Rated R (Strong Brutal Violence Including A Sexual Attack, Menace, Some Sexual Content, and Pervasive Language)
Starring James Marsden, Kate Bosworth, Alexander Skarsgard, Dominic Purcell, Laz Alonso, Willa Holland, and James Woods
Straw Dogs is a surprisingly well-made remake that doesn't go too over the top. It is pretty violent though, and I'll warn that there is a sexual attack in the film. I remember when I watched Wes Craven's original The Last House on the Left I enjoyed it because even though it was brutal it didn't exactly try to put a label on itself as a flat-out horror film. The 2009 Dennis Iliadis remake is suspenseful but tries too hard to act like a horror film. And worst of all, the violence goes completely over the top. Straw Dogs is different though. It's brutal but doesn't try to celebrate horror movie conventions. This is strictly a thriller about the animal inside us and the time it takes for us to release it.
The controversial Sam Peckinpah original, though, is much much much much much better. It came out in 1971 and it still manages to shock me every time I watch it. It's about Dustin Hoffman and Susan George, a married couple that decides to move into George's old house in Cornwall, England. Their lives get mixed up with some creepy old british men and thennnnnn it get bad. That's all I'll say. Hoffman and George give grade A performances and the editing is exhilarating. Best of all though is the movie's views on violence in society. Why are certain people fascinated by it? Sometimes we exhibit violence when we don't mean to and sometimes we're forced to to protect our own lives.
The remake is set in the south this time and stars James Marsden and Kate Bosworth as the couple and Alexander Skarsgard, or Eric from True Blood, as the main baddie. The movie certainly isn't as effective as the old one and its philosophical views feel less intact. However I was engrossed by its effort. Director Rod Lurie understands the meaning of the original and tries his absolute best to make a faithful remake and in many ways he succeeds. The acting is superb. Marsden makes his character as dorky and awkward as Hoffman's. Bosworth is surprisingly natural here. Skarsgard is great at being bad. James Woods, as well, is so amazing at being bad too.
The editing is very well-done as well. The cross-cutting technique that signifies Peckinpah's films (specifically The Wild Bunch) isn't really used here but does it need to? I'm glad that Lurie didn't simply repeat what Peckinpah did in the editing room. The soundtrack in the movie is also very nicely handled. If you've seen the trailer for the movie then unfortunately you pretty much know what will be the big climax of the film. Take my word for it, DO NOT WATCH THIS TRAILER. Be surprised. Even though Hollywood made this trailer to try and get more audiences Straw Dogs still got #5 at the box office its opening week. Trailers don't always work!