hey hey i appreciate the ask, but this is just a meme blog! if youre interested in rping my rp hub is over at @mudskip-muses, you can find all my blogs from there!
I'm making this guide because I noticed that while there are others with the same information elsewhere, many of them are incorrect or not as comprehensive as one might like. It started as my own personal notes, but I figured I'd go a little deeper and post it for anyone else like me who wishes to choose the "correct" dialog options/is curious what the choices not picked lead to, among other things. I plan on going through the main story to start, and then do guides for all advice/classroom questions as well as tea time and gifts for each character. This will be a post as I go project with no specific schedule in mind, so stay tuned for each chapter's guide as I will only be posting them as I complete them!! Please feel free to ask questions about any route though, or if you have something to add I may have missed and/or corrections to anything I might have gotten wrong!! I have an ungodly amount of knowledge and time into this game, may as well put it to use lol
All that being said, there WILL be spoilers!! I will do my my best to be as vague as I can overall, seeing as I can't block them out on tumblr, but I apologize if I miss something!!
General Notes:
- Byleth's canon birthday is 20th of Horsebow Moon (9/20 or September 20th for us), this makes a good default if you dont have one in mind like me
Male Romance Options (Alphabetical):
• Alois (Platonic)
• Annette
• Bernadetta
• Catherine (Unless you choose Edelgard at the midpoint in the Black Eagles Route)
• Constance
• Dorothea
• Edelgard (Black Eagles Only, Must choose her at the midpoint of the game in the Black Eagles Route)
• Flayn (Unless choosing Edelgard at midpoint in the Black Eagles route)
• Gilbert (Blue Lions only, Platonic)
• Hilda (Unless you choose Edelgard at midpoint in Black Eagles route)
• Hapi
• Ingrid
• Jeritza (Same restrictions as Edelgard)
• Leonie
• Linhardt
• Lysithea
• Manuela
• Marianne
• Mercedes
• Petra
• Rhea (Unless choosing Edelgard at the midpoint in the Black Eagles Route)
• Shamir
• Sothis
• Yuri
- Female Romance Options (Alphabetical):
• Alois (Platonic)
• Ashe
• Balthus
• Caspar
• Claude (Golden Deer Only)
• Cyril (Unless choosing Edelgard at the midpoint in the Black Eagles Route)
• Dedue (Blue Lions Only & You complete his paralouge/save at least half of the Duscar army before time skip)
• Dimitri (Blue Lions Only)
• Dorothea
• Edelgard (Same restrictions as male Byleth)
• Felix
• Ferdinand
• Gilbert (Blue Lions Only, Platonic)
• Hanneman
• Hubert (Same restrictions as Edelgard)
• Ignatz
• Jeritza (Same restrictions as male Byleth)
• Linhardt
• Lorenz
• Mercedes
• Raphael
• Rhea (Unless choosing Edelgard at the midpoint in the Black Eagles Route)
• Seteth (Unless chooseing Edelgard at midpoint during Black Eagles route)
• Sothis
• Sylvain
• Yuri
- It should be mentioned that while it is possible to gain or lose approval with Jeralt, there are no rewards or penelties for this as he does not have supports like the other characters, though he was originally intended to have them according to the game files
- Similarly; Sothis' approval only matters if you plan on pursuing her paired ending/"romance" route. Dialog options are the only way to gain or lose points, so choices that gain approval are important if you want this path, otherwise they sereve no purpose
- With gaining approval between the three house leaders, you can only earn supports with them if you choose to teach their house, afterwards you can no longer gain or lose approval with the other two. The choices during the prologue that can gain you points simply serve as a headstart of sorts for whichever house you plan to choose in the long-run.
