RABBIT PIE - a traditional pastry dish of the Wildwood Elezen formed to resemble a rabbit, but not necessarily containing any meat of leporine origin.
ingrediants:
1lb of steak (of your choice). I used sirloin here, as I got lucky and there was a sale. Any kind of stewing meat is fine though.
4 stalks of celery
4 medium carrots
handful of baby asparagus (do NOT use full sized arugula. it’s much too big) OPTIONAL
4 potatoes
1 yellow onion
3 tablespoons garlic
1 1/2 containers beef broth
1 cup of flour
1 cup of butter
1/2 cup marsala wine (can sub for sherry or red wine if accessible)
2 pie crusts
variety of spices (for taste)
Despite this recipe being in the 11-21 category of culinarian, this recipe took a lot of time to complete! It’s not hard per-say, but you’ll need some dedicated time to prepare this. Don’t worry. It pays off ~ !
First you’ll need to prepare you veggies! Keep your cuts of the vegetables small and bite sized, otherwise the pie filling will be too chunky. We want a smooth pie filling! Everything should be at least an inch cut or smaller. Potatoes I quartered and then quartered again. Carrots you can cut in half and then cut into your inch pieces from there. Celery is fairly easy to cut, just be sure to cut off the dirty roots. Asparagus, though it is optional, adds another veggie to the mix and just adds an extra body to the filling and can be cut into inch stalks. When you’re finished, place in a bowl and set aside. Add some garlic to the veggies as well (I used pre-cut garlic)
Now, for the steak! If you’re using stew meat, you don’t have to prep your meat save for salt and pepper. Get some oil and garlic going in a pot and toss the meat in to begin browning. If you got yourself a full steak like I did, begin to cube it into one inch sized cubes so it’s bite sized and able to get tender. Don’t forget the salt and pepper! For my meat, I had to cut it from the fat which keeps it fresh and moist while not in use. The marbling of the steak (or the meat-to-fat ratio) is very important here as that will tell us how the cut of meat will hold up to stewing.
Now that your meat is cubed and ready, and if you skipped the second step, grab your pot, some oil and garlic and start browning your meat! YOU ARE NOT COOKING THE MEAT FULLY THROUGH HERE. It’s just a quick sear! Your meat should look like this when it’s all said and done. Notice we’ve got a nice brown color to the meat, but it’s not cooked through. That’s perfect!
Now we move onto making our gravy. You can now add your veggies to the meat with one container of beef broth. Cover and let it stew for about twenty minutes. During this time you can add your other spices to the dish. I added taragon, rosemary, marjoram, dill, oregano, salt and pepper. This will not only flavor our filling will the veggies and the meat but the flavor will transfer to our gravy! Let this stew for about twenty minutes or so on medium heat
When the stewing is almost complete, grab another pot. This will be the pot for our roux. Roux, if you don’t know, is butter and flour and is used to make gravy and the base for other thick sauces. It’s fairly easy to make and even easier to mess up. The key to a good roux is equal parts butter and equal parts flour. Get our butter melting in your second pot (about half the butter as directed). Once it’s halfway melted, begin sprinkling in your flour (also about half as directed). If you feel like there is not enough roux OR it is not smooth enough, melt in the rest of your butter and sprinkle in the rest of your flour until you have a nice smooth roux.
By this time, our veggies and meat should be done stewing. Lower the heat and begin pouring the liquid from our filling pot into the one with the roux. Don’t worry if any veggies get into the gravy! Grab a whisk now and begin stirring the roux and the liquid together! A couple things -- the gravy should be SMOOTH when it is finished. If it is not, you may have added too much flour. If that’s the case, open your second container of beef broth and add a tablespoon of broth and stir it again. It also, because of our addition of garlic, may appear to have pockets of flour but i can assure you it’s just the garlic. If you’re nervous though, keep whisking until its the consistency you want.
Once the gravy is finished, add it back into your pot with the veggies and meat. Add in about 2 cups more of beef brother and a cup of marsala wine. If you happen to have red wine on hand, use that! Sherry cooking wine also works! I used marasala cause it goes great with the vegetables, especially the asparagus and gives the meat a nice full-bodied and earthy flavor. Feel free to add some more spices here. The gravy should be flavorful enough but I added a little more salt, pepper and I threw in some cayenne pepper for good measure. Once everything is mixed thoroughly together, set your stove to low and cover your pot. You’ll need about four to five hours for everything to stew properly together.
Once you have about an hour left into stewing, grab your pie crusts (which should be frozen) and let them defrost. I made the mistake of trying to roll my dough too early and I tore through it. This is fine though! You can still work with torn pie crust. Butter your dish and lay the crust into your pie tin or (in my case) casserole dish. This will ensure that the pie crust doesn’t stick to the bottom and tear further. You can set your oven to 400 degrees now and if you see fit, crisp the bottom pie crust for about five minutes. Once everything is finished, add your filling to the dish.
Grab an egg and when you’ve covered your pie with the second crust, coat the top with a bit of eggwash. This will ensure that the crust doesn’t burn and that it stay crispy and moist. I also added a little course salt to the top of the crust for some crispness! Bake for about twenty minutes and....
Tada!! Your pie is complete! Sorry it doesn’t look like a rabbit, but I promise it tastes good enough for the Wildwood Elezen! Serve as soon as you can and cover with tinfoil for later. I know I’ll be eating this for weeks! It’s great to share with friends and if you have any leftover filling that didn’t make it into the large pie, save it for later and get yourself some individual puff pastries and cook yourself some individual pies as a nice treat to yourself.
And let me tell you what .. it tastes SO much better than anything from the frozen food aisle! In fact, this picture is from my second helping! It was so good I almost forgot to show you!
If you have any questions or concerns, please send me a message and share with me your cooking adventures!











