Ngl I think the song Lonely Day by System Of A Down fits Haymitchâs spiraling grief of loosing Sunshine and everyone else dear to him
i couldnât even get through the first line without tearing upâŠgood lord
youâre 100% correct with this comparison. one of the cruelest aspects of haymitchâs circumstances post-games is the isolation. from what we can infer throughout the original trilogy, thatâs true of all victors to an extent. the way theyâre utilized as propaganda tools both requires and produces the effect that theyâre a separate sect from any other citizen in panem. they arenât capitol obviously, but they also stop truly belonging to their districts the second they become victors.
haymitch is in an even worse position because not only is he cut off from twelve (which at first is snowâs doing and later becomes self-inflicted), he doesnât even have an inner circle of support. aside his fellow victors, ofc, but they arenât daily presences. and they canât supplement the loss of everyone heâs loved.
âand if you go, i wanna go with youâ is a standout lyric to me because while iâve talked at lengths about how haymitch wants to die with sunshine, he also wants to be with his family. i think the lyric speaks to how his loneliness is as crippling as his grief. he just wants to be with his love and his people again đ
olivia was fr possessed by haymitchâs spirit when she wrote this album
i canât not think about haymitch (and sunshine) when listening to âthe cure,â and itâs comforting to know how many of you share in the misery of it đ thinking about it in the context of him and burdock is especially heinousâŠthey were both hurting in their own ways, but burdock wanted so badly to be there for him âčïž to try to help each other heal âčïžâčïž
also the fact that in this case the cure would be sunshine, which goes back to haymitch telling burdock they donât need to see her in each otherâŠ
to some extent, burdock definitely felt like he failed haymitch and sunshine by not getting through to him
There is a part in âDan the dancerâ by mitski that kinda reminds me of sunshine & haymitch.
âHe liked her more than life itself, Iâm sureâ
It rlly reminds me of how Haymitch was ready to die for sunshine if it ment that she will be alive and win the games + after her death he stopped valuing his life kind of (there was some scenes that he was thinking how to âaccidentalyâ end his life like in the scene with Effie holding the tweezers)đ PLEASE end his suffering đđđ
lord this one nearly took me out đ the lyric is, in fact, a good descriptor of haymitchâs sentiments towards sunshine and general mental illness. itâs pretty self-explanatory why haymitch would die for sunshine (and vice versa), but i also think the aftermath of him devaluing his life is interesting to dissect.
part of it is simply that he loves her, canât fathom living without her, and is depressed. thereâs also the factor of him believing she deserves to live more than he does. iâve mentioned before itâs not as rose-tinted as in everlarkâs case, but sunshine and haymitch do put each other on a slight pedestal. sunshineâs death catapults her onto a higher one in haymitchâs mind for a long time. which leads to the third point: haymitch canât reconcile being worthy of the kind of sacrifice she made.
the tweezers detail will never not be insane to me (i say like i didnât write it) because he really was looking for ANYTHING that might âaccidentallyâ kill him đ but my guy how exactly are the tweezers winding up in your jugular???
in conclusion, itâs ultimately a very jack and rose, âhe died for her, she lived for him,â predicament. haymitch did his best to make something of the life she sacrificed her own to give him.
was in public and did you know that theres a tunnel under ocean blvd by lana came on and its like my third eye opened
the lyrics "dont forget me, there's a tunnel under ocean blvd" which then turn into "dont forget me, like the tunnel under ocean blvd" speaks to sunshine's wish in chapter five for her death to not be meaningless and to be remembered
she ultimately gets her wish because haymitch never forgets her (âčïž) and she, in a way, lives on through him and his memory
oh youâre actually a genius for this
the tone and themes of memory/forgetting are too perfect đ that transition in the lyrics is slight but adds a whole other layer of pain. the first line feels like a warning or plea, and the subsequent equation of herself to the tunnel feels like sheâs anticipating being forgotten in spite of her pleading. also, it just makes me think of that scene in ch19 when sunshineâs ârealâ ghost appears to haymitch and questions how he remembers her :(
thereâs something so special about sunshineâs wish hinging on being remembered when itâs placed in the context of the erasure of the covey (and the everdeenâs cultural histories being rooted in the same). specifically, as clerk carmine states, the erasure of the covey girls. but none of them are ever really forgotten.
(also, this edit feels relevant to shareâelsa duttonâs monologues = sunshineâs narrative voice)
You like to watch them dance, and so does Haymitch. They wander through the meadow most often, which has long since gotten its color back. On warmer days, they drag him out and use the geese to help tug on his heartstrings. They do a fine job on their own, well aware of how much Haymitch adores them.
The dark haired little girl whoâs already learned to use that charming smile of hers to wrap the world around her finger. The shy baby boy whose bravery rears its head with each attempt to climb the highest of trees on his little limbs.
Burdock looks after them, after his own little girl and his love, separately. Sweet Primrose likes to go with him, or finds company in your presence and Lenore Doveâs. When she first showed up, Burdock scarcely let her out of his sight, if at all. Not so different from how it was when you found one another again in this world. He took that page out of your papaâs book.
There isnât meant to be pain in the hereafter, but emotions still have free rein. Often, itâs as mournful as it is joyous to receive your loved ones, especially when they arrive sooner than they shouldâve. Early on in your time here, Maysilee reminded you that you did too. She couldâve gone years without seeing you, she claimed. You both know full well she missed you in that brief period of separation, same as you missed her.
Patience never was your strong suitâdeath hasnât changed that so much as itâs taught you the wait doesnât have to be excruciating. You have your people here, the ones you watch over there. Knowledge pops up in your head, memories you werenât there for become yours, and if youâre quiet enough, you hear them talking to you. With your feet in both worlds, your kin and your allies within reach, you donât get by alone.
Seeing the life Haymitch has built, the good he finally found in a heap of bad, eases your longing, too. Itâs all you wanted for him.
You feel the wait coming to an end, anyway.
Haymitch has lived longer than heâor the doctors who gave him his lease on lifeâthought he would. Before Burdockâs girl and Othoâs boy came around, he was only surviving because you wished it. His pain has lessened to a scar that only opens when it rains, and there have been no storms as of late. Healed by those heâs let into his heart, by the forgiveness heâs learned to apply to himself.
Heâs forgiven you, too, for leaving him in what surely seemed like a punishment inflicted upon him alone. He never had to forgive what you believed to be your greatest crime against him. Neither did Sid or Willamae, you realized soon after they joined you. Too soon, but they didnât let you dwell on that as far as they could help it.
You let go of your own angerâfinicky emotion that it isâages ago. Itâs no good here, and neither is regret, after so many years waiting in equal measure, knowing you wouldâve done the same as each other, for each other. Despite all your prior human doubts, youâre certain now he feels how truly you loved him, and always have.
In some ways, funnily, death has only strengthened the piece of you thatâs occupied by Haymitch. Like the incessant weed he is, nothing could uproot him from your soul. Heâs everywhere in your neck of the meadow, home to more dandelions than any other flower. Heâs present even without you watching over him, or Burdockâs girl and Othoâs boy and their beautiful children.
Haymitch never denies them a thing, not even the chance to celebrate his birthday. His struggles to view the day as cause for celebration persist, but he likes to make them smile, and they always do when they know theyâve done something kind for him. The two brightest lights in his life. Your peopleâs future, learning from their past.
He plays it off as annoyance, but you see the smile on his face, too, whenever they burst through his doors beaming and shouting, âHappy birthday, Papaw!â
The girl learned to speak early on, and the first time she named the roles of those in her life, Haymitch complained. Not to her face, but straight to her mama.
âWhat else is she supposed to call you?â was her answer, mirroring the blunt edges of Haymitchâs tone. Sheâs exactly like him in most ways, and you rest easier with the assurance that they have an understanding between them. That Haymitch opened his heart to Katniss and Peeta.
Fiercely as your love extends to them, you can stand the wait to meet them. They deserve a lifetime. Some day, youâll hear all about the good memories they made for yourself. Youâll sit in your dandelion meadow together, taking back your stolen time, as youâve done plenty with those you only ever met in the impact they left behind. In the pieces that could never really be taken.
You prefer hearing her stories than telling your own, and maybe Katniss will be the same. Primrose sure likes listening to you. It dawned on you after a time that having the truth, having her pass the answers to you, is what you liked best. You imagine thatâs true of your nieces.
The performance of it all didnât hurt either. Guarded as she kept your aunt, your mama didnât shy from describing her skillful storytelling when she first spoke her name to you.
Lucy Gray sometimes sings the same lullaby that your mama wielded to tuck you in. The very one that drove your desire to know the mind behind it. Sheâll perform it with the family she grew in, the one who raised you, for all those who lived without her rainbow eyes. Others, itâs a show privy only to you and Lenore Dove.
And when itâs just the two of you, one lost Covey girl to another, you have the birds do the singing for you. She doesnât let you off easy, though. Youâre meant to listen to your elders, after all, and Lucy Gray doesnât mind pulling that card on you. So when her tales have run out, repeated and recycled an immeasurable number of times over a blink of an eternity, you share yours.
Though it isnât yours technically, not by name or in writing, you often find yourself reciting your poem to her. Bits of it, at least. Mostly, just the one:
Beat, happy stars, timing with things below,
Beat with my heart more blest than heart can
tell.
Blest, but for some dark current woe
That seems to drawâbut it shall not be so:
Let all be well, be well.
You told Haymitch once that it was the happiest part of the poem, but you couldnât lead him to believe it. He teaches that verse now to the girl and the boy.
You know he trusts the words, you know heâs ready, but he worries about them. About the happiness, as much as the safety, of Katniss, Peeta, and those beautiful, brilliant children. He worries about how heâll take care of them, and how heâll teach them about everyone who came before.
But Katniss and Peeta, even with their long-lasting scars, have finally found their peace. They have themselves, each other, the girl and the boy. Theyâve memorized the pasts Haymitch has bestowed them, along with their own, and what they havenât committed to memory is written down in that book of theirs. The girl and the boy wonât go without understanding.
Theyâll grow, and theyâll learn, and theyâll get by dancing freely and wildly. The girlâs hair blowing all over her face, the boyâs arms stretched out as he spins. Sunlight glinting off the copper bluebird around one of their necks. Depends on the day.
On the day your waiting ends, Haymitch leaves it to them. You still wear your other charms, though you have your family with you now. Haymitch is wearing his too. Itâs the first thing you notice against the flowers and weeds before his pretty eyes find yours. He blends right into your kaleidoscopic sky and steady earth. You can tell heâs thinking the same of you by the curve of his smile.
Your effort to suppress your own is weak, and you fail to keep a scowl as you demand, âWhatâre you staring at?â
You canât say who moves first, only that you wind up meeting each other, his back pressed against the dirt and fallen maple leaves, your voice dissolved into a fit of laughter. Haymitch peppering kisses along your eyelids and nose.
âI missed you, sunshine,â he mutters against your temple. âEvery day, but I tried. I tried not toââ
âI know. Iâm here now,â you murmur, barely getting out the last syllable before his mouth is on yours. As soft and warm as you remember him to have been in life.
It wasnât dull before, exactly, but your meadow feels brighter. Brought to life and color at its fullest by the hands cradling you to the ground.
Between the two of you, youâve racked up a long list of things you want to say once the glee settles. The agony of waiting mixed with the peace of the other finding their version of freedom. Everyone whoâs stuck to your side here, the people whoâve missed him and want their turn at hello. Youâll ask to hear about the girl and the boy, and Haymitch will share the joy of adoring them. Heâll tell you about carrying your spirit with him, and youâll swear everything he felt was real.
There is no rush. There are no sunsets forcing you away. And when you part, thereâs nothing more important to say than the words that tumble out of Haymitch. âI love you.â He kisses the corner of your mouth. âYou beautiful, infuriating hypocrite.â
âOh, youâre still no picnic, peach.â You bring your forehead down to his, but itâs devoid of any worry. He beams, and what other choice do you have but to respond against his lips, âI love you, too.â
Just as good and bad walk hand-in-hand, your proclamations of hate never existed without the truest of loves. Theyâre distant memories now, tuned out by the confession you repeat over and over. A promise you and Haymitch have no trouble keeping together.
