fvckmatts:
‘was it?’ her words rang in his head, cracking open the what if’s that popped up in his mind from time to time. always during the late nights, always when his medication wouldn’t work and no amount of booze was able to cloud his emotions. seeing her hands reaching out for him made him nervous. almost as though she was trying to pull him back into the man that he once was, the man that was able to charm her and make her fall in love with him. the version of matteo that always stayed with a smile, and got a kick out of keeping the people that he loved happy — gemma being one of those people. “ it-it had to be. look, you have so many things going for you. you have all of these amazing things beginning to happen in your life and you’re too hung up on me to accept it. i’m literally blocking you from finding any kind of happiness and the thought of that alone just confirms that as much as it hurt, i did the right thing. ” he knew that they weren’t perfect. that there were issues in their relationship that neither of them wanted to believe was true, but matteo knew that his bad habits was one of the things that broke them for good. just as he was about to open the door the leave, he turned around, her voice pulling him back in. just like it always found a way to do. “ why? so i can keep making you cry? ” he asked. “ there isn’t anything that i can do — nothing i can say or even do can help fixed all that i’ve wronged. you should want nothing to do with me, gem. you should be begging me to get out, and yet you still want me to stay. ” he wanted her to yell at him. he wanted her to hit, push, and tell him that he’s the worst thing to ever happen to her. he needed to hear her say that she no longer wanted him in her life anymore, tell him all of the right things that he needed to hear that would make walking away from her one last time along with the memories that they’ve shared for good. because looking at her now, seeing her in such a weak state, begging for nothing else but to have him with her almost made him regret that night — a thought that he knew was wrong in so many ways. he instantly moved closer to her, their bodies almost touching. “ why don’t you hate me? ”
“it doesn’t matter if i had so many things going for me.” her tone is still soft, but the air is thick in gemma ashmore’s home. it is although she can barely breathe standing in her own living room. matteo was so close now. honestly, she wasn’t sure whether she was hearing his heart beat or the pumping of the blood in her veins. for the first time in far too long, gemma and matteo were closer than they’d been. all gem could ask for was to stay in this moment forever, but she knows it won’t last. she reaches up to him, placing her hands on his chest. her fingers curl up forming small fists grasping the material of his shirt. gem’s eyes are shut, yet tears still roll down her cheeks silently. for a second, she can smell his cologne and things are okay again. why don’t you hate me? the question lingers too long in the air, and she wonders what she could possibly say to change his mind. make him stay, gem. you’ve come too far. “there’s nothing i can hate about you, matteo. why couldn’t you just understand that despite everything i still needed you - hell, i still wanted you. i still do.” she leans forward, her forehead resting on his chest. this time - she’s sure that it’s his heartbeat she hears, and it’s racing just as fast as hers. “i love you, matteo santiago.” she says softly, her voice breaking mid-sentence as her cries choke her up. “i love you with all my heart and there’s nothing i can do to make you stay.”












