Simplify
Summary : Bucky falls in love with his best friend's ex-girlfriend.
Pairing : Bucky Barnes x reader (she/her)Â
Warnings/tags : You're Sam's ex. Cursing, CA:BNW spoilers. Fluff!!!! Angst. Hurt/Comfort. Sexual references, sexual themes, and implied sex, though no overly graphic descriptions. Break-up grief.
Word count : 12.9k
Note : Whooo I definitely went overboard with this. Will respond to comments soon! Enjoy!
The first time you met Sam Wilson, you were in your early twenties, freshly heartbroken, and three shots deep in a hole-in-the-wall bar just outside D.C. He was a little bit older, maybe in his late twenties, cocky in a way that was still charming.
You had no idea who he was going to be back thenâ he told you he was a pararescueman, not a superhero in the making. To you, he was just a guy who slid into the seat next to yours and made you laugh so hard you forgot why you were upset in the first place. Â
âYou look like you just got stood up,â he had said to you that night.
You glanced up at him. âI wasnât,â you corrected, taking a sip of your drink. âJust⌠broken up with.â
âDamn, thatâs even worse,â he said, chuckling. âGuess you wouldnât mind some company, then?â
You shrugged. âDepends. You a creep?â
âNah,â he said, placing a hand over his heart. âIâm Sam. Air Force. And a gentleman, despite what my sister says.â
So you introduced yourself to him.
It started casual between you. Late-night texts, stolen weekends when he was not in a war zone. Sam wanted someone to fool around with in between deployments, and you had this fucked-up military fantasy that he fulfilled. You became friends with benefits, sharing nights in tangled sheets and lazy mornings where neither of you bothered to define whatever this was. You were young, reckless, and Sam had the kind of charm that made it easy to keep things short-sighted.
And then, one day, he stopped texting. Â
Not in a cruel way. Life just⌠happened. The deployments got longer, life got busier, and you had to move away to take a job. No hard feelings, it was just time pulling you both in different directions.  Â
â
Years later, after the whole Flag Smashers mess, Sam found you again. It was pure coincidenceâhe ran into you at a coffee shop in D.C., and the moment your eyes met, it was like no time had passed.
âYouâve gotta be kidding me,â Sam said, smiling as he approached your table.
You looked up, startled. âSam?â
âIn the flesh,â he said, arms outstretched like he was waiting for a hug. âWow, you look good.â
You laughed, standing up to hug him. âAnd you look... exactly the same.â
âI age like fine wine, sweetheart.â He pulled back, winking. âWhat are you even doing here?â
âLiving,â you teased. âI moved back a while ago. What about you? You flying around saving the world now, Cap?â
He rubbed the back of his neck, pretending to look modest. âSomething like that.â
That coffee turned into lunch, which turned into dinner, which turned into you waking up in his bed the next morning, except this time, things werenât just casual fun. Sam wanted more.
âYou know Iâm not just passing through this time, right?â he murmured against your bare shoulder, tracing patterns on your skin.
And before you knew it, you werenât just someone he called when he was in townâ you were his girlfriend.
â
A couple of months later, Sam took you by the hand and said, âOkay, you gotta meet my boy. Heâs a softie, youâre gonna love him.â
âWho, Joaquin?â you teased.
âNah, not Torres. My other best friend.â
That was how you found yourself sitting across from Bucky Barnes in a small cafe, nursing a cup of coffee while Sam rambled about something you werenât really paying attention to.Â
See, Bucky was exactly as advertised. Standoffish at first, eyes studying you like he was assessing a threat. But the thing about Bucky was that even if he didnât talk much, he listened. And once he realised you werenât just Samâs temporary fling, he started to warm up. Â
From that moment on, it was easy.
You and Bucky clicked in a way that surprised you both. He was quiet, but you could get him to laugh. You teased each other, shared inside jokes, andâmuch to Samâs delightâbecame friends faster than either of you expected.
âYou two are like⌠my proudest achievement,â Sam said one night, slinging an arm around both of you as you sat on the dock behind his house. âMy best friend and my girl? Getting along? Life is great.â
You leaned into Samâs side, content. You glanced at Bucky as Sam rambled on about how great this all was. And for a second, you let yourself admit itâ Bucky was handsome.
Not in the same way Sam was, not in the way that made you dizzy with laughter. No, Buckyâs was different. It was something you would neverâneverâact on.
Right?
Over time, Bucky watched you and Sam together, and saw the way Sam beamed every time you saw each other. He could see how much you cared about each other.
But Bucky also saw the cracks.
The way your smile faltered when Samâs phone rang. How Sam never hesitated before answering. How you always waited.Â
Bucky had seen it before. Samâs heart belonged to the job. It always had.
But it wasnât Buckyâs place to say anything.
â
Two years later, things werenât bad between you and Sam. Not exactly.
But they werenât good, either.
Sam had spent the last two years becoming Captain Americaâ taking on mission after mission, rebuilding trust with the government, working with Joaquin, training, speeches, outreach programs, meetings.Â
Always something.
And you understood. You knew who Sam was before you got involved with him. You knew what being with him meant.
But lately, it felt like you werenât his girlfriend so much as his afterthought.
It was little things at first.
Heâd cancel dinner plans last minute because Joaquin needed him at the base. Heâd text you not to wait up because a job he couldn't refuse came up. Heâd say he was exhausted when you finally got time together, and then turn around and fly across the country at a momentâs notice.
The worst part was you didnât even think he realised he was doing it.
So, you didnât say anythingâ not at first.
The night it all came to a head, you were sitting at a restaurant alone, your fingers tracing patterns on the linen tablecloth.Â
Sam was supposed to be here. It was your anniversary.
Then, you heard a notification.Â
Your boyfriend texted you: Something important came up. Rain check?
That was it. No apology. No phone call.Â
Were you not something important to him?
You shouldâve seen it coming, but it didnât make it sting any less.
You scrolled through your contacts, wondering if anyone would be available for a rant.Â
Bucky. He was your friend, too, right?
So you texted him: are you free tonight?
Not a minute later, he answered: Yeah. Sam told me something came up. You okay?
You stared at the message for a second too long.Â
A few minutes later, you called. Bucky answered on the second ring.
âYou still at the restaurant?â he asked.Â
âYeah,â you admitted. âBut I think Iâm heading home.â
âIâll meet you at yours,â he said, and you didnât argue.
â
By the time Bucky arrived at your place, you had already changed into sweats and wiped off your makeup. You looked tired. AlmostâŚÂ defeated.
Bucky sighed, setting down a bag of takeout. âFigured you didnât eat,â he said.
You gave him a small smile. âYou figured right.â
He sat down next to you on the couch, cracking open a takeout container. âSo. You wanna talk about it?â
You let out a deep breath. âI donât know what to say that I havenât already said to myself a hundred times before.â
âTry me,â Bucky said, handing you a fork.
You poked at the food, hungry but not really having the energy to eat. âI just⌠I feel like I come second. Like, if itâs between me and the job, it's always going to be the job.â
Bucky was silent for a moment. Then, he said carefully, âAnd is that something you can live with?â
You blinked, caught off guard. âWhat?â
âI mean, itâs not Samâs fault that he puts the job first, thatâs just who he is,â Bucky said, watching you closely. âBut if heâs not willing to compromise, then maybe his values are⌠not suited to you.â
Your throat tightened. âI care about him, Bucky.â
âI know,â Bucky said, gently. âBut do you see a future like this?â
You didnât answer.
And Bucky didnât push. He just stayed with you, eating in silence, ignoring his phone when it buzzed. Samâs name lit up on the screen, probably to ask him to check on you.
And he ignored it. Because you had called first.
â
You didnât sleep.
The hours bled together, stretching endlessly as you lay awake, staring at the ceiling, listening to the too-quiet nothingness.
Sam wasnât hereâ not that he usually was.
Maybe thatâs why this hurt so much. You had already felt alone for so long.
The sun had barely risen when you sent Sam a text.
Can I come over? I need to talk to you.
His response came an hour later.Â
Sure, sweetheart.
When you walked through Samâs door, he looked tiredâ his uniform still slung across the kitchen table, his hair slightly damp from a shower, like heâd come straight from a mission. Like always.
âHey, sweetheart,â he said, pressing a quick kiss to your cheek as you sat down in the kitchen. âSorry about last night. I know I messed up, I justââ
âSam.â
Your voice wasnât malicious by any means, but it stopped him in his tracks anyway.
Slowly, he turned to face you. His eyes scanned your face. He sighed as he sat down, rubbing a hand over his jaw. âWhatâs wrong?â
You swallowed against the lump in your throat.