In a week by hozier is haymitch begging sunshine to let him die
active footage of me listening to the song with this comparison in mind
itâs him!!! itâs them!!! what stands out to me the most is how the first verse indeed feels like haymitch pleading with sunshineâs ghost, but the second verse is actually her. she doesnât want to push him out this time, and she doesnât mean to condemn him. her desire is the same as his: to be together. but as much as she wants to be with him, she wants him to find happiness and peace in life more. and those are the vibes i get in the second verse.
also the crescendo of the last verse and the repetition of âiâd be home with youâ can be read as haymitch coming to his understanding of sunshine, and knowing sheâs still with him (or perhaps a more literal reunion between them)
not to be too political âđœ how do you feel about joseph zada as an actor and him playing haymitch? thereâs currently a lot of controversy about his race and the issues with him playing haymitch because of this (do not answer if you do not feel comfortable, feel free to ignore it)
OH YOU JUST UNLOCKED MY FAVORITE TOPIC (racial politics in thg)
in my humble opinion, suzanne ultimately lacked the backbone to fully commit to addressing race. when coupled with the interviews in which she literally stated she did not intend katniss in particular to be nonwhite, she is largely to blame for the lack of diversity in the films. my point in saying that is the books themselves, not just the films, are riddled with suzanneâs racially ambiguous writing, which in some ways is tastefully executed. in most, itâs not, and has honestly enabled the racist rhetoric in the fandom.
to answer your question: i have mixed feelings? maybe not mixed exactly bc i am firmly on the side of yes, the movies should have gotten it right from the beginning, and suzanne shouldâve too by explicitly stating all necessary characters to be nonwhite. however, because haymitch was played by a white man in the trilogy, itâs not shocking heâd be played by one in his prequel.
i believe joseph zada has spoken on being aboriginal? that doesnât mean he doesnât benefit from whiteness, but iâve seen some of these conversations veer into an erasure of his identity, so i feel itâs important to acknowledge indigeneity doesnât âlookâ one way, nor is it solely hinged on oneâs skin color.
i often picture woody harrelson as haymitchâand subsequently, joseph has also become enmeshed as his young counterpartâbc i read the books at the same time i watched the films growing up. woodyâs performance stuck so deeply with me that heâs how i envisioned him when reading. and i do think joseph will give a good performance. but book accurate haymitch still has my heart through and through.
when i approach race in itsdr, itâs through the lens of someone who isnât white, and also believes panemâs racial politics are both existent and more complex than suzanne ever dared them to be. much like those in our real world. that includes there not being a super âclean cutâ racial stratification in twelve, though the merchants are all explicitly white.
again, i think the criticisms are valid, and at once, the casting is ultimately reflective of a larger issue in the series.
I have a question about Oliver (or wtv his name was). Was was HIS reaction to Sunshineâs death?? Did he move on from her in the future? How would he react if Sunshine came out of the games alive in a alternative universe? Idk why, but something about thay boy makes me curious đ Peak series tho twin đđ«Ș
lol i love when yâall ask about oliver! he originally was just a throwaway oc meant to serve as what maysilee means when she mentions him: an example of sunshineâs influence over people. now heâs a full-fledged person in my head and vp of the âcrush on sunshineâ club (haymitch and maysilee are co-presidents)
to answer your question, his live reaction to sunshineâs death is a mix of shock, disgust over the gruesomeness as a whole, and empathy for haymitch. in the aftermath, he doesnât experience the same crippling grief as haymitch, and thatâs due to the vast difference in how they each experience sunshineâs death, as well as the varying levels of emotional intimacy they had with her.
still, oliver grieves her as a person who he did have romantic feelings for; mostly, as someone he never got to know fully.
oliver does move on from sunshine to some extent. he marries and has kidsâitâs an arranged marriage a la merchant class customs. he has a content life, but i think sunshine creeps up on him every now and then. she exists as a wistful âwhat-ifsâ in his mind as opposed to the object of an on going yearning. (kinda like the tone in which otho talks about asterid and burdock imo đ)
and as for how oliver would react in a sunshine lives auâŠletâs just say, he will be making a bigger appearance in that exact au series iâm cooking up 𫣠so youâll get to see that play out soon!
breaking my silence to say thank god âdreaming of youâ by selena is a lost archive in panem because haymitch wouldâve been grabbing a gun and not a bottle if he ever listened to it
(i swear the epilogue is coming tmr, along with a spam of answered asksâŠforgive me for becoming sidetracked again đđ)
The kind Nurse Esper said it would peak around day three. She isnât remotely kind, actually, but sheâs the only one of them who will look him in his yellowed eyes like heâs more than an inconvenience. Even though he is, because District Thirteen isnât equipped for drunkards coming off a decades-long bender, and itâd be easier leaving him to die in this room than help him dry out. But he saved their mockingjay, and heâs proved himself worthy to their cause, and Plutarch has made it clear they need him.Â
What use Haymitch serves by wasting away in fevers and chills, choking on nosebleeds and failing to aim his bile into the small bucket theyâve left at his bedside, he doesnât know.Â
He does know Nurse Esper was wrong. It only gets worse on the fourth day.Â
Though the walls of his room are small, identical in their eggshell shade, they seem larger this morningâafternoon, or night?âand Haymitch feels like heâs falling endlessly through the clouded sky. He waits for the impact, or for yesterdayâs claustrophobia to return full force, and instead, all he gets is that incessant itching all over, which convinces him a horde of bugs has made a nest on him. He paws at his neck, chest, arms, and legs, as best he can through the gauze they taped around his hands to stop him from tearing his skin apart like he wants.Â
His mouth is dry, despite having water forced down some twenty minutes ago, and his tongue has shriveled up like a dead flower. Haymitch has scratched his throat raw; metal climbs up the lining until he tastes it in his mouth, a byproduct of all the yelling heâs done in the dead of night and height of day. Heâs sure he has more in him, but right now, heâs falling again, and thatâs more pleasant than the itching. Than the feeling of being turned inside out.Â
The most fragile pieces of him are displayed on the outside to be spat on with every too bright clang of trays and too loud flicker of lights. Every one of his senses is jumbled up, and every thought is muddled like heâs still on the alcohol, but heâs not. And thatâs the worst partâthere is no purpose to any of this besides reacquainting his mind with his body. A necessity Haymitch has dedicated his life to running from.Â
Not only will he not survive this, but Haymitch realizes he envies Chaff for not needing to. Oh, and how Chaff teases him relentlessly for his suffering when day six rolls around, after Nurse Esper takes his vitals and brings in the head doctor.Â
Haymitch wouldâve thought living with the ghosts for so long would make him immune to them now. It hasnât, and the sequence always starts the same.Â
Their wails are loud, healthy, and familiar even though heâs never heard them before. They wake him when the sun sets and his wing of the hospital is empty save for the two night nurses. But they arenât trained to soothe a pair of dying twins the same way they donât know what to do with Haymitch when he begins to shout and writhe on his bloodied cotton blankets. Easier to ignore all three of them.Â
Haymitch wishes he could. They have no names for him to call, and their cries are only getting louder. He tries to reach for them with frail hands that are better suited to cradle bottles and not babies.Â
âTheyâre all right now, son.â Itâd be easier to believe his pa if he were still a kid, but the blood is on his sheets and the walls are dripping with it.Â
Droplets pool onto the floor in a puddle, pattering like the saline bag the night nurse comes in to attach to his veins. He tells her to do something about the walls and his sisters, but she ignores him until he makes good use of the barf bucket.Â
In the wake of the crimson, the eggshell turns into a burnt orange. Mags perches on the chair in the far corner of the room. Haymitch asks her what he can do to make the spores on her face and neck better, but each time she tries to speak, a piece of her evaporates into the fog that took her. Eventually, thereâs nothing of her left besides the pain in his chest.Â
Wiress spouts riddles in her place. âMirror, mirror, on the wall, whoâs the fairest of them all?â And when Haymitch canât answer, the slit above her collarbone blows right open.Â
Maysileeâs throat wound is nearly matching, the hole at the base of it oozing with blood. It matches the dead ladybugs in her hair, and Haymitch dry heaves at the sight. She teases him for it each time. âCâmon, Itchy. Youâve been around the Capitol long enoughâsurely, youâve seen worse.âÂ
âHeâs looking pretty bad himself.â Wyatt frowns at the foot of his bed, but theyâre in the same boat. Panacheâs sword makes a home in his stomach, the tipped blade pointing right at Haymitch. âShe said itâd peak on day four, and youâre already a week in. You donât need me telling you your odds of living to see the sunrise.â
No, Haymitch doesnât, because he will not survive this nor does he want to. There is no point to wanting things here, where his sun cannot reach him. Where there is no warmth and no melodies to sing him to sleep. For all that Haymitch searches for you in the space between Wyatt and Maysilee, the vacancy condemns him to hold on longer.Â
âCold,â Haymitch wheezes when the head doctor comes in with a notebook and questions instead of a blanket like he asked.Â
âThey say you have a fever,â he says, cool-toned like the groups of medical types Haymitch hears outside his door.Â
Itâs just fevers, itâs just nosebleeds, itâs just an old drunk incapable of riding it out. Heâs lucky he hasnât seized yet, or dropped dead completely, or gone insane.Â
Haymitch is so very lucky.Â
Over a cacophony of chittering, Ampert calls for help from Haymitch and Beetee before he chokes out, âYou said weâd beat the odds.âÂ
âYou said youâd be right back,â cries Wellie, head rolling off her shoulders and landing by Silkaâs. Tears spill out of the gap where her eye once was, and Haymitch stammers out apologies to both.Â
He said, he said, he said, so many things.Â
Sid and Ma repeat each word, each empty promise of his, back to Haymitch. Their burnt flesh clogs his nose and steals his voice. They scream for him like they have in all his nightmares before. The only difference now is that Burdock is right there, attempting to put out the fire only to get caught in it himself.Â
Itâs during one of those conversations between the robots who shouldâve learned better about running their mouths that Haymitch learns the news about Twelve.Â
âHave you seen the new refugees?âÂ
âThey brought kids with them. More bodies, but more mouths to feed, too.âÂ
âThatâs not even half of them. Might be a good thing that the others were all killed in the bombing.âÂ
Haymitch bangs his head against the wall, earning gasps from the other side of the door. For the rest of the morning, before they give in and enter with a sedative to shut him up, he begs them to stab the needle in his arteries. Or to give him a bottle. Whichever stops his heart first.Â
Pinned down by his weightlessness, Haymitch canât do a thing but yell at Burdock to run, to leave before he burns too. Burdock never listens, but the fire dies out, leaving them both to a meadow of ash and blackened skies where his song has free rein to suffocate Haymitch in turn.Â
Itâs sooner than later that Iâm six feet under
It's sooner than later that you'll be alone
So who will you turn to tomorrow, I wonder?
