you? Because you know good girls—” he slammed up into you, making you keen, “—take it.”
You cried out, nails raking his shoulders, but your hips betrayed you, meeting his with frantic need. He set a brutal rhythm, every snap of his hips forcing another ragged sound out of you. You bit down on his neck hard enough to bruise.
Something in you shattered. Between his words and the rough but measured thrust bottoming out in you, you came again. You felt a kind of release inside you you'd never experienced before and you wanted more.
Ari looked at her in awe. Her fight and efforts had renewed, but with that fire her eyes had shifted. They might've been rolling to the back of her head as they struggled over who was taking who, but there was no mistaking the now very Lycan eyes staring back at him. Ari snapped.
He was now done with the back and forth and fucked her roughly through her second orgasm, bouncing her on his cock until she started to cry and twitch. By now she was wrecked—sweat-drenched, pliant, moaning freely. Begging, the fight stripped down to its last embers.
“Please,” she gasped, voice breaking, her body arching under his hold.
Ari groaned, hips slamming harder, savoring the way she opened for him. “Color?”
“Green!” she sobbed, “Green. Green.” She was a mumbling mess as she rode out the aftershocks of her last orgasm.
Ari flipped her onto her knees, one hand anchoring her hip, the other closing firm around the back of her neck. He pressed her cheek into the mattress and shoved inside of her in one hard thrust.
“Good” he snarled in her ear as he drove into her from behind, steady, relentless, savoring every sound.
He growled, driving her harder into the mattress, ripping a scream from her throat as her body arched helplessly beneath him.
“Look at you,” he rasped. “Is this what you needed? Someone you couldn’t fight because you’re just so frustrated? Yeah… you need me to fuck it out of you until you’re so limp the only bone in your body is mine.”
Her body shook, every nerve lit. She moaned, begged mindlessly, no fight left.
“Again,” he growled, driving into her, pounding harder, until the world narrowed to heat, muscle. Pinned face-down into the sheets, his grip iron at the nape of her neck, she shattered around him one last time. The orgasm dragged her under as he shuddered his own release. He pulled out, his instincts taking over. If he couldn't knot her, he'd at least mark her. He removed the sheath she’d applied and pumped the rest of his spend on her ass and back. He guided her to turn over and did the same to her breasts and belly. Satisfied, he rubbed it all into her skin and held her until her breathing evened out.
You came back to yourself, feeling Ari's hands massaging your body. It was so pleasant you hummed and leaned into it. “There she is,” he murmured into your neck.
He brushed damp hair from your face. “Color?”
Your lips curved, weak but satisfied, voice hoarse. “Green.”
Ari gave you the most gorgeous smile and you realized you were smiling back at him. You basked in the afterglow. You had fought harder and longer than you'd ever been allowed to before and you'd had yielded. It was everything.
His thoughts must've been in a similar vein.
“So strong,” he murmured against your throat, “you take it so well.”
As happy and satisfied as you were, his acknowledgment had you feeling playful again. Your smile edged sly. “Not bad, lumberjack.”
Ari huffed a laugh through his nose, surprising you both. “Such an impertinent pup.” He poked your rib making you laugh.
You gave a content sigh and eased back into him, letting him hold you while your body trembled.
They lingered cuddling and chatting, about nothing really. They showered together, cleaning up and enjoying the easy intimacy as they prepared to part ways for the evening.
As Ari left the club to head back to the apartment he realized, for the first time in years, he didn’t feel restless. He felt… sated.
The lobby was quiet at this hour, just the hum of lights and the soft shuffle of the concierge behind the desk. Ari pushed through the glass doors, hands shoved in his jacket pockets, hair still damp from the club shower.
He didn’t expect to find Lloyd waiting for the elevator with three bags of takeout dangling from his hand.
“Well, well,” Lloyd drawled, eyes flicking up and down Ari in a quick sweep. “This is awkward. I figured you two would be working—or sleeping. Surprised Jake’s been okay on his own this long.”