Here goes nothing. âI canât do this anymore.â
His expression didn't change right away. It was like his brain refused to register the words. Then, after trying to process, his brows furrowed, his lips parting slightly. âWhat?â
You let out a shaky breath. âI love you, Sam.â Your voice cracked at the mention of his name, and that made his entire body go still. âI do. But I canât keep coming second to everything else in your life.â
He blinked, thoughts shifting behind his eyes. âCome on, thatâs not fairââ
âBut it is.â Your voice was firmer now, more desperate. âItâs fair, Sam. Because I get it. I get why you put the job first. I get that the world needs you. I get that youâre Captain America.â Your throat tightened. âBut I need you, too.â
For a second, there was only silence. Samâs muscles flexed. He looked away for a moment, inhaling through his nose. âIâm here now.â
âNo,â you whispered. âYouâre here today. But what about next time? And the time after that?â Your voice wavered, hands starting to tremble now. âHow many more anniversaries are we going to rain check?â
Sam didnât answer. Because you both already knew the answer.
Your chest ached with dull pain. You felt like you were holding onto sand, the last of it slipping through your fingers.
And fuck. Fuck. He wasnât even fighting for you.
He shouldâve said, Stay. Please, stay.
He shouldâve said, Iâll do better.
But he didnât. Because those were promises he just couldnât keep.Â
So you reached for his hand instead, threading your fingers through his fingers like you had so many times before.Â
For two years he had been your safe place. Your home.
âI will always care about you,â you whispered, blinking back tears. Sam shook his head, looking down on your clasped hands, his fingers tightening around yours like he could hold you here forever if he just gripped hard enough.
âThen why are you leaving?â he asked, barely above a whisper.Â
Your heart shattered. âBecause I care about myself, too.â
For a long moment, neither of you moved.
Then, finally, you leaned in⌠and kissed him.
It was slow and painful. The kind of kiss that felt more like a gunshot. The kind of kiss that left a wound behind, that dug into your ribs like a knife and twisted around in your flesh. You kissed him like you wanted to memorise him one last timeâ how he felt, how he breathed, how he tasted.
He tasted like salt and sweat and regret. Like the past. Like he was already slipping away.
Sam kissed you backâ just once. Like if he just kissed you hard enough, maybe youâd change your mind.
But you didnât.
So you pulled away.
And Sam let you go.
You turned toward the door, pausing only once to glance back.
He was sitting there, looking at you like he wanted to stop you, but he didnât know how.
But he didnât say anything.
So you left.
â
That night, Sam called Bucky.
âMeet me at the gym,â was all he said.
Bucky didnât ask why. He just went.
When he arrived, Sam was already wrapping his hands, his movements more rigid and mechanical than usual, like he was just itching to hit something.
Bucky grabbed his own wraps and joined him. They didnât start with words nor questions. They sparred in silence for a long time, fists landing against pads, grunts filling the space where words shouldâve been.
Then, finally, Sam stepped back, rolling his shoulders.
âShe broke up with me,â he finally said.
Bucky already knew that. Or at least, he suspected. He had watched you cry last night as Sam ditched your anniversary dinner for a mission, but hearing Sam say it out loud⌠That made it real.
âIâm sorry,â was all Bucky had to offer.Â
Sam let out a humourless laugh, shaking his head. âMan, Iââ His voice broke.
And suddenly, he wasnât okay.
Buckyâs stomach dropped.
Because Sam WilsonâCaptain Americaâwas crying.
It wasnât loud. It wasnât dramatic. His sobs came in choked breaths, his hands on his hips, his head dropping forward.
Bucky had never seen him like this. Ever.
ââŚShit,â Bucky muttered, pulling off his gloves. He hesitated, then stepped closer. âSamââ
Sam wiped his face, shaking his head. âI knew,â he said, voice open like a fresh wound. âI think I knew this would happen. I knew I wasnât giving her⌠enough. I justâI thought I had time to fix everything.â
Bucky swallowed hard, and repeated. âIâm sorry, man.â
Sam let out a shaky breath, blinking up at the ceiling.Â
âI got a mission coming up,â he said. âCouple of weeks.â His voice was quieter now, like he hated the words coming out of his mouth, because this had proved you rightâ that the mission will always come first. He finally looked at Bucky with red eyes. âCan you just⌠make sure sheâs not alone?â
Bucky hesitated. Then nodded. âYeah.â
Sam nodded too, like he already knew Bucky would say yes.Â
You were his friend, too.Â
And then, without another word, Sam threw his fists back up.
And Bucky let him punch the grief out of his body.
â
The next day, he found himself on your doorstep.
And Bucky didnât knock.
He just let himself into your apartment, the way he always did when Sam asked him to check on you. But this time, Sam wasnât your boyfriend anymore.
The apartment was dark, the curtains drawn, the television playing some random sitcom you werenât even paying attention to. You were curled up on the couch, buried under a blanket, staring at the screen but not really seeing it.
You looked⌠tired. Worn down, the way people got when they spent too much time wanting something they couldnât have.
Bucky sighed, setting yet another takeout bag down on the coffee table before sitting beside you. Close, but not too close that it felt claustrophobic.Â
âHey,â he said, voice softer than usual.
You blinked, slowly turning your head to look at him. But you didnât respond.
Bucky nudged your foot lightly with his knee. âCâmon. Say something. At least yell at me for letting myself in.â
You said nothing. Perhaps because you felt nothingâ numb and hollow, because you just broke it off with the man you loved.
You had been Captain Americaâs girlfriend for two years. You have occupied that space, and he had filled in so much of your life, that you donât even know what made you special if you werenât tied to his whole Stars and Stripes career.
Bucky, perhaps, knew a little of what that felt like.Â
He frowned, leaning forward. âYou miss him.â It was an observation.Â
Your breath hitched, and just like thatâ you broke.
A choked sob clawed its way out of your throat. You pressed the sleeve of your sweatshirt to your mouth like you could somehow shove it back down, like you could hold it in if you just tried hard enough.
But you couldnât.
Tears spilled over, your shoulders trembling, and you turned away from him. You didnât want him to see.
Bucky could only lean back against the couch. He didnât tell you not to cry. He didnât tell you Sam wasnât worth it. He didnât say it was going to be okay.
And when you finally stopped pretending he wasnât there and pressed your forehead against his shoulders, he didnât hesitate putting his arm around you.
Bucky held on to you until you stopped shaking. Until your breathing evened out, until the tears slowed down.Â
Eventually, you spoke. âI-itâs only been a day,â you choked out, âa-and I already miss him.â
Bucky sighed. âI know.â
You exhaled shakily. âI miss everything. I miss how he always made me feel safe. I miss how he would bring me coffee in the mornings he was available and complain about how mine was too sweet. I miss how he always smelled like clean laundry and aftershave. I miss how he laughed at his own jokesâ God, his dumb fuckinâ bird jokes.â
Bucky let out a quiet laugh, shaking his head. âThey were terrible.â
âThey were,â you whispered. âBut I loved them anyway.â
A comfortable silence stretched between you, letting your thoughts settle.Â
Then, softly, you said, âI miss the way he used to look at me like I was his whole world.â
Bucky swallowed hard. He had seen that look. Had seen Sam look at you like you were everything.
But he had also seen the way it faded. The way he took your presence for granted.
And now Sam was not your boyfriend anymore, and you were here, sitting beside his best friend instead.
Bucky let out a slow breath. âYouâll be okay.â
You closed your eyes. âI donât feel okay.â
He nodded. âNot today. Maybe not tomorrow. But you will be.â
You didnât argue. You just sat there, leaning into him.
â
It became a habit. Heâd visit every other day.Â
The third time Bucky checked on you, you didnât let him leave. Not really.Â
You werenât okay, and he could see it in the way you hesitated when he got up, the way your eyes darted toward the door like you were already dreading being alone again.
So he sighed and said, âIâll crash on the couch.â
Youâd say âthank youâ and hand him a pillow and a blanket before retreating to your bedroom.
That was the first night. Then the second.
And then, without really thinking about it, Bucky just⌠stayed every once in a while.Â
He spent his nights on the couch, spent his mornings making coffee in your kitchen, spent his afternoons convincing you to leave the apartment to do small things to keep you from going insane. Sometimes, he offered a walk. Maybe a visit to the bookstore. Or a late-night grocery run because he laughed and said he couldnât eat another one of your sad freezer meals.
Little by little, you started getting back on your feet.
Until one night, you saw Sam on TV.
You had just started feeling normal againâhad started breathing without it hurting, had started waking up without reaching for someone who wasnât there.
And then there he was.
The news anchor was talking about Captain America, but all you saw was Sam. He was at a podium, addressing the country about a recent mission. He looked strong, like he always did. He looked⌠whole.
