clare/crescent

any pronouns tmf analysis shit

[tmf-confessions]

is jailey predictable? yeah, sure, whatever. but i’m a sucker for parallels and you would have to be dumbbbb to not see them with jailey. like rosy shoves it in ur face multiple times. they are VERY similar and are mirror images of eachother. because think about it, jake could’ve, with the right support system and friends, been just like hailey. and vice versa (emzii’s swap au, anyone?) they both got bullied for being too into music and dealt with it in diff ways. they both found security in suppressing their passion and were kind of just in survival mode due to the circumstances they were put in. hailey didn’t sing on stage for 4 years, and jake didn’t show that side of him at all. parallels ppl… parallels. as much as i understand the appeal of drake, drew is gonna need a zuko level redemption arc next season for it to be possible and healthy 💀💀 i really don’t see why people like him and the dromies so much because they’re kind of just. there. like they’re judgy and they’re mean and their there but that’s a whole other can of worms i won’t get into.

confession #1215

[pastara-cell]

First freakblr post in a while but what the fuck is up with people coming up with the most outlandish, one dimensional takes on the characters as of recently on here?? Like?? Can we stop that?? Thank you??

Like voidDAMN I feel like im on fucking Pinterest with the amount of actual hate i’m seeing on fictional TEENAGERS. I’d tell the people who have those takes to look back on their own high school experiences, but I wouldn’t expect them to have gotten to high school yet with those critical thinking skills/silly/nsrs.

Please, PLEASE for the love of GOD take more than 5 seconds to look at these characters.

Hailey is not EVIL. Liam is not a EVIL. Drew is not EVIL. Henry is not EVIL. Zoey is not EVIL.

Why are some people acting like they’re saints and that they’ve always been nice to absolutely everyone and have never had negative feelings before, like AUGHHH please keep the weird ass hate on pinterest

Its such an awful and dismissive way to view the world. This is coming from someone who has been bullied for YEARS, by the way. Saying that people cant change or “are irredeemable” when they’re that young just enables people to keep going because they think they’re incapable of change.

Whether they’re fictional or not, its a shitty mindset to have. People change, and people arent evil for being stupid teenagers.

[tmf-confessions]

this fandom is where nuance goes to die

confession #1015

[noveunicornreal]

Just realized why everyone says there was a big change in everyone’s character between Gacha life and Gacha club. It’s cuz of who jake spent most of his time with

During the gacha life episodes (ep1-4) and ep5 as well (since it’s a continuation of 4) Jake spent most of his time with the dromies. So we got to see those moments of weird and disgusting comments from Liam and Henry, along with how they’d bully the club, how Drew thought he was higher than anyone and could “get any girl” he wants. Simultaneously we saw the club (especially Hailey) as a group of bullied kids with a sassy personality, who could stand up to their bullies and does absolutely nothing wrong.

But then when we get to the gacha club episodes (ep6-11) (which was also when Jake hanged out with the club more) we saw the dromies as just a bunch of popular kids who hang out at malls, play games together and make funny jokes, but then we see the club for all their flaws. Hailey had it worse in this case since she spent the most time with Jake from being viewed as controlling, manipulative, etc (I’ve seen someone say narcissistic so we’re gonna throw that in too). Not to mention the more vulnerable moments of the club and all of them softening their personalities (which is why people say Zander and Hailey lost their personality.)

In actuality none of them changed. The only one who actually changed was Jake. The dromies are still the same people they were at ep1, and so was the club. It’s based on screentime and Jake’s perspective of them that we see different sides of each character, no one else had a drastic change.

[tmf-confessions]

droey and drake should’ve been more toxic. god bless

also i think a lot more ppl would’ve liked jailey if their rivalry lasted longer or at least treated a bit more seriously instead of the weird ass tsundere x flirty trope we got. maybe the trope would’ve worked more later on in the development but right at the first episode??? it just makes the rivalry feel bland and watered down imo. they had a lot of potential to be interesting rivals bcus of their parallels and stuff but NO!!! haha princess malarkey go!!! and i think jake should’ve been more of a bitch to hailey bcus he saw his middle school self in her which he hated and he coped with that by throwing the most vile insults at her and blablabla would make things more interesting for the ship and their characters (i think pre-redemption jake should’ve been more of an asshole in general but thats for a another confession for another time)

don’t get me wrong i think jailey is generally a good ship. good. not great bcus they fail to live up to the enemies part in enemies to lovers and are generally very watered down is some parts in their relationship

confession #978

[crescent-rolls4]

favorite hailey outfit?