âI donât wanna hear this,â Haymitch tells Burdock, choking on the soot in his lungs. He canât hear this, and he canât see her againâthe rainbow girl who isnât you on that Capitol television. Burdock sings louder, soulful as the mockingjays and furious as he should be over having his twin lost, his family torn, and his little girl made into a pawn of war. Thereâs no mistaking his agony for anything else, or Haymitchâs role in causing it.Â
Lenore Dove picks up where Burdock left off, exacting in the message she leaves for Haymitch. He left her to face the gallows alone. He can handle a song.Â
âDo you want to know what it felt like, Haymitch?â she asks, face full of sorrow over the deaths of her people and her dreams of a different world. âTo have my neck broken like my heart.âÂ
Haymitch shakes his head no, but she meant it rhetorically and tells him what he doesnât want to know in excruciating detail. The burn of the rope, the pressure to her pulse point, the shooting pain of Tam Amberâs sobs. He hears them for himself, under the taunt of Burdockâs voice as he returns to finish the last lines.Â
The resulting fracture lodges itself with the rest of Haymitchâs rot. Itâs the only place inside him that hasnât been scraped raw, a twisted safe haven for the worst parts of him to hibernate. From his heightened nerves to the shame heâs racked up to the wicked, vile grief that ravages him anew. All of them twined together at the base of his ribcage like the roots of a tree.Â
His rotten tree is an ugly thing with no bright red leaves or branches to climb. No color, no life, and the absence of both, which he should be used to by now, is sharper than heâs known it to be. Even in the once radiant woods of Twelve, everything is loudly barren.Â
You're still angry with Haymitch, so he canât see your face. At most, he catches the angles of your shadow in the glaring sun, which is fine by him. Throw him scraps, scold him until his ears fall off, haunt him however you see fit. Just haunt him. Itâs what heâs asked for since you left, isnât it?Â
Haymitch mouths your name, thinks he says it out loud too, but thereâs no sound besides the blood rushing to his head and the shattering of glass.Â
Steam explodes out of the aftermath, following the current of your hair as it blows around you. Curling around your shadow like a noose, the steam does little to stop you from bending down for a scoop of hot chocolate.Â
âNo!â Haymitch croaks, suddenly seven and fourteen and sixteen all over again. Suddenly made to confront each age of innocence and fault and all the years in between. âItâs poisoned! You have toââ He stammers and falls lurching forward to get to you. âDrop it!âÂ
You donât, because youâre angry, and youâre starving, and youâre desperate for something Haymitch hasnât remembered to feel in so long.Â
âPlease drop it,â he begs, shutting his eyes and opening them again, the same force pinning him to the floor at once prying them open. He calls out your name softer, deciding in his panic thatâs the only way to get through to you, and he receives your back in response. âYou canâtâitâll kill you.âÂ
His rot buckles under the burden of the boy he was before the Games and the consequences of the man heâs become since. Thereâs no safe haven for the excruciating, stubborn pain, and it spills out of him in tears. He cries for a bottle, for death, for you.Â
âItâll kill you,â Haymitch repeats, sobbing. You donât care to hear him, or maybe heâs just not trying hard enough. He could scream louder, or bargain with you, or wrench the poison out of your grasp and send it far, far away.Â
But itâs already in you; already in him.Â
Your stomach is coated in decay, dripping onto the glass and down your fingers. Glass, not a knife. Your fingers, not Maritteâs. Theyâre yours, and you know that. Youâll die, and you know that.Â
Haymitch pleads with you anyway, his effort ragged and strained. âDonât do this, sunshine. Please.âÂ
By the time he wakes up in his bed again, youâre gone for good. Heâs tied down by restraints, which draws a startled, hollow laugh out of him. Feels like a waste of energy and supplies. Where else would he go? The walls are bleeding again, his sisters are wailing, and thereâs no place for Haymitch but here.Â
Somewhere between the second and third week, his ghosts turn over a new leaf.Â
They arenât in a forgiving mood, but they arenât vengeful, or even fully resentful anymore. Sadness is what Haymitch finally ascribes to them. He realizes it during Magsâs last visit, while she soothes him through the nausea, her face coated in the same ointment he fought tooth and nail to send to his kids in the arena. She watches him with sunken eyes, and when she goes, patting his hand goodbye, she leaves her sorrow behind for the others.Â
Anger is easier to feel for himself and to accept from them. Their sadnessâtheir resignation, which extends to Haymitch as much as to themselvesâis rough against the skin and harder to stomach. Itâs their version of grace, which is different from forgiveness but a kindness just the same.Â
Maybe theyâre tired of stewing in the substitute emotion of anger and letting it do the work of moving on for them. Maybe they realize itâll punish him more to stop their cruelty. Maybe Haymitch is tired, too. So very tired, he lets his ghosts be kind, and lets their kindness hurt.Â
Haymitch welcomes the sting Chaff and Seeder bring to their shared corner during his weekly check-up, when the good doctor comes in to see if heâs died yet. Maysileeâs frozen fingers check his forehead for fever most evenings, drawing acidic tears out of him when he finally notices her throatâs been stitched up. Wyatt isnât wounded anymore either, as he watches over the little ones, every dove and every Newcomer, in the springtime meadow. Once is all Haymitch needs to see of them together for it to break him clean in two.Â
Those that never come back, he doesnât call for. He has his own mind fill in the mysteriesâMa and Sid holding each other fearfully, Hattieâs heart giving out on her, Wiressâs eyes twitching into lunacyâbut he doesnât pull them out of whatever resolution theyâve found. He doesnât try to summon them.Â
And if he knew any better, if he werenât a rotting hole of a person, heâd stop trying to summon you too. Haymitch canât help himself or his selfishness or the breath that gives life to all the dead parts of him that still have so many questions and wants. He can blame sobriety and the lucidity it brings, but even when every bit of him was good and numb, alive but dead, he wanted more than he should.Â
So he doesnât stop asking for you, and waiting for answers, or even a reminder of how he let you down in every way a person can be. He asks and waits and cries, and the only thing that gets him to calm down in these fits of despair is Lenore Doveâs tune box.Â
Her eyes donât meet his, turned down to the keys over which her fingers glide like the wings of her namesake bird in the breeze. The quiet of her playing, devoid of bitterness, soothes him. Comforts him more than he has any right to accept from her.Â
The notes flit into lyrics. Tam Amber kicks them off as he did all those years ago. Lenore Doveâs soft lilt and Barb Azureâs low warmth float alongside him. Together, they lull Haymitch to sleep while singing of sunflowers.Â
With his forgiving heart on his sleeve, Burdockâs soot-covered face is there when Haymitch wakes. He isnât singing, isnât blended into the backdrop of the meadow, and like the others before him, isnât carrying a lick of anger in his soul-searching gaze.Â
Haymitch blinks slowly, hoping childishly each time he does that Burdock will be gone. Itâs one thing for his ghosts to have reined in their vengeance, another to have accepted the lost Coveyâs song, but whatever Burdock brings with him now isnât something Haymitch can take.Â
Though heâs the same age as he was the last Haymitch saw him in the Hob, Burdockâs salt-speckled hair has grown well past his shoulders. It unnerves Haymitch to see Burdock settled into adulthood yet carrying the possibilities of youthâa contradiction that shouldnât fit together so seamlesslyâand all he can say is, âIâm sorry.âÂ
Burdock frowns and leans back in the chair at Haymitchâs bedside. âYouâve told me dozens of times already, Hay. Itâs time for you to pick up a new tune.âÂ
âItâs my fault,â Haymitch mutters, hearing Burdock and choosing not to listen. Thatâs the cycle theyâve established between them the last Burdockâs hair was this long, so why quit it now? He focuses on the freshest failure, the one without years of resentment built in, the one heâs certain Burdock is here to talk about. âSheâs too young for what I roped her into.âÂ
At the mention of his little girl, the ease in his eyes dissipates into anguish. Even though the symptoms of withdrawal have finally begun to subside, Haymitch is certain heâs imagining the lack of betrayal on Burdockâs face. âYes, she is. But I canât fault you for saving her in whatever way you could.âÂ
âYou telling me you ainât pissed?â he asks skeptically.Â
âIâm saying you give yourself too much credit.â Burdock clicks his teeth, and the overhead lights seem to flicker in response. âYouâre doing your part, Hay, and you got a lifetime to make things right with both of them.âÂ
Maybe, so long as Haymitch manages to get one of them back from Snow and the other through this war alive. âI never wanted a lifetime.â Not the one heâs been dealt.Â
âYou got one anyway. Donât take it for granted.âÂ
Haymitch rolls onto his back. Looking at Burdock for too long strains his eyes more than the fluorescents. Poor imitation that they are. He squints up at the dome of light, waits for it to blind him, to make his vision spotty enough to turn to Burdock again. âIsâŠshe happy over there?â As his vision quickly fades back, Haymitch can see Burdock expected some variation of his question, and he almost seems pleased Haymitch isnât skirting around it. He canât even if he tried, with the words spilling right out of him now in a pathetic murmur. âShe wonât come to me. Wonât let me follow.âÂ
âFor good reason.â Burdock doesnât say more for a long stretch, laying his palms flat on his lap. He glances at the ceiling, and Haymitchâs head snaps in the same direction, a part of him instinctively assuming Burdock is searching for you to impart whatever riddled wisdom he seeks. The difference between Burdock and Haymitch is one of them has access to you, and the other youâve shunned for said good reason.Â
âYou know,â Burdock finally begins, âjust because we arenât here to live life doesnât mean we canât see it. I see every day through both my girlsâ eyes. Through Asteridâs. You may not believe it, but sheâs here, seeing through yours, too.âÂ
Beneath the rot, where a maple red heart beats unevenly, a memory fizzles of Burdock at Haymitchâs side much like now, telling him death doesnât mean the end of everything. Maysileeâs voice, repeating her grandmotherâs words to him, echoing that old Covey song, sneaks up in agreement. âThatâs nice, but not what I asked.âÂ
Burdock rolls his eyes and decides against pulling out Haymitchâs saline bag. âI think my sister made a choice that you wouldâve,â he says pointedly. âSheâd probably be happier once you accepted it for yourself.âÂ
Haymitch draws a painful breath, tries to send Burdockâs answer to where all the unwanted thoughts and ugly pieces belong with no success. Itâd be easier with a bottle in hand, but theyâve already wrung him dry and split him open to exposure. He canât avoid what heâs known in his bones, or heard through his ghosts, or felt in the colorless world youâve damned him to all these years. And he canât keep avoiding the pit in his off-kilter, maple red heart reserved for the person as precious as those he brought into his life.Â
Haymitch rubs his nose with the sleeve of his sweater. âDid you ever go to Cindy and Hemlockâs wedding?â
The distance between them, which will always exist in some way, is made less impossible by Burdockâs smile. âThey had cake.âÂ
Vanilla, Burdock says, and itâs the last detail Haymitch remembers when he comes to evenings later. A blurred figure stands at the doorway, shaped nothing like his old friend. But his mindâs great at playing tricks, and naive as it makes him, Haymitch would rather believe his ghost has lingered than deal with whatever mess is waiting outside this room.Â
âBurdie?â
âGuess again.â Plutarch takes a step forward, all smiles and olive branches Haymitch would rather snap in half. âYouâre being discharged tomorrow.âÂ
Haymitch sits up and drops his jaw in pretend shock. âAm I? They failed to mention that this morning when they brought the head doctor to clear me.âÂ
Plutarch chuckles, relieved and amused. He scans the eggshell room for the damage he mustâve been expecting, but the cleaning crew discarded all the evidence yesterday while Haymitch was allowed a walk down the corridor. Haymitch resists the urge to say Plutarch shouldâve visited sooner if he wanted to revel in the pigsty. âIâm glad to see youâre feeling better, and right on time. Katniss has agreed to be our mockingjay.âÂ
âLooks like you didnât need me after all,â says Haymitch, though he is surprised she agreed so soon. He assumed itâd take months they didnât have for her resolve to crack, but then again, he has no idea how exactly sheâs been faring. The last he saw of her was when he passed her room on the way to his, half sedated himself but lucid enough to see the hatred in her empty eyes.Â
Plutarch crosses his arms. âShe had a long list of demands in exchange for her complianceâI know you donât want to hear this, but the resemblance is uncanny sometimes.âÂ
Haymitch is well aware.Â
âAnyway,â Plutarch rattles on, âyou shouldâve seen Coinâs face.â
Ah, yes, the elusive President Alma Coin with whom Haymitch hasnât had the displeasure of meeting yet. He doesnât want to see her face, nor imagine it, if the personnel whoâve come in and out of here are any reflection of her governance. âI reckon the girlâs entitled to some demands.â Good on her for making them sing for their supper. Haymitch knows heâll have his own hoops to jump through if he ever expects her to trust him again.Â
Plutarch hums in agreement. âOne of them includes rescuing Peeta and the other captured victors from the Capitol.â A given, but again, Haymitch has to wonder how thatâd be possible. Thirteenâs compassion surely wonât be fueling the supplies theyâd need for that kind of mission any time soon. âHe made a few appearances on Caesarâs show. Seemed unharmed.â For now. Haymitch swings his legs over the bed as Plutarch continues, âMy point is we do still need you on this team, Haymitch. Katniss needs you.â
He stares at the chair where Burdock sat. He was right about Haymitch having a lifetime. Whether he wants one or not, whether heâll get to keep it after this war or not. Heâd like to bank on not, but thatâs secondary to what his girl needs now. âWell, Iâm being discharged tomorrow, arenât I?â
âGreat,â says Plutarch, nodding as he backs towards the door. Haymitch would also get a kick out of slapping the grin off his faceâanother thing thatâll have to wait. âGet some rest then. Tomorrowâs our first filming day.âÂ
âGreat,â Haymitch echoes dryly, and waits until the door shuts to fall back into bed.Â
Without the sedatives, without the numbness or the company of spirits outside his own wayward imagination, Haymitch has no idea what rest looks like. Different from distraction, that much he can say. Heâs a miracle case. Sober and alive, and he hasnât conjured anyone in days. A miracle still in the thick of his own personal hell. Still walking through the fire in the hopes itâll soon take him too.Â
Haymitch fixates on the chair again, thinks about the lifetime he wouldâve traded in a heartbeat for yours, and drifts off with a sorrow so spiteful he can only call it his own.Â
Itâs only in dreamless sleep that the spite chips away little by little. The sorrowâs still there, and so is the shame, but with no company to keep, no nightmares to ward off, and no bottle to distract him from either, Haymitch doesnât flinch awake from the nothingness. He doesnât scramble when it turns into a song. Found in the blur of days past, and made real by that long lost, never forgotten melody of yours.Â
Are you, are you coming to the tree,
Where I told you to run,
So weâd both be free?
Strange things did happen here,
No stranger would it be,
If we met up at midnight
In the hanging tree.