And God, if it made you selfish⌠but it hurt that he wasnât shattered, that he hadnât fallen apart the way you had.
That he didnât seem like he was missing you at all.Â
You werenât sure when the tears started again.
Bucky walked in just as you swiped at your face. His eyes flicked from the TV to you.
Oh.
Sam looked.. fine on screen. But Bucky knew his best friend. And his best friend hid his emotions well when he wanted to.
âYouâre not okay,â he muttered.
You let out a huff. âYou think?â
He tilted his head, watching you for a second before stepping in to turn off the TV. âSo, whatâs the verdict? You planning on crying yourself into dehydration, or is this just a one-night special?â
You shot him a glare. âYou have the emotional depth of a teaspoon.â
âThatâs not true,â he said, faking offense. âIâm at least a ladle.â
You huffed out something that wasnât quite a laugh, but it was amused enough.Â
Bucky took that as a win.
âListen,â he continued, plopping down onto your couch like he lived there (He practically did at this point), âIâm heading out of town for a couple of weeks. Campaign stuff.â
Ah, right. Congress. Everyone said he had a real shot. An honest man in politicsâ you knew Capitol Hill could use a guy like him.
He stretched his arms behind his head, shooting you a glance. âAnd, uh⌠clearly, you canât be left alone for two seconds without turning into a wet puddleââ
âWow. Thanks.â
ââso, Iâm just gonna extend the offer.â He hesitated, rubbing the back of his neck. âCome with me.â
You blinked. âWhat?â
âTo events,â he clarified. âSpeeches. Dinners. Awkward meet-and-greets with people who pretend to care about the publicâs welfare.â
You narrowed your eyes. âThat sounds awful.â
âRight? Misery loves company.â He chuckled. âAnd clearly, you could use an excuse to get out of the house. And I might need you to hold me back from punching a lobbyist.â
You frowned. âSo, what, Iâm your emotional support human now?â
âI mean.â He shrugged. âI seem to be yours right now.â
You threw a pillow at him. He caught it with a kind grin.
âI just figuredâŚâ He hesitated, the playful edge in his voice smoothed out by sympathy. âInstead of sitting here, waiting for things to get better, you could go out and use my campaign circus as a distraction.â
You stared at him.
Sam wouldâve left you behind.
Sam wouldâve told you to âtake care of yourself,â give you a kiss, and assumed youâd be fine.
But BuckyâŚ
Bucky was asking you to come with him.
Because maybe this wasnât just about you being alone. Maybe he didnât want to be alone, either.
Your throat tightened. âOkay.â
His eyebrows lifted slightly. âYeah?â
You swallowed, nodded. âYeah.â
He nodded, rocking back slightly like he hadnât expected you to actually agree. Then, because he was Bucky Barnes, he just shrugged.
âCool. Pack something nice.â
You narrowed your eyes. âWhy?â
âBecause,â he stood up and stretched, âif I gotta suffer through these events, Iâd rather not do it with someone in smelly sweatpants.â
You gasped, pressing a hand to your chest. âAre you insulting my loungewear?â
âNot insulting. Just⌠youâve been wearing those for five days.â
You hurled yet another pillow at him. He caught it easily, a smile tugging at the corner of his mouth.Â
âBut these are comfy.â
He groaned, heading for the door. âFine. Stay here. Cry over Sam.â
You laughed, catching his sleeve before he could escape. âIâll pack something nice.â
He paused to look at you.
Then, quieter than ever before, he said, âokay.â
You werenât sure why that made your stomach flip.
Or why you let yourself watch him walk away, just a little longer than necessary.
And you definitely werenât sure why, when you finally dragged yourself to your room to pack, you found yourself reaching for something really nice.
Something you knew would make Bucky look twice.
Not that you cared.
Obviously.
It was just⌠strategic. For the campaign.
That was all.
Right?
â
When you showed up at the airport the next day, Bucky told himself he was just doing Sam a favour.
That was all this was.
He was keeping you company, making sure you werenât alone, just like Sam had asked.
It wasnât because he liked having you around.
It wasnât because he liked the way you smiled at him.
It wasnât because you made him feel more human that he had even been.Â
It wasnât any of that.
At least, thatâs what he kept telling himself.
â
Campaign life was a whirlwind. Speeches, press conferences, stiff handshakes with people who smiled too wide and cared too little.
Bucky took it all in stride. He gritted his teeth and smiled through the fake pleasantries, rolled his eyes at the bullshit, and kept himself calm when answering the same three questions a hundred times.
You, however, were just trying to survive.
âYou didnât tell me thereâd be this much small talk,â you whispered at one of the evening fundraisers, swirling the champagne in your glass as you stood beside him in a too-shiny ballroom.
âI figured youâd figure it out,â Bucky said, scanning the crowd. âBesides, you like talking.â
âNot this kind of talking,â you grumbled.
And it was easyâeasier than it shouldâve beenâto fall into step with him. To stay by his side during conversations. To steal each otherâs untouched hors d'oeuvres when no one was looking. To sit beside him in the car after a long day, both of you half-asleep, Bucky rolling his sleeves up to his elbows, stretching his legs out with a tired groan that you definitely didnât stare at.
And somewhere in between the speeches and the late-night drives and the endless political nonsense, he became the person you talked to about everything.
And, yes, that included Sam.
âI mean, I get it,â you sighed one evening, your shoes discarded on his hotel couch. âI get why things didnât work out. I do.â
Bucky nodded, sitting beside you, his tie loose, his jacket ohh. âMhm.â
âAnd I get that heâs this whole⌠larger-than-life thing now.â You exhaled, stretching your legs across the couch in his hotel room. âBut itâs likeâhe thought of me like I was a footnote.â
Bucky was silent for a moment. âTrust me,â he told you, âYou were never a footnote to him.â
You scoffed. âSure feels like it.â
Bucky sighed, rubbing a hand over his face. âLook, Iâm not saying Samâs not an idiotââ
You rolled your eyes. âGood start.â
ââbut I need you to know he didnât mean to hurt you,â Bucky said. âHeâs just⌠Sam. He doesnât always see things the way other people do.â
You rolled your eyes. âYou always defend him.â
âBecause I know him,â Bucky said simply.Â
â
Somehow, you got more⌠involved in his campaign.
When he muttered, âI fucking hate this paperwork,â and you just laughed, took the folder from him, and organised it yourself.
The next morning, after you restructured his entire PR strategy, Bucky stared at you in horror. âIâm gonna have to hire you.â
You scoffed, flipping through notes. âBucky, no. This is just a favour for a friend.â
Yeah. A favour.
A friend.
You both kept pretending thatâs all it was.
Thatâs all you were.Â
â
It had been two months since you walked out of Samâs apartment. Two months since you had kissed him one last time.Â
You were sitting on your hotel bed, curled up in one of Buckyâs campaign sweatshirtsâbecause apparently, there was merch nowâscrolling mindlessly on your phone when the screen lit up with a name you hadnât seen in weeks.
Sam.
Your stomach didnât drop the way you expected it to.
You hesitated for half a second before answering.
âHey.â
There was a pause.Â
âHey.â
His voice was steady. A little too steady, like he was putting conscious effort into making sure it stayed that way.
You werenât sure what to say.
And maybe he wasnât either, because for a moment, there was nothing but silence.
âHow are you?â He finally asked.Â
You blinked. That was not what you expected.
âIâmâŚâ You thought about it. âIâm okay.â
You could hear him processing that.
âYou are?â His voice was careful, as if he didnât believe you.
You shifted against the pillows. âYeah. I meanâdonât get me wrong, I was a mess for a while.â You let out a small laugh, shaking your head. âBut, yâknow. Time, distractions. That kinda thing.â
âDistractions?â He echoed.
You hummed. âBuckyâs been dragging me around on his campaign. Keeping me busy. Making sure I donât, I donât know, waste away in my apartment or something.â
Something changed in Samâs breath. It wasnât loud, nor was it obvious. But you knew him.
ââŚYouâre travelling with Bucky?â
You frowned slightly. âI mean, yeah. Itâs notââ You hesitated. âItâs not a big deal.â
It shouldnât have been a big deal.
And yet, on the other end of the line, Sam was gripping the edge of his kitchen counter, staring at the floor, trying to ignore the splintering feeling in his chest.
Because he had been so sure you were still drowning without him.
Had convinced himself that maybe, just maybe, you were just as wrecked as he was.
But here you were, saying you were okay.
That Buckyâhis best friendâwas the one making sure you were okay. Sure, he had asked him to, but he didnât realise the lengths he would go to just to make sure you werenât lonely.Â
And now, Sam was suddenly, completely, unbearably aware of the fact that he wasnât okay.
