My Thoughts on the Oscar Nominations...
I'll start with the good...
My favorite movie of the year, Hugo, leads the nominations with 11. Hugo is an incredible film with amazing directing & acting. It is innovative without trying too hard to be. It captivated me from beginning to end. I haven't been impressed with a 3D movie since Avatar (though only the visuals of that movie impressed me...the rest was unoriginal, predictable and boring). But Hugo managed to use 3D brilliantly. It added to the film in such a way that you felt you were on a journey with Hugo & Isabelle. Scorsese is a genius!
Best Actress Nomination for Michelle Williams in My Week With Marilyn - She deserves that nomination. Her performance was incredible. She is captivating. I love Marilyn Monroe!! I planned on watching this film and thinking that Michelle Williams (or anyone) wouldn't be able to capture the essence of Marilyn. BUT SHE DID!! She's up against Meryl Streep (I have yet to see The Iron Lady). After I see that, I'll be able to more definitively say who I think should win this. But I am glad that Michelle Williams received the nomination.
Original Score - John Williams is the best film composer of all time. It's not even a question. He is nominated twice (War Horse, The Adventures of Tin Tin). Great. But what about DRIVE!?!?!? As I watched Drive, I kept thinking, "This music is fantastic." (Sidenote: It's great!! If you haven't seen it, go see it!!)...I'm upset that it didn't get nominated, but I'm not shocked that the Academy voted in Oscar favorites.
Original Song - TWO nominations?!? That's ridiculous.
Best Director - Terrence Malick for The Tree of Life...First off, he is one of my favorites. I looked forward to seeing The Tree of Life because of him and Sean Penn (though Penn played a smaller role than I anticipated). I wanted to like it. I hated it (I will discuss this further when I discuss Best Picture nominations). I thought the directing was underwhelming. I was upset with the progression of the film. The ending was awful. The film tried TOO HARD to be innovative (which is one of the worst things a film can do, IMO).
Ryan Gosling - He had a phenomenal year. Of the movies I saw in 2011, Drive was in my top 5. But his role in The Ides of March is what should have been nominated. AND, if Melissa McCarthy can get a Best Supporting Actress nomination for Bridesmaids (What a joke!! Don't get me wrong, though...I thought that movie was hilarious), then Ryan Gosling should get a Best Supporting Actor nomination for Crazy, Stupid, Love. That film was much funnier and he brought more to Crazy, Stupid, Love. than McCarthy brought to Bridesmaids. I understand that their competition is different. I'm just pointing out that Gosling gave 3 great performances and they all went unrecognized. I see him becoming one of the best actors ever. Yes, EVER.
Leonardo DiCaprio - Snubbed. Again. I also think Armie Hammer got snubbed out of a Best Supporting Actor nomination just because Leo was his co-star. I'm not going to discuss this because I have already written a blog about Leonardo DiCaprio & The Oscars. If you want to read my thoughts on that, go here: http://awhite615.tumblr.com/post/7174521315/there-are-plenty-of-great-actors-without-an-oscar
My last complaint: Best Picture nominations. I have only seen 4 of the 8 films. But, I only enjoyed ONE of those films, Hugo.
The Tree of Life - Terrible. Absolutely terrible. You would have to pay me a lot of money to sit through that again. Malick tries too hard to bring in innovative visuals. Oftentimes those visuals didn't fit with the movie or add anything to the screenplay. Instead, it took away from the screenplay. It created a disconnect from the emotions I may have started to feel with the characters. By the time it got back to the story of the film, I was so bored that I just wanted it to end. I always say that if you want to critique the Oscars, you have to watch all the nominated films...but if you critiqued the Oscars without seeing this film, I wouldn't undermine your opinion at all. It's THAT bad.
The Help - I am one of the most sensitive movie watchers. Even bad films can make me cry. There are two things in movies that make me cry more than anything though... Animals and Racism. I brought tissues because I just knew this was going to make me cry. WRONG!!! This movie is everything you expect. It brought nothing new. I didn't feel any connection to any of the characters. I wanted more to happen. It was just predictable, predictable, PREDICTABLE. It wasn't horrible, but it definitely wasn't good. I'd give it a 5.5/10 (and most of those points are for Minny's "pie").
The Descendants - I thought this was going to be an original movie about love and life. It wasn't. It was just a boring film with uninspiring characters. I didn't care what happened to anyone because none of them drew me in. There were a few decent scenes here and there, but I found it to be mostly boring.
With that being said, I have a lot of movies to watch. After I watch all the nominated films, I will give my list of who I think should win versus who I think will win. :)