You donât show yourself to Haymitch beyond singing that forbidden song. Come morning, a gray jumpsuit and the bracelet thatâd been confiscated when he was admitted is all that waits on the chair at his bedside. Detox has done a number on Haymitch, beaten him to a pulp, because the paralyzing urge to call you and beg for more glimpses hasnât seized him yet. He gives it another minute, and when his chest sizzles, he accepts last night wasnât a pitiful scrap on your end or a trick of his self-loathing mind.Â
Haymitch leaves it be as you meant it: the first sign of dawn in twenty-five years.Â
Properly rested and miserable, per Plutarchâs instructions, Haymitch dresses the part of a revolutionary, so he might as well fall back into the role of mentor too. Whatâs it matter that heâs not even forty-eight full hours out of the hospital and wants a drink so bad he might actually rip his own throat out? Doesnât matter none, because no one else in this nation of robots has the aptitude to state the obvious: forcing Katniss into a box is exactly how their revolution dies.Â
After the headache of a morning spent convincing them of her limitations, piled onto an afternoon listening to his girl butcher their chance for freedom one bad line delivery after another, Haymitch is no mood to bury the hatchet with her. He needs to, though, if theyâre ever going to get his boy back and pull this war off.Â
As Coinâexpectedly as dull as the country sheâs runningâadjourns their meeting, Haymitch asks to speak to Katniss privately. She narrows her eyes at him, turns them into daggers when Coin agrees and the others file out. Gale lingers, the gentle angles of his familyâs genes now forged into weapons by what heâs been through. He saved as many as he could from the bombing, Haymitch was told. What nightmares must the kid be wrestling behind his rageful shield?Â
Briefly, Haymitch searches for anything Blair mightâve left behind in his nephew. He shakes it off; there are more important things than nostalgia. "What are you worried about?" Haymitch motions accusingly to Katniss with the marker he used earlier. His eye is healed, and the scratches she left on his face have long since gone away, but the damage between them is a physical presence in the room nonetheless. "I'm the one who needs the bodyguard."Â Â
Katniss inhales sharply and looks at Gale, who still seems uncertain. She assures him, "It's okay."Â
Gale presses his lips together and leaves them to the purr of the ventilation system.Â
Sighing in sync with the roomâs humming machinery, Haymitch sits across from Katniss. It takes him several attempts to finally look at her properly. Sheâs determined to be the model rebel, to do whatever it takes to save PeetaâHaymitch sees it clearly laid out before her. The same way he sees past her stone-faced shield, right into the shame that reflects his own. "We're going to have to work together again. So, go ahead. Just say it."Â Â
Katniss stares at the spot of the table in front of her. It doesnât take her long to find her voice. "I can't believe you didn't rescue Peeta."Â Â
"I know," Haymitch replies instantly. What else is there to say? He broke his promise, went back on his end of their deal, and did so willingly. Heâd apologize if she thought sheâd want to hear it, or if he could say it out loud to her without sinking into himself. And thatâs not going to bring Peeta back.Â
Katniss glances up at him. "Now you say it.â
Haymitch doesnât hold back his own scorn. "I can't believe you let him out of your sight that night."Â
She nods, dropping her gaze again, and it kills him how small she sounds, exactly like she did when they made this drunken, unrealistic deal. Like you, damning him with your own binding yet breakable promises. But when she curls in on herself, the memory of you ripples like a reflection in water, making room for a present which is plenty painful in its own right.Â
âI play it over and over in my head,â she starts off, digging her fingers into her arms. âWhat I could have done to keep him by my side without breaking the alliance. But nothing comes to me."Â Â
"You didn't have a choice,â he says truthfully. If she stayed with Peeta, Johanna wouldnât have gotten her tracker out, and sheâd be in the Capitol too. If Haymitch hadnât chosen her, both kids would be lost to him forever, and so would the revolution. And if heâd done things right the first time around⊠For everything that may have gone right if theyâd done what they wanted, or thought they shouldâve, thereâs plenty that wouldâve turned out worse. Katniss canât wait as long as he did to realize it. âAnd even if I could've made Plutarch stay and rescue him that night, the whole hovercraft would've gone down. We barely got out as it was."Â
Hesitantly, she meets his eyes. Her own are red-rimmed and dragged down by sleepless nights. Haymitch says the only thing he knows can comfort her now: "He's not dead yet, Katniss."Â Â
"We're still in the game,â she murmurs, voice cracking on the last words.Â
"Still in. And I'm still your mentor." No matter how many people are now tasked with the impossible mission of keeping Katniss alive, the weight of it falls solely on Haymitch. Whatever the cost, heâs not giving up his job any time soon. He points his marker at her. "When you're on the ground, remember I'm airborne. I'll have the better view, so do what I tell you."Â Â
Although it was his idea, Haymitch feels less confident about sending Katniss into combat when she shrugs halfheartedly. "We'll see.âÂ
Pain in the ass brat.Â
Katniss pushes up from her chair, and Haymitch does the same, giving her the go ahead to leave first. She stands frozen for a second, staring at some spot over Haymitchâs shoulder, and itâs all he can do not to react to the look she gets. The very one that crossed her steely expression after he busted her and Peeta for watching his Games, and occasionally popped up in the days that followed. No matter how subtle and how quick it appears, that look is loaded with the desire of knowledge in place of your presence in her life.Â
The look is a reminder to Haymitch, too. Peeta isnât the only broken bridge between them.Â
Once she leaves without another word, Haymitch doesnât stop himself from turning around. Thereâs no stopping the curdling in his stomach either, no matter how stupid he knows it is to have checked for you in the first place. He rubs his knuckles until they stop trembling, and walks out the door.Â
Plutarch waits on the other side with a set of plans and directives he wants Haymitch to communicate to Katniss. Did he emphasize how imperative it is that she stay out of any direct line of fire? Martyrdom is something they can work with, but sheâs more valuable alive. Itâs important Haymitch second all creative directives Plutarch doles out, too. After all, he is the âmockingjay whisperer.â What a load of crap.Â
Getting through that dense head of hers is a waste of energy, and Plutarchâs wilful ignorance on that front is tested hours later when Katniss reminds them just how stubborn and reckless she is. And thanks to her little stunt, Haymitch gets to pay a special visit to Beetee in Special Weaponry. Â
It makes no difference where he stands; the lights are dizzying and blinding in this room for all the wrong reasons. Theyâre even worse than those in the hospital wing, and Haymitch paces through the rows of weaponry to distract himself while Beetee whips out the alternative earpieces he asked for. Itâs a marvel Thirteenâs arsenal is so well-stocked, along with the rest of the district.Â
A hospital wing with a range of staff, a handful of hovercrafts, and an entire floor dedicated to weaponry. Theyâve done more than well for themselves over the last seventy-five years. Have downright flourished when compared to the rest of the districts, whoâve left to suffer under the Capitolâs thumb. Thirteenâs their ally now, Haymitch tells himself. And an overthrow of the Capitol, as his own history has shown, is far from straightforward. Besides, if the nursesâ loud mouths are to be trusted, theyâve had their fair share of challenges. Still, he never has gotten the hang of controlling his bitterness. Â
Haymitch fiddles with the headgear Beetee has laid out on his work desk. Heâs not big on the idea of muzzling the girl. Itâs bad enough he shoved her into this war. âAnything more permanent?â
Beetee nods and sets down a silver chip as small as a grain of bread. âNow this would have to be surgically implanted, but it would allow you to speak to Katniss at all hours of the day.â
âEven better.â Haymitch doesnât want it to come to thisâand as the overhead lights grow impossibly brighter and Haymitch grows doubly nauseous, he thinks about those Capitol surgeons whose teeth he almost knocked out to keep them from âfixingâ Katniss. Heâd be no better than them if he followed through. ButâŠheâs not above scaring her into being less reckless with her life. âThank you, Beetee.âÂ
When the thanks leaves his mouth, genuine as it is, Haymitchâs head spins. He realizes he hasnât even asked Beetee how heâs been, or offered condolences for Wiress, or made any effort to check in on him now that heâs been out of detox. âI didnât get the chance to tell you earlier.â
âOh,â Beetee brushes him off with a wave and wheels back behind his desk. âI should be thanking you, too.â
âWeâre not out of it yet,â Haymitch reminds him, because itâs important Beetee knows that. He has to know Haymitch has done nothing to warrant his gratitude in the first place. Beetee is the one who helped save his girl, who has continued to trust Haymitch in spite of the insurmountable loss thatâs resulted from the moment he walked up to that potato booth with you. Then again, Haymitch has continued to trust Beetee in the face of his own insurmountable loss.
âNo,â Beetee agrees, glancing up at Haymitch with a glint of warmth. Haymitch tries his best not to, but his mind wanders to Burdock and his life after death, to Lenore Dove and her angels, to you and your talking birds. He holds Beeteeâs gaze, and doesnât flinch when he catches Ampert looking back. What a strong pair of eyes to see through.Â
Beetee manages a hint of a smile, and he adds, âNot yet.âÂ
Not ever, if Katniss doesnât listen for once in her damn life. Haymitch thinks he at least manages to get through to her when he pays her a visit in the hospital. Sitting idly by her bedside for a whole afternoon pays off in lunch and her agreement, however begrudging, to save him from a near heart attack by wearing her earpiece.Â
On his way out of the hospital, Haymitch passes the corridor which held him not so long ago. And when Plutarch summons him to Command to discuss his next intended propo, a part of Haymitch wants to retreat into that eggshell purgatory, shut off from the world and its demands of him.Â
âCressida wants to do unscripted interviews on the bombing in Twelve,â says Plutarch, pretending not to see the noticeable wince Haymitch gives in response. He hasnât allowed for much wallowing on the destruction of Twelve since he first heard the news through clogged ears and a thinly constructed door. Plutarch relayed more details the day Haymitch was discharged, but even then, he cared more to focus on Katniss than to take in what Snow had done to his people. To ask of the survivors outside those heâd seen for himself. Â
Plutarch sits forward in his chair at the head of the table. He gives away even less than he usually does down here, even though itâs only the two of them in this room. Haymitch figures he has to if he means to stay in Coinâs good graces. She may be fighting for their side, but he reckons thereâs more to her behind that head of platinum and a commitment to equality. Enough for Plutarch to fall back on his habit of ass-kissing. âThat, of course, requires us to actually be in District Twelve.âÂ
Cut to the chase, why donât you? Haymitch feigns well-meaning ignorance. âYâall have a safe trip then.â
âHaymitch,â Plutarch starts off with his usual I-want-something-from-you friendliness, âYou should come with us.âÂ
Should, he says like he hasnât already put it in Haymitchâs schedule. âI canât.âÂ
âCressida wants to focus on Katniss and Gale, but itâd be great if we could get you on camera, too,â says Plutarch, drumming his fingers on the table. Â
Haymitch scoffs. âNobody wants to see me in one of those things.âÂ
âI can guaranteeââÂ
âUnless you can guarantee me a bottle, Plutarch, I wonât do it.â Already, his chest is tightening and the threat of bile is clawing at his throat. Haymitch hasnât had a home in what seems like an eternity, and he as good as turned his back on his district. But it was his district. His home, even if it hasnât felt like it in a long time. And he sees it all nowâevery place where he grew and loved, every porch he ever sat on with lost friends, every corner you touchedâburied under rubble like those in the worst of his nightmares. âI canât face it.âÂ
Plutarch waits a moment and is surely disappointed when Haymitch gives him no choice but to concede. âAll right,â he sighs. âWeâll handle it.âÂ
âI have full faith in you,â says Haymitch, offering a mock grin through his trembling breath.Â
The funny thing about avoidance, which Haymitch shouldâve learned with his time in detox, is it doesnât work in the long run. Itâs a childâs luxury. Everything comes back around eventually.Â
While the camera crew and Boggsâs squad accompany them to Twelve, Haymitch is scheduled to assist Beetee in Special Weapons all day. Assist is used loosely, as Haymitch is better served as a soundboard for Beetee to bounce ideas off of. Katnissâs friend is the one whoâs taken to this side of the war.