âThatâs good,â he finally said, âIâmâIâm glad.â
For the first time, you heard a break in his voice.Â
It shouldâve made you angryâ shouldâve made you want to throw his own actions back in his face. You left me no choice, Sam.Â
But instead, you just felt⌠tired. Because it was too late for both of you.
âYeah,â you said softly. âMe too.â
Sam cleared his throat. âWhen are you back home?â
You glanced at your calendar, thumb hovering over the screen. âTwo weeks. Tuesday.â
âOh.â His tone was unreadable. âWell⌠call me then. I want to pick up my stuff from your place.â
Your stomach twisted at the thought of seeing him again. âYou have a spare key, Sam. Just use it.â You still trusted himâ of course you did. That had never been the issue.Â
Sam let out a deep breath, like he was tiptoeing around glass. âI know. I just⌠I wanted to do it in person.â
Oh.
Your fingers curled against your palm. âOkay.â The word felt insignificant, but what else was there to say? Sam would come over. Heâd gather his things. Youâd stand in the doorway, hands tucked into your sleeves, watching as he took the last of himself out of your space.
Or maybe⌠he had something to say. Maybe he needed an excuse to see you again.Â
âTake care of yourself, Sam,â you said finally, gentler this time. âI better not see you outside the hotel room window, throwing hands with another rage monster.â You joked, because maybe, you wanted to make sure this didnât become awkward. You wanted to make sure that even if you werenât his, he would always be your friend.
âYeah,â he chuckled in a whisper. âYou too.â
And so, even when the call ended and the silence settled back in, you didnât feel like crying.
On the other side of the country, Sam put his phone down, pressed the heels of his hands against his eyes, and wished, for the first time, that he had done things differently.
â
You knocked on Buckyâs hotel room door.
âHey.â He said when he answered voice was a little rough from disuseâ maybe heâd been winding down for the night. He was in a Henley and sweatpants, barefoot, hair in a bun a little messier than usual.Â
You sucked in a breath, needing to justâŚÂ talk. âSam called.â
Bucky didnât say anything. Just stepped aside to let you in.
You sank onto the edge of his bed, arms wrapping around yourself. He sat across from you in the chair by the window, forearms resting on his knees.
âI think we needed to hear each otherâs voices again,â you admitted.Â
Bucky nodded, waiting for more.
You shook your head. âAnd I think⌠I think he really did care about me.â You chewed the inside of your cheek. âBut he was always looking at the next thing. The next fight. The next problem to fix. And Iâ never felt like I could share my problems.â
âYou knowâŚ,â Bucky started, âThe break up wasnât your fault.â
Your throat tightened. âThen why did it feel like it?â
Bucky inhaled sharply, like heâd given this a lot of thought. âBecause it wasnât his fault either,â he said simply. âYou just wanted different things.â
You licked your lips, but you saw itâ that look in his eyesâ a certainty, as if he had been sitting on this for years.
You narrowed your eyes. âYou knew it was never gonna work between me and Sam, didnât you?â
Bucky swallowed hard. âYeah.â
Your heart ached. âWhy didnât you say anything?â
âIt wasnât my place.â
You studied him. âBut you knew.â
âI knew Sam,â he admitted. âAnd I got to know you. You needed more than he could give.â
âAnd what was that?â
Buckyâs eyes flicked to yours, hands nervously twitching. âHe did love you.â His voice was quiet. He felt like he needed to preface that. âBut I think⌠I donât think love was enough.â He considered. âI think you⌠wanted time with him. I think you wanted attention.â
You closed your eyes briefly, nodding. You knew that. You had always known thatâ that Samâs attention was always on the good of all mankind.Â
âBucky, Iââ You stopped mid-sentence.
Because suddenly, the realisation hit you.
Time. Attention.
The things youâd never gotten from Sam.
Bucky had stayed. He had been there, making sure you got out of bed, making sure you were okay, pulling you along on this campaign, keeping you close.
And suddenly, you were seeing itâhimâdifferently.
âThose are the things youâre giving me now,â you whispered.Â
Bucky gulped.
His teeth clicked. His fingers curled against his thighs. His eyes didnât move from yours.
Neither of you said anything for a moment, but the silence wasnât empty. It reminded you of every moment youâd spent together the past few weeks. The banter. The glances. The way you gravitated toward each other in a crowded room without even thinking about it.
âYou should go to bed,â Bucky finally muttered. His voice was low, a little uneven. Fuck, was he scared. You were getting too close to the truth, to how heâs always felt about you.Â
âYeah.â You agreed but didnât move. Neither did he.
His fingers twitched. Your breath hitched.
âThis isââ He groaned like something inside him snapped, dragging a hand down his face. âThis is so stupid.â
You swallowed. âI know.â
âHeâs my best friend.â
âI know.â
âAnd youâreâŚâ He trailed off, shaking his head, eyes flicking down to where your trousers met his sheets. You shouldâve moved. You should have gone. You shouldâve this shouldâve that.Â
But you couldnât bring yourself to.Â
Buckyâs fingers curled, gripping the edge of his chair like he needed to ground himself.Â
âThis⌠this is nothing, right?â you said, and you said it like a warning. You were trying to convince yourself to believe.
His jaw was tight, his throat bobbing. So quietly you almost missed it, he whispered, âThen stop looking at me like that.â
Your breath caught in your throat. âLike what?â
His fingers curled against his thighs. âLike Iâm your next mistake.â
A heat bloomed in your chestâ something that felt too much like frustration, like a want that you had denied, that had been simmering under the surface for weeks and was finally clawing its way out.
Your heartbeat pounded against your ribs, your hands fisting against your lap. âYou could never be a mistake.â
Bucky flinched.Â
And the way his shoulders stiffened made it seem like he didnât believe you, because of course he didnât.
Of course he thought this was wrong.
Of course he thought he wasnât allowed to want this. Want you.Â
Buckyâs breath was shallow. His lips parted slightly, like he wanted to say somethingâlike he wanted something.
And thenâ
âFuck it.â
His chair scraped back. His fingers found your wrist.
And then his mouth was on yours.
The kiss wasnât gentle. It wasnât soft. It wasnât careful.
It was desperate.
Sam kissed like a promise. Bucky kissed like he was drowning and begging for air.Â
His hands were firm but hesitant, gripping your waist like he wasnât sure if he was allowed to touch youâ like he was waiting for you to push him away.
You didnât. Instead, you were pressing closer, fingers fisting in his shirt, tilting your head to deepen the kiss, gasping when his hand trailed up your spine, leaving a burning trail of in its wake.
You had only broken up with Sam two months ago. But you couldnât bring yourself to stop.
âShit,â Bucky muttered against your lips, exhaling hard, like he was trying to catch his breath. His forehead pressed against yours, his grip on your waist tightening like he was afraid to let go. âWe shouldnâtââ
You swallowed. âI know.â
âThen why does it feel like Iâll fucking die if I stop?â His voice was ragged. This was killing him.
You closed the gap and kissed him again, because kissing Bucky was addicting.Â
Sam had always kissed you slowly, held you like you were fragile.
Bucky?
Bucky kissed you like the wild thing he was. Like he had been starving for you.
His hands were firm, his mouth rough against your skin, his hips moving like he couldnât help himself, like he needed this, like he needed you to survive.
He gripped your waist, mouth moving against yours, the way he groaned when your fingers tangled in his hairâGod, you couldnât stop.
He sighed when you moaned against his lips. He gripped your thighs hard, dragging you closer, deeper, until there was nothing left between you but heat and aching want. Soon, your back was against the mattress, your clothes discarded.Â
His weight pressed you into the sheets, his lips dragging down your throat, hot and desperate. His stubble scraped your skin, sending sparks of heat curling in your stomach.
Sam used to be careful. Always controlled, always measured.
Bucky was not.
His hands were everywhere. Rough, needy. His metal fingers traced over your ribs, cool against skin.
âTell me to stop,â he rasped against your throat. His breathing was ragged. âIf you want me to stop, justââ
You didnât.
You grabbed his face, dragging him back to your mouth to taste himâ and he tasted sweet. He tasted like your future.
His name slipped from your lips like a prayer, and when he finally sank into you, you shattered.
Sam was always slow. Always careful, murmuring praises against your skin, pressing feather-light kisses to your collarbone.
Bucky was none of those things.
He buried himself in you, his forehead pressing against yours. He felt so good, so full, so muchâ it was overwhelming.
And fuck, he looked at you like you were a vice he wasnât supposed to have, but took you anyway.
Sam used to say your name, pressing kisses to your jaw. Bucky grunted your name like a prayer, like he was losing himself.
