I'm sorry this thought doesn't let me go, you know. Dilf Armin from your work, birth control didn't work and your boyfriend is happy, BUT you share quick glances with Armin both knowing the truth. Like "our kid has this beautiful blue eyes" bc of Armin, not /him/.
holy fuck this ask took me by the fucking throat afeafnufn
dilf context / tw; dilfs/daddy kink, cheating, pregnancy, breeding
perhaps your boyfriend was drawn away from work more often than you'd expected. the "one time thing" armin had promised you becomes "just once more" and "i know you want more".
your boyfriends father looks down upon you most nights now, his cock bullying it's way inside your tight pussy. armin is anything but an underachiever, and even in his later years he can breed you completely. cum oozes from you, leaving a sloppy white ring around his pretty pink cock. several loads will be fucked back into you, his words falling so daintily to your ears, "fuckin' take it, you're s'good, s's'good for your daddy"
and maybe in this new routine, you'd forgotten to take the pill when your alarm went off. it was okay, just once every now and then.
your boyfriend continued to check in, make sure staying with his father was okay. you'd reassure him that "armin is nothing but a gentleman and a lovely host," whilst his hand squeezes your thigh under the dinner table.
when you took the test, and it showed up with 5-6 weeks pregnant you knew. straight away you could see the shared calendar on your phone with those particular days blocked out as your husband being away. it's easy to spin the dates a little to make it work.
after the baby is born, with bright blue eyes, it becomes harder to twist a tale of lies. your boyfriend has always had his mothers eyes, and he's sure the babies will change as weeks progress.
your childs eyes don't change color or settle into a new hue. they remain beautiful and light, just like their fathers.