Haymitch keeps his communication device by his side at all times, checking for updates on the crewâs movements, even as theyâre herded into the cafeteria for lunch. Mushed peas, stew, and a roll of bread make up his plate. Haymitch has had worse, so whoâs he to complain? His appetite is lost to him anyway when he spots a recognizable pair of wrinkled, disapproving eyes attached to a head of short gray hair.Â
Haymitch assumed Clerk Carmine was in the group of Seam folk who managed to surviveâhoped for it, just as he hoped heâd never have to see the man again in his life. Heâs aged, clearly, but he stares at Haymitch from three tables down with the same closed off indignation as the day they buried you.Â
Somewhere in the woods, maybe deep enough that your grave, and Lenore Doveâs, were untouched by the bombs. What of Burdockâs? He was buried in Twelveâs cemetery, and Haymitch knows because he woke up in it months after his death and found a freshly dug patch of dirt in the Everdeen plot. A grave without a body, but did Katniss know of the Everdeenâs funeral traditions? Whatever it was Burdock and Sorrel dug for you in lieu of your coffin.Â
What about your peopleâs funeral song? Or your grave? Something in Haymitch tells him no, Katniss doesnât know. Burdock was the last living person with the knowledge of where to find you. Not counting the scornful old man sitting three tables across from Haymitch.Â
His legs nearly give out when he stands and mutters, âBe right back.âÂ
Beeteeâs voice sounds muffled, like heâs underwater. Or Haymitch is the one beneath the waves, and heâs drowning under his curiosity of whether or not the resting places of his family and friends and tributes were collateral. Heâs suffocating in this too small cafeteria with no air and no sun.Â
He needs out of this room, this underground hellhole, this cycle of constant death and loss and no one to hate more than he hates himself. Except Snow, but he didnât make Haymitch into anything he wasnât already. A traitor, a liar, a coward who canât even muster half a day of support for his girl without a bottle in his hand.Â
Rounding the hallway leading out of the cafeteria, Haymitch rubs a hand over his shirt pocket and presses down until he feels the metal leaving an imprint through the fabric. Heâs so caught up in trying to erase the images of fire in his head that he nearly topples over her.Â
âHi, Hay.âÂ
Haymitch takes a large step back and blinks slowly, but Louella isnât a ghost and closing his eyes wonât make her go away. His hands shake as he tugs on the collar of his jumpsuit. Itâs too tight, and the room is too small, and heâs too sober for this. Much, much too sober.Â
Louella tries her hand at a smile, but it wobbles when she asks, âHow are you?â
âPeachy,â he answers, immediately tasting acid. He forces his hands to stop shaking and manages to get out, âSorry. Howâre you?âÂ
Louella brushes off his rudeness with a shrug. âItâs different from Twelve. Harder, but that might just be the circumstances of why weâre here.â She glances past his shoulder at the cafeteria doorway. âWeâre still adjusting.âÂ
Haymitch exhales slowly, gives his collar another tug, and feels his chest begin to loosen. Weâre, as in her whole family. Not the McCoy clanâthough he hopes and imagines theyâre includedâbut the family she made for herself.Â
As if picking up on his train of thoughts, Louella supplies, âTheyâre at our table. Jack and the kids.âÂ
In all the years sheâs been marriedâhow many exactly, Haymitch isnât entirely sureâthis is the first heâs heard her husbandâs name. âHow many of âem you got?âÂ
âJust two. Hewer and Bluebell.â Louella smiles proudly, just like those days sheâd trail behind him wherever he went. Sheâs found her own path now. âDo you want to meet them?âÂ
âNo,â he says clumsily, the walls closing in on him again at the thought of sitting down with her family and meeting the children with no home. His eyes flicker to the space around them. âNot right now. I donâtâI have toââ
âItâs okay,â Louella cuts him off softly, if not disappointed. He doesnât glance her way to find out. âSome other time.âÂ
âSure,â Haymitch says with no intent of ever following through. Â
And Louella must know that, but she doesnât seem to mind the lie. Sheâs earnest and kind in the way she tells him, âItâs good to see you, Hay.âÂ
The walls stop where they are. Haymitch looks at her as she is now, the hidden whites in her dark coils, the tough set in her eyes, the lines around her mouth that speak to a life happily built with a future yet to live. But she will. Sheâll get to live it. âYou too, sweetheart.â
Louella leaves Haymitch to pick up whateverâs left of his shattered will to do anything of real use. When he returns to his table, slots into his seat without a word to Beetee, and musters the courage to lift his head, Clerk Carmine is no longer in view. But youâre there, in the empty space meant to remind Haymitch the old man has every right to avoid him, not the other way around.Â
Youâre there in the days that follow, too. Little traces of you, Burdock, and Lenore Dove woven into Plutarchâs footage of Katniss singing that same forbidden song you delivered in Haymitchâs dreams. Flashes of your dying breaths sneak up when he watches his boyâs blood splatter on white porcelain before the television turns to static.Â
And now, as Katniss crumbles over the stream of wilted red and pink roses, itâs all Haymitch can do not to picture your tears in the taunt of Snowâs sadistic trademark.Â
Katniss is a stumbling mess, and Haymitch meets her halfway when she asks for him. He catches her before she can trip over herself. However fraught things remain between them, thereâs little worse than seeing her in pain like this.Â
"It's okay. It'll be okay, sweetheart." He guides her to a piece of broken marble and sinks onto it with her. Â
"I can't do this anymore," she cries, shaking like that ugly Calla look-alike she smuggled in for the little one.Â
"I know.â Haymitch wishes he didnât.Â
Much like on the hovercraft, there is no talking Katniss down from her hysteria. The best Haymitch can do is hold her through it as she continues to panic. "All I can think of is,â she gasps, âwhat he's going to do to Peetaâbecause I'm the Mockingjay!"Â
"I know," he repeats and tightens his arms around her, rubbing her shoulders. Â
"Did you see? How weird he acted? What are theyâdoing to him?" She hyperventilates, her sentences broken and garbled by her sobs. Haymitch shushes her softly and manages to make out a final snippet of her despair: "It's my fault!"Â
He shakes his head, a fragment of his poorly patched heart chipping as she wails into his shoulder. She canât hear him, and wouldnât listen or believe it if she could. Haymitch didnât; still doesnât, really. Yet, he means it when he says it to her. âSweetheart, you did everything you could.âÂ
Katniss remains inconsolable, which offsets a meltdown from Finnick. Haymitch would go to him if he werenât scared Katniss would fall straight through the ground the second he lets go. So he keeps his steady hold on her, even as the ground begins to feel unstable beneath his own feet. Even after theyâve sedated her. Only when they bring a gurney does he let her go, and walks her down to the hospital.Â
Asterid and Prim are both in the hallway when they arrive. Similar in their worry, distinct in how it shows up on their identical faces. Haymitch loathes looking at either one of them, and heâs managed to coast by with little interaction with them in the last weeks. Now, he canât pretend not to notice Asteridâs glassy eyes and Primâs scrunched up nose, the latter of which guts him as much as the echo of Katnissâs distress.Â
Prim is the one to speak up when a pair of nurses wheel Katniss past them into her designated room. Sheâs calm as she asks, âWhat happened?âÂ
âShe figured out Snowâs plans for Peeta. Freaked out.â Concise and to the point, as Haymitch prefers all conversation with this pair of Everdeens to be. He goes dizzy for a second when he notices the copper bluebird dangling from the little oneâs neck. Last he saw of the thing was when he gave it to Tam Amber to bury it with you. But here it is, making a mockery of his best intentions. âSheâll be all right.âÂ
Asterid nods, but the sorrow in her eyes is permanent. Haymitch doesnât remember much about the year Burdock died, besides the forming of another pit in his heart and a matching one in his stomach when he saw his eldest girl in the reaping eligible crowd. He wasnât any happier with the pair he got. Marigold and Ambrose, more Seam kids.Â
That aside, the year is a blur. But Haymitch doesnât need to remember details to know Asteridâs sunkenness started with Burdockâs death and has persisted ever since. He canât bear to linger on the thought, or to look at her at all, lest the image of her bloodied forehead creep up. Over the last year, Haymitch has thought to apologize for it more times than he can count.Â
He tried once, back around the time Gale was whipped. The house had gone quiet in the aftermath, and Haymitch was in the kitchen sniffing the alcohol they kept around for disinfection. When Asterid walked in, he nearly dropped the bottle, feeling shame and wondering where its origin came from before realizing it wasnât the drinking he was ashamed of in her presence.Â
The words were forming on his tongue, long overdue, and she could probably sense it, too. Asterid always was the understanding type. Heâd seen in during their youthâshe knew what wounded souls needed before they could name it themselves. Which is why, Haymitch figures, she never held it against him when he couldnât say them out loud. She just carried on in the kitchen, packed the medical supplies back under the sink counter, and left with a nod goodbye sent Haymitchâs way.Â
The same nod she gives him now as she crosses the doorway into Katnissâs room.Â
Prim stays put, and he canât tell if sheâs waiting for him to say more or to leave. Strangely, this kidâs harder to get a read on than Katniss. Stonefaced as she appears, his girlâs got a thousand tells for those who pay attention. Whatever turn Haymitch assumes Prim will take, she surprises him by choosing another. Sheâs her motherâs kid in looks and prowess, but she didnât go without inheriting a thing or two from her paâs branch.Â
Mystery that the kid is, like those before her, Haymitch doesnât expect her to say, âWe talked about it in the bunker. I told her Snow would do whatever it took to break her. I didnât thinkâŠâÂ
âShe wouldâve put it together eventually,â says Haymitch, because itâs true and because guilt doesnât suit anyone so young.Â
âProbably,â Prim agrees in a murmur. âKatniss is really strong, butâŠâ A wisdom beyond her years of life settles in her merchant blue eyes. âThereâs only so much a person can take alone. Thanks for looking after her.âÂ
Haymitch tears his eyes away from the crop of yellow hair the same shade as her namesake flower. The glass or the primrose? Where did you land? The confusionâs still there, even knowing the answer. He looks back down at her and decides on how to deflect when a meow sounds from his feet.Â
More orange, less beige, but just as picky as Calla. The cat prances straight into its ownerâs arms. Haymitch scratches his temple. âDoes that have medical clearance?âÂ
âButtercup doesnât do well staying cooped up in one place, especially after the bombings,â she says. Right. Sheâs survived two of them now. She goes wide-eyed as she clutches the bag of fur closer to her. âDonât tell any of the nurses you saw him.âÂ
Haymitch holds up his hands and shrugs. âI donât make it a habit of chatting up the wardens.âÂ
Prim smiles, reflecting the familiar disposition of someone born on the sunny side of life. âThanks again.âÂ
Rather than brush her off, Haymitch chooses not to respond at all. As Prim turns to Katnissâs room, Buttercup hisses in his direction.Â
âFeelingâs mutual, furball.â But Haymitch takes that as his cue to get the hell out. Katniss is in fine hands now. He only returns to the hospital a day later, when he has good news to deliver to her for once.Â
Equal parts good and bad really, considering her anticipated reaction to Galeâs role in Boggsâs rescue mission. All that manages to calm Katniss down when she begins to work herself into another frenzy is the promise to find her a job of some kind. Which is exactly what Haymitch does for both Katniss and Finnick, and Katniss manages to do well filming the footage they need to detract attention from the squadâs break-in.Â
Until Plutarch gets it in his head to push Finnick in front of the camera.Â
Theyâre above ground, the smell of wilted roses crushed beneath their boots, the air open and endless around them. But Haymitch can hardly breathe through his fuming.Â
Finnick reveals every sordid secret, weaponizes every dangerous detail whispered about their president and government, and exposes the worst of the Capitolâs crimes for Panem to hear. Detached as he is through his recounting, Haymitch can hear the tremor of his breath and see the twitch of his fingers in search of a knot to tie, or a noose to hang around his neck.Â
Long after the crew heads inside, Katniss stays slumped on the same piece of pillar where she broke into sobs not two days ago. Haymitch takes a seat next to her. He picks up on the hint of worry in her tone as she asks him, "Is that what happened to you?"Â
"No,â he assures her, ignoring the voice that chimes, oh but it couldâve been. âMy mother and younger brother were dead two weeks after I was crowned victor. Because of the stunt I pulled in the arena. And you already know what happened to myââ Haymitch stops himself, a surge of cowardice forbidding him from putting a name to what you were to him, and continue to be. Every description suddenly feels flat. And he doesnât have the strength to explain that, to talk about you so openly with her of all people, right now. âSnow had no one to use against me."
