Whatever's Left Over
Pairing: James Potter x Reader Summary: James gave away the one weekend that was meant to be just yours. The argument that follows isn't really about the barbecue. Tags: arguments, angst, hurt/comfort, established relationship, happy ending
It starts with the kitchen table between you, same as it always does when things go wrong. You're stood at one end with a tea towel in your hands, twisting it, and James is at the other, still in his coat, still holding his keys, his hair doing the thing it does when he's dragged a hand through it on the walk home.
"You said yes," you say, "before you even asked me."
"It's one weekend," he says, dropping the keys on the table with a clatter, "Sirius has had it planned for weeks, mate practically begged, I could hardly say no—"
"We had a weekend, James." You hear your own voice climb and try to bring it back down and don't quite manage it. "We planned it, a weekend just for us. Six weeks ago. You circled it on the calendar yourself, with a little star, I watched you do it."
"I know, and we'll do it," he says, easy, like it's obvious, like you're the one being difficult, "just — not this weekend, is all. We'll move it. It's not going anywhere."
"That's not the point—"
"So what is the point," he says, and grins, quick and automatic, the grin that's got him out of detentions and worse, "because from where I'm stood the point seems to be a barbecue versus my girlfriend, and I'm fairly sure I know which one wins—"
"Don't," you say, "don't do the charm thing, not right now."
That lands somewhere. His grin drops half a second too fast, and something flickers behind his glasses that isn't a joke at all. "I'm not doing a thing, I'm trying to—" He stops, starts again. "It's Padfoot. You know what he's like when he's organised something, he'll sulk for a fortnight if I pull out, and Moony's driving up specially—"
"And what am I meant to do," you say, "just... shuffle round in the diary until there's a gap left over? Because that's what it feels like, James. Like I get whatever weekend nobody else has claimed."
"That's not fair."
"Isn't it though." Your voice cracks a bit on it, which annoys you more than anything he's said. "This was ours. We picked it because it was the one free weekend we had. And you gave it away in about four seconds flat because Sirius asked nicely."
"So I forgot, all right," he says, an edge creeping into it too, because James hates this — hates thinking he's let you down, hates it so much he'd rather argue his way out of the feeling than sit in it — "I'm not allowed one mistake now, is that it? I have to run every single thing past you before I so much as say hello to my own mates—"
The room goes tense in the particular, horrible way it only can with someone you love. Nobody's shouting. That's almost worse.
You put the tea towel down on the table, right in the middle, like a small white flag neither of you asked for.
James looks at it. Then he looks at you. And something in his face changes — you watch it happen, watch the argument go out of him like a held breath finally let go.
"This isn't about the barbecue," he says, quietly, like he's only just heard himself.
"No," you say.
"It's about you thinking you come after everyone else." He says it plainly, no charm in it, no joke to soften the corners. "That you get slotted in around Sirius and Remus and the footie and whatever's left over."
You don't answer straight away, because your throat's gone tight, and because he's right, and hearing it said out loud by him is somehow harder than thinking it yourself at two in the morning.
"Yeah," you say, finally. "That's it."
He pulls out the chair across from you — the one that's always a bit too far from the table, that always gets shoved back in properly by whoever tidies up last — and he sits. He doesn't cross his arms. He doesn't make a joke about how he'd rather sit through his own dentist appointment than have this conversation, which is the sort of thing he'd usually say to get you laughing before you're ready to laugh.
He just sits, and looks at you, and says, "I'm sorry."
Properly sorry. The kind with nothing hiding behind it.
"I keep doing it because I don't think," he says, "I say yes because it's easy and it's my mates and I don't stop to think what it costs you, and that's — that's rubbish of me, isn't it."
"A bit," you say, and your voice wobbles on it.
He reaches across the table, over the tea towel, and turns his hand palm up. Doesn't grab. Just leaves it there, open, waiting.
You look at it for a second. At the space between his hand and yours, the little stretch of wood grain and one abandoned tea towel that's somehow come to mean everything's fine or everything's not, depending on who reaches first.
You reach first. You always do, in the end, because staying angry at James Potter has never once outlasted the sight of his open hand.
His fingers close round yours, and something in your chest loosens that you didn't know was wound so tight.
"I should've said something the second you said yes to Sirius," you admit, "instead of letting it sit for a week and stewing."
"And I should've asked before I said yes," he says, "instead of assuming you'd just... fit round it."
"Both true," you say.
"Both true," he agrees, and there's the ghost of a smile now, careful, testing whether it's allowed.
You let it be allowed.
"I'll tell Sirius it's just me this weekend," he says, "you and me, here, nothing else. I'll text him tonight."
"You don't have to cancel—"
"I want to," he says, and squeezes your hand, once, like punctuation. "The barbecue can wait. Sirius'll sulk for an hour and then forget he was ever cross. This can't wait. You can't wait."
You laugh, a small wet sort of laugh, the kind that comes right after nearly crying. "That's dead soppy, Potter."
"Yeah, well," he says, "you make me soppy."
The chair across from you isn't too far away any more. It's right where it should be, pulled in, close enough that your knees knock his under the table when you shift, and neither of you moves away.
The tea towel's still sat there between your hands, forgotten now, its little white flag job done.
"Tea?" he says, after a while, nodding at the kettle.
"Go on then," you say.
He gets up to put the kettle on, and on his way past he presses a kiss to the top of your head, easy, like breathing, like nothing at all happened five minutes ago. But something did. And you both know it, and you both let it settle, the way the kettle settles into its low building hum, the way his chair sits pulled in at the table now, waiting for him to come back and fill it.
He does.










