Til It Happens to You// Puckleberry
Puck thought for one quiet, shallow moment that the tension would begin to dissipate with Rachel’s choked laugh, but as soon as he’d begun to relax into the odd circumstances, Rachel pulled away, stony and independent once more.
Thinking back on it, Puck could definitely see what Jesse saw in Rachel, that strong structure, the large heart she had, as the girl cried for her recently deceased friends. Admittedly, Puck was underreacting, if he thought about it honestly. His best friend of many years was now dead, her child left in the care of someone as incompetent as himself and his other dead best friends’ self-centered BFF. If it wasn’t happening to him, he was sure that he would find a large amount of irony in the situation.
“A little insane, yeah,” he murmured, rubbing a large palm over the heated skin of the back of his neck, his mohawk just a little longer than usual. Puck leaned back against one of the far walls. “I dunno, San doesn’t really think anything through–” he started, watching Rachel’s back as she paced, “–but it’s hard to imagine that Q didn’t but no thought in this.” Puck grimaced at his misuse of grammar, hoping that Berry wouldn’t catch it in her hysterics. He had sincerely begun to try and fix his horrible Lima accent and terrifyingly inaccurate grammar since they’d left Ohio, people only judging him more when he couldn’t speak professionally within the force. Puck was a trained fire-fighter for God’s sake, he should know how to avoid saying “ain’t” all of the time.
Trying not to overthink all of his actions, he punched out a quick, “Would’ya stop walkin’ around so much? Y’er makin’ me sea-sick.” The nausea wasn’t coming from Rachel’s pacing, he argued against himself, but Puck wasn’t willing to admit that he was starting to feel a little gross from the whole situation in general. The crescents on his arms burned.
“She doesn’t have anybody if we don’t do somethin’ for her, and I ain’t lettin’ my baby girl go into the hands of Judy. She’s a nice lady, really– even kind of hot if you put a bag over her head – but she really messed up Q, and I’m not lettin’ that happen to Sof.” Puck slowly took a few steps toward Rachel, genuinely feeling a bit weird at trying to comfort her, and laid a hand on her shoulder. “We’re what she’s got, and we’re gonna have to do, even if we don’t get along.”
Scrunching his nose, Puck tried to swallow down another bout of nausea. He was not ready to be a parent, not even a pretend one, he thought. And Berry? Yeah, she was hot, Puck had always known that, but she was Rachel Goddamn Berry, the most annoying woman he had ever met, and she knew every possible way to get under his skin. Where would they stay? “This is so fucked up,” he muttered, pulling away from Rachel again, palm sliding down over his face.
“Any thought into this.” The tiny brunette mumbled under her breath as she made her way into the guest bedroom. What was wrong with her? She couldn’t cut him some slack just this once? Rachel quickly reached into her hand into the tiny room to grab a tissue sitting on the sink, barely looking to see where she was reaching in hopes that her muscle memory would take it from there. There was no need to risk being sent into another another meltdown from the sight of Quinn’s favorite hand soap. “But you’re right. It’s just that they know how we are together, and they still thought this was a good idea?” She was talking to herself now, mostly just for the sake of doing anything other than sobbing.
Rachel had returned to wearing away at the carpets with her brisk pacing when she heard Puck’s snappy request and froze immediately. Under different circumstances she would’ve continued doing what she was doing, even more so just for good measure. But this was different. He was doing the strange kind of coping, and Rachel was worried that he could snap at any moment. And yet, he was still trying to comfort her. She couldn’t help but place her hand on top of his. “I agree. And she’s been drinking more and more... and who know’s what’ll happen now that...” She couldn’t say it. That meant that it was real. Rachel Berry would go her entire life without saying that Quinn and Santana died if that’s what it took to keep it from being real.
Instead of suggesting he watch the language she just nodded in agreement, worried eyes scanned his face before he slid his hand over it. Out of some strange instinct she never had before Rachel reached out and placed her tiny hand on the back of his head in an attempt to comfort him, moving her thumb back and forth against his hair slowly. “Noah, are you...” She was about to ask if he was okay. That was moronic. Of course he wasn’t okay. Thankfully, a knock on the door interrupted Rachel’s shaky words, giving her an excuse to break contact again. “Rachel... Puck. Everyone’s still here.” Kurt paused, waiting to see which one would have another outburst first no doubt. “I’m so sorry. They just need to go over the will then they’re gone. I promise.”