- Each route, of which there are four despite there only being three houses, has a story of its own with different characters only accessible in that specific route. Those characters are listed above under the Romance Options for both male and female Byleth since supports between characters/Byleth's chosen S support/Ending Route are the only things really affected by them. Characters with these route specific restrictions will become locked via their supports with all characters even if they were accessible before the timeskip
- There are many supports between all the characters that also become locked after the time skip/need to be accessed before a certain point or can only be unlocked after reaching a certain point in the story. I will list those in another post and link it once finished
- As far as I can tell, if you skip a scene of dialog, if there was a choice to gain or lose approval somewhere along it, it simply doesn't affect the approval rating it was tied to. However, I would imagine if you get until a choice needs to be made, it will count towards the tally should you skip after choosing it
----
Part One; Prologue: An Inevitable Enoucounter
General information:
- You don't need to follow Jeralt's instructions if you do not wish to
- You will only lose the battle if you, Edelgard, Dimitri and Claude all fall. - Because of this, on higher difficulties it may be better to simply let Jeralt handle most, if not all of the enemies he can
Dialog Choices (In Order):
(The choices that are bolded are the ones I tend to pick simply because I feel they fit or flow better than the others, they're just there for fun uwu)
Before battle (Game Start):
- Human, ghost, demon - You have to choose human to progress, she will make you choose again minus the one you picked the first time around if you answer ghost or demon, both of which earn same response of "Do not deceive, you would do well to keep your wit in line."
- War: "Massive armies clashing on a vast field, right? There hasn't been a battle like that in over three centuries..."
Girl: "You've described her to me before, I don't think I've ever met anyone like that.."
- "Oh, right" or "Of course" Both earn the same response but "of course" nets Jeralt approval +1 while "oh, right" is -1
Battle Dialog:
- Have the three kids talk to you (Byleth) if you'd like, it's just there as extra flavor. If not, here's what they say:
Edelgard: "You have a strange aura about you...You say you're a mercenary, so show me what you can do."
Dimitri: "Thank you. We are in your debt. It wouldn't do for us to fall in a place like this. Please, lend us your strength. Let's work together to drive our these thieves!"
Claude: "It's because of you guys I'm not dead right now. Thanks for that! I didn't expect to run into mercenaries like you in some remote village. The gods of fortune must be smiling on me!"
Unique boss dialog upon first initiated combat against/by Kostas (also a simple extra):
- Byleth - "Hey, you with the blank stare! Outta my way!"
- Dimitri, Claude, Edelgard - "I'm gonna kill you where you stand..."
- Jeralt - K: "What the?! Aren't you Jeralt the blade breaker? What's a renowned mercenary like you doing here?"
J: "I'm the one who should be complaining. I'm caught up in the mess you started!"
After battle w/ Sothis:
- "What are you talking about?" or "Sothis?" both earn "I was not able to recall my name... until just now."
- "I am no child." - "Ha! Such arrogance. You look the part, but are you truly an adult?"
"I'm less than a child?" - "Correct! You understnad." (+1 Sothis approval)
- "Thank you." - "There now. Is gratitude so much to ask? I did deem you worth saving, after all"
"You stopped time?" - "Hm. I do not hear your gratitude. Perhaps I should force you to leave?"
Either way you give your thanks and earn the same response as if you thanked her right off
- "What will happen when time resumes?" or "What now?" both earn "When time begins again, the axe will tear into your flesh, and you will surely meet your end."
- "Turn back the hands of time" - "Of course! I must turn back the hands of time!" (+1 Sothis approval)
"Keep time frozen until I'm safe" - "That is ridiculous! Oh, but perhaps..."
"I'll just stay here and wait to die" - "As if I could stand idly by and watch that come to pass! Oh, but perhaps..." (-1 Sothis approval)
After Battle:
"He is a stranger to me" & "I'm a bandit" both earn "Great sense of humor, this one. Clearly cut from the same cloth as the captain" from Alois BUT the first earns -1 approval from Jeralt while the second you get +1 from Alois instead
"That is correct" - "Is that so? Well, physical differences aside, your mannerisms do remind me of the captain."
- "The Knights of Seiros?" - E: "You haven't heard of the Knight's of Seiros? The most famous knights in all of Fodlan?
"I didn't know he was a captain" - "How curious. I'd wager the explaination for that is fascinating indeed." (+1 Edelgard Approval)
- Andrestian Empire: "A wise choice. Though the Empire has fallen from its former glory, the other regions are merely offshoots that pale in comparison." (+1 Edelgard Approval)
Fareghus: "Understood. Faerghus is a noble and distinguished kingdom that has always valued chivalry." (+1 Dimitri Approval)
Alliance: "Is that right? Well, that's a win for the Alliance, so I suppose I'm obligated to be happy." (+1 Claude Approval)
- At the choice to ruminate in your thoughts between Dimitri, Edelgard, and Claude it doesn't matter which one nor the order you pick them in as you will go through all three before progressing.