Katniss doesnât press on the subject of your relationship. "I'm surprised he didn't just kill you.â
"Oh, no. I was the example. The person to hold up to the young Finnicks and Johannas and Cashmeres. Of what could happen to a victor who caused problems," says Haymitch. And how fortunate he was to have escaped the fate befallen desirable, popular victors. All it cost was everyone he loved. "But he knew he had no leverage against me."Â Â
"Until Peeta and I came along," she says softly, staring at the side of his head. Haymitch doesnât acknowledge her. He canât deny it, as much as his instinct is to. And he canât admit, no matter how true it may be, that after the better part of two decades wishing for death to deliver him to you, they gave him something to live for again. He still doesnât turn when, after a long beat of listening to nothing, she murmurs more to herself than to him, âIt was real for you.âÂ
Maybe one day heâll tell her just how real it was. How his love for you has never dimmed a day; how a piece of him was buried in the earth with you; how he carries you and every person heâs lost in the forefront of his mind. Heâll tell her the truth about what you did in the Games together, and how heâs spent year after year seeking a free world with no real hope. Until she and his boy came along. One day, maybe, heâll have the courage to say everything out loud.Â
âHow have you endured it, Haymitch?â Katniss asks, more hesitant.Â
He hasnât is the truth, and the liquor is no more than a bandaid over a bullet wound. He echoes the same sentiment he told her back when they came to their truce. âI didnât have a choice.âÂ
âYou do now.â
Underneath her whisper, floating into the air above them, your own rings, completely distinct in both rhyme and rhythm this time. âDonât follow.âÂ
Those two damning words, which Haymitch has never been able to erase, no matter how many bottles heâs chased, will always sting to some extent. Theyâll always come with the memory of your empty eyes and frozen skin, condemning him to a lifetime without you. But as Haymitch sits with them, allows them to soak down into his heart, they donât sound quite like a punishment anymore.Â
âYeah,â he sighs, sparing Katniss a glance, âI guess I do.âÂ
For five fleeting seconds, behind the tiers of a blue-green sea and frosted dolphins, Haymitch catches a glimpse of his boy again. From the doorway, he points to the border of the bottom tier. âMissed a spot there.âÂ
Peetaâs head swivels to check the spot, and he narrows his eyes at Haymitch. âYouâve been told youâre an ass plenty of times before.âÂ
âPlenty,â Haymitch agrees, guilt lapping at his insides. Katnissâs accusations on the night he allowed Peeta to slip out of his grasp have been playing on a loop in his head since they got him back. Theyâre fresher than your hazy snipes. âBut go ahead. Lay it on me.âÂ
Peeta sets down his piping bag, the cuffs around his wrist clanging against the metal table. Out of the corner of his eye, Haymitch sees the guards stationed around them tense in preparation. The doctors warned Haymitch not to agitate Peeta, but the boyâs already chained to his work station and heâs earned the right not to be treated like broken glass. An instinct that is admittedly difficult to shed.
Peetaâs nose flares as he glowers at Haymitch. âYou shouldâve told me about the plan.âÂ
âMaybe I shouldâve.â Haymitch doesnât see any way in which that option wouldâve played out better. Knowledge is a curse as much as it is a privilege sometimes. âBut I couldnât risk the consequences of you knowing everything.âÂ
âThe consequences?â Peeta seethes. The vibrancy of the colored frosting dims with his anger. Warranted but no less cutting. âIâd say what happened was consequence enough, wouldnât you?â
Heâd been prepared to receive Peetaâs ire, to see the damage that was done to him and reckon with his role in all of it. What theyâve done to his boy is a peculiar torture Haymitch couldnât have imagined. âIâd say so, too.âÂ
âThen it made no difference in the end,â says Peeta, teetering between resentment and acceptance. Haymitch expects him to fall one way or another, maybe yell or fight against his restraints to throw a punch Haymitchâs way. He takes another step closer as Peeta continues in a sneer, âYou lied to me, kept me in the dark, and chose her for nothing.âÂ
Along with the doctorsâ reminders to steer on the side of neutrality with Peeta, Haymitch was under orders to avoid direct mention of Katniss. Peeta hasnât had a meltdown over her in daysânot since he recalled his memory of Burdock singing âThe Hanging Treeâ around townâand theyâd like to keep it that way. Haymitch figures if the boy brought her up first, itâs fair game. He sucks his teeth and taps his fingers to his head. âI know your mindâs still foggy, but you canât get mad at me for that last one. You asked me to pick her.âÂ
âI remember,â says Peeta, and Haymitch nearly reels back in surprise. Although Primâs suggested treatments have helped in the reversement of Peetaâs hijacking, there are still large gaps in his recollection.Â
They donât know what else to call it. Itâs more than an injury or an illness or a case of mental disorientation. And itâs not a death, technically. But the Peeta that went into that arena is not the one who stands before Haymitch now, and it sure feels like he died. He hasnât though. Peeta is here, and heâs alive, and Haymitch is no less responsible for him than he was before this. More so, if anything, given anyone who mightâve served as his guardian is dead.Â
Nowâs not about imagining his old schoolmatesâand nice, generous Oliver Schmidt in particularâturning to ash. So Haymitch erases the pictures popping up in his head. He doesnât respond either, giving Peeta the floor to work through what he needs to say.Â
âYou said itâd destroy her not to save me,â Peeta murmurs, and when his eyes drop to the cake, he seems caught in a daze of realization. âYou were talking about yourself, werenât you? You and that girl from the tape who looks like her.âÂ
Of all the things for Peeta to remember. Haymitch hadnât been ready for him to bring up Burdockâs lulling voice when he had, and he certainly isnât prepared for the subject of you right now. He shoves his hands into his pockets and struggles against the newfound heaviness in the room. âOther way around, actually.â
Peeta mutters something under his breath and shakes his head. âI donât think thereâs much of a resemblance anymore. That girl wasnât cruel. Howâd she end up with you?âÂ
âBeats me.â You wouldâve been much better suited for this conversation than Haymitch is. Really, he used up all his luck in becoming yours. Â
âI want to see Katniss,â Peeta decides, picking up the piping bag again. âI want to see if sheâs as torn up as you said sheâd be.âÂ
Haymitch sighs and looks over his shoulder at the one-way mirror. âI donât know if I can make that happen right now, Peeta.âÂ
âYou owe me,â Peeta says, parroting the desperation that overcame him on the day he burst into Haymitchâs kitchen with a kinder yet equally taxing demand. âMaybe you made good on what I asked for back then, but you left me to fend for myself again. I figure you owe me for that, at least.âÂ
And like that day in his kitchen, Peeta has Haymitch cornered. âLook, from now on, I wonât hide things from you. But I canât promise to bring Katniss down.â It wonât take much to get Katniss to agree to talk to himâwhether Peeta is really up for it is a different case. So is the task of convincing the doctors to give Katniss visiting privileges.Â
Peeta focuses on the cake, pipes a U shape thatâll surely turn into a ship. Seems a little like the underside of a duck for now. Between the seriousness of Peetaâs concentration and the illusive U, Haymitch thinks of you and your doodling, of Sid and his fuzzy newborn hair. Haymitch takes a deep breath at the same time as Peeta. His boy looks up. âNo more secrets.âÂ
Haymitch holds his hands out in surrender. âI donât have any more up my sleeve.â
âIâll have to wait until I see you mean it.âÂ
âFair enough.â Thereâs a subtle tap on the mirror, signaling his timeâs up. Haymitch waits for another handful of seconds to pass and another knock to say, âNice job on the cake, kid. Finnick and Annieâll like it.â
Peeta murmurs, âI hope so.âÂ
On the other side of the one-way mirror, Haymitch watches his boy pick up a new piping bag and frost purple flowers onto the top tier. Nearly the same shade as a larkspur.Â
When they land for the surrender, which isnât much of one in the wake of the final bombing, Haymitch doesnât care about anything else but getting to his clever, stubborn, badly burnt kids. Even seeing Snow bound in chains and dragged down his own hallways, catching his eye before heâs turned down a corner to his cell, elicits only a brief satisfaction. Brief but mighty, because what poetic justice it is to be the one looking down instead of up. To have toppled the invincible President Coriolanus Snow from his throne.Â
As the satisfaction lessens and his concern for Katniss and Peeta returns full-force, all Haymitch can hear is the sadistic chime of the man who wrung every bit of love out of his life. âWhat a well-earned victory, Mr. Abernathy.â
Well-earned indeed. The war is over and won, but what did their victory cost? Finnick, little Primrose, and hundreds more Haymitch tells himself not to think of yet.Â
Plutarch assures Haymitch on the day before Katniss is discharged from the hospital that theyâll be memorialized in some way for their contributions to the war efforts. As will the tributes taken by the Games. âIâm only brainstorming now, but itâs worth keeping in mind.âÂ
Haymitch, fuming silently, refrains from telling Plutarch exactly what he thought of that idea. He canât talk about it with Katniss fast asleep, doped up on morphling, and Asterid in the room, lingering in the corner like a ghost herself. Â
Itâs only after Plutarch leaves that Asterid moves to the foot of the bed. Haymitch waits for the room to stop spinning to say, âIâm sorry, Asterid. About Primrose, andâŠâ He draws a breath when she flinches and averts her gaze. âIâm sorry.âÂ
Asterid presses her lips together. Minutes of listening to the beeping machines and dripping saline bags passed before she speaks. âMedicine can treat most anything, but it canât fix how losing them will change you.â She shuts her eyes, and when she opens them again, she looks at Haymitch. Burdockâs death changed her differently but no less severely than yours changed Haymitch. And with the loss of her little one⊠Haymitch suspects her eyes will always be hollowed out. âWe all knew what we saw wasnât the whole story, anyway. And it couldnât have been a coincidence your house caught on fire when it did.â
There is no mistaking her grace, like that of Burdockâs, for anything less than forgiveness.Â
Asterid stares at Katniss, and eventually Haymitch turns his focus back on her, too. Sheâs still fast asleep when Asterid whispers, âYouâll take care of her?âÂ
âAs best I can,â he promises. She doesnât need to ask it of Haymitch for him to do all he can for Katniss.
Haymitch splits his coming days between visiting Peeta in the hospital and chasing Katniss around the presidential mansion, making sure theyâre both fed and medicated. And when his shift with either kid ends, Haymitch is free. Free, and unsure of what to do with it besides what he always has: drinking his own weight, cycling through his worst memories, and searching for his love.Â
Heâll never make peace with you, he fears one especially bad night when he dreams of the terrors that mustâve passed in his assigned room. Missing you is all Haymitch seems to know, and it gets worse, not better, in these early days of a new Panem youâll never get to see. None of his dead will, their resting places blown to bits. Maybe thatâs why the nightmares have come back and the ghosts havenât. They said their goodbyes back in Thirteenâs eggshell hospital room, and the new ones have skipped over their need for vengeance. But youâŠÂ
Is this all heâs good for, he wonders while sitting in the mess he canât remember making. He canât even pinpoint what pushed him to take his fists to the room besides the instinct to destroy anything he touches and the explosive need to put his emotions somewhere.Â
It doesnât work because it never has. Peel back the bandaid and the wound is still there. The longing, the shame, the self-loathing is sitting right on his chest. It just might be all heâs good for.Â
Haymitchâs pity party takes him away from his responsibilities, and Katniss comes to remind him he still has a purpose in this new, free world.Â
Things are better but frail between them, and when the dust settles, heâll have to answer for it. Half aware of the strain, half trapped in the nightmare she woke him from, Haymitch lets a cruel joke slip and watches her face crumble in a way it so rarely does because of something he said. He stumbles up and down every corridor, but he doesnât find Katniss until a couple hours have passed. By then, sheâs sealed her voice to him again.Â
The apple doesnât fall far at all; it just keeps hitting Haymitch over the fucking head.Â
But in the days that follow Coinâs death, with Katniss in solitary confinement, his concern for her and Peeta becomes its own living, breathing entity. Coexisting with his grief for you, instead of taking its place.Â
They donât allow Haymitch to speak to Katniss, or even see her, during the weeks of her trial in which he is a witness in her defense. Newly appointed President Paylor finds exile the most fitting for the deranged yet harmless mockingjay. She didnât seem all that convinced by the opposing argument. Haymitch figures she wasnât keen on what Coin was selling either.Â
Asteridâs letter burns a hole in his right pocket, the envelope jingling with more than paper as he walks the halls of the Training Center. Haymitch already said his goodbyes to Peeta, who he knows will return to Twelve as soon as heâs cleared, and Effie, who he doubts heâll ever see again. Keeping her alive was difficult, and Plutarch had to help him convince Coin she wasnât a threat.Â
For all her ignorance, Effie never has been the worst of them. Haymitch hates that months of captivity are what finally opened her eyes to the Capitolâs evil and the pillar she maintained under it. She seemed to have some color back to her when he told her he and Katniss were leaving this morning.Â
âI donât have to tell you to watch over her,â said Effie, her voice losing its chipperness, âbut donât forget to take care of yourself.â
He would, and he already has. But he still nodded and said, âThank you, Effie.âÂ
Standing outside Katnissâs door now, Haymitch takes a sip from his flask. More out of habit than necessity. The liquorâs effect has been slow as of late. He might as well be stone-cold sober as the guards let him inside to where Katniss is curled on her bed, quietly singing a tune he hasnât heard since nights spent star-gazing.Â
And there's no past, and there's no future, only now
And we have chanced upon this fragile scene somehow.
