HTGAWM rewatch blog "He Deserved to Die" (1x07)
Wesbecca was my favorite ship, so an episode focusing on Wes & Rebecca is of course gonna be one of my favorites :)
This episode doesn't have a very clear theme, unlike some of the other episodes, but if there's one thing many characters have in common, it's that they are dealing with relationship issues. Annalise & Sam, Wes & Rebecca, Laurel & Kan/Frank, Michaela & Aiden, Connor...
In the spotlight this episode: Rebecca Sutter (& Wes Gibbins) Seriously, Rebecca gets more and more awesome on every rewatch. People tend to call her awful, but I really don't get why. Did she do an awful thing when she drugged Rudy? Yes. Is she a vulnerable orphan with no support system, a rough upbringing, and who always had to look out for herself? Also, yes. Does she have trust issues? Absolutely, but seeing her past, I wouldn't say that's surprising. Rebecca does the things she does because she's always had to fend for herself. I don't think she's a horrible person, she's just incredibly misunderstood by both people in the show and many viewers.
Rebecca doesn't trust people, so she has her walls up and acts snarky and manipulative around everyone. But underneath that mask is a very vulnerable person, who comes through when Lila's mother accuses her of killing Lila, and when Wes tries to kiss her. She's also protective of people she cares about, which we see in the present day where she manipulates Laurel and Michaela into shutting up about Rebecca sleeping with Wes, and also in the flashforward where she offers to take the fall to protect Wes.
Despite her armor, we've gradually seen her open up to Wes, and this episode marks another step in their relationship. Wes is very similar to Rebecca: he also had a rough upbringing, is the outsider, and doesn't let people in. He desperately tries to help Rebecca, but at the same time, she still knows little to nothing about him. In this episode, she calls him out on it twice: first when she teasingly calls him "the most privatest person ever," the second time when they fight and she asks him if his parents had issues and if that's why he's so obsessed with her life. She absolutely has a point there.
Wes just keeps insisting that he wants to help her, but if she doesn't want that, he'll stop. Which is honestly a bit manipulative and very characteristic of someone with a savior complex. I don't think Wes is doing it intentionally, unlike Annalise or Rebecca, who manipulate the hell out of people. But he is doing it, and it gives us a glimpse into Wes's dark past and how he has no idea how to be in a healthy relationship.
Wes and Rebecca then just... start making out... in the heat of the moment, which is also kinda toxic, and I guess that is expressed by intercutting their make-out scene with Lila's autopsy scene. I guess that's also a bit of foreshadowing that Rebecca is doomed, basically. She also showed up twice in a bathroom, once in the present day and once in the flashforward.
I love how Wes finally opens up to Rebecca. He tells her a lot of random things about his hobbies and his life, but also drops a bomb when he somewhat casually glosses over how his mom killed herself when he was 12. Rebecca stops him, but he barely seems to be able to talk about it, which shows how deeply that trauma or even PTSD is still buried. He tells her his mom is messed up, too, just like he is. Rebecca is there for him, accepts him.
I really, really love that moment after they made out and they're just lying in Wes's bed. I also love that Rebecca is looking for Wes's favorite ice cream when she's in the supermarket, and tells Nate that her "boyfriend" is waiting for her in the car. I just find it sweet how two guarded, somewhat broken outsiders open up to and protect each other.
In the flashforwards two weeks later, they are madly in love. Wes lifts her upstairs moments after Sam's death. He cleans the blood off her face. They kiss, and he tells her everything's gonna be fine over and over throughout their flashforward scenes. Is it? No, but that's his savior complex speaking. Rebecca lets Wes take care of her (which I think is very rare for Rebecca). Rebecca mostly looks out for herself, but her willingness to take the fall for Wes shows how much she cares about him.
The Lila Stangard case This episode didn't feature a case of the week, but focused solely on the Lila Stangard case. Rebecca and Griffin have their hearings, but things get a bit ugly as the press gets involved, rumors are spread, and plea deals are (almost) made.
Griffin's lawyer wants to exhumate Lila's body to prove Griffin's innocence, but Annalise and the prosecutor (Wendy Parks, who is one of the most awesome minor characters) are against it. Sam gives Annalise a hint on how to block it, but ultimately, the judge orders to continue with the exhumation. Turns out that some red marks were ant bites instead of Rebecca's fingernails, and Lila was six weeks pregnant.
Annalise and Sam have been working on their relationship. Annalise tells Sam she needs more time, but things improve throughout the episode. At least, until Bonnie reveals that Lila was pregnant. Annalise seems shattered while Sam couldn't look more guilty after that revelation.
Meanwhile, Nate confronts Annalise with planting Lila's phone in Griffin's car, and says he knows she doesn't believe that Sam is innocent. He approaches Rebecca in the convenience store and asks for her help to take Sam down. Nate, what the hell.
Wes & Annalise... don't really have any scenes together. Wes still seems to be a bit annoyed with her and intervenes when Annalise yells at Rebecca for not taking her trial prep seriously. Annalise still has a sweet spot when she actually listens to Wes's suggestion to take a break. But when Annalise & Rebecca team up to leak a fake story to the press, Wes is annoyed with both of them.