Edelgard: (She is a refined young woman...But I feel as though she is always evaluating me...)
Dimitri: (He seems quite sincere...But I sense a darkness lurking beneath...)
Claude: (His easy smile is striking...But that smile doesn't reach his eyes...)
After that, you all begin your trek to the Monastery
(End of Prologue)
Chapter One, Part One: White Clouds
General Notes:
- You are considered part of the church until choosing a house, this is a good point to save after completeing the first quest but before you report back to Rhea if you wish to do different routes in the future but do not wish to go through the prologue or charcter interactions again. Any dialog choices made during it will not have an effect on anything but approval points, which are easily gained even if you didn't choose whichever options would gain you one of the three's approval
- During your first quest, Informal Introductions, while you do have to speak to each leader to progress the quest, you do not have to actually go through all the students they will tell you about. It's just a general look into their stats as well as a short insight as to what the house leader thinks of them. Interesting, but not nessecary. When they ask if you would like to hear more, say no and it will end the conversation but count as "speaking" to them. They do not comment on this nor is there a penelty for not listening to them
- You can speak with many other students/faculty in greeting in this stage as well. It doesn't count towards anything, but again, it's an intersting look into the characters.
- In order to speak with those on the far end of the second floor (the offices/library), you either should go at any point beforespeaking with all three of the house leaders, or choose to keep exploring if prompted once speaking with the three, then head to the second floor, speak to who you wish and head back to the glowing spot at the entrance of the audience chamber where you started to complete the quest
Dialog Options:
-"Her?" - "You saw her in the courtyard earlier, didn't you? The archbishop...Lady Rhea."
"You've been here before?" - "I've never spoken of this to you before, but...many years ago, I was a knight here. I reported to the archbishop...Lady Rhea."
- "The archbishop?" & "Lady Rhea?" both earn "As you know, the majority of the folks in Fodlan are devout followers of the teachings or Seiros. The leader of that ridiculously large relious organization is the archbishop. Lady Rhea."
- "My name is..." Rhea: "A fine name indeed" (+1 Rhea Approval)
"..." - Seteth: "You must at least show the basic curtosy of telling us your name! Do you not think you are being a bit rude to the archbishop?"
Rhea: "It is alright, Seteth. My Dear, I am called Lady Rhea. I am the archbishop of the Church of Seiros.
In truth, I was only being polite. I already know your name, and what a fine name it is."
- "As a servent?" & "As a mercenary?" both earn "Nothing like that. They want you to teach, by the sound of it"
-"You're a physician?" - "(Good-natured laugh) I look too pretty for that line of work, do I? But yes, when I'm not teaching, I can be found in the infirmary."
"You're a songstress?" "Of course. Before I came here, I belonged to a renowned opera comapny. Perhaps you've heard of me? The Mittelfrank Opera Comapny's beautiful, peerless--"
After choosing house (Happens no matter the choice):
- "Do what you can to find out "- "Yes of course. I'll get to the bottom of it straight away" (+1 Hanneman Approval)
"There is no need" - I most strongly disagree! There absolutly is a need. My Crest research is of critical importance to the church, I'll have you know. Since you are now a professor here, I must insist that you aid in my research.
Of course, there are those who lack the foresight to aid in my endeavors, such as that stubborn Seteth. But such individuals are the rare exception."
Either way, you comply and discover you have a "Mystery Crest"
---
This is the end of the prologue/the initial start of chapter one where you become the professor for the class you picked earlier. I'm starting with the Blue Lions route as I feel it is best for the first playthrough because of how it plays out in the key points of the story. Ultimately it doesn't matter which order you play them in, it's simply my opinion this is a good place to start if you wish to better understand the main plotline (I'm also biased for Dimitri, but that's neither here nor there lol)
I will post the dialog options and other such important moments/information like that above as I complete the chapters. Again, I cannot promise this will be done in a timely manner nor on a schedule, simply when they are completed I will post them. I will link back to Chapter One of each route here as they're posted as well!!
theartofmadeline
dededos
origamiaround
kaledo-art
pixelskylines
tangentwithtanner
ellievsbear
