514. The Paula Poundstone Show, 10/30/1993, 11/6/1993
I associate this show with Halloween when I was 10. No, I didn't watch it the night it aired, because it aired on a Saturday at 10pm, but for some reason I remember the show from the constant promotion. I distinctly remember her giving those trick or treaters the show's logo.
Thing is, why would I know who Paula was when I was 10? I feel like I remember seeing her on TV before this, but I didn't watch her classic Cats, Cops, and Stuff until I was in middle school when Comedy Central showed it all the time. I think I was just interested in her from those commercials, I guess? We watched a lot of ABC back then, so the promos were inescapable. This fellow kid on Reddit remembers the commercials being shown relentlessly as well.
Also lil me wouldn't forget someone who dressed as quirky as she did. I loved quirky clothes back then as much as I do now.
She hosted the ABC Saturday Night movie two weeks before as a way to promote the show. The movie was When Harry Met Sally.
The graphics department was ITC Curlz'ing it UP. There's this cute bit where Paula and Pepe the dog reenact the infamous scene from the movie.
(source, TV Guide Fall Preview 1993 issue)
Early press on the show wasn't that great?
Take “The Paula Poundstone Show,” which has a star in stand-up comic Poundstone and a network in ABC, but apparently not much else at this writing. Ask ABC for details regarding this Saturday-night hour, and the response is hemming, hawing and shuffling feet. What is “The Paula Poundstone Show” about? The answer you finally get could apply to much of television itself. 1
Not long after ABC announced a 13-episode order for this series, rumblings began that the show was in trouble because it didn't have a concept. And up until a few weeks ago, it still didn't have a concept. That attitude will probably be its strength as well as its weakness: Series may seem too loose and goofy to attract masses of Saturday night viewers, but cult status seems assured. 2
The comedian is fighting a series of minor skirmishes with the network to create a program that's a comfortable fit for her, if not cut from typical TV cloth.
"I suppose it's a cross between a variety show and a talk show, I guess. But I don't really have a good one-word description," Poundstone says. "I realize this has somehow bothered people."
There are fresh cautionary tales out there about folks who said they wanted to be different, but had a hard time describing exactly what that meant.
Remember The Chevy Chase Show? Talk show by a tall guy, movie star type, lasted shy of two months? Going in, Chase and Fox Broadcasting Co. said the show would be different. Uh huh.
Now comes Poundstone, echoing those comments. Uh oh. 3
Ok ok ok, I'll begin watching the first episode. There's one copy on the Internet Archive , and there's another copy on YouTube. The YouTube copy is missing the first few seconds.
There's a brief house tour. She has a water pistol in case her cats are bad, and she keeps take out menus in her dishwasher. Check out the fax machine.
Shelley the recycling lady. Telephone books used to take up a lot of room in landfills! I think the phonebook my parents and I got at the house this year was 50 pages. It was less pages than a monthly magazine.
Paula's "oh you're 90s rich rich" tv set.
Ned Flanders was in the audience! Ned's father in law liked Paula's recent coverage at the Emmy awards, which sadly I cannot find on YouTube. I vaguely remember this! Until ten minutes ago, my entire life I thought that was Ellen doing commentary. I remember a joke about Paula showing things backstage. One of the things was a high ladder that went into crawlspace? She joked that a very pregnant Laurie Metcalf had to climb that ladder to get to the press room. See, I'm not explaining the joke correctly.
The timeline of other Saturday night at 10pm shows on ABC. Love Boat was the last show to succeed at that time slot. I think that season of China Beach was the season before it was put on hiatus during the middle of its final season.
"The two hundred people here may be the only viewers!"
She then measures audience shares with cookies with a guy from ABC as her guest. She gives a cookie to someone in the audience who remembered Pink Lady and Jeff. Paula's show needed 12 cookies to stay on the air.
Sam Donaldson reading Where the Wild Things Are. How did they get the rights to read that book? Is Sam still with us? *googles* Yes, he's 91!
Did the audience get beer?
Lowlights:
People in the audience kinda didn't get her standup at the beginning, I don't think? The response was a little tepid? David.
Talking to economists on a teacup ride. This subject was just too serious for a comedy show. Don't bum us out about the economy while we're trying to have a good time.
Since Paula couldn't talk to a Neilsen family, she talked to people who lived next to Leslie Neilsen? According to one of the kids, nobody gives out Halloween candy in that neighborhood.
JOEL FROM MST3K?! What are you doing here?! Oh, now I KNOW there has to be some posts about this show in the MST3K newsgroup archives. I didn't really see any!
(source)
The second episode aired on November 6, an hour earlier at 9pm. Why did ABC do that? Way to confuse your viewers, ABC. I only found one promo for the second episode.
Carl Lewis. She channels him to a race for December 4th. Oh.
According to Paula, Jackie Joyner-Kersee was going to help train her in an episode in her race against Carl! She told Paula that Carl starts races slow and then speeds up, so Paula should start the race fast to give her an edge. 4
Paul and Senator Paul Simon ride on some amusement park rides while he gives her a lesson in Civics. I wondered why we hadn't heard from him lately. He died in 2003.
Paula gave a little shout out to Nurses on NBC: "the home viewer right now could switch to watch Nurses." My mom and I would watch that show on Saturday nights.
The nurses lounge bit with Lily Tomlin when Paula splats ketchup on her with a syringe.
Al Green singing "Love is a Beautiful Thing." I remember hearing the Michael Bolton cover of this song on the radio constantly around this time. This version is better. No offense to Michael, I love Michael.
She talks to a 17 year old boy named Curtis who works at a movie theater in Idaho. They were decked!out! for Addams Family Values. The hardest part of his job was telling customers the price of popcorn. It was ... $3.50 for a large popcorn in 1993. I checked the amc app, and it's $10.79 right now at the amc in my hometown of Hampton, Virginia. The audience was grossed out to find out that the theater kept the leftover popcorn til the next morning in case the popcorn maker is broken. (Oh, turns out the audience is drinking soda!)
Lowlights:
The opening segment was so dry. It was Paula getting out of a hot tub in a full scuba suit with flippers, picking up the shows logo, and walking into the studio. Mr. Blackwell had criticized her fashion the week before in TV Guide apparently.
The conversation with the CPA who recognized the movie The Trouble with Angels. Thankfully, Al Green's baby crying in the dressing room interrupted them.
The budget bit? Where Paula brought up a guy who tried to explain the 1993 budget? That bit took too long! More people in Iowa on a Saturday night!
Paula talking to the practices lady, Susan from ABC again at the end of the show. It was the same.exact.bit.
And that's a wrap for Paula. That was it. The show did not get those 12 cookies it needed. It got NO COOKIES:
ABC, not amused by rock-bottom ratings, has canceled "The Paula Poundstone Show" after only two airings. "Matlock" reruns are filling in while the network tries to decide what to do with the tough 8 p.m. Saturday time slot. Poundstone's self-consciously quirky mix of music, comedy and audience interaction finished 96th in the Nielsens in its second and final outing, coming in just above Fox's last-place "Townsend Television." 5
This show would've slapped on Comedy Central back in 1993, however I don't know if Comedy Central had money for something of this level back then.
The end of year TV reviews were harsh:
The Paula Poundstone Show" (ABC)/ Canceled after two episodes, Poundstone's new-wave variety show was about as enthralling as an old-fashioned high-school assembly. 8
The Paula Poundstone Show got a double exposure before ABC yanked it into oblivion.
The ratings for both shows were disastrous, and not just compared with those of other new network programs this season. They made history. South of Sunset had what are believed to be the lowest numbers of any big-three-network prime-time fall premiere since ratings began. In its second week, Poundstone's numbers were even worse than Sunset's.
"The Paula Poundstone Show wasn't just weak," said Alan Sternfeld, ABC senior vice president for program planning and scheduling. "It was extremely weak. Live From Studio 8-H With Zubin Mehta could have gotten the same numbers." 9
We all remember South of Sunset.
There were some nice things critics said about the show:
Worst use of talent: ABC's jilting of ``The Paula Poundstone Show'' after a two-episode engagement.
Poundstone was an erratic rambler. But if ABC hadn't forced her to cut out the heart of her stand-up act, she would have rocked boats and won viewers with a humorous but hard-edged package of opinions and common sense. 6
The Paula Poundstone Show, ABC: Standup comic Paula Poundstone can be hilarious, but this hour-long variety series, while showing flashes of real brilliance, spread her too thin. 7
In closing, here is a giant poster for her show that I found on eBay from seller Lost Vintage, who has several posters of other short lived ABC programs from the early 90s. I tried to make a $30 offer for that poster, but they were charging $20 for shipping. Nah, I can barely afford food right now. I need my lil treats.
Facebook | Etsy | Retail History Blog | Twitter | YouTube Playlist | Random Post | Ko-fi donation | instagram / threads @thelastvcr | tik tok @ saleintothe90s | TeePublic Store | BlueSky
Rosenberg, Howard. “THE NEW TV SEASON : You Can Laugh All You Want . . . : Of the 38 New Series, Five Are Stellar Comedies. That’s Nice. But Where Are the Dramas with Something to Say about Life?” Los Angeles Times, September 13, 1993. https://www.latimes.com/archives/la-xpm-1993-09-13-ca-35403-story.html.
Gray, Tim. “The Paula Poundstone Show.” Variety, October 29, 1993. https://variety.com/1993/tv/reviews/the-paula-poundstone-show-1200433536/.
LYNN ELBER. 1993, Oct 30 "LETTING LOOSE THAT'S WHAT COMEDIAN PAULA POUNDSTONE IS DOING ON ABC. CELEBRITIES AND EVERYDAY FOLK WILL GET THEIR SHOT ON HER NEW NOT- QUITE-TALK, NOT- QUITE-VARIETY TV SHOW.: [ALL EDITION]." Sun Sentinel, 3.
Poundstone, Paula. There’s Nothing in This Book That I Meant to Say. Three Rivers Press, 2007. 55.
Pennington, Gail. 1993, Nov 16 "POUNDSTONE'S QUIRKINESS DRAWS TOO FEW VIEWERS: [FIVE STAR EDITION]." St.Louis Post - Dispatch, 6D.
Engstrom, John. "CHECKING THE TUBE CONTRAST AT MIDSEASON." Seattle Post-Intelligencer, December 31, 1993: 26.
Smith, Steven Cole. "Facing the nation - The television networks produced a mixed bag of tricks this year, not all of which were magical." Fort Worth Star-Telegram, December 29, 1993: 1
Holston, Noel. "One year's story - It's the best of TV, it's the worst of TV - choice viewing." Star Tribune: Newspaper of the Twin Cities, December 27, 1993: 01E.
Storm, Jonathan. "NOW YOU SEE THEM, NOW YOU DON'T." Philadelphia Inquirer, The , November 21, 1993: H01.