And you wanted him to.
You wanted him to lose himself in you.
Because right now, you werenât thinking about Sam.
Right now, you werenât second place to a job.Â
And when you finally broke apart beneath him, gasping, trembling, falling apart at the seamsâ
Bucky followed right after.
â
Bucky was a light sleeper. After years of war, of Hydraâhis body never let him sleep too deeply.
Which was why, when his phone buzzed on the nightstand, his eyes snapped open instantly.
His arm was still wrapped around you, your bare skin pressed against his. You were still asleep, your breathing soft, lips slightly parted.
Fuck.
His chest tightened, guilt gnawing at the edges of his thoughts.
He carefully reached for his phone, trying not to wake you, and when he saw the caller IDâ
Sam.
Fuck.
He answered anyway. âHey.â
âHey, man.â Samâs voice was too kind, like he was trying to mask something else. âUh, thanks for keeping an eye on my girlââ he stopped in his tracks, before letting out a quiet, bitter laugh. âI mean⌠well. Not my girl anymore. Justâuh, I didnât expect you to bring her with you.â
Bucky glanced down at you. What was he doing? What was he supposed to say?Â
âShe was in no place to be alone in D.C.,â he replied. âI did what I had to.â
âYeah,â Sam sighed. âYeah, I get that.â
Then, Sam said something so soft Bucky almost didnât hear it.
âDo you think thereâs a chance she might want me back?â
Bucky closed his eyes.Â
No. No, no no. Sam couldnât still love you that way, right?
He swallowed hard. âSam⌠you⌠thisâŚâ He exhaled. âYou know how this ends.â
Then, he heard a longer sigh.
âRight.â Samâs voice was strained. âYouâre right.â
Bucky stayed silent, listening as Sam shifted on the other end of the line.
âIâd just hurt her again,â Sam murmured, almost to himself. âWouldnât I?â
Buckyâs throat tightened. âHm.â
âI donât want that,â Sam admitted. His voice was stripped back. âI donât want to do that to her again.â He let out a bitter chuckle. âGuess we should just be friends.â
Bucky swallowed. âHm.â
Sam was quiet for a long time, before saying, âTake care of her, alright?â
Bucky looked down at you again, at the way you had shifted slightly, brow furrowing, lips parting. His fingers brushed over your shoulder.
âI will.â
And for the first time since he answered the phone, Bucky didnât feel guilty about it.
â
When your eyes fluttered open, you woke to the scent of him still lingering in the sheets. The room was still dark, the hotel curtains muting the scorching sunlight.
You could hear the faint rustling of clothes, the sound of trainers being laced up.
Bucky was standing near the desk, already dressed in his jogging clothesâ sweatpants, a t-shirt that clung to his frame, a hoodie zipped halfway up. His hair was damp, probably from a shower. He glanced at you when he noticed you stirring.
âMorninâ,â he greeted.
You sat up slowly, the sheets pooling around your waist. Your eyes went to the clockâ 8.45 AM. âPress today?â
âYeah,â he exhaled, rubbing the back of his neck. âFigured Iâd go on a coffee run first.â
You tilted your head, watching him. Then, before you could overthink it, you pushed the blankets back and stretched. âIâll come with you.â
â
The cafĂŠ smelled like burnt espresso and fresh pastries, the morning rush having finally calmed enough for you and Bucky to claim a quiet booth in the corner. The windows fogged up, the city humming on the other side of the glass.Â
Bucky sat across from you, stirring sugar into his coffee even though you knew he drank it black. A distraction, maybe. Or maybeâŚÂ he needed a shock to his system.
âYou good?â he finally asked, hesitantly.
You nodded, but he didnât look convinced.
âIâŚâ You hesitated, choosing your words carefully. âI donât regret it.â
The spoon in his hand stilled. The soft clink of metal against ceramic was the only sound between you. Then, slowly, he looked up, blue eyes searching for any sign of a lie. âNo?â
You shook your head. âNo.â
His throat bobbed as he swallowed. âEven though itâs⌠messy?â
You huffed, almost amused. âBucky, our lives have been messy for a long time.â
That made him laugh. His shoulders relaxed, just a little.
âWhat about you?â You tilted your head, arms crossing over your chest. âDo you regret it?â
He exhaled through his nose, glancing out the window like the answer might be written in the crowds. âI thought I would,â he admitted. âI thought Iâd wake up and⌠feel like Iâd done something wrong.â
âBut you donât?â
His fingers tapped against the side of his cup, like he was cataloguing his thoughts. Then, quietly, almost like a cardinal sin, âNo. I donât.â
The silence between you stretched before you swallowed, voice quieter this time. âIâll always care about Sam.â
Bucky nodded. He had already known that.Â
You sipped your coffee. âWhen I was youngerâŚâ You sighed, choosing your words carefully. âWhen I first hooked up with Sam, it was just a fling. I knew he could get up and leave at any time, and I wouldnât blame him. So when he offered a relationship, I was over the fucking moon. I thought it would be different. I thoughtâif I could make it workâit would prove I wasnât disposable.â You let out a self-deprecating laugh.âI think staying as long as I didâknowing Iâd never ask him to stop being Captain Americaâjust gave me⌠abandonment issues.â
Buckyâs eyes softened, âYou were never disposable.â He reassured. âNot to me. Not to Sam, either.â
You looked away. âIt doesnât matter if he thinks so. I donât feel like Iâm not.â You exhaled, barely believing that even after you had just slept with Bucky, after breaking things off with Sam, yet here he was, still defending his best friend.
âSam⌠Heâll always put the world first.â And you understood that. So you let the statement steep in silence.
He stared down at his coffee for a long moment. His fingers drummed against the ceramic, like he was debating whether to say something, anything. Then, so softly you almost didnât hear it, he said, âIâve been in love with you for a long, long time.â
Your breath hitched.
He let out an almost bitter chuckle. âFigured I should put that out there.â
Your heart pounded in your ears âHow long?â
Buckyâs eyes darted, like he was debating whether to tell you the truth. âSince the first time you laughed at one of my jokes.â
A disbelieving gasp left your throat. âBuckyââ
âI hated it,â He ran a hand over his face, shaking his head like he didnt like admitting it. âI fucking hated it, because you were with Sam. Heâs my best friend.â His voice cracked, just a little. âAnd Iâd never do that to him.â
Your chest tightened. âDid you ever think about telling me?â
He hesitated. âNo,â he admitted. âNot as long as you loved him.â
But you didnât, didnât you? Not anymore, not in any way that mattered in this conversation, anyway.
You swallowed hard, the truth pressing against your ribs. âI think⌠in the last couple of months, when Sam started taking on more and more missionsâafter the president, after everythingâI think I started⌠having⌠feelings for you.â
Buckyâs head snapped up, his eyes locking onto yours so fast it almost startled you. What?
You didnât let yourself back down. Not when you owed him thisâowed yourself this. âBut⌠I was with Sam.â
Bucky didnât say anything right away, but you could see his fingers twitching where they rested on the table. When he finally nodded, it was slow, like he was letting each word sink into his skin. âAnd now youâre not.â
You nodded, searching his eyes. âNow Iâm not.â
You could always tell when he was holding something back, his muscles would tighten just a little too much, his fingers would tap away. He was doing it now, tracing the rim of his coffee cup. His lips parted, âI didnât tell you something.â
Your stomach twisted. âWhat?â
He looked up at you then, âSam called this morning.â
You blinked. âOhâŚâ
Buckyâs grip on the cup tightened. âHe asked me if I thought youâd take him back.â
The words hit like a punch to the gut.
A month ago, you wouldâve said yes without hesitation.
A month ago, if Sam had promised to changeâto make more time, to choose you over the mission just onceâyou wouldâve taken that deal in a heartbeat.
But now, after knowing what it felt like to have someone who was there, who made sure you were okay before you even thought to ask, who would make you his first priorityâ You couldnât imagine life without him.
Your throat felt tight. âWhat⌠did you say?â
He shook his head, âI told him he knew how this ended.â
You looked down nervously at your lap.
Bucky sighed, rubbing a hand over his face. âLook, Iâmaybe I shouldnâtâve assumedââ
âDo you think I should take him back?â you interrupted.
He went still. His blue eyes locked onto yours, and they looked like they were burning.
âNo,â he said, hopeful.
The cafĂŠ buzzed with life around youâclinking mugs, distant chatter, the hiss of steam from the espresso machineâbut none of it mattered.
All that mattered was the way Bucky was looking at you the way you wanted him to.