Just an observation, but Wes's behavior toward Rebecca is very similar to Annalise's behavior towards the Keating Five (and Wes especially) later on. In the flashforwards, Wes keeps telling Rebecca that he's just trying to help her and that things will be fine (even though he just killed a man), and Annalise constantly does that with people later on. Pete Nowalk has said in interviews that he sees Wes and Annalise as two sides of the same coin, and even though this episode showed once again how different their values are, they are very similar in the lengths they go to protect the people they love. Wes isn't the only one with a savior complex.
Wes and Annalise are both traumatized by losing people, feel they might be unlovable (or "messed up," as Wes calls himself), and basically have built a fortress around themselves. But deep down, they are both just craving connection. Wes finds it in Rebecca while Annalise works on restoring it with Sam, but eventually they'll find it in each other.
The Keating Five This episode didn't really have that many group scenes, but the moments they had together were mostly spent mocking Wes (or "Romeo") with his obvious crush on Rebecca. Asher thinks they are doing the nasty, Connor says some people just have it up for crazy, Michaela calls it inappropriate, and even Laurel seems a bit awkward when she says it's kinda sweet.
This episode has a few scenes in a row that are comedic gold. It starts with Bonnie asking the guys to go to a bar to get Wendy Parks's assistant to talk:
Asher: On it. Bonnie: Connor and Wes, you go, too. Asher: What do I need them for? Connor: This works on women as well as men. Bonnie: He's right. Rebecca: Hey, can I go, too? I'm really good at flirting with girls. Bonnie: I'm sure. You stay here with us. Rebecca: Girls' night. Whoo-hoo...
Followed by a scene where Rebecca skillfully manipulates both Laurel and Michaela to get them to stop talking about her and Wes. Laurel can be pretty manipulative, and she's also a bit more resistant to Annalise's manipulation than the others, but she's no match for Rebecca. Michaela is just incredibly easy to manipulate.
Next is the scene at the bar, where Connor is talking to the assistant, drunk, dumping his worries about him cheating on his girlfriend "Olive." Followed by a hilarious interaction between Wes, who only cares about getting the assistant to talk, and Asher, who just wants to "release the kraken." It's a mystery to me how Alfie (Wes) managed to keep a straight face while Matt (Asher) was saying the most ridiculous lines ever, but I love it xD.
Finally, Wes and a drunk Asher report back to Annalise and Bonnie. I love that interaction between Asher and Bonnie (and how he makes a complete idiot of himself in front of Annalise), before Wes steps in and kills the fun.
Oh, and for the record: it is Wes who got the assistant to talk. Not Asher, who insisted he didn't need Connor and Wes. Not Connor, who said 'this' works on both women and men. But the puppy. Don't underestimate the puppy.
Besides the comedic moments in this episode, the students also have some more serious individual plotlines:
Connor hooks up with a random guy through Humpr, but can't seem to get over Oliver. When Connor shows up in front of Oliver's door with flowers, a random guy opens and tells Connor to stay away.
Kan offers Laurel a job at Legal Aid, but Laurel is torn. Frank is still pissed at Laurel for telling him she's not interested, but when he finds out she's considering taking another job, he tells her he'll get over his feelings for Laurel. Laurel tells him she doesn't want him to get over it, and they kiss.
Michaela thinks she's invited for an interview at a famous law office, but when she shows up, it turns out Aiden's family wants her to sign a prenup.
(Asher... has the trophy, flirts with someone at the bar by using the lamest pick-up line ever, and gets drunk.)
A few other random observations Connor mentions that "Romeo saves Juliet again" implying Wes has been mediating between Annalise and Rebecca more than once. Not really an observation, but I just love that moment where Annalise yells at Rebecca, Wes proposes to take a break, and Annalise slowly turns to Wes without saying a word. It's such an awkward moment, I love it.
Annalise mentions having miscarriages. She may have been manipulating Wes in the pilot when she told him she and Sam were trying for a baby, but she wasn't entirely lying. We'll see it play out a bit through flashbacks in 3x05.
Also, I have a feeling the writers very intentionally had both Annalise bring up her miscarriages, and Wes bring up his mother's suicide in the same episode. Love how the writers are planting seeds for their relationship in the back half of season 1.
Rebecca is really smart, btw. During her psych evaluation with Sam in 1x05, she already said she had a high IQ. In this episode, she brings up the O.J. trial, showing she's clearly done her research, and we learn that she's really good at reading people. Annalise, Laurel, Michaela, Wes...
We can also piece together Wes's academic background based on this episode. He went to community college and got his degree from a night school. Wes is 21 throughout most of his 1L year (his DOB is 6 October 1993, this episode takes place early December 2014), so I suspect he graduated from high school at 17 and got an Associate's Degree at his community college at 19. He then may have transferred his credits to his night school and crammed a lot of courses into one year to obtain his degree at 20. In that same year, he was placed on the waitlist of an Ivy League-level university, which is seriously impressive when you think about it. Wes is really smart, he just doesn't brag about it.
Final thoughts This is one of my favorite episodes. It has some great comedy, is full of Wes & Rebecca moments, Wendy Parks and Keegan bring some spice to the court scenes, we get some more background on Wes... There are so many moments I like in this episode that I don't even notice the lack of Wes & Annalise scenes (and they still have their moments, even though they only happen in group scenes). I'd say this episode is an underrated gem, at least for the Wes and Rebecca fans out there.
Rating: 10/10










