This is actually a horrifying gut wrenching take and I feel so distressed for the alters being referenced by anon. This is just. Blatantly untrue. I'm writing this as someone who has alters who exist to retraumatize us, who exist to harm the body, and who exist to be "malicious." I'm writing this as someone who has parts who were programmed to sabotage our recovery, to negatively interfere with our therapy, to punish us for breaking the abuser's rules, and more. And you know what? Every single one of those parts still can be healed through love and support. Every. Single. One. And actually, that's the only way for them to access healing. There's no other solution than love, compassion, support, patience, and understanding. No one is beyond help. No one "requires" imprisonment. Of COURSE there's no one size fits all, but responding to trauma with more trauma and more harm is never, ever, EVER the answer.
Like seriously, this is breaking my heart. It's very common for RAMCOA survivors to have alters who were intentionally created to serve the purposes of the abusers, and to harm the other members of the system. Those parts often seem very scary, extremely mean, very abusive, and impossible to work with. And you know what? They're traumatized children. They're. TRAUMATIZED. Children. Can you imagine saying to a child who's been through the absolute worst things imaginable that they're beyond the reach of love and support and that they deserve to be imprisoned? Children who were tortured and coerced to do things that no child would ever willingly choose to do? Children who took up those horrible, horrible, horrible roles IN ORDER TO SAVE THE LIFE OF THE REST OF THE SYSTEM?
HOW do you think these parts were created in the first place? The worst persecutors and abuser-imitating parts in survivors of extreme and organized abuse are typically the parts who endured the WORST traumas. The parts who stepped up and said "okay, I'll be the bad guy" because they knew they'd die if they didn't agree, and they knew no one else was saying yes. They're put in mind altering double binds where it's impossible for them to win, and they're tricked and lied to and told that now their entire identity is Evil and that they belong to Evil and to the abusers forever. And you want to respond to these parts--the true, real saviors of the system--by reinforcing the beliefs that were programmed into them by abusers? That they're irredeemable, that they're beyond saving, that they deserve punishment and scorn and hatred? That's what they've always been told. And you're pushing them deeper into those beliefs. This is horrendous. This is gut wrenching. This is the opposite direction of healing.
I'm not saying it's easy to work with these parts. I'm not saying there aren't times for cutting off their access to other areas of the system or other alters in order to keep everyone as safe as possible. I'm not saying it's easy to look at and accept the truth of these alters and what they've endured and how they came to be in the first place. But I'm begging, BEGGGING, you to understand that no one chooses to be this way. No one wants to be bad. Many of these parts had no say in the roles they ended up with, beyond knowing that if they resisted, they would be killed or tortured or worse (and yes, there's worse). ALL alters can choose to change. Even these ones. They just need time and unconditional positive regard and support. No one is beyond love's reach.
Please for the love of everything, remember that most of them are children, split in childhood in order to save the rest of you from things that the rest of you could not or would not endure. Even the ones who split later in life are performing a function that they often feel they have no other choice but to perform. We don't change people by ostracizing, demonizing, and punishing them. Remember who the real enemy is. REMEMBER WHO THE REAL ENEMY IS. It's not them. They're a part of you too. You're a part of them too. Even when they're continuing to serve the purposes of the abusers (and I know many of them are doing that! I experience that too!), remember that they're doing that because of being abused, tortured, manipulated, brainwashed, and coerced into compliance. Do they really deserve more harshness? They're trying to save you too, at the end of the day. I'm not saying there are no boundaries and you can't negotiate or set limits or communicate with them about the effects of their actions. And I'm not saying it's easy to cope with the horrendous things they do. But telling someone they're incapable of change and redemption is a guaranteed way to make sure they continue to enact harm.
Ellen Lacter wrote a wonderful article on working with abuser-imitating parts, which has been incredibly helpful in my own work. It has the potential to be extremely triggering, especially for RAMCOA survivors, so I encourage a good deal of caution with reading it. But if you've been stuck in this mindset of thinking that some parts are beyond redemption and are just pure evil, then consider reading it, perhaps alongside a safe support person. Or at least read this quote here to understand that I'm not making it up when I say that compassion has to be the first approach with all of these parts: "A position of compassion is the essential foundation and over-riding approach to helping 'abuser personalities' to begin to discover the truth of their own histories as self-states, to understand that they were also victims of their abusers, to be able to re-consider who they perceive themselves to be, and to be able to make their own choices about who they wish to be." Every single one of them has the ability to make their own choices about who they wish to be. They must first be given that chance.
Internal incarceration, punishment, us vs. them dichotomies, repeating cycles of harm in response to harm, and lack of positive regard will not save us. Remember who the real enemy is. They want to turn us against each other. That serves the abusers too. Compassion holds the cure.