A Feminist Analysis of the General Election
The run up to this snap election next week has been crazy. I don’t know about you but it has totally thrown my political views into turmoil, and all I seem to hear is Brexit Brexit Brexit. Of course, the way in which Brexit is handled is ridiculously important for the UK, but we can’t forget that there are other factors to take into consideration when you step into that polling booth on the 8th of June.
Firstly, I want to address something I have seen cropping up a lot on social media in the run up, not only to our own general election, but also during the French presidential election too. There are many aspects to a party that forms their manifesto, and their party views. Having a female leader does not mean a party is a feminist party. A feminist vote is not a vote for a party only because their leader is female, a feminist vote considers what a party promises in their manifesto, and the work they plan to do to combat the gender imbalances across our society. The age old saying ‘actions speak louder than words’ is definitely appropriate here. It is less about your gender and more about what you and your party stand for.
Another important point to note is that a lot of women’s rights are safeguarded under EU law, and once Brexit is complete, we will lose these rights unless our government create UK replacements. While the UK does already have similar laws in place, there is nothing to completely protect them from deregulation; unless we have a government who is dedicated to doing so.
Below is my feminist analysis of some of the party manifestos, and my thoughts
Theresa May, even since she became Home Secretary, has been very adamant about her feminist views, yet in the time so far in which she has been prime minister has been surprisingly quiet about the matter. A quick google search goes to show that the conservatives, being right wing, don’t exactly have the best rep for being a feminist party. In their manifesto, their intentions to specifically help women are mentioned four times:
To ‘continue to lead a global campaign for the education of women and girls’
To ‘introduce dedicated provision for women offenders’ in the prison service
To ‘help women in the workplace’
To ‘increase the number of women sitting on boards of companies’
Undoubtedly, all four points detailed above are important, and do need to be worked upon. However, in comparison to other aspects of their manifesto, women’s rights are surprisingly generalised, and are lacking in detail. It was surprising for myself to find that the conservatives had mentioned women’s rights a similar amount of times as the Green Party had – and their manifesto was a quarter of the size. I understand that there is many different aspects of our society to take into account when it comes to publishing a manifesto, but I am shocked to know that our current government appears to have no interest in the gender pay gap or support for domestic abuse victims. Not ok.
Labour have never had a woman leader, and that’s fine. While it would be awesome to see a strong woman stand in opposition to Theresa May, it seems 2017 just is not the time. Looking to their manifesto, woman’s rights are mentioned several times. They also have a full subsection dedicated to women within Chapter 11: A More Equal Society. This includes:
At work, ‘strengthen protections for women against unfair redundancy – because no one should be penalised for having children’
Address the issue that: ‘Over 2.5 million women born in the 1950s have had their state pension age changed without fair notification,’ and act on this
Emphasising the reporting of violence against women with disabilities
‘The level of violence against women and girls is not acceptable. Labour ‘will emphasise the safety of women and girls by appointing a commissioner to set new standards for tackling domestic and sexual violence.’
It is also noted within their manifesto that: ‘Under the Conservatives, progress is being rolled back for women, people with disabilities, LGBT people and BME communities. Cuts to public services and social security are landing disproportionately on women and ethnic minorities, with 86 per cent of the money raised from the Tories’ tax and social security changes coming from women’s pockets.’
Additionally, their manifesto notes: ‘Violence against women and girls continues to be a global epidemic, affecting an estimated one in three women worldwide. In the UK, on average two women are killed by their current or a former partner every week. Under the Conservatives, over a third of all local authority funding to domestic and sexual violence services was already cut by 2012.’
Appointing A Violence Against Women Commissioner to assure ‘stable central funding for women’s refuges and rape crisis centres.’
Review support for women who have miscarriages
Labour also have a full section for LGBT Equality, Diverse Communities and People with Disabilities. Their manifesto is very clearly laid out for minorities who are looking to see what a Labour government could do for them, and it is evident that they would be striving for equality as a left wing parliament. From a feminist perspective, Labour does tick a lot of boxes. I think that in practice, Labour could do wonders for gender equality if they stayed true to their manifesto.
When it comes to the Liberal Democrats, there is a whole backstory to where they stand politically in 2017, and it is safe to say their popularity has rapidly decreased since the coalition government of 2012. Looking to their manifesto, it is not convincing to a feminist. Women’s rights are mentioned just 5 times:
To reach a goal of one million women in work by 2025. This will be done by funding more childcare and providing better back to work support
Pushing for 40% of board members in FTSE 350 companies to be female.
Establishing a Women’s Justice Board in order to meet the needs of women offenders
Protecting ‘vaccination and family planning’ internationally in the wake of the ant-vaccination trend in the USA
‘Prioritise support, protection and equal rights for women and girls, which is both right and essential for effective, sustainable economic development. We will aim to end female genital mutilation worldwide within a generation.’
The mention of combatting female genital mutilation is one that is all but unique to the Lib Dem’s manifesto thus far. In comparison to Labour, their promises when it comes to feminism and LGBT rights are very general, with no specific implications.