Ari huffed a laugh. “If you were also out, I’m amazed he wasn’t blowing up our phones.”
The elevator opened and they stepped in.
“I brought a peace offering.” Lloyd lifted the bags. “I suppose you can benefit, too. I got you a steak stir fry, greens, and fried rice. And the very sweet lady insisted we try something called ‘crab rangoons.’”
Ari focused on the varying scents coming from the bags. “Thanks. Smells good.”
After a comfortable silence Lloyd’s mouth curled into a wicked smile Ari didn’t trust. “You must be hungry after such a strenuous night.”
Ari just sighed, and Lloyd laughed.
“That scent doesn’t suit you, by the way,” Lloyd added.
Ari’s brow furrowed. “Excuse me?”
“Relax, Wolfman,” Lloyd smirked, straightening as they exited the elevator. “I mean whatever soap they had, not her sweet scent—which is very pleasant.”
Ari stopped midstride.
Lloyd quickly corrected himself. “Her scent is pleasant on you. The blend suits you, unlike whatever soap is still lingering on top.” He eyed Ari with a hint of chastisement at his defensive posture. “I’m Lamian. I can hardly ignore scents any more than you can.”
Ari sighed and muttered an apology.
“No worries,” Lloyd said cheerily, slipping back into his teasing tone. “Though I thought you’d be more relaxed with empty balls.”
Ari groaned as they stepped inside the apartment.
The apartment lights were still on when they pushed through the door, the glow from the TV flickering across the living room. Jake was sprawled on the couch, but his head snapped up the second he saw them.
“Finally,” Jake said, pausing the show. His eyes narrowed, flicking from Lloyd with his armful of bags to Ari’s damp hair and loose shirt. “Where the hell have you two been?”
“Relax, mama bird.” Lloyd kicked the door shut behind him, setting the takeout on the counter. “Brought food. That should count for something.”
Jake didn’t budge, gaze bouncing back and forth between them like he was solving a crime. “Food doesn’t answer why you both smell like trouble.”
Ari just shook his head and toed off his boots. “Trouble? When are we ever in trouble?”
Lloyd laughed.
Jake leaned forward, elbows braced on his knees. “No, seriously. Lloyd, where’d you vanish to? Ari, why do you smell like cleaner?”
Lloyd shot Ari a sidelong look and breezed right past Jake’s question, “I told you. Not a good scent.” Lloyd reached for the bags, opening a carton with exaggerated care. “I considered getting you the chicken lo mein, but I wasn't sure if that was cannibalism.”
Ari laughed while Jake just sighed.
“So, I got you the Hunan shrimp,” Lloyd continued, “with spring rolls and chow mein.”
Jake’s eyes narrowed further. “You’re dodging.”
“Of course I am,” Lloyd said cheerfully, handing him the bag. “What fun is life without a little mystery? Besides…” He turned, grin sharp, “…we should really be talking about your stellar performance tonight, Mr. Jensen.”
Jake frowned, looking up from his chopsticks. “What?”
“The name thing,” Lloyd said, dropping into a chair with his own carton. “You know—‘Jake… Jensen.’ You panicked.”
Ari bit into his stir fry, watching with faint amusement as Jake sputtered.
“I didn’t panic,” Jake argued, pointing with his chopsticks. “It was… improv. I just…realized we never actually did my name, so I said the first human surname that came to mind.”
“Improv?” Lloyd laughed. “You turned us into a goddamn German cake. Hansen and Jensen? Do you know what a Hansen Jensen Torte is? It’s a fruitcake, Jake. You made us a fruitcake.”
Jake groaned, dragging a hand down his face.
Ari huffed, shaking his head. “Is it even a common fruitcake? Rogg didn't seem to realize.”
“True,” Lloyd said smoothly, gesturing between himself and Jake. “The man clearly didn't know his desserts.”
Jake shook his head, relaxing. “He does seem like the type to skip dessert.”
“Well, that settles it,” Ari added without missing a beat. “He clearly can’t be trusted.”
