5 things that give us hope from the season two premiere of True Detective
True Detective is back, and this time it has brought a whole new set of dysfunctional characters.
Goodbye to Rust and Marty, and hello to a new load of struggling cops and a brooding mobster.
When do Rust and Marty turn up? #TrueDetectiveSeason2
â Spooner (@Spoonerverse15) June 22, 2015
In the episode we meet Colin Farrellâs alcoholic detective Ray Velcoro, see how his relationship with mobster Frank Semyon, played by Vince Vaughn, came about. We also meet two more cops, played by Rachel McAdams and city manager, and start to see how the disappearance of a city manager brings them together.
Mostly, though, we sit around to comparing it to season one. How could we not? Hereâs how it shaped upâŠ
2 minutes into #TrueDetective and the theme tune sucks. That's 1-0 to season 1.
â Robin Edds (@robinedds) June 22, 2015
#TrueDetectiveSeason2 worst themetune ever
â Eamonn Moran (@Eamonnmoran) June 22, 2015
Wtf is this bad ass new theme tune to #TrueDetectiveSeason2 ? Brilliant tune
â simon_tucker (@simontucker1979) June 22, 2015
Letâs get one thing straight, we LOVED the theme tune to the first season, Far From Any Road by the Handsome Family. It perfectly summed up the drama â dark, brooding, slightly creepy, 100% American and utterly compelling.
We werenât entirely sure what to make of the new one. Leonard Cohenâs Nevermind was very similar and very different â slow, tuneless and bleak, weâre somehow wondering if that means this series is going to be even darker than the first.
While we canât imagine too many people went straight to iTunes to download it, we like the Wire-esque way different series are using their theme tunes to set the tone.
Test two: The rehabilitating actor
Here comes the #McVaughnaissance. I know I buy in. Do you? #TrueDetective
â Taz Matsui (@TazMatsui) June 22, 2015
The only standout performance in the first episode has come from Vince Vaughn. #TrueDetective
â Amar bin Ayub (@AlephAmar) June 22, 2015
I can't take Vince Vaughn seriously in @TrueDetective. I'm just expecting him to crack a joke every time he speaks. #TrueDetective
â Anthony Shannon (@AnthonyShannon2) June 22, 2015
This is a very big moment in the career of Vaughn, the actor who announced himself as the tremendous Swingers nearly two decades ago and has been in nothing but utter drivel ever since.
In season one we saw Matthew McConaughey â he of the dreadful rom-coms â in the midst of his McConaissance, reinventing himself with this show and films like Killer Joe, Dallas Buyers Club and Interstellar.
McConaugheyâs turn as Rust Cohle was truly one of the most mesmerising TV performances of recent years. As mobster Semyon, Vaughn has a long way to go to match that â and a far worse back catalogue to try and forget. Weâre keeping an open mind â thereâs a quiet menace to Vaughnâs performance thatâs promising, but itâs not enough for us to forgive him for Fred Claus just yet.
Test three: Female characters
Fifteen minutes in and the new series of True Detective has passed the Bechdel Test. Hurrah!!
â Ali Jackson-Carter (@alisonmjackson) June 22, 2015
So I'm probably not going to stop talking about how great Rachel McAdams is for the next month⊠#TrueDetective
â Emma Brooke (@ejbrooke) June 22, 2015
Rachel McAdams the only thing keeping me interested. Nice not watching her in her stereotypical role #TrueDetective pic.twitter.com/FC7PIKW3gY
â Shuja Pasha (@Shuj7) June 22, 2015
One criticism of the first season was its depiction of women. All the major protagonists were men, with most of the women there simply in the context as being wives, girlfriends or victims â all a bit one-dimensional in what was an otherwise beautifully complex show.
This time around, we have genuine female leads â one, at least, in the form of McAdamsâ detective Ani Bezzerides. Sheâs a million miles away from a cliched female character â terse, driven, sexually confident and downtrodden all in one.
Couple that with her Bechdel-positive scenes with her sister and an impressive turn from Brit Kelly Reilly as Vaughnâs wife, and it looks like this series has gone a long way to answering the showâs woman troubles.
Test four: The double act
I miss Matthew McConaughey and Woody Harrelson #TrueDetective
â lara cannon melchor (@littlelaz_) June 22, 2015
I'm convinced that Farrell's character has more evil in him than Vaughn's.
â Joe (@Interestein) June 22, 2015
A Solid premiere for @TrueDetective. Colin Farrell & Rachel McAdams look like being the standout stars of the series. Cant wait for the rest
â Anthony Shannon (@AnthonyShannon2) June 22, 2015
McConaugheyâs on-screen chemistry with his co-star Woody Harrelson was probably the main reason for the showâs success. The pair are similar in a lot of ways, but their wildly different characters made for one the best screen partnerships in years.
As yet, a driving central relationship has not emerged in the new series. Instead we have whatâs shaping up to be a triangle between Vaughn, McAdams and Colin Farrellâs broken and self-loathing detective Ray Velcoro. It could end up making the show even richer â or it could end up being muddled.
Only time will tell, but the characters are all intriguing in their own right â so we expect great things when they clash.
Off to an emphatic start. Complex & arresting television. #TrueDetective @skyatlantic
â Chris Haydon (@Haydonsmovies) June 22, 2015
I'm out. Seems like it won't be worth sitting through all this preamble. I'll catch up if general consensus contradicts me. #TrueDetective
â Maria (@Maria_____airaM) June 22, 2015
omg can something happen already!?!? #TrueDetective
â gitit cohen (@gita212) June 22, 2015
Itâs episode one, so of course itâs a scene-setter. What grabbed us in season one was the narrow focus of the show â yes it was grindingly and unremittingly bleak, but with its nods to the occult and clearly defined relationships it was easy to work out exactly what the show was. With so much going on here, it wasnât quite so easy to see why youâd come back for more.
When season one finished, the speculation about series two was over who would be playing the two series leads, as that one central relationship seemed to be at the heart of what the show was.
This is a new True Detective, though, not about two people. If this first episode is anything to go by, itâs dealt with some of the showâs weaknesses, but found some new ones along the way.