Its meh motherfrickin' birthday today, so you know what that means? /Birthday DeanBenny/. Like what if it was Benny's birthday and the whole dang time Dean keeps making old man jokes and Dean even sets up a party for Benny (sure only Sam and Cas will come but hey). And the party is pirate themed with boat streamers and a Jack and the Neverland Pirates Walmart cake and everyone's wearing eyepatches. Benny nearly tears up because its been so long since someone cared, even if its incredible silly
eeeee, happy (technically late but i talked to you yesterday) birthday!!!!!!!
Dean would 110% be a total nerd and do all of that. He'd probably relentlessly quote Jack Sparrow till Sam smacks him with his plastic hook hand, but Cas and Dean would be giggling because they maybe had a little too much rum already. Benny is just happy to be surrounded by people he calls family :')))