They finished their food talking about everything and nothing—Rogg, his lackeys, Jake’s show. Ari got up without preamble, tossing his containers in the trash. “We should get some sleep. See you in the morning.”
The others acknowledged him, Lloyd with a nod and Jake with a small salute.
He headed to his suite and got ready for bed. He stared in the mirror as he brushed his teeth. He paused, shifting his eyes—just like her eyes had been. He hadn’t imagined it. She was part Lycan. She had to be only part, otherwise they would’ve scented each other long before their eyes ever met.
He rinsed, thoughts turning over. His eyes had kept drifting to her form. He must’ve realized on some level. How was that possible, and what did it mean?
He undressed and stretched out in bed, arm behind his head. He thought of her smile, the way she constantly challenged him. He loved it. She wanted desperately to be a good girl for a worthy mate—and her standards were high.
He smirked to himself. Of course she’d found human men lacking.
His groan slipped out as his hand wrapped around his half-hard cock. She’d felt so good wrapped around him, teeth in his neck. Gods, he regretted not tasting her properly. Fuck, he wanted her musk all over him.
He remembered how good she’d looked when she’d gazed up at him, struggling to swallow his cock and enjoying every second of it.
“Fuck,” he muttered, stroking himself harder, faster, thoughts spiraling. He wanted to claim her in every way. The next time she wanted his cock in her pretty mouth, it’d be while he fucked her perfect tits.
His hips bucked into his hand, chasing release. It’d never be enough. He needed her… and he didn’t even know her name.
You were exhausted in the best way possible. You admired all the marks Ari had left on you while you did your nightly skin care. God, what was that? You didn’t even know sex could be that good. What a swing from all the disappointing encounters.
You were definitely feeling yourself after such an evening. You put on your favorite little sleep shorts and your softest crop top, enjoying the occasional twinge of your muscles as you got into bed.
You couldn’t help but play with your breasts as you thought of Ari’s big hands and how thoroughly he’d ruined you. Fuck, the mere memory had you needy all over again.
You shimmied back out of your sleep shorts and reached for your vibrator. You were still almost too sensitive, but tried to imagine what Ari would say right now. You can take it for me, can’t you, little one? Be my good girl.
Fuuuuuck—your body jolted, writhing, but it wasn’t enough. You whimpered, trying to chase the edge but just not getting there.
That toy isn’t going to cut it anymore, princess.
You could just imagine how smug Ari would be if he could actually see you. Then again, if he could actually see you right now, he’d help you out. Grind harder. Bully that little clit.
You didn’t know when you’d flipped onto your stomach, but you were grinding your vibrator into the mattress, desperate, chasing it. You started whimpering his name, begging a man who wasn’t even there to help you.
You imagined his weight at your back and his voice in your ear. Tsk. Poor thing. I’ll take care of you next time. But for now… come.
And God help you, you did. You came hard… and passed out.
You woke up with your alarm the next morning. You weren’t exactly refreshed, but it wasn’t your worst morning. You fished your dead vibrator out of the sheets and tossed it in your drawer to deal with later.
You tossed everything—including your linens—into the hamper and took a shower. The warm water was relaxing and grounding. It let you think.
You had to see Ari again, that was obvious. But would he want to see you? You hoped so, but there were no illusions about what it was—or what it started out as, anyway. Maybe sex was always that incredible for Ari and you were just another night.
That thought pained you and you literally snarled. “No,” you said out loud to yourself. “That was incredible. You’re just having dark thoughts because you need to eat and could use more sleep. Stop it.”
You opted for a white turtleneck under your pale blue scrubs. You’d have to remember not to pull up your sleeves as you were wont to do. Your watch could hide the marks on one wrist, but the other—you still had some silicone bracelets from the last event, right?
You checked yourself in the mirror. No one at the clinic or shelter should look twice, you thought. You giggled. Covering up Ari’s marks was a wonderful way to pick your look for the day.
You phoned in your breakfast order for pickup, grabbed your purse, and headed out into the world, heart thrumming.
Ari's story continues in Marked: Ari, Part 2