Precisely what Bernie and dreadful said. I have and will side-eye the shit out of gay couples who say âOh, weâre so normal we forget weâre gay!!â (Yeah, thatâs an actual quote that has been said to my face before.)Â
But a lot of this âfuck marriage because ASSIMILATIONâ rhetoric is forgetting a few key things, specifically, that âmarriageâ is not just about a party. Itâs not just about buying a dress or tux or dresses or tuxes or cakes or whatever. Itâs not even about what heteros define âmarriageâ as, and itâs not even about what society considers a âmarriage,â for the most partâ a lot of us simply want the opportunity to protect ourselves in the case of our partner getting sick, being hospitalized, and want the opportunity of sharing our health-care benefits, and in the event of one of our deaths, wanting the surviving spouse to be able to receive inheritance without ridiculously high tax rates because weâre not considered next-of-kin. Also, how the US defines âmarriageâ is, in my mind, just one simple title that fixes (or helps alleviate) a LOT of problemsâ just look at binational couples. Consider adoption rights. Marriage-per-the-state is a fucked up system, but guess what? Thatâs the system we have, and itâs not gonna change, ESPECIALLY just because we gays want it to change.
Also, letâs not forget about the religiously devout LGBT folk who DO want to have the so-called ânormal life, white picket fence, kids, a dogâ etc. If theyâre not othering more radical LGBT folk, why shit all over them for something you perceive to not be âradicalâ enough? Mind your business.
I canât speak for everyone (and I donât want to), but there wonât be anything societally normative about my girlfriendâs and my life together. (But heyâ I donât feel the need to earn a âbadge of radicalismâ by some nameless group of glitter-shitting gays, either.) We just want the same protection that my brother and sister will get if they decide to get married, too.
Iâve seen a lot of bullshit, also, about how these so-called âassimilationistsâ only care about marriage, as if people are so dense that they canât care about more than one thing at a time. There are those who think marriage is the endcap to a century of fighting for equality, and fuck those simple people. Seriously. Marriage equality is sooo not the most important thing out thereâ passing ENDA and equalizing trans* issues to catch up with the popularity and âsuccessesâ of LGB advances are way more important. Meaningful outreach for our younger community members is incomparably important, and NOT just the white, cis, monogamous-leaning âso cute they could be on Gleeâ gays, either. When are people going to make a big show about the number of trans* WOC put behind bars for protecting themselves, or the ridiculously high suicide rate among the trans* community? (Spoiler alert: HRC is not going to be the one leading THAT crusade.) Itâs a shitty hand to be dealt, that marriage is becoming the #1 issue, but itâs one part of the puzzle. Also, letâs not forget how marriage will affect a ton of people under the LGBTQ umbrellaâ not just cis gays.
Last point on this disjointed rant is the fact that being able to be out, loud, proud, and demonstrably gay is a fucking PRIVILEGE. If I were out, Iâd be fired. Who would that help? Iâll tell you who it WOULDNâT help: it wouldnât help my wife and our financial stability. It wouldnât help the gay and trans* kids who attend my school and see me and their other (closeted, yet they-know-that-I-know-that-they-know) teachers/staff members/counselors as an example of well-established, successful LGBT adults. Some people canât be out not only because theyâd be shit-canned IMMEDIATELY, but also because they could be hurt or KILLED because of it. Letâs not sit here and demonize them for not âfurthering the cause,â just because you think them putting their livelihood and LIVES on the line is somehow worth it, especially when theyâre helping people within these sheltered communities.
tl;dr there are serious issues here, but letâs not be ignorant and lazy by focusing on demonizing so-called âassimilationistsâ just because you (collective, non-specific âyouâ posed to whomever) want to pat yourself on the back for earning your âMost Radical Queer in the Communeâ award. Fuck straight-laced (pun intended) gays who think the more radical set will âruin the chance of âequality,ââ but also fuck self-proclaimed radical-gays for demonizing those who arenât radical enough for their liking.