Dude, aren’t Murtagh and Eragon half-siblings? They have the same mom. Why are we shipping them.
believe it or not, people are allowed to ship fictional characters without submitting an ethics application to the tumblr morality council first. shocking concept, i know.
i'm neutral on shipping in general, but since you’re coming for those shippers who are literally harming no one by doing so, let’s apply your logic consistently for five seconds.
if shipping fictional characters means endorsing everything those characters do, then congratulations: christopher paolini is apparently every kind of criminal that exists, and you’re complicit too for liking, buying, and consuming his work.
arya is over a century old and gives her true name (described by paolini himself as “a closer sharing than any physical intimacy” aka sex) to a teenager, veering into pedophilic territory. that’s also the most popular ship on ao3. morzan and selena have a massive age gap. brom and selena have a massive age gap. fäolin and arya have a massive age gap. those ships are also on ao3. murtagh tortures nasuada and commits a genocide, and that’s the second most popular pairing on ao3. galbatorix and morzan are serial abusers and rapists, and that’s the fourth most popular pairing on ao3.
fiction is where people examine themes like power, horror, trauma, desire, obsession, violence, and complicated relationships. the entire series is built on those things because that is what stories are.
depiction is not endorsement. exploration is not advocacy. fiction is not a declaration of personal morality.
and fandom purity crusaders never apply this logic consistently outside shipping discourse. you’re on tumblr? cool, the platform has a long documented history of horrific moderation decisions and targeting marginalized communities like trans people and palestinians. you own a smartphone? guess you personally endorse exploitative labor practices in congo and the violence tied to global mineral extraction. you consume media under capitalism? damn, sounds like you support every unethical practice involved in its production.
or (and this is the conclusion any normal person reaches after ten seconds of thought) consuming or creating fiction does not mean you morally endorse every aspect of it.
most people understand that fiction is a space to explore themes and dynamics without believing those things are good in real life.
kill the cop in your head.