Are All Three Up For It?
Natemare/Anti x reader
Prompt: "I'm sorry for asking for a threesome okay, now please don't leave"
You stood with bated breath as you had just asked the question, broadly speaking that had been in your mind side puberty, to your boyfriend. Natemare hadn't looked at you since you asked him, but you couldn't read his expression, his eyes kept looking around, his mouth moving to form words but not speaking any. Not being vocal was not a part of Natemare.
You watched as he put his black jacket over his arms while looking at you with an expression you knew he didn't want you to be able to read, oh no, he was really angry with you wasn't he?
You followed him downstairs where he grabbed the keys from the bowl by the door. You panicked, feeling selfish and scared, sad you'd hurt his feelings.
"I'm sorry for asking for a threesome okay, now please don't leave!" You begged with your voice almost wobbling, there was no way you were going to cry over this, but you were nervous! Especially when Natemare smiled at you, something you weren't expecting, before jogging out the door.
"Natemare?" You asked, popping your head out the door as you watched the car speed away.
You sighed, locking the door behind you and going to the couch, flopping on it face first, clogs dangling from the arm, as you screamed into the cushion.
It was just less than an hour later when you screamed. You didn't know why but your body was telling you it was an appropriate response, and when your eyes began to work too, having almost fallen asleep on the couch, you realised you were no longer on the couch, but instead in the air, in Anti's arms.
"Aw, I thought you'd be ready waiting for us doll." Anti teased, winning down at you. You whimpered sleepily, looking over and to your surprise you found your boyfriend smiling excitedly at you. You thought he left, mad at you. "Mare?.." you asked confused, rubbing your eyes.
Natemare uncrossed his arms, walking over and nodding to Anti, who set you down on your feet, his hands settling on your hips. You first thought thsi was to steady a sleepy you, but he didn't let go.
Natemare smiled, grabbing your chin between his thumb and forefinger and kissing you deeply, you flared up, very aware Anti was in the room and still attached to you as you and Natemare kissed. The whimper you again made just made both boys laugh. Antis tickling against the nape of your neck and Natemares fanning over your cheeks as he pulled back slightly. "Sorry for speeding off like that love, but I didn't want to keep you waiting." He explained. And suddenly all your cognitive functions came back to you. Oh, he wasn't mad at you, not even mad at Anti for gaining your affection. So that means that, oh... oh shit!
Natemare but his bottom lip, his fingertips just sliding underneath the hem of your trousers ever so slightly. "Are you still up for it kitten?"
You already felt yourself leaning into his touch. But you had to make sure this was right. You turned your head, not realising you were licking your lips as you looked at Anti. He smiled wickedly, giving your shoulder a purposeful nip, putting as Natemare slipped his hand further, making you arch into his hands. Anti kept eye contact with you as you moaned at this over the underwear contact before saying "I know I'm definitely up for it"