I was in a relationship with an alien part 8/??
Seems like there’s quite a bit of interest in a dedicated post about alien biology and sociology, so leave your questions in the comments and I’ll write something up soon. Please keep in mind I am neither a biologist nor a sociologist nor a xeno/anthropologist so take all of this with a grain of salt and forgive me if some of the language isn’t perfect, but on the other hand posting something that’s wrong is usually the best way to get someone in the comments to explain why it is wrong so we all win either way I guess.
Continuing where we left off with the discussion with Silk about bodies and gender.
The main issue was that for aliens, there is no distinction between biological sex, gender identity, and sexuality (as in, the experience of being capable of sexual desire). The sea urchin phase has all three, the other phases have none of them. Like I said in my last post, they have NO concept of transgender identities, and asexuality in the sea urchin phase is something they only understand as a medication side effect or illness. They do have homosexuality and as far as I can tell, there have been very few places and periods in alien history where this was considered an issue. They almost treat it as a sort of misfiring of whatever instinct drives the sea urchin phase: just something that happens, it’s the body, what can you do.
That “it’s the body, what can you do” attitude became extremely clear as we started discussing my surgeries. Silk initially didn’t realise I had had any surgeries at all, or that I was on hormone treatment. Remember they’re functionally blind, so all he was getting was they/them pronouns, a fairly gender-neutral voice, and whatever chemical signals I was giving off (I’m just going to call it scent/smell from now on, the chemical detection thing is a bit cumbersome). Now imagine you’re an alien and that’s all the information you get. It’s not unreasonable to think “oh, this must be a “parent human”, like we have”. Silk quite reasonably assumed that I was a type or phase of human that normally doesn’t go to space, just like aliens in the parent phase don’t. And my “no I started gendered like any other human and deliberately made myself like this” was completely incomprehensible to him. What do you mean, CHANGE your body to fit your mind? Your mind is shaped by the body, not the other way around!
Of course he had a point: human minds are in human bodies and our bodies shape our brains and thus our minds through millions of years of evolution. But still there’s obviously a difference between humans and aliens, who went through the same process of evolution, because we CAN experience a disconnect between our body and our mind. I took my attempts to explain this to Silk quite seriously both out of personal interest but also because it was energising to encounter a completely new category of intellectual problem. Like trying to explain colour to a blind person. I had a lot of fun trying to explain certain religions that try to achieve a complete mental separation of the body while they were still alive. Silk thought this was hilarious, I think it triggered the paradox thing.
But finally after a lot of philosophical debate when it got right down to it Silk wanted to know about me.
Now I don’t normally talk to people about my birth sex, and I won’t talk about it here, but it felt churlish not to tell Silk about it because he was trying so hard to understand. So I told him what I had started out as and what I had done to make my body fit “me”. He was quiet through most of the explanation and then he asked “But how did you know what your body needed to look like?”
And there’s no satisfying answer to that, right? “I thought about it long and hard and just knew what felt right” is not really answering anything. So I just sort of stared into space (ha I didn’t write that to be literal but as it happens I was literally staring out into space, we were sitting at a viewport) for a while and then had what I still think was a stroke of brilliance:
Me: “When you become a parent after this, you will want to go home, right?”
Him: “Yes.”
Me: “Well, how do you know what home is?”
And then it was Silk’s turn to be quiet and then, and I realise this sounds like a movie script but it really happened, he said: “You know when your body feels like home?”
So there you go, we reached a breakthrough after all. I was quite pleased with that. Felt like a proper xeno/anthropologist. And then Silk repeated back to me what he had learned over the past week: that adult humans are all either “in the reproductive phase” (i.e. sea urchins, capable of/interested in sex and romance) or not (asexual people) but that this is an individual difference not dependent on age (we did go over the impact of things like medication and hormones but this was never a point of contention because aliens have the same thing); that there is such a thing as a feeling of gender that feels like being at home in your body when it matches your body and like not being home when it doesn’t; and that if the body doesn’t feel like home, it can be made to feel right. All in all not bad for a couple of treaty law specialists.
(I can already hear someone type up a thing about aromantics: I tried, okay, but this was another thing that is completely unknown to them and I had a hard enough time making him understand asexuality. If anyone wants to give it a go, find an alien and have at it.)
And then he said: “So you are without gender, but are still in the reproductive phase?” And I said yes.
And then his spines rattled.
At first I just thought oh, he’s happy that he finally understood it. But then he went very, very still. Like, not standard sea urchin still, where their outer spikes freeze and their body spikes keep undulating, but all the little body spikes just stood up straight and still. It very much gave the impression of someone in shock, and I confirmed later that yes, that is a threat response like our fight/flight/freeze.
And then he said: “Excuse me I have to go” and just rushed out of the room.
So that ruined my entire weekend because stupid as it may sound, after a whole week of talking about bodies and sexuality it hadn’t occurred to me until right that moment that maybe Silk had a reason beyond academic interest for asking me all this.












