This had worked in the past. Kitty had seen a time when Sonny wasn’t nearly this difficult to reel in, but times change and broken boys only grow harder. Raised a particularly fickle child, Kitty was never as certain about anything as she was when choosing which of her toys to play with for the month. Like dolls, all of her lovers were all special to her until they weren’t. There was always a new doll with prettier eyes and softer lips that managed to catch her greedy little eye and distract her from the one that she was playing with.Love was a game that few were ever willing to play with her, but when they did, Kitty would always play to win. Children are allowed to be selfish in that way when they’re playing with dolls, but Kitty was no child and Sonny was the furthest thing from a doll. His anger towards her, while understood, was unsettling in a way that she never quite expected. What made this time any different than all the others before it? They weren’t that much older now than they were the last time their paths crossed one another, so what had changed? Yes, Sonny would add up another wall to guard his heart every time she came barreling back into his life, but never before had Kitty worked this hard to break through those walls. Sonny intended for the poison that dripped from his tongue to hurt her, to keep her far away from the wall of ice that concealed his bruised heart, but Kitty was never one to give up that easily. Sonny, didn’t anyone tell you that Kitty dealt in flames?
The very moment that her full name fell from his lips like a curse word, Kitty could feel her skin start to melt right off the bone. He was hurting and that was a sure-fire way to show her that she no longer meant anything to him. So long as Sonny only saw Katherine and not Kitty when he looked at her, she was sure that he would be able to continue icing out his heart. Kitty might have been like the elusive and mysterious wizard to the rest of oz, but Katherine was the girl the behind the curtain who worked all those pretty brass bells and whistles. Calling Kitty by her real name was the equivalent of pulling back that velvet curtain to see the fraud for what she really was. She needed him to seeonly Kitty if she had any hope of permanently replacing the bone chilling frost that coated his words with golden sunlight. Winning him over again would take some time, but Kitty was nothing if not determined. She had nothing but time in a town as small and uninteresting as Boot Hill. “I deserve that.” Kitty answered, releasing her gaze from his. She deserved to swallow every last bit of poison that he sent her way, and she would do just that. Kitty would endure his anger to show him that she cared about his feelings, that she was actually listening this time around. If making her feel small made him feel better, then she would suffer through it for him. Truthfully, Sonny was the only one that Kitty would ever suffer through it for.
“I’m not playing with you, Sonny. I meant what I said.” A lie. Playing games was all that Kitty Briar knew how to do. What use were real feelings when artificial ones were so much more fun? “I want you to know that I’m sorry.” Once again her hand found its way back on top of his in an attempt to draw him in. Part of her fully expected him to snatch it away from her given how disgusted he was with her, but she put all of those negative thoughts out of her mind and enjoyed the moment while it lasted. “I know you don’t believe me or even want to hear me apologize to you, but it’s the truth.” Apologies, genuine or not, were often overlooked by Kitty. Girls like her were rarely ever sorry for the choices that they made, but she felt different this time. It almost felt right to apologize to him, but she quickly suppressed that thought. Of course it wasn’t right, this was all for fun, he was for fun. Why should she feel bad about playing with Sonny when he was the one that allowed himself to be played with? Yes, that’s a much more appropriate thought for her to have. That thought justified it all. “You don’t care about what I have to say and that’s more than fair, but just let me prove it to you.” Sliding her fingers in between the spaces of his own, Kitty locked their palms together as she looked for an answer in his eyes. Let her in Sonny, she promised to be better. Her own cool blue eyes were soft and glossy, preparing for a fake flood of warm tears should he further reject her. There was no greater actress in Boot Hill than Kitty Briar when she really wanted something.
kitty briar is a heat-seeking missile, that’s all sonny can think. she knows exactly where to hurt him and twist him, how to wrap him around her fingers right when he’s finally pried himself out of her grasp. that must be why she comes back, why she doesn’t give him up even after discarding him like macclean trash time after time: he’s all too willing to be in her grasp again. even now, putting up such a fight, the fates know it’s all for naught; they must be laughing at his sorrowful display. even with a brother’s voice in his head warning him to keep up that wall, even with the ghost of finola’s soothing circles rubbed against his back each time kitty breaks his fractured heart, even with his own will screaming to keep kitty far away from himself and that fractured heart, he can feel himself weakening. how can she tire of him when he’s the one always ready to shine her throne, make his back the rightful place for her to rest her feet? could someone really tire of such devotion, of the loyalty he showed to a girl he knew didn’t deserve it? and kitty doesn’t deserve it, he knows that. alison didn’t always know, but now he does. oh, now he does.
the queen of boot hill looks more like a pitiful little girl just then, tears in her eyes and begging on her lips. i deserve that, i meant what i said, i’m sorry. from her looks and from her words, it should be so easy for his will to break. he should be so easy to slide himself back into her servant role, it sounds so true! it sounds like the truth he’s been waiting to hear for years—no, that’s been i love you. suspiciously, that’s the one that’s missing. well, perhaps not suspiciously, but regretfully. shamefully. with all that’s happened, that’s all that alison wants to hear from kitty. (that’s all alison’s wanted to hear from anyone.) her burning touch is back, but he doesn’t retract it quick as flesh meets flame. no, he keeps it there, glancing down wearily. all of it sounds so true, looks so true, but there’s something telling him not to accept it. something tells him it’s all facade, just a little vaudeville show. it’s all the times she’s done the same song and dance, only to have his heart fractured all the more in the end. it’s all the times she looked so sincere when she wanted something, only to be fucked in someone else’s bed while sonny waited on the couch for her to be done, all because she needed a ride home. that’s what it is.
the definition of insanity: doing the same thing over and over, expecting different results.
maybe alison macclean has finally learned. maybe sonny is finally sane. maybe, for once, sonny has an excuse not to let her edge her way into his life again. “kitty...” his acidic tone has softened, just a little, but it carries the forewarning shake of a rattlesnake’s tail—even so, he’s dropped her formal name, back to the name that feels so natural in his mouth and not something he has to force out heavy. glancing from her glassy eyes to her heavy hand, he bites at his lower lip for a little bit of courage. when he returns his sight to her, there’s a bit of an edge there, the look of ‘i know something you don’t’. “truth is, i’m... sort of seeing someone right now.” that’s not really the truth, erika yosano has made it more than clear that boot hill, arizona (and by extension, sonny macclean) is just a stop along the way, but he likes her. it’s nice to have someone in his bed, someone to hang around. most of all, it’s nice to have someone in his life that doesn’t know everything the macclean name carries, all the history of the maccleans in boot hill, every dirty rotten thing they’ve ever done. in a town where everyone knows everything about everyone, it’s an unlikely thought. unlikely, but not impossible. sonny sighs, already so tired from just a few minutes with kitty. “so you’d have to prove it.” it’s not exactly an acquiesce, at least not in his opinion, but it carries pointed weight. “you’d have to really prove you’ve changed. you’ve got to prove you want me in your life and not as your little chew toy, alright?”