Haymitch shoves the flask into his left pocket and approaches her bed. If he had any to give, or thought itâd serve her, heâd offer words of comfort. Instead, he tells her the information she needs. âYour trialâs over.â She can barely lift her head to acknowledge him. He squeezes her elbow softly. And even though they donât have much of one anymore, he says, âCome on. Weâre going home.âÂ
While a team of medics and nurses file in to help bathe and feed her, Haymitch is escorted to the roof of the Training Center. There, Plutarch waits with a hovercraft at his disposal. Heâs taken to this new world with no reserve or difficulty, like a leaf in the wind. Who knows where itâll take him next? Good thing Haymitch wonât be around to find out. Heâs officially been discharged of all his rebel duties. Plutarch assured him he and Beetee had a handle on things for now. But Beetee has his own bridges to mend, with himself most of all.
Never one to let things be, Plutarch talks the entire waiting period on the hovercraft. âFor what itâs worth,â he chimes, taking the seat next to Haymitch, âyour better half wouldâve been proud of you.âÂ
Haymitch has never cared for Plutarchâs opinions on you before, and he doesnât now. He doesnât need them either to know that whether youâd be proud of him or not, he did this for every person who isnât here and those that still are. Finally, finally, after all his failures, he managed to get one thing right. And the success belongs to Katniss more than it does to him. Youâre proud of her, of that heâs certain.Â
Plutarch buckles his seatbelt. âAnd I think sheâll make a great special feature on Never Forgotten.âÂ
Haymitch glares at him blankly. âIâd workshop the title.âÂ
Plutarch grins. An attendant carries Katniss in and fastens her into the seat across from them. Haymitch tunes out Plutarchâs musings on war and the fickle memory of humanity. He doesnât say much until long after Plutarch is deposited in Three and Katniss directs her new questions to him.Â
He answers every one of them with the delivery of Asteridâs letter. Katniss holds the envelope in both hands, running her fingers over the handwriting, pinching the bump in one of the corners. She only sets it down when Haymitch forces her to eat something, and he sees her pick it back up again on his way out of the compartment.Â
When they touch down on the unblemished grass of Victorâs Village, he makes sure Katniss is safe and soundâsafe, at the very leastâinside her house. Haymitch contemplates staying, but the bottles in his bag are calling to him, and by the empty glower she sends his way, he reckons she needs the space as much as he does.Â
So he gives her plenty for the rest of winter. The frost begins to dissipate, the snow long since having melted. So much for landing on top.Â
Haymitch visits at night, when Sae is washing the dishes and Katniss is fast asleep in her room. Sae tells him how sheâs doing, but thereâs never any change to her updates. Katniss wakes and eats and wastes away in the same rocking chair until itâs time to sleep.Â
âYou should talk to the girl,â Sae tells Haymitch about three weeks into his new, recycled routine.Â
He should, and he will, but he doesnât want to right now, too scared to see her for himself. Scared to find your reflection in her broken spirit. If Haymitch talks to Katniss, itâll force him back into that eggshell room with no choice but to confront his own damage and make something worthwhile of his new circumstances.Â
They continue on their separate and passive paths, more than happy to do so, until Peeta shows up out of the corner of his eye, a moving blur through his kitchen window. Convinced heâs making up the sight, Haymitch scrambles to his feet and towards the front door.Â
Daylight blinds Haymitch for a moment, and he rubs his eyes to clear the blur in them. Peetaâs still there when he gets his vision back. He breathes in. His boy is right here, blinking right back at him. âWhen did you get here?âÂ
âThis morning,â answers Peeta, out of breath. What he couldâve been doing to make him that fatiguedâ
Haymitch notices the wheelbarrow in his hands, full of primrose bushes. His throat clogs up. âWell,â he sniffs, âgood to see you, kid.âÂ
Peeta offers a smile, as gentle as Haymitch remembers it to be even if it doesnât shine as bright as it used to, and turns down the pathway to Katnissâs house. Haymitch spends the rest of the day holed up inside his own as usual, but come sunset, he takes a walk to check on the kids.Â
Slowly, with the return of spring, Haymitch sees a light come back to Katniss. As he begins to join her and Peeta for the occasional breakfast or dinner, he feels it infecting him too. He starts to look both of them in the eye without flinching or searching for ghosts. Since the liquorâs mostly lost its powers of anesthesia and Twelveâs ration only comes once a month by train, thereâs no point in hoarding it. No point in messing up his house again either.Â
He slips up as always. Sometimes itâs because the memories of your death and everyone elseâs wonât stop tormenting him. Others because itâs the only thing he can count on. Once because he decides to take a walk through the groundwork of a new District Twelve and stumbles upon the ruins of where the old Donnerâs sweetshop stood.Â
After that, Haymitch spends more time with Katniss and Peeta, learns to nurse his drinks, leaves his house while itâs light out.Â
He catches glimpses of the book theyâre working on in passing, pictures or sketches of people he knew. He never lingers, and he never acknowledges the book. Sometimes Haymitch thinks they leave it out when they know heâs coming on purpose, to remind him that forgetting is the real betrayal. Doesnât matter how true it is, or how different their intentions are from PlutarchâsâHaymitch has no interest in contributing to their project.Â
But then he sees them working on Burdockâs page, the sketch of his smile so accurate, so reminiscent of the moment Burdock declared them friends, Haymitch canât help himself. âWe used to go skinny dipping, you know.âÂ
Nothing comes quite as amusing as the reactive disgust on Katnissâs face.Â
From there, everything spills out. Burdock taking Haymitch through the woods, days spent throwing knives and picking apples, the love he showed Haymitch even when he least deserved it. Talking about Burdock leads Haymitch to Lenore Dove, how she loved her tune box and geese, and about their Covey roots.Â
The more Haymitch reveals, the less it costs to say their names out loud. He describes Sid and his starry eyes, and his ma with her initials written in the sky, for Peeta to draw. They arenât exact replicas, but theyâre pretty damn close. Theyâre memorialized side by side, as they were in life.
Each day that goes by is dedicated to one of his losses, those he loved and others he never had the chance to. He shares the names of every one of his kids over the first twenty-three years before Katniss and Peeta. Then the names of his allies, and bits of the reality of his Games. To tell it how it happened reminds Haymitch that none of it was in vein. However long it took, the Hunger Games are dead and buried, and the Capitol with it.Â
During Maysileeâs entry, he talks about her necklaces and how she loathed that mockingjay pin, but oh how she wouldâve loved the poster it turned into. Her page comes between Merrileeâs and Madgeâs.Â
Somewhere down the line, the memories heâs been carrying on his own become something beyond a burden. Itâs strange to think of his loved ones and not have their deaths be the first image that comes to mind. Strange but welcome. And by putting all their good somewhere safe and permanent, Haymitch feels them come alive again.Â
The only person he canât bring himself to share is you. Not fully and not yet, but you come up in snippets. He canât avoid you when he tells them about Burdock bringing him the bracelet. Or when he mentions your role in tending to the geese, or you and Maysilee singing about ladybugs.Â
They never ask for more details, and Haymitch is surprised Katniss doesnât push on the matter. In the absence of your page, they find other things to contribute: a dried primrose here, a photo of Finnick and Annieâs son there.Â
By the time a second winter has passed, the book is filled with hopes of the future as much as recollections of the past. More people return after they break ground on a factory for medicine, including Louellaâs family, and the meadow begins to bloom again.Â
Itâs there, in the fresh grass concealing the graveyard beneath it, that Haymitch runs into Clerk Carmine one afternoon.Â
The geese Katniss gifted him have barely hatched, and they enjoy the meadow more than his backyard most times. They honk when Clerk Carmine nears, and if Haymitch werenât caught up in wishing he had a bottle on hand, he might laugh at the irony.Â
Last heâd seen of Clerk Carmine was during Finnick and Annieâs wedding. Lively and downright spirited in a way Haymitch never thought possible. How he managed to keep his fiddle on him was a mystery Haymitch didnât care to solve. He stuck to the edges of the room, out of his sight, and cared more about how he was going to pull Katniss away from dancing to tell her about Peetaâs progress at the time.Â
There are no corners or walls to stick to now. Clerk Carmine stops right in front of Haymitch, wordlessly motioning to the treeline of the woods, now fence-free. Grown as Haymitch now is, Clerk Carmine elicits the same brutal instincts he developed at sixteen. A dozen cruel, petty words come to mind, partially from a need to send Clerk Carmine away and mostly from the desire to inflame his hatred of Haymitch. He doesnât say any of them. Theyâre pointless now, and Haymitchâs feet have already decided to walk after him.Â
Though itâs been decades since he walked this exact path, his bones know where heâs heading. For years, Haymitch tried to retrace his steps, mimic the trail, and find where it ended. He never did, forgetting turns and markings with each failed attempt. Always retreating with his own vicious reminders of your damnation. Haymitch doesnât hear them now, neither from your voice nor his. Only birdsong and wind chimes by the time they reach the clearing of graves.Â
Haymitch counts the seven headstones, spread across two rows and half filled with the names of those etched upon his heart, and sinks to his knees before yours. They let out a crackling sound in protest, but the dirt softens the stiffness of his joints. Thereâs no soothing balm for the ache spreading inside his body, credited to loss, not age or liver failure.Â
Tears prick behind his eyes, and his lungs constrict with the lack of air, but Haymitch manages to read the words carved on the limestone.Â
Where the Youth pined away with desire,
And the pale Virgin shrouded in snow:Â
Arise from their graves and aspire,Â
Where my Sun-flower wishes to go.
Sensing Clerk Carmine take a step beside him, Haymitch croaks, âWhyâd you bring me here?â Heâs done nothing to Clerk Carmine to earn his sympathy, and heâs never cared for it anyway. So why would he extend this kindness now? Out of the goodness of a heart completely closed off to Haymitch? Thatâs unlikely.Â
âI have a couple of years left in me, but itâs any day now.â Clerk Carmine lets a beat pass. âIâm ready to be with my people again. Wouldnât be right to leave without settling things.âÂ
âWhat for?â Haymitch scoffs, finally turning to him. Clerk Carmine keeps his gaze on the graves before them. Flitting from the very first behind yours, which tells of a girl named Lucy Gray, all the way to Burdockâs honorary slab. âYou were right not to trust me.âÂ
âMaybe at the time,â Clerk Carmine says, head dropping slightly, âbut you were just a boy then. YouâŠwerenât to blame.â He lifts his head, allowing Haymitch to see the guilt written in the weary set of his eyes. âI knew my niece, and I knew her heart. She chose to give it to you for good reason.â
For good reason. Gravitating towards the words meant to immortalize your spirit, Haymitch lets the shame wash over him in waves, and when it calms inside him, heâs no more ready to listen to Clerk Carmine than he was to Burdock in his withdrawal-induced hallucinations.Â
âI never thought Iâd live to be free again,â says Clerk Carmine abruptly and begrudgingly at the same time. âSuppose I have you to thank for that.â
âBurdockâs girl did all the work,â deflects Haymitch.Â
He doesnât turn to see if Clerk Carmineâs leaving, but he picks up on the shuffling of his steps and the pensive hum. âShe wasnât alone,â he sighs so lowly, Haymitch can hardly hear him. His footsteps dwindle, offering a final kindness of privacy.
The sun dips below the trees and looms directly above your headstone, brightening the hint of blue. Haymitchâs knotted lungs constrict until his breath comes out in a choked laugh. âHear that, sunshine? I finally won over Clerk Carmine.âÂ
He stares at the flowers growing from your grave and thinks about all the nights heâs spent wanting to be with you, buried in the same earth. Resenting the life you gave him. âI wish it hadnât taken so long, me getting here.â No talking birds deliver your voice to him, or give him the answer he wants to hear from you. Those surrounding the clearing flit from branch to branch, free as can be. âAnd now that I have, I know I canât stay. I got kids to take care ofâyouâd love âem, headaches that they are.âÂ
His eyes begin to blur. Thereâs dozens of things he wants to, and should, say to you now that youâre as close to face-to-face as you can get. About Katniss and Peeta, about Snowâs demise, about Twelveâs reconstruction. Apologies, pleas, offerings. Most of them heâs said already, running that tune ragged.Â
Haymitch glances at Lenore Doveâs grave, then at the evergreen leaves sprouting from Burdockâs. The plot of primroses are fresher, newly sowed and barely coming into themselves, unlike those Peeta planted about a year ago. Theyâre everywhere now, carrying the memory of the little one who took on their name as her own. Sheâs who Haymitch thinks of now when he looks at them. Not the shattered glass and your poisoned blood. Not the death of the little girl he hardly knew except for her sweet soul. But the one whose spirit lives on, as her pa would have Haymitch believe, seeing the world through her brilliant sisterâs eyes.Â
And why shouldnât he believe it? Haymitch can almost hear Burdock asking him. He can almost feel you wondering the same. You were always tangled by your roots, as much of Haymitch as he was of you.Â
âIâm gonna make good on this new life for us,â he swears, running his pinkie over the words on your headstone.Â
Haymitch thinks you believe him, because when he dreams late at night, he finds you in your meadow, dandelions and wildflowers twinkling under the sun. Your face is still obscured from where he stands, but as you recite your dear poem beginning to end, whateverâs left of his rotten heart unfurls. Â
Itâs still partially dark out when he wakes the kids. Neither of them are pleased, and Peetaâs torture in the Capitol has chipped away at his tolerance some. They both snap at Haymitch, only retracting their hostility when he clues them in to his request and motions to the counter where their book has made a home.Â
He sets down the bracelet and a bottle. Katniss and Peeta exchange wary looks, their silence a question for him to answer. Haymitch has been doing his best to make his supply last as of late, and he never drinks when they work on the book.Â
âI just need the option,â is what he tells them before sitting at the kitchen table. He needs the drink more like it, but they deserve his memories at their sharpest. So do you.