You swallowed. âDo you think Iâm a bad person for wanting to be with you instead?â
âNo,â he whispered
Your hands found the sticky vinyl of the booth seat. âShit,â you shook your head. âI feel like I should feel worse about this.â
Bucky tilted his head, âYou loved him.â
âYeah,â you admitted. You traced the tabletop with your finger, avoiding his eyes. âBut I love you more.â
Bucky took a deep breath, like youâd knocked the air clean out of his lungs. His pupils blew wide, and for a second, he just stared at you, lips parted like he wasnât sure if he was awake or dreaming.
âSay that again,â he breathed, almost begging. âPlease.â
Your throat went dry, finally looking him in the eyes.âI love you more.â
Bucky let out a shaky breath, raking a hand through his hair, like he didnât know what the hell to do with himself. He dragged his tongue over his bottom lip. âI shouldnât be this happy, should I?â
âProbably not,â you admitted, laughing weakly.
Bucky leaned in slightly, nearly knocking over his coffee. âIf you let me,â he promised, âIâll spend the rest of my life making sure you never feel disposable again.â
The world outside your little coffee booth faded into nothing. Just you and him and this inevitable connection.
âDeal.â
Bucky froze, just for a fraction of a second, before shoving the contained aside, climbed halfway over the table, and kissed you like a man starved. His hands cradled your face, fingers tangling in your hair as his lips crashed into yours. The kiss was messy, and perhaps a half apology for making you wait this long.
You gasped against his mouth, fisting the front of his jacket to pull him even closer. His metal hand slid against your neck.
Somewhere in the distance, a throat cleared.
âUh.â The baristaâs voice rang in your ears. âNot to kill the vibe, but this is a family-friendly establishment.â
Bucky pulled back slightly, forehead pressed against yours, and let out a breathless laugh.
You bit your lip, trying and failing to keep a straight face.
âRight,â Bucky muttered, still dazed, âSorry.â He leaned back, but not before pressing one last, fleeting kiss to your lips. And then you just looked at him.
Hair tousled from your fingers, lips kiss-swollen, eyes alive in a way you hadnât seen before. He grinnedâgrinned, like he couldnât believe this was real. Like he couldnât believe you were real.
In that moment, you realised that while Sam had spent the last two years figuring out what it meant to be Captain America, Bucky had spent that time figuring out who he was outside of the Winter Soldier.
So of course Sam couldnât put you first. He had the whole damn world resting on his shoulders.
But Bucky could.
Bucky would.
And maybe it was complicated. Maybe it would get messy.
But with Bucky smiling at you like that, you couldn't bring yourself to care.
â
But how do you even bring something like this up to Sam?
How do you look him in the eye and say, Hey, I know we broke up, but your best friend and IâŚ
So, you didnât. Not yet.
When you got home two weeks later, you didnât call Sam like you said you would. You figured he could survive a night without the spare clothes you still had.
But Sam had texted earlier, even called a couple of times, too. When neither you nor Bucky answered, he started to get worried. It wasnât like either of you to ignore him completely.
That worry led him here.
Standing at your door, with his spare key in hand.
He knocked. Once. Twice.
Nothing.
That was⌠weird.
He hesitatedâjust for a secondâbefore slipping it into the lock. The door swung open, and he stepped inside, expecting a dark apartment. Maybe you were curled up on the couch watching something with Bucky eating ice cream, both too distracted to check your phones.
What he didnât expectâwhat he never could have expectedâ was the sound that stopped him cold in the doorway.
âOhâGodâplease, pleaseââ
His stomach turned to ice.
He heard the bed creak, he heard the sound of skin hitting skin at a pace so incredibly intense, he felt like he was about to throw up.Â
Then Buckyâs voice followed, so goddamn gentle.
âThatâs it, thatâs it. Let me hear you.â
Oh.Â
Oh. No.
Why did it have to be Bucky? Sam thought, why couldnât it have been anyone else?
Samâs lungs filled like it might as well have collapsed.
He shouldnât be here. He shouldnât be hearing this, but his feet wouldnât let him move. His fingers gripped the key so tightly it cut into his palm.
âYou like that, sweetheart? You know Iâd give you anything. Just gotta tell me what you need.â
Sweetheart.
Sam used to call you sweetheart all the damn time. He used to say it over breakfast, in sleepy murmurs when he curled around you at night, with laughter in his voice when you teased him. You had smiled, then. You had kissed him. You had never asked him for more.
âPleaseâŚâ
Sam could count on one hand the number of times you had begged him for anything.
You had never been needy with him. Never desperate. You had been understanding. You had been patient.
âBuckâ Jamesâplease, Iââ
And the worst part?
You had never once said his name like thatâ like it was a prayer, like it was the only thing tethering you to this world.
A choked sound tore out of him before he could stop it.
He barely managed to step in, barely remembered to breathe as he forced his legs to carry him into the kitchen, blinking rapidly.
The spare key felt heavy as he set it down on the table. His hands shook as he reached for a pen, vision blurring as he scribbled the words before he could think too hard about them.
He left immediately.
â
Bucky was up before you the next morning.
When he walked into the kitchen, he saw the key.
The note.
The second he recognised Samâs familiar handwriting, his stomach dropped.
âSounds like this key belongs to you, Barnes. -Sâ
His fingers trembled as he picked up the key, as if it might vanish between his fingertips.
He knows.
The room suddenly felt too small, his chest too tight.
You walked in a moment later, rubbing the sleep from your eyes, his henley hanging off your frame. âSweetie⌠you left me alone,â you mumbled adorably, voice still groggy.
But the second you saw his face, your brows knit together. âWhatâs wrong?â
Bucky didnât answer immediately. He just handed you the note, watching as your expression shifted from confusion to horror.
âOh,â you whispered.
Sam had heard, Sam had been here, and Bucky hadnât even noticed. He had been too caught up in you, too caught up in the way you had fallen apart beneath him.
âIâll call him.â he gulped, âIâll meet him. Iâll talk to him.â
You swallowed, watching the tension grow in his shoulders. âI could come withââ
âNo,â Bucky interrupted, âI need to do it on my own.â
You didnât push, though concern flickered in your eyes. You just nodded.
â
Bucky had asked to meet in a text.
Sam had agreed.
The bar was nearly empty, the kind of place where no one asked questions and no one cared about anyone elseâs problems.
Bucky sat across from Sam, hands wrapped around a half pint of beer he hadnât touched. Sam hadnât touched his either. Neither of them were here for that.
Sam didnât waste time. He didnât dance around it. âHow long?â
Bucky blinked. âHow long what?â
Samâs teeth clenched, his fingers curling into fists against the wooden tabletop. âHow long have you been in love with her?â
What was the point of lying?
âLonger than Iâd like to admit.â
Sam sucked in a deep breath. He shook his head once, like he could shake them off. âHow long have you been waiting for me to fail?â He demanded, âHow long were you just waiting to step in?â
Buckyâs brows furrowed. âThatâs not what happened.â
âNo?â Sam let out a humourless laugh. âThen tell me what did.â
Bucky didnât answer fast enough for Samâs liking.
âTell me,â Sam repeated, âTell me everything.â
God, it was terrifying to see Sam like this.
He was always so level-headed, so in control. But now his anger crackled like a live wire.
It didnât feel like him. It didnât look like him.
âSam,â Bucky said slowly, âI never told her to leave you.â
Sam leaned back. âSure.â
âI didnâtââ Bucky insisted, leaning forward. âI justâ I pointed out that you two had different values. That maybe you werenât giving her what she needed. Thatâs it.â His mechanical fingers whirred. âI did nothing wrong.â
Samâs eyes flashed with red. âNothing wrong,â he repeated, like he could barely believe the words. His voice was quieter now, but it cut deeper. âYou knew.â
Bucky didnât move.
âYou knew how much I loved her.â
Bucky scrubbed a hand over his face. âSamââ
âNo. Donât âSamâ me,â Sam snapped. His voice was rough. âYou answered the call and listened to me talk about her. You knew how much I still cared, and you lââ He stopped himself, chest rising and falling too fast.
âShe wanted more,â Bucky said, exasperated, âYou didnât see it, or maybe you did and you didnât care, but she was waiting for you, Sam. And she got tired of waiting.â
Samâs hands curled into fists. âAnd you just happened to be there when she did, huh?â His voice was scathing.
