Audrey Jensen x Reader - Killer
Pairings: Audrey Jensen x Reader
Warnings: Swearing
Words: 2194
Request: “An Audrey imagine where you’re Noah’s twin and Audrey likes you and the killer knows and stalks you because of it and threatens her with what they know so she gets really clingy” - anon
Request (2): “Hey babe. Do you think you would be able to do a short lil Audrey drabble where the reader walks in on Audrey changing? And the reader is Noah’s sister if possible? Thankyoooooooou :DDD” - @ezramillerqueer
Note: I posted this first part for like a minute the other day before deleting it cause I thought it’d do better with this request than on its own. And btw, does anyone know when Audrey and Noah met? Cause I always just assumed that they were like always friends since children but idk. Thanks :)
“Noah, you prick!” I slammed his door open, “Stop using my chapsti-“
I froze in my tracks, eyes trained on the half-naked girl on my twin brother’s bed who was previously struggling to pull her tight jeans on, now staring at me like a deer caught in the headlights. My posture straightened and I breathed in slowly as my brain slowly processed what was happening, delayed slightly by the wonderful sight before me.
“Hey Audrey,” I breathed in awe, hand still on the doorknob but making no attempt to close it.
“Oh my god (Y/N) get out!”
“Huh? Oh. OH!” I finally regained my senses, “Oh god, I’m so sorry, I di- Wait, why are you half-naked in my brother’s room?”
“Is this really the time?” she replied, throwing her hands up in exasperation.
“Right. I’ll just uh– yea bye,” I stumbled hurriedly, spinning on my heel and slamming the door behind me.
I moaned, banging my head against the door in humiliation, resting it there as I released a string of incoherent curses. I’d had a crush on my brother’s best friend for years now and somehow always managed to look like a massive dork in front of her.
But, I mean at least I got to see Audrey with her pants off. If that isn’t something to cross of your bucket list, I don’t know what is.
“Well done (Y/N),” a voice whispered in my ear.
I whirled around, whacking the person behind me.
“Fucking hell Noah. Don’t do that,” I whacked him again as he rubbed his throbbing arm.
“Fine,” I huffed, glaring daggers at my annoying brother.
“You know that that’s the closest you’ll ever get to seeing your little crush naked, right?” he smirked knowingly.
“Oh shut up Noah. Besides, what the hell is Audrey doing getting dressed in your room?”
“Ooh is someone jealous?”
“Shut up Noah!” I frowned, shoving his shoulders.
“Calm down (Y/N), god. She wanted to check on you last night for some reason and she ended up crashing here so I was just giving her some privacy to get changed out of her pyjamas. Well at least until you walked in.”
I rolled my eyes, crossing my arms and mumbling unintelligible insults of nonsense under my breath.
I always struggled to act like I wasn’t totally jealous of Noah but no matter how hard I tried, I always wished I was as close to Audrey as he was. Mainly so I could share a bed with her. But, I mean… details.
“Wait. Why did she want to see me?” I scrunched my face up in confusion, only just realising what Noah said.
“Probably just wanted to laugh at your ugly face.”
I shot him a sarcastic smile as I leant back against the door.
I squealed as the door swung open and I stumbled backwards against a hard body, strong arms wrapping around my waist to keep me from falling. My breath hitched when I realised that my body was literally pressed against Audrey’s boobs.
“Oh shit, I’m so sorry Audrey,” I regaining my footing, spinning round to face her, “and I’m so sorry for walking in on you. If I had known you were in there I totally would have knocked. Actually no I wouldn’t, but that’s beside the point. I’m just really sor-”
Audrey grabbed my face in her hands, cutting off my incessant rambling, my cheeks flushing as I realised how close we were and that this was literally the prime position for kissing.
“Oh my god, Foster. Calm down, don’t worry about it. It happens,” she smiled reassuringly, dropping her hands, “I mean, it’s not like I haven’t walked in on you changing before.”
