In this verse, Billy gets portrayed during his teen years, especially during the events of the movie. Driven by revenge and his emotions, he plans the murders of multiple people before the final showdown at Stu’s house where he gets shot by Sidney.
Verse Two - canon divergent
Billy survives the night Sidney stabbed him with the umbrealla and Gale shot him. Billy didn’t make his final move, believing he was slowly dying before he got recovered still alive and the ambulance brought him to the hospital. Billy received medical treatment and after a few months he was brought to court and pleaded guilty for his murders. He went to jail for two years and after getting into arguments and fights with cell mates, he was brought to a psychiatric hospital after he had killed one of his cell mates by choking him to death. He was only 18 when he was locked away in a single room and a doctor came to talk to him every day. And Billy changed. His whole behaviour changed. The sessions he went to helped him go through the process of his grief, releasing the anger and finally being able to let the past go. After 7 years, he was proven stable and Billy was sent back to prison for another 16 years. To be released for good behaviour, Billy was a free man again at the age of 42. Instead of moving somewhere else for a new start, Billy thought there was a lot to make up for and so he remained in Woodsboro, right before the murder in 2022 started.
It was known that Billy was free again and after Tara got attacked, police considered him the number one suspect and arrested him. Even though he declared his innocence, no one believed him and he was kept at the sheriff station for the time remaining. Even after the killing continued, police didn’t believe him a word since he had fooled them once and was marked a black sheep. After he found out that Sam was his daughter, he asked the police as for why he would be going after his daughter? He had no family left, his father abandoned him the moment the truth had been revealed and he had been alone for 25 years. Billy was longing for a family, and Sam was a part of his.
Police released him and he was tricked into being part of the bigger game and he found himself back at Stu’s house where it all started. Amber and Richie had never believed that their movie could become even better by not only framing Sam to be the maniac of the story but also her father being in the picture again. Billy was shot again, same way he was 25 years ago, laying on the floor bleeding. Sam killed Richie, Tara shot Amber and the nightmare was over. Billy had his chance to apologize to both Gale and Sidney that night, and spoke his sympathies for Dewey’s death. They all decided it was time to make a cut and move past this, leaving Billy back to finally start his new life.
He moved to New York with Sam and Tara after talking to them. Mad at their mother for abandon them as well, he promised to be there and look out for them.
Verse Three - canon divergent with @faeryworlds
Back in 1996, Billy and Sidney had their first time together before the final night, resulting in Sidney becoming pregnant. Sidney told him at the party the night at Stu’s house. He had a change of heart about what he had planned to do, knowing he could not risk to lose his child or its mother. He called things off and Stu was turning mad, not only trying to kill Sidney but also shooting Billy right through the heart. But he missed. Billy was on the floor, bleeding like hell before he was brought to the hospital for recovery. Sidney went on to kill Stu by pushing a telly onto his head but the truth had been revealed that Billy had been part of this nightmare and so Sidney broke up with him and never wanted to see him again. After his recovery, Billy was brought to court and received his life sentence. After that, Sidney found out that the baby had survived the horror she had been through, and not only was she carrying one child but two. Torn between