âI didnât plan this!â
âBut you sure as hell didnât stop it,â Sam shot back. âYou sure as hell didnât tell meââ
âWhat was I supposed to say?â Buckyâs voice rose into a subtle shout now, frustration bleeding through. âThat Iâve been in love with your girl for longer than I can remember? That every time I saw her look at you, I wishedââ He cut himself off before he could spiral, shaking his head. âWhat would that have changed, Sam? Huh? Would you have treated her any different?â
Samâs nostrils flared. âI loved her,â he could only repeat those words.Â
âI never told her to leave you,â Bucky said again, as if to drive the point home. âBut I wasnât gonna tell her to stay, either.â
Sam shook his head, laughing under his breath, but there was no humour in it. âYeah. Yeah, I bet you werenât.â
Bucky let out a deep breath. âSamââ
Sam shoved back from the table, chair scraping against the tile as he stood.
For a second, it looked like Sam might say something else.
But he didnât.
He just turned and walked out.
And Bucky let him go.
â
When you saw Bucky by your door, you knew something was wrong.
He looked drained, like he had been hollowed out from the inside.Â
You reached for him the second he stepped in. âBuckyââ
âI told him,â he said, voice rough. âWe talked.â A dry chuckle left his lips. âIf you can call it that.â
Your chest tightened. âThat bad?â
Bucky closed the door behind him. âYeah.â
You stepped closer, resting a hand on his hipbones. âDid he say anything else?â
âNothing I didnât already know.â His voice was quieter now, more worn out. âHeâs hurt. Heâs pissed. And Iâ I donât know if heâll get over this.â
You didnât push for more. Instead, you just pulled him into you, wrapping your arms around his waist.
The moment your arms circled him, his entire body gave out. He melted against you, burying his face in the crook of your neck.
âI got you,â you cooed, one hand threading through his hair, the other rubbing slow circles over his back.
You werenât sure how long you stood there like that, but eventually, Buckyâs weight grew heavier against you. You carefully guided him to the couch, easing him down beside you.
The second you settled in, he curled into you without hesitation, head resting against your chest. You ran your fingers through his hair, pressing a soft kiss to the top of his head. âGet some rest, baby,â you said.
Bucky sighed. He nuzzled closer, and within moments, he was asleep in your arms.
â
Two hours later, Bucky was still asleep. He hadnât moved in a long timeâso emotionally exhausted that even when you carefully shifted out from under him, he barely stirred.
You knew you had to do something about this.Â
If you left this too long, the fallout between Sam and Bucky would be worse than when you and Sam broke up. So much worse.
So you grabbed Samâs spare key buried at the bottom of a drawer, shoved there weeks ago like out of sight meant out of mind.
On the way out, you grabbed the last of his thingsâ the small pile he had planned to come back for. A sweatshirt, a couple of books, little trinkets he probably hadnât even realised he left behind.
You called Joaquin on your way there.
When he answered, he was half-yawning. âKinda late, isnât it?â
You shifted the bag higher on your shoulder. âYeah. Justâchecking in.â
Joaquin sighed. He already knew why you were calling.Â
âItâs bad,â he admitted. âNot gonna lie.â
Your stomach dropped.
âI checked on him after he met with Bucky and⌠Heâs not talking much, which is weird for Sam.â Joaquinâs voice was quiet, like he wasnât sure he should even be telling you this. âJust kinda⌠sitting in it, you know?â
You swallowed. âYeah.â
Joaquin hesitated. âHeâs pissed. I think heâs justââ He sighed. âI donât know, man. Itâs rough.â
You knew this would hurt him. You knew it would break something between you, between all of you.
But knowing didnât make it easier.
âIâm bringing his stuff now,â you said.
âYou sure thatâs a good idea?â Joaquin asked.
No.
But it didnât matter.
â
Sam opened the door on your first knock like he had been waiting for you.
The circles under his eyes were deeper than you remembered. His usual magnetic warmth, that easy charm, was gone.Â
Without a word, you held up the bag. âBrought your stuff.â
Sam didnât reach for it. He just stepped aside. "Come in."
The apartment looked the same. It was the same kitchen where you used to make coffee while he read the news, the same living room he used to sneak up behind you, pressing a sleepy kiss to your temple.
But it didnât feel the same.
It felt⌠abandoned. Like a house after the fire has burned outâeverything still standing, but covered in soot.
You set the bag down and turned to face him.Â
Joaquin had warned you that he was not himself.
But seeing him like this⌠made it real.
He broke the silence first. âJoaquin said you called.â
"Yeah."
Sam let out a dry chuckle. âChecking to see if Iâm still breathing?â
You looked at him in half-shock. He had always been so calm and collected. He had never, ever been self-destructive before. "Sam."
He shook his head, looking away. âI donât need your pity.â
âI care about you, Sam.â
That made him laugh. âFunny way of showing it.â
You flinched, but held your ground.
"Come on,â you said, voice tight. âYou know this isnât about that.â
His eyes flashed. âEnlighten me, then.â
"We just werenât a good fit,â You trailed a hand on his forearm, somehow feeling too close and not close enough. âWe kept pretending, we kept trying, but deep down, we both knew it wasnât right.â You gestured between the two of you. âI did nothing wrong. You did nothing wrong. We justâ We just werenât meant for each other.â
His fingers trembled just a little. âDoesnât mean it doesnât hurt.â
"I know.â You soothed. âI know it hurts.â
For a moment, the anger bled out of him. "He shouldâve told me before it happened."
"Heâ we,â you corrected, âWe didnât plan this.â
Sam scoffed.Â
Your frustration bubbled over. âYouâre really gonna let your friendship with Bucky die over a girl?â You shook your head, voice finally rising. âOver me?â
He had nothing to say to that.
"Two months, Sam.â You swallowed hard. âTwo months we werenât together before anything even happened. You canât sit here and act like we were stillââ You stopped yourself, shaking your head.
He swallowed hard, finally meeting your eyes.
"I loved you," he said, voice rough, like the words had splintered on the way out.
"I know," you whispered.
He looked away. His fists unclenched. âWell this fucking sucks.â
"Yeah." You gave a sad, tired smile. âIt does, but Iâm always going to be your friend." You gave his arm a gentle squeeze. âAnd Bucky⌠Bucky is your best friend.â
Samâs lips pressed into a thin line.
"Donât treat him like this,â you almost pleaded. âNot over me.â
With a long, tired sigh, he nodded. He never could argue his way out with you.Â
"J-just give me time," he said.
And you did.
â
A week later, Sam wasnât angry anymore. Not really.
But he didnât know how to fix it.
He had never really exploded on anyone before, not in a way that left wreckage behind. He had spent so much of his life learning how to hold it together, how to bite his tongue and keep moving forward.
But this wasn't something he could outrun.
Because now, when he looked at Bucky, all he saw was you leaving him.
Maybe that wasnât fair. Maybe that was selfish.
So yeah, he was not angry anymore, but he hadnât really processed the fact that you had found something with Bucky that you couldnât find with him.
And Sam didnât know how to move past that.
He let the days blur together, filling them with distractions that didnât work, pretending he wasnât falling apart.
Until Joaquin called him on his shit.
"Alright, man. Enough of this."
Sam barely looked up.
Joaquin stood across the room, arms crossed. Sam had been so unfocused while working on his wingpack that Joaquin had finally just snatched it from him, setting it down with a loud clank.
"You can sulk all you want, but this is ridiculous." Sam sat at the table, fingers loosely curled around the glass of iced coffee he hadnât touched in over an hour.
"Didnât know my personal life was any of your business," Sam shrugged.
Joaquin scoffed. "You broke the law for him, Sam.â His patience was running thin. He was sick of being stuck at work with a fucking brick wall that only said one or two words every two hours. âYou broke the damn law for that man, stood by him when no one else would, risked your life a hundred times over. And youâre not even talking to him!â
Samâs fingers tightened around his glass. "It ainât that simple.â
"It is," Joaquin said. "Iâm not saying Bucky isnât a dumbass for falling in love with your exâ but have you even tried being happy for them? The guy whoâd take a bullet for you is the same guy whoâd take a bullet for herâ You think thatâs a coincidence?â
He didnât want to hear this. He didnât want to admit that Joaquin was right.
But⌠he knew had to face it.
Sam let out a long breath, pressing his thumb and forefinger against his eyes before finally pulling out his phone.
Then, finally, he typed:
Iâm ready to talk again.
And he hit send.
â
So now, here they were.
Sitting in silence in the same bar, drinks in front of them.
Sam just sat there, studying Bucky like he was waiting for somethingâan explanation, an apology, hell, maybe a fight.
âSo⌠you ready to yell at me again,â Bucky sighed, rolling his shoulders, âOr can we just talk?â
Sam scoffed, shaking his head. âYou act like Iâm the unreasonable one.â
"I mean." Bucky gestured vaguely. âYou did storm out of a diner after accusing me of stealing your girl.â
Sam leveled him with a flat look. âBecause you did.â
âWeâre already doing this wrong.â He leaned back. âLook, I donât wanna fight you. But Iâm not gonna sit here and pretend like I donâtââ He stopped, considering whether or not Sam wanted to hear him out. Then, quieter, âLike I donât love her.â
For a long moment, neither of them spoke.
Then, Bucky huffed out a laugh. âLook, I am sick for her, man.â
Sam raised an eyebrow.
"No, I mean it," Bucky continued, rubbing a hand over his face. "Itâs disgusting. You ever see a dog get left alone for too long and lose its goddamn mind the second someone walks through the door? Thatâs me. She walks in, and suddenly I forget every bad thing thatâs ever happened to me."
For the first time in what felt like forever, Samâs lips curled into a small smile. âThatâs pathetic.â
"I know."
"Youâre a grown man."
"I know."
Sam took a slow sip of his drink. "Thatâs embarrassing for you."
Bucky just shrugged.
ââŚWas it always like that?â Samâs voice was quieter now, but not accusing. âDid you always love her like that?â
Buckyâs fingers tapped against his glass. âI tried not to. I really did.â He huffed. âTold myself you were my best friend, told myself it wouldnât happen. Butââ He shook his head. âIt wasnât something I could turn off.â
Samâs jaw tightened. He knew he had asked his next question before, but he had to ask again. He had to be sure.
"So did you?â Sam leaned back, eyes narrowing. âDid you sit there the whole time, waiting for me to fuck up?â
âNo,â Bucky said without missing a beat. âI sat there hoping you wouldnât.â
That shut Sam up. How was he supposed to answer that?
Bucky sighed, his fingers curling loosely around his glass. "Sam, youâre a better man than me."
Sam rolled his eyes. "Donât start with that dramatic assâ"
"I mean it." Bucky turned toward him fully, "The world will always be your priority. You are a hero, Sam. You always will be. That makes you a better man."
Sam scoffed, tipping back the rest of his drink. "Yeah? And what does that make you?"
"More selfish." He admitted. "More broken."
Sam didnât think so, but he didnât argue, either.
Buckyâs voice went a bit more quiet. âYou will always protect the world." He looked him in the eyes. "I will burn the world for her."
Sam froze.
"Have you ever thought thatâs what she wants?" Bucky asked.
He hated how much sense it made.
"Sam." Bucky leaned forward, elbows on the bar. "She is as selfish as I am."
Sam shook his head. "Sheâs not selfishâ"
"She is." Buckyâs voice was firm, no room for argument. "She asked to be the center of my world. And I can give her that."
Sam inhaled deeply, tilting his head back. âShit.â
Bucky huffed. âYeah.â
Then, Sam shook his head, letting out a cynical laugh. âYou know what pisses me off?â
"What?"
"That I have to admit I overreacted.â Sam let out a deep breath, running a hand through his hair. âI was mad, I was hurt, butâshit, Buck. She wasnât mine anymore. And I acted likeââ He shook his head. âI acted like an asshole.â
Bucky smirked. âYeah, you did.â
Sam shot him a pointed look.
Bucky held up his hands. âHey, your words, not mine.â
Sam sighed. "I still think you shouldâve at least told me."
âI know,â Bucky nodded. "And Iâm sorry you found out the way you did."
Sam groaned, shaking his head. "Man, I did not need to hear all that."
"Yeah, that was rough."
Sam groaned louder, rubbing his temples.
âSoâŚâ Bucky nudged his shoulders. âYou done being mad at me?â
Sam shrugged, shaking his head. "Youâre still a pain in my ass."
Bucky smirked. "You wouldnât know what to do without me."
"Whatever,â he dismissed, but there was no real disdain behind it.
Bucky arched an eyebrow. âThatâs it?â
"Man, what do you want from me?â Sam finally chuckled. âYou already stole my girl, you want my blessing too?"
Bucky grinned. âWouldnât hurt.â
Sam groaned, shoving at his shoulder. âFuck off, Barnes. Now buy me a drink before I change my mind.â
Bucky just laughed, and somehow, somehow, it felt like things might just be okay.
â
A Year LaterâŚ
"To the left."
"No, the other left."
"Barnes, if you drop that couch, I swear to Godâ"
"Itâs fine, Sam, I got it."
"Do you? Do you really? Because that thing is tilting real suspiciouslyâ"
"Bucky, sweetie, please donât break the couch before we even sit on it."
"I got it."
THUD.
Joaquin snorted. âYeah, you totally got it.â
Bucky shot him a glare as he flexed his metal fingers. The couch had technically made it inside, albeit with a new scuff mark or two. It now sat in the middle of the living roomâyour living room. Yours and Buckyâs.
"I shouldâve stayed home," Sam muttered.
"Me too," Joaquin agreed, clapping him on the back.
"No one asked you two to help," Bucky pointed out.
"We came because she asked," Sam insisted, pointing his chin at you.
You grinned, stepping around Bucky and squeezing both his arms. "Alright, enough whining, boys," you said. "We need to get everything unpacked before we drown in boxes."
Bucky sighed but gave in, nudging Joaquin toward the kitchen to help with electronics. Before he left, he pressed a kiss to your lips. It was a bit rough, but still loving, as it always was. He never failed to make your heart flutter.
When Bucky was out of earshot, Sam leaned against the wall. âYou know,â he said after a moment, holding up his hand. âI was this close to asking you to move in with me our second year together.â
You turned to him, "Oh?"
He shrugged, a wistful smile tugging at his lips. âFigured it wouldâve been nice. You and me. House in the suburbs, co-parenting RedwingâŚâ
You laughed, shaking your head. "SamâŚâ it was a gentle warning.
âI know, I know.â He shook his head, crossing his arms. âYouâre with him now.â
And that was okay.
It really was.
âHey,â you stepped closer, bumping your shoulder against his. âIâm glad you boys came around.â
Sam huffed, shaking his head. He glanced toward the kitchen, where Joaquin was currently attempting to swindle Bucky out of the last slice of pizza.
âI justââ He hesitated, like he wasnât sure he should say it, ââIâm glad itâs him.â
You blinked. "What?"
Sam sighed. âWith you. If it had to be anyone else, Iâm glad itâs Bucky.â
You hadnât expected that. A year ago, he mightâve made a snide remark. Maybe stormed out.
But heâd done the work to balance job and life. Heâd gone to therapy. Heâd let himself heal.
And now, here he was. Helping you move in together with his best friend.Â
You swallowed. "Me too."
He shrugged, then sighed. "You know what I realised?"
You shook your head.
"I was never mad that you moved on with him," he admitted. "I was mad that you moved on easier than I did."
You let the confession settle between you.
Then you broke the silence, âIâm⌠Iâm proud of you.â
For putting in the work.Â
For being happy for you.
For being happy with himself.
And you meant it.
He only smiled.
You and Sam were always going to be friends. Maybe not in the way you once were, but in a way that still mattered. That would always matter.
Then, Bucky caught both you and Sam staring at him, he waved.
Sam waved back.
And when Bucky smiled at you again, this time with an adoring look, like you were the best damn thing that had ever happened to himâ Sam knew, without a doubt, that the truth had always been simple:
Bringing you and Bucky together was still his proudest achievement.
-End.
General Bucky taglist:
@hotlinepanda @snflwr-vol6 @ruexj283 @2honeybees @read-just-cant
 @shanksstrawhat @mystictf @globetrotter28 @thebuckybarnesvault@average-vibe
@winchestert101 @mystictf @globetrotter28 @shanksstrawhat @scariusaquarius
@reckless007 @hextech-bros @daydreamgoddess14 @96jnie @pono-pura-vida
@buckyslove1917 @notsostrangerthing @flow33didontsmoke @qvynrand @blackbirdwitch22
@torntaltos @seventeen-x @ren-ni @iilsenewman @slayerofthevampire
@hiphip-horray @jbbucketlist @melotyy @ethereal-witch24 @samfunko
@lilteef @hi172826 @pklol @average-vibe @shanksstrawhat
@shower-me-with-roses @athenabarnes @scarwidow @thriving-n-jiving @dilfsaresohot
@helloxgoodbi @undf-stuff @sapphirebarnes @hzdhrtss @softhornymess
@samfunko @wh1sp @anonymousreader4d7 @mathcat345 @escapefromrealitylol
@imjusthere1161 @sleepysongbirdsings @fuckybarnes @yn-stories-are-my-life
@cjand10
the way i loveeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeee this fic like omg. i re-read it all the time and think about it at least ten times a day. sam honestly took it better than me because i would've crashed out! but also it's bucky!!
10/10+ chefs kiss mwah mwah love it.
i'm spamming thee fawk out of these tags because more people need to read this masterpiece.





















