While reading the case, it was very easy to distinguish products with high market potential and adoption rates. In particular, I decided to explore two products, one of which I believe will be slow to diffuse in the market (the sliced peanut butter) and the other which I expect to diffuse rapidly in the market (the silver nanocrystal band-aids).
I have outlined my thoughts below:
What is the market potential for each of the products? There is a small market potential for this product. It can be used by virtually anyone who wants to efficiently and quickly make peanut butter sandwiches. Unfortunately, the product use is limited to sandwiches, as I believe people will prefer to use regular peanut butter while preparing other snacks.
Time to reach market: Slow - I think people are familiar with the jar container packaging for peanut butter products. They may be hesitant to try peanut butter in slice form.
Relative advantage: The sliced peanut butter allows one to create sandwiches quickly and easily without tearing the bread or using a fork or knife.
Compatibility: The product is not compatible with current peanut butter offerings on the market. The product is presented in a different shape and form than that of traditional product offerings. Consumers may feel that this packaging will impact taste, freshness, consistency and texture of a traditional peanut butter sandwich or other peanut butter snacks.
Complexity: The product is not complex for consumers to use if they are creating peanut butter sandwiches. It may be complex to use if the peanut butter slices are used while preparing other peanut butter snacks. In addition, I would imagine that this product would need to be refrigerated unlike traditional spreadable peanut butter.
Trialability: The product is easy to test by consumers.
Observability: The product is observable to a degree if the consumer prepares food items around others. The slices in the end product may not be observable to others.
All in all, this product has a small market potential. Although it is not complex, easy to test and is relatively observable, I believe that the product will be adopted at normal pace due to its in-compatibility with current peanut butter product offerings. Peanut butter is a traditional American spread with a longstanding tradition and history in the country. The negative impact of changing the consistency of the condiment outweighs the efficiencies it brings to the user.
2) The Silver screen takes on germs
What is the market potential for each of the products? There is a large market potential for this product. Consumers can treat serious burns and injuries more effectively with this over the counter treatment.
Time to reach market potential? This product will be reach market potential rapidly as it is presents a relative advantage, it is compatible with current product offerings, is easy to test/use and can be observable to others.
• How do Rogers’ five factors apply to the four products?
Relative advantage – The product offers an advantage to kill germs and treat wounds effectively with silver nanocrystals. The band-aid prevents further infection and this can save consumers time and money. Currently, this is the only type of band-aid that is available for customers to use over the counter.
Compatibility: The product is very compatible with current offerings. The product looks and feels like a regular band-aid.
Complexity: The product is very easy to use.
Trialability: The product is very easy to test. In fact, the FDA has approved these band-aids to treat serous wounds. This approval will give the OTC products instant credibility in the market.
Observability: The product can be observable to others if the manufacturer chooses to design the band-aid to have a distinguishable color or shape.
All in all, this is product is highly disruptive and its ease of use and relative advantage will allow it to be quickly adopted in the market.