When hearing of the SNP’s, it is quickly to be caught up in the independence debate, but there is a lot more to Sturgeon and her party. Their manifesto states firstly how they have lobbied against the rape clause, and against the injustice that arose from women born in the 1950s having their state pension age raised. They also had a Private Member’s Bill passed, which required the UK government to do more to end domestic violence. In the next 4 years, they are promising to:
Axe the tampon tax, and until it is done so, for Scotland’s share of the tax fund to be transferred to the Scottish Government to be distributed amongst organisations working with and for women in Scotland
Pressure the UK government to limit immigration detention. ‘We continue to oppose the detention of children and vulnerable people, including pregnant women and people with mental illnesses.’
Continue the process of their Private Member’s Bill, which will commit the UK government to fund women’s refuges and rape crisis centres.
Continue to pressure the UK government to drop the rape clause.
SNP back the Women an Equalities Committee’s ‘recommendation to strengthen the law to protect women from discriminatory redundancies and practices.’
Combatting the gender pay gap in several ways:
1) ‘We will seek to ensure that any employer who loses an equal pay claim conducts and publishes an equal pay audit and then takes appropriate action on the results.’
2)’ Equal pay audits should cover gender, race and disability. SNP MPs will support lowering the threshold to 150 employees, from the current level of 250 employees, and the introduction of sanctions, including fines, for employers that fail to comply with the law.’
3) ‘We will also call on the UK government to follow the lead of the SNP Scottish Government by ensuring all public authorities with more than 20 employees provide gender pay gap reports every two years. We will also call for equal pay statements every four years, which provide policies on equal pay and occupational segregation and include reporting on gender, disability and race.’
‘To tackle workplace discrimination and sexist dress codes, SNP MPs will vote for a change in the Equality Act to strengthen and change the law that currently allows employers to have different dress codes for men and women.’
SNP promise to protect new mother’s rights currently protected under EU law, ensuring that ‘No-one should face discrimination at work because of pregnancy or childbirth.’
SNP will also rally the UK government to introduce the legal right to breastfeeding the workplace, like most other countries in the world do.
‘Building on the experience of the Scottish Government’s partnership with the United Nations to empower the women of Syria and promote Scotland as a centre for training of female peacemakers, the SNP will continue to support UN Security Council Resolution 1325 reaffirming the important role of women in the prevention and resolution of conflicts.’
SNP’s manifesto is promising from a feminist perspective. No other manifesto specifically opposes the rape clause, and promises to rally against this in parliament. They are also unique in setting out a plan to combat the gender pay gap, as well as in looking for policy with recognises and works to combat sexist dress codes. In comparison to the other manifestos, I love how SNP are actively setting out plans within their manifesto and directly explaining how they plan to put their promises into action. Similarly to Labour, they do tick a lot of the feminist boxes
The Green’s are a small party, with a very small manifesto. Within their manifesto, they promise to:
‘Implement a UK-wide strategy to tackle gender based violence, including domestic violence, rape and sexual abuse, FGM and trafficking’
Implement a UK-wide strategy to tackle gender based violence, including domestic violence, rape and sexual abuse, FGM and trafficking
End the gender pay gap, and require a minimum 40% of all members of public company and public sector boards to be women.
The Green party’s manifesto is very generalised, and while they do follow similar policies as Labour and SNP, their manifesto lacks action or information on how they will achieve these targets. As I said earlier, the volume of information on women’s rights in their manifesto is on par with the conservatives, which says more about the conservatives than the green’s when it comes to prioritising women’s rights.
Having completed my small analysis of all the main manifestos, I have to say my vote has changed. While I absolutely understand there is more to this election than feminism, feminism is something that is so important to me that it does influence my vote a lot. I urge you to have a little read of what is most important to you, and vote based on that. It is OK not to understand fully the jargon and the figures but please please please PLEASE VOTE! Your vote matters so much, even if you don’t think it does. I hope this little summary has been useful for you out there who are still perhaps on the fence, unsure of your vote. Politics can be overwhelming, set out your priorities, do a little research if you get a moment, and put a bit of education behind your vote. “Democracy cannot succeed unless those who express their choice are prepared to choose wisely. The real safeguard of democracy, therefore, is education.” Franklin D. Roosevelt. This Thursday, 8th June, VOTE!
Conservative: https://s3.eu-west-2.amazonaws.com/manifesto2017/Manifesto2017.pdf
Labour: http://www.labour.org.uk/page/-/Images/manifesto-2017/labour-manifesto-2017.pdf
Lib Dems: http://d3n8a8pro7vhmx.cloudfront.net/themes/5909d4366ad575794c000000/attachments/original/1495020157/Manifesto-Final.pdf?1495020157
SNP: https://d3n8a8pro7vhmx.cloudfront.net/thesnp/pages/9544/attachments/original/1496139998/Manifesto_2017.pdf?1496139998
Green: https://www.greenparty.org.uk/assets/files/gp2017/greenguaranteepdf.pdf