They follow slowly. Katniss opens the book in front of her, pencil in hand. Peeta lays out his sketching tools.Â
Tapping the cap of the bottle, Haymitch lifts his gaze to Katniss. âWhat do you want to know first?âÂ
âI donâtâŠâ Her eyes migrate from him to the bracelet to the bottle. When they meet his again, recognition cracks her expression. âShe liked maple leaves, right?âÂ
Haymitch feels a smile tugging at him, and he leans back from the bottle.Â
With no shortage of stories, he makes sure they know who you are. Your affinity for tree climbing and rock collecting and maple creams from the sweetshop. The day you showed your hate for him, and the morning you showed up with three hot pepper cherry taffy pieces for his mamawâs funeral. Even the time his pa made you laugh.
Happy memories weave themselves in with the bad. That scrawny, hideous cat of yours. All the riddles and nonsense youâd sprout about your beliefs, which he never fully understood then. How deeply you loved your people. How restless you were, and self-righteous, and stubborn. What a gift it was to be yours. Even in the wreckage left behind by your absence, Haymitch wouldnât give that up.Â
He tells them that. He shares every bit of you, because itâs all worth remembering.Â
And Haymitch gets through it without a lick of alcohol, but after he finishes detailing your last poster together in the arena, your last words, he grabs the bottle and mutters his goodbyes. Heâs not two steps down the porch when he senses Katniss hot on his heel.Â
âWhy are you trailing after me?â he snaps, spinning around and expecting her to snark back. If she thinks heâll accept her pityâ
Katniss wraps her arms around him tightly. The urge to snipe and scold her is stopped short. Hesitantly, Haymitch returns her embrace.Â
âThanks,â Katniss murmurs earnestly.Â
Haymitch clamps his eyes shut, feeling the sting behind them. He waits until it passes and lets go of Katniss with a sigh. âSee you at dinner, sweetheart.âÂ
Like the others, it becomes easier to talk about you, even with your entry in their book completed. Little things and details crop up. Moments Haymitch canât help but want to reminisce on.Â
That yearâs spring passes by like a breeze, and come summer, on what wouldâve been the 77th Hunger Games but is now Haymitchâs birthday, he wakes at peace.Â
Though they agreed not to fill the day with fanfare or gifts of any kind, the kids never do listen fully. Peeta bakes a wildberry pie for breakfast, tasting like the jam his ma would make. By the third bite, his hands stop shaking.
Halfway through his slice and his drink, Haymitch watches Katniss slide over a neatly folded napkin. He glares at her but unfolds it gently. Nestled in the center lies your bluebird, vibrant and polished. He hasnât thought of it since he saw it around Primroseâs neck in Thirteen, which feels negligent on his part. Itâs not attached to any cord now, and his mind lands on the envelope Asterid trusted him to pass along.Â
âShe gave it to you,â says Katniss, anticipating the questions about to fall out of his mouth. âYouâll have more use for it than I do.âÂ
The memory of you in the arena, of Ampertâs trembling hands passing over this very charm, comes and goes in the blink of an eye. Whatever lump beginning to form in his throat is shoved back down by the wandering cat under the table who bumps into his ankle, looking for scraps and bringing him back to reality. Haymitch swallows, gives her a short nod of thanks, and finishes his pie.Â
Less than a week passes when he decides to repay Katniss. High time a proper introduction was made anyway.
Haymitch hasnât returned since the day Clerk Carmine brought him, but it doesnât take him long to recall the way. There, carrying enough willow tree branches for each grave, he bypasses the honor to Katniss.Â
She doesnât divide them immediately, stopping right in front of Burdockâs empty grave first, her shoulders rising and falling with the telltale sign of an impending sob. Haymitch reaches out, ready to catch her, but Katniss steadies herself on her own and lays her paâs willow branch.Â
Your grave is saved for last. Katniss crouches down and reads the lines in a whisper, lower than she did with the others. She presses her three middle fingers to her lips, and Haymitch waits for her to lift them. Instead, she places her fingers atop your headstone.Â
He looks away while Katniss says goodbye to Burdock again. She returns to his side seconds later. âIâll meet you back home.âÂ
Understanding each other to a degree above frightening sometimes, Haymitch appreciates the privacy as heâs sure Katniss appreciates her time alone.Â
Once heâs sure Katniss has left, he kneels before you and digs for the bluebird in his jacket. The most precious thing you owned, weighed and measured in the palm of his hands. Youâve been without it for so long, and in returning it to where it belongs, in showing you he finally understands your wish for him, maybe youâll recognize Haymitchâs own wishes for you.Â
He begins to scoop out a small plot of dirt right beside your headstone. He stops, fingers twitching, when an old warmth runs up his arms. One he hasnât felt in ages but has never fully shed. Itâs been lying in wait, nestled beneath his ribcage, alongside the distinct melody of your voice.
âYou best not be giving that back, peach.âÂ
Haymitch takes deep, slow breaths. His heart thumps at the base of his throat, but he doesnât taste bile or tears. By sheer force alone, he manages to say, âWouldnât want you going without the full set, sunshine.â He keeps watch of your headstone as pieces of it glint under the afternoon light. âBesides,â he continues tightly, âI got your gift.âÂ
âYou liked it then?âÂ
The teasing edge to your question undoes the tension inside him. Haymitch glances down at the charm and picks apart the hazy image of sitting under that oak tree in the schoolyard. He snickers a little. âYou were never subtle at all, were you?âÂ
âYou werenât exactly a needle in a haystack.â You scoff, but he can hear the smugness in your tone and imagines the grin plastered on your face. Haymitch wants to see it. He wants to see you in all your ghostly brilliance and know that you are free. That youâve found peace in your world where birds talk and lost souls are found.Â
Without wasting a second to fear or cower, Haymitch turns his head.Â
The passage of years in your eyes strikes him. Unlike your youthful ghost, you hold his gaze without anger or shared resentment. Without pressing Haymitch for more, without exacting any vengeance. But your gaze is as raw and all-consuming as before. Forever the brightest sight heâs beheld. He thinks of the time youâve lost and the future youâve lived out together, even worlds apart. A future Haymitch has taken for grantedâone he might not have for much longer, if the recent pain in his abdomen has anything to say about it, and only does in the first place because of you.Â
All that comes out of his mouth is a murmured âWhy?âÂ
You smile, even as your eyes glisten. Haymitch feels his own welling up. He knows your answer, has known it all along, hidden as youâve both kept it. Even so, his aching chest calms as you say, âI love you, Haymitch.â You lift a shoulder, shrugging off any other reason as secondary, as unimportant as the simple truth of your unabashed heart reserved for him. No walls could keep him out now, and they never really could, he realizes. âI was never going to choose not to save you.âÂ
Salt settles on his tongue. Haymitch takes a shuddered breath, the warmth bubbling inside him to a near boiling point, leaving him utterly helpless to blurt out in equal measure, âI love you.âÂ
The wind passes between you, carrying a weight off his shoulders. Haymitch wouldâve died for you too, had the roles been reversed. He wouldâve taken that poison in a heartbeat, and he canât blame you for beating him to the punch. He canât keep hating himself for what he failed to achieve at sixteen. The only ones to blame have paid for the lives theyâve cost with their own. Theyâre gone, and Panem is free, and for the first time since, Haymitch feels he could try to be too.Â
You tilt your head, beaming, and motion to the spot between his brows. âYouâve been worrying a lot.â
âItâs those damn kids,â he sighs, heavy yet lighter than heâs ever felt in his adult life.Â
âLet them fret over you every now and then,â you say, gentle as the tears streaking your face. Â
Closing his eyes, indulging one last time in the phantom sensation of your forehead pressed against his, Haymitch wipes his face and nods. They already do, downright irritating in how they stick to him. But heâs their family, same as they are his, and they mean well. And it isnât hard to catch onto what you really mean.Â
Your gift to Haymitch is the time he has left to live with and love them. Heâll visit, and heâll see you again, and on the days until then, youâll be with him. You always have been. If a piece of him was taken with you to your grave, then a piece of you is still this side of earth. Steady and true, like the rising sun. Itâll be there tomorrow, in this world and the next.Â
The nightmares will still come, too, because there is no cure for them. Haymitch will go on fearing and grieving and drinking because the scar isnât one that goes away, only fades. And habits are hard to discard when theyâve been drummed into your bones. As impossible as forgetting, but Haymitch has no need to anymore. He accepts his losses and his wounds because he believes that death is not the end. His lost loves are everywhere, in everything he does and sees before he meets them in the hereafter.
So, when Haymitch looks up again to find no more than the rustling branches and dimming light of day, he doesnât keel over. He patches up the unfinished hole in the ground, and carrying your love, he follows the sun home.Â
A/N: thatâs a wrap? đ part of this chapter taking so long to come out was my dissatisfaction with it, which i still feel some of. i realize iâll always be a little dissatisfied by it because i simply donât want it to be over. genuinely, thank you so very much for all the kindness and support youâve sent me over this series. it means the world to know yâall care about it as dearly as i do.
thereâs still an epilogue to come! and much more content about sunshine and haymitch! but weâve officially said goodbye to itsdr and here are some parting tweets to cope with my sorrow
I teared at where Haymitch saw Baby Katniss in Sunshines old clothes and sobbed at where Haymitch realized he actually wanted children of his own, and possibly have them with Sunshine. The little part of him looking through poems for babynames was what fully broke me.
(Also love how it also shows that Burdock and Sunshine are two side of the same coin. They both would have followed their family traditions in naming their children, only that Burdock named his following the Everdeen family, and Sunshine would have following the Covey traditions.)
i knew i wanted to weave in some kind of interaction with baby katniss, and as soon as i got into the minefield of older haymitchâs depressive brain, it just came up as a natural longing for his stolen future. also, haymitch thinks of having had children with sunshine in another life as a possibility, but the detail of him searching for baby names in poetry shows how he only ever saw sunshine as the person he wouldâve had that future with đ
(and how he knows she wouldâve wanted to name them the covey way, and so would heâher culture is as important to him as it is to her!)
iâm so glad you picked up on that detail! haymitch and sunshine mayâve been each otherâs âbetter halvesâ but she and burdock are made up of the same soul. aside their mindsets being complimentary, they were both raised with a strong sense of their identities/culture. it emphasizes their shared understanding of maintaining their culture, and it also reflects which sides of their identities they connect with more.
I donât want it to be over đđđ anyways your writing is probably the best thing that happened to me this year
neither do i đđ itâs the first series iâve actually seen through and finished, and that makes me all the more nervous about actually finishing it lol
and thank you!! thatâs one of the sweetest compliments ever đ„șđ«¶
on top of the entire song describing ch19 to a t, the opening lyrics also makes me think of haymitchâs pov during her death scene. âsing me to sleepâŠi want to go to bedâ = âhis brilliant, dazzling sunâŠsinging him homeâ
also, the verse on longing for a better world so poignantly fits haymitchâs recurring thoughts on the hereafter and his wishes to be there with sunshine and his family. and ofc sunshineâs similar wishes to be in a better world with him in ch17
âMaggots for brainsâ is haymitch after sunshine died.
heâs like nothing without her n like I imagine everytime he got real drunk he would hallucinate her
the song is insanely accurate for him!! heâs a husk of a person, just like her husk of a ghost :(
like i mentioned in another ask, sunshineâs ghost in the first years after her death is a mix of haymitch hallucinating and her actual ghost. and i think he knows, even though he always describes her as a ghost, when itâs just in his head. even so, what other option does he have but chasing bottle after bottle to try and see her?