“Oh thank go-” I paused, registering her words, “Wait, what? When did y-?”
“See you later. Gotta go,” she hurried past me, grabbing Noah’s arm as she went, dragging him off and leaving me standing there, mouth gaping like a fish out of water.
I shoved the popcorn in the microwave, slamming the door and pounding on the minute button twice. My mind was too preoccupied with the events of this morning to care about the poor heating box I was inflicting my emotions on.
I yelped in surprise as an unknown presence appeared behind me, calling my name in my ear as they poked my side.
I spun around, coming face to face with the girl who decided to sneak up on me.
“Oh fuck Audrey, you scared the shit out of me,” I gasped, pressing a hand to my speeding heart.
“Sorry,” she giggled, the adorable noise causing an affectionate smile to appear on my face as I gazed at her amused form.
“What are you doing back here? If you’re looking for Noah, he’s still out-”
“No, I was looking for you.”
“Me?” I raised my eyebrows in surprise.
“Yes you,” she smiled, shoving my shoulder playfully, “Is it really that difficult to believe that I want to hang out with you?”
I shrugged, smiling bashfully, a warm feeling spreading through my body as I realised my brother’s best friend/my billion year crush actually wanted to spend time alone with me.
“Well I was just about to watch a movie if you wanted to do that?” I suggested, turning back to the obnoxious beep of the microwave.
“Sounds perfect,” she placed her hand on my hip, giving it a quick squeeze before walking away, “I’ll go pick a movie. Thriller, romance or comedy?”
“Do you even know this family?”
Audrey smiled to herself, falling back on the sofa, propping her feet up. She scrolled through Netflix, trying to find the perfect movie for her and the girl she’s been in love with since 5th grade to cuddle up to. Her smile quickly fell as her phone buzzed. She accepted the call from the unknown number, placing the phone to her ear as her jaw clenched with anger.
“Is that any way you should be greeting your partner, partner?”
“You can’t always be around to save your little girlfriend, killer. Tell her about me and I make sure she dies knowing you betrayed her.”
The killer hung up as Audrey’s breathing became uneven and she ran a hand through her hair in concern.
She scrolled up through her messages, shivering at the video clip sent not long ago, filmed only a couple hours after Audrey and Noah left.
The camera was trained on (Y/N)’s unsuspecting form, completely unaware of the danger lurking nearby as she jumped on the couch, grabbing her laptop. The camera pointed to a nearby mirror, revealing a figure adorned with the haunting Brandon James mask, a knife in their hand as they lurked in the room across from (Y/N).
It was similar to a video Audrey received the previous evening. She rushed over in the middle of the night as soon as she saw the clip, relieved to find that Noah’s sister was alright.
Someone was after (Y/N) and Audrey was determined to keep her safe.
Audrey jumped as she heard my voice, shoving her phone into her pocket as I studied her anxious form.
I shot her a look of disbelief before rolling my eyes in dismissal and throwing myself down next to her, placing the popcorn on the table in front of us.
“So, what are we watching?”
“(Y/N)?” Noah’s voice echoed throughout the dark house.
“Shut up Noah, you’re going to wake her up,” I replied in a hushed whisper.
“Wake who u-? Oh,” Noah walked into the room, finding Audrey’s passed out body on the sofa, curled up against mine.
She fell asleep after the eighth episode, pressed up against my body and gladly using me as a pillow.
“Did you drug her?” he smirked, grabbing a blanket to toss over us.
“Oh shut up you ass,” I threw back at him half-heartedly, too focused on Audrey’s peaceful face to come up with a decent comeback.
“Well I’m heading off to bed. Enjoy this while it lasts,” he grinned, gesturing to Audrey’s relaxed form snuggled close to mine before heading to his room.
I grinned down at the girl practically on top of me, running my hand through her silky black hair as she smiled softly in her sleep.
“I’m going down to the café today to see Emma,” I mentioned as we ate breakfast, Noah nodding in acknowledgment as he shoved a spoon of frosted flakes into his mouth.
“I’ll come too,” Audrey hurriedly offered.
I looked at her in confusion. Ever since Audrey slept over last week, she had barely left my side. She walked me to and from my classes, insisted on coming with me and Brooke on our shopping trip (much to Brooke’s excitement), slept over almost every night and even waited outside the bathroom while I showered. It was cute at first but now I’m seriously wondering if something is wrong.
“You don’t have to. I’m sure I’ll be fine on my own-”
“No, I want to go. I haven’t seen Emma in a while. Plus I really fancy some coffee.”
“I guess I’ll tag along too then,” Noah shrugged, downing his orange juice.
“Well okay then,” I muttered, slightly sarcastically, getting up to wash my bowl out, a million thoughts rushing through my head.
I drowned out the sound of Emma’s voice as she droned on about Kieran and Eli, Noah occasionally making an unnecessary comment as usual. As much as I loved Em, she could be so repetitive.
I snuck a glance at Audrey only to find her already looking at me. She snapped her head back to Emma as I caught her gaze before discreetly looking around the café as if searching for something.
What the hell is her problem?
“I’m going to the ladies room,” I announced, placing my coffee down harshly before stomping off.
I leant against the wall, hidden in the shadows of the dimly lit bathroom, waiting for Audrey to no doubt arrive.
She pushed open the door, frowning in confusion and she looked over the seemingly empty bathroom.
“(Y/N)?” Audrey called, sounding panicked before trying again, “(Y/N)?-”
I stepped out from the shadows, Audrey spinning around to face me as I pushed her against a wall by her shoulders, keeping her pinned there as her hands automatically went to my waist.
“Why are you following me everywhere? What the hell is going on with you?”
She looked at me in shock, mouth opening and closing, unsure how to reply.
Her grip on my waist only tightened as I pushed her shoulders harder into the wall.
“I just- I-” she stuttered, looking into my eyes worriedly, “I- I love you. And I like knowing that you’re safe. Plus I- I thought the only way of making you see me as more than just your brother’s friend was to spend more time with you. I- I guess maybe it was a bit too much,” she looked at the floor, clenching her jaw in worried anticipation.
It was silent before I burst into a fit off giggles. Her head snapped back up as she looked at me with an expression of complete and utter confusion as I let my hands slide down her arms, resting my forehead on her shoulder, body still shaking with laughter.
I stood up straight, eyes glistening as I contained my amusement, yet a large grin remained stretched across my face.
“You are such an idiot,” I grinned, shaking my head with amused incredulity.
I grabbed her face as she opened her mouth to defend herself before pulling her into a deep kiss. Her hands snaked around my waist, pulling me closer as she bit my bottom lip, inciting a sharp gasp from me which she took advantage of, pressing her tongue past my lips. My hands trailed down her body and began to remove her jacket when a loud knock interrupted us. I stepped back just as the bathroom door opened.
“(Y/N)? Audrey? What on Earth is taking so lo-”
Noah paused as he took in our dishevelled appearances.
“Noah! What the hell? It’s called the ladies room for a reason!” I yelled in exasperation before sighing as I rolled my eyes.
A cheeky smirk made its way onto my face as he continued to look between the two of us in shock.
“And just so you know, I’m going to get very close to seeing my ‘little crush’ naked,” I smirked at Noah, using his words from earlier against him.
I walked out the bathroom, grabbing the stunned Noah’s arm, pulling him along behind me, not before sending Audrey a wink as she smiled back at me.
Audrey’s phone buzzed as she watched her two favourite Fosters walk out of the bathroom, shaking her head in amusement. Her attention dropped to the lit up screen as she pulled her phone out her pocket, her smile immediately dropping as she saw the message.
areudirty
gummygunk
germansingergirl
dailybridgerton
tangentwithtanner
ellievsbear
amandla
theartofmadeline
gamechangershow