gacha club

gacha life

band competition

beta

middle school

other

Voting ended onMar 20, 2025

[tmf-confessions]

I love that it's a musical. I really don't get people who skip the musical numbers-

confession #957

[annamatix]

TMF FANDOM

DREW

WILLIAMS

RODRIGUEZ

neither (say your preferred in replies)

Voting ended onMar 18, 2025

PLEASE VOTE

[tmf-confessions]

transmasc sean real

drops mic

confession #954

[tmf-confessions]

people really overlook how fucked up it is that Zoey. A teenage girl in high school. Has a sugar daddy like. Yeah. That's fucked. We should talk about that.

confession #948

[tmf-confessions]

adding on to the last confession, I feel like people shouldn’t expect some flawless writing yet want Rosy to release season 2 already. Like either wait for Rosy to develop the story which is going to take time mostly if you want a decent show or have a lackluster show but season 2 drops early like let her cook!!! I don’t want a water down show!!

confession #946

[tmf-confessions]

The music club is better than me because imagine giving a chance to someone that bullied you for years, decides to help you with your personal problems (with also ulterior motives back then) which ends up convincing you to let him in, only for him to trash talk you behind your back.

I know that Jake regretted what he said but I still cannot believe how easily Jake was forgiven after everything he has done and I feel like some of the fandom kinda babies him a bit too much it’s not like he was mind controlled by the jomies to say those things

confession #947

[tmf-confessions]

liam’s a misogynist + objectifies women and anyone who says otherwise is a liar ^_^ also henry not washing his underwear is js disgusting like i did NOT laugh

confession #932

[tmf-confessions]

This isn't necessarily related to the actual show but everyone in this fanbase is so unbelievably bad at identifying bait/trolling and love giving these people the attention they want for acting like creeps instead of reporting/blocking them and moving on like they should, it's really annoying because it only encourages these people to continue when they'd likely move on if you didn't give them the satisfaction of a reaction

confession #936

[tmf-confessions]

For the person who said we cant expect amazing writing and flawless plot from rosy because she works by herself, I agree! I do agree, infact, even with huge teams we still shouldn’t expect things to be perfect! However, just because things are made by small teams doesn’t mean that we cant criticize them. I dont mean that in a bad way of course, I love the music freaks heavily, ive been in this fandom for what?? Since episode 2? But everything needs a bit of constructive criticism at some point. No one should be attacking rosy ofc, she did nothing wrong, but the point still stands that when you put something out on the internet, no matter how big or small, you are subject to criticism and opinions

confession #943

[tmf-confessions]

Sometimes this fandom pisses me off. You can't expect good writing, flawless characters, animation and deep characters from a single animator that does all the writing, episode making, and didn't even expect the gacha show to take off like it did. Some of yall expecting too much from a gacha show musical ☠️🙏

confession #942

[noveunicornreal]

I hate how people fail to understand Liam’s character. No he’s not a funny high school student who got stuck with bad friends and is secretly abused by Drew. He’s perfectly ok with Drew’s actions because he sees no issue in it. He’s just as much of a bad person as Drew especially towards the club, just not manipulative.

He doesn’t respect women especially not after that “I guess she’s the type that can’t be tamed” line and his failure to realize that hey… your friends mothers do not want to date you! And if they do that’s a problem 😅

He’s your typical high school weirdo who’s character code is litterally described as a pervert. He’s not a feminist, he’s not supportive of women and women’s rights, if he was he never would’ve implied you can tame women which just so everyone is on the same page is extremely misogynistic and dehumanizing!

He’s just as bad of a friend as Drew and Jake too. He can’t communicate either like yeah he was probably being blackmailed or theatrenednby Zoey but bro genuinely kept this hidden 😭🙏even before that he knew Zoey was using Drew for money and he was like yeah… this is perfectly ok I’m just… not going to tell him??

Obviously he can change he’s a teenage boy, but some fans are genuinely struggling to understand his character and badly mischarterizing him.

“You just don’t understand his character” no I do. You don’t.

[crescent-rolls4]

YOU GET ITTTT OH MY GOSH

liam has always been a character who made me uncomfortable and its nice that other people are talking about his weirdness bc ive seen WAY too many liam defenders on here…