The weirdest part of the Torrie Lemon arrest story is that Bob Jones University is the hub.
Lemon didn't even attend here, and still BJU becomes the center of the story. It adds to the proof that
So here's the timeline according to the Indianapolis Star in July 2025.
August 2024: Torrie Lemon began teaching kindergarten at Chuck Phelps' Colonial Christian Academy in Indianapolis.
January 2025: Lemon started texting with a 17yo female student "as friends." Things quickly turned "sexual." The student "never intended" for their relationship to "turn sexual" since she "knew it was wrong." On January 1, 2025, two counts of "child seduction" occurred.
February 9, 2025: The victim's parents invited Lemon over for a Super Bowl party. The mother observed a hasty relationship forming. This is when the third count of "child seduction" occurred.
February 10, 2025: A fourth count of "child seduction" occurred.
March 2025: Lemon and the underage student "had sex" at Lemon's on-campus apartment, in a church, and at the student's house.
April 10, 2025: Colonial Christian made their annual trek to Bob Jones University for the AACS National Competition. Lemon acted as a chaperone. The victim was present as a participant. Another friend found a hidden folder on the victim's phone which contained a video of Lemon and the victim kissing. The snoopy friend immediately informed a male teacher. The male teacher informed the parents, dismissed Lemon from the BJU trip, and filed a report to Indiana DCS and the Greenville police dept. Lemon and the victim admitted in Greenville that they were "in a relationship." The victim stayed in Lemon's room in the BJU dorms. Lemon told the Greenville police that "was having an inappropriate relationship with a student from her school" and she was "struggling with it."
April 14, 2025: Indianapolis police interviewed the victim and her mother.
April 16, 2025: Indianapolis police tried to contact Lemon, but she had left the state to move back to New Hampshire. That is, Phelps et al scuttled her away from the investigation. Lemon told the principal in her exit interview that things "started with hugs, then longer hugs, then kissing, and then sexual acts."
April 23, 2025: The case moved to Hamilton County.
July 1, 2025: Lemon was charged with two counts of Child Seduction.
November 5, 2025: Lemon was charged with two more counts.
November 6, 2025: Lemon was arrested.