To kick off Cronkite schools’ weekly Must See Mondays events, administrators brought in bright local talent, with three of the four panelists being proud ASU alumni. The night’s guests were Clara Colmenero of Univision (class of 2009), Kris Pickel of CBS 5, Linda Williams of FOX 10 (class of 1981), and Kim Tobin of ABC 15 (class of 2010). The panel was moderated by Lin Sue Cooney, formerly of FOX 12 News.
The night started with an intro by assistant director and executive producer of Cronkite News, Melanie Alvarez, introducing the women and the moderators, and setting a tone for the evening.
Ms. Cooney started the panel with discussions of the pros and cons of working in the journalism industry, what it’s like to work in the era of social media, and what it’s like to work with the old-fashioned perceptions of the diva anchorwoman of the 60s still pervasive today. Every panelist had a different response as to why they loved their jobs; for Ms. Williams, she has a passion for writing and this is her chosen method of sharing her writing. For Ms. Pickel, she enjoyed the connection she has with the community by sharing stories that impact people’s lives For both Kim and Clara, they find that the impact they have on their community to be the most rewarding. As veteran reporters, Pickel and Williams discussed the unstable nature of their careers, and how it is the greatest cons in their line of work. “The lack of control over your own career” Pickel declared, was the worst part about her job. She explained that in her experience, she had bosses who didn’t like her, and made it difficult for her to continue her job or personal life. Williams discussed how the “pressure and stress” made her work challenging, as deadlines on TV are set in stone: “if it’s late, it’s not even there”.
Moving beyond just the struggles and triumphs of journalists, moderator Cooney moved the conversation to social media. A consensus appeared among the panelists: social media wasn’t going to destroy local news. According to Pickel, stories can go viral, but people still return to local media for them to be “vetted”, as the local news remains as the “reliable source” in the era of free information. She also saw social media as a “tool to interact”, in order to know what does the audience “want to know about?”. She also noted that with the booming industry of streaming (Netflix, Hulu, etc), that many people may transition back to “rabbit ears” types of broadcasting, boosting local news. For Ms. Tobin, she said she spent as much as 30% of her workday on social media, dropping hints on to stories that she is working on, prior to broadcast.
It isn’t possible to have a panel of exclusively female anchors without touching on the problems of sexism in the world and how it affects them in their day to day lives. Cooney asked whether the stereotype of the “diva anchorwoman” is still relevant today, to which every panelist scoffed or at least chuckled. Tobin declared, “No divas allowed” in the newsroom. Williams speculated, that maybe in the 50s and 60s that caricature was real, but it “went out the door in the 70s”. For Pickel, in her experience working in the Midwest, that sort of anchor still existed. She said she sense a sort of derogatory attitude towards the term “anchor”. For this reason, “I don’t introduce myself as an anchor. I’m a reporter”.
For me, anecdote that resonated with me the most was Pickel’s about her trying to get onto the US Navy’s icebreaker ship for a story. She said she fought for a month to try and get on the ship for the story, and once the station was approved to be on board, she got a phone call. There were no women on the crew, and the Navy said that they required a male reporter to do the story. “I hung up the phone, waited a moment, and then called them back. ‘I’m sorry, are you telling me I can’t do this story because I’m a woman?’”, she laughed “We had a er, cordial, discussion after that. ‘If that’s the case, then let’s have a conversation about gender bias in the US Military then. I’m sorry do you think I am going to have sex with the crew, is that the what it is?’”. Apparently the reasoning for her not being appropriate for the story was because she “couldn’t sleep on the bunk”. To which she replied, “give me a blanket, I’ll sleep on the floor.”
The overarching message from the diverse set of talented, smart women, was if you love what you do, and are determined to do it, nothing can stop you. Be dynamic, be driven, be a “fiver” according to Williams. Be willing to do anything, and success will be yours.