On âContact Clan Lavellanâ, and Deshannaâs Letter
Clan Lavellan offers greetings to the Inquisition and wishes it well in sealing the Breach that has opened in the sky. While some Dalish clans hate humans and wish nothing to do with them, Clan Lavellan has always dealt fairly with all and wished only for peace. That said, we have on occasion been forced to defend ourselves from those who saw us only as potential victims.
It has come to our attention that a member of our clan is being held captive by your Inquisition. She went to the Conclave only to observe the peace talks between your mages and templars, and we find it highly unlikely that she intentionally violated your customs. If she has been charged with a crime, we would appreciate hearing of it. If not, it would ease our concerns to hear from her to know that she remains with the Inquisition of her own will.
We await your reply,
Keeper Istimaethorial Lavellan
So like, off the top: I donât buy this as a polite, friendly letter of inquiry at all.Â
To me, this reads like it was very carefully crafted to send a very specific message. Deshannaâs being polite only on a surface level, to be diplomatic and try and achieve a desired outcome, but sheâs not fucking around, and this letterâs full of politician-style double talk (and perhaps thinly veiled threats) thatâd give even Josephine Montilyet pause. This is the type of letter Iâd expect to be sent by Trevelyanâs family of nobility, if Trevelyanâs family couldâve been arsed to inquire about their well-being instead of scrambling for a little slice of that sweet Herald of Andraste spotlight like a bunch of parasites.
First, compare this to the letters sent to Adaar and Cadash by their close associates. Both Adaar and Cadashâs letters are addressed directly to the individuals in question. Meanwhile Lavellanâs letter - even though itâs clear Deshanna wants it to reach Lavellan, directly, just like Adaarâs and Cadashâs - is instead addressed to the Inquisition, to the people in charge, which indicates to me a certain level of mistrust. Deshanna doesnât seem to think, if she addressed her letter directly to Lavellan, that the Inquisition would actually deliver it to her. I mean, literally:
It has come to our attention that a member of our clan is being held captive by your Inquisition.
Deshanna wrote this letter under the premise that Lavellan is being held prisoner. Neither the Valo-Kas nor Lantos seem to assume the same in their respective letters to Adaar or Cadash. In short, while Clan Lavellan may trade with and attempt friendly relations with humans, they donât really trust them any more than any other Dalish clan would.  Deshanna is doing exactly what any Keeper would likely do in this situation. However, sheâs doing so in a very carefully diplomatic fashion, instead of sending her people in making demands and pointing weapons (like, you know, Clan Borahnen did in Knight Errant. Which got them killed).Â
This seems to me to be what the text really means when it says that Clan Lavellan ârespects and deals fairly with humansâ. And to me, I feel like thatâs Deshanna influence, because she makes references later to the fact that itâd be too easy for the hunters to argue with the humans if the clan joined the Inquisition, and anyway if you approach them with soldiers, they immediately think youâre attacking them and bloodshed assumes. So I take this to mean that itâs Deshanna whoâs the politician, the diplomat, and the rest of her clan has mixed feelings about it/isnât used to this but sheâs trying to guide them in what she sees as the right direction.
(which leads to me spinning Deshannaâs backstory as an outsider who took on the role of the clanâs keeper at Fenesvirâs insistence, but more on that another time)
Back to the first paragraph:
Clan Lavellan offers greetings to the Inquisition and wishes it well in sealing the Breach that has opened in the sky. While some Dalish clans hate humans and wish nothing to do with them, Clan Lavellan has always dealt fairly with all and wished only for peace. That said, we have on occasion been forced to defend ourselves from those who saw us only as potential victims.
If youâre being friendly and assuming the best, why include that last throwaway line at all? It seems only tangentially related to the rest of the letter. But Deshanna ends her opening paragraph with this, and then jumps straight into âwe noticed youâre holding our first/hunter prisoner!â
Which makes it seem, to me, that Deshanna is lowkey threatening the Inquisition.
Did I mention this woman has balls of steel? Because yeah.
This, to me, sets the tone of the rest of the letter as she goes on:
She went to the Conclave only to observe the peace talks between your mages and templars, and we find it highly unlikely that she intentionally violated your customs. If she has been charged with a crime, we would appreciate hearing of it.
Translation: Iâm making passing pretense at respecting your shemlen laws, because diplomacy, but I donât actually give a shit and I think youâre holding my First prisoner unjustly. Refer back to aforementioned thinly veiled threat.
If she has been charged with a crime, we would appreciate hearing of it. If not, it would ease our concerns to hear from her to know that she remains with the Inquisition of her own will.
Translation: Iâd appreciate it if you didnât try to bullshit me, so Iâm not going to believe any reassurances unless I get the letter directly from Lavellan. I wouldâve liked to just contact Lavellan directly in the first place, actually, but I didnât think you were going to give her the letter, so here I am politely listing my demands that you give me back my First or have her respond to this so I know sheâs ok.
tl;dr Deshanna will fuck you up, but sheâll fuck you up while smiling sweetly and pouring you a cup of warm tea. If youâre not nice back then sheâll probably, idk, get tired of your shit and shapeshift into something mean to eat you.