[ID: The posster for Hazbin Hotel depicting the main cast--Husker, Angel Dust, Alastor, Adam, Sir Pentious, Charlie, Vaggie, Niffty and Lucifer--wreathed in flames, some of them singing and some looking grumpy with the singing. End ID.]
I finally got around to binging this without giving Amazon a penny and I had a good time! My favourite character's definitely Alastor, because I enjoy the shit out of a Token Evil Teammate who is genuinely evil and ridiculously powerful and just so happens to be pointing all that power in the same direction as the good guys... for now. They're a lot of fun! The 20s radio presenter voice is also just inherently comedic to me, I'm a simple creature easily entertained by an old-timey presenter accent saying some deranged shit
Is it good? The animation is a matter of taste but I really enjoy the energy and creativity and the songs are unambiguously bangers performed extremely well by a very talented voice cast. The storyline is trying to keep a lot of balls in the air at once and wobbles a bit in the execution, especially because its internal morality is... kinda messy? Which is partly intentional--none of the angels know what the criteria for getting into Heaven actually are and the criteria for getting into Hell seem to be overly broad and then people just get worse once they're in there as a self-defense mechanism (much like prison). On the other hand, I did notice a trend that made me uncomfortable in how the overall narrative handles sex and sexuality; it's entirely expected that Hell would be full of abusive, unhealthy sex (and Angel Dust's song Poison about it is one of the best) but it seems to lump in the suggested trip to a BDSM club--one where nothing shown is unsafe or unconsensual--with unhealthier expressions of Angel Dust's sexuality. The main couple of Charlie and Vaggie, the closest thing to straight-up good characters that the show has, are noticeably chaste and don't so much as kiss until the last episode despite being in a multi-year relationship. I wanna emphasize there's absolutely nothing wrong with having little or no sex in a relationship if that's what you and your partner want (or don't), it's just that in context it comes off like good people have little or no sex while only unhinged assholes or the painfully broken have lots of sex or non-vanilla sex (Adam, one of the biggest assholes in the show, also never shuts up about having raunchy sex). Points for apparently both of Adam's wives having ditched him for Lucifer (who implicitly gives more than he gets), but overall there's a possibly unintentional but still present pattern that makes me uncomfortable as a queer person who reads history; pathologizing/criminalizing safe, sane and consensual sex between two adults always leads to defining queer people doing anything in public (such as holding hands or wearing a rainbow earring) as an extension of that kind of eeeeeevil sex. We'll see where it goes in S2.
Is it fun? EXTREMELY taste-based, but I really enjoyed it. I can see how it can come off as thinking humour consists entirely of cartoon characters saying fuck and making sex jokes, but I'm enjoying the shit out of the clever, snappy writing in the musical numbers and the creative art designs, and Niffty's general existence never fails to entertain me.
Is it queer? Yes, with Charlie and Vaggie canonically being in a WLW relationship, Angel Dust doing a lot of gay porn, and Alastor being referred to as asexual (though he doesn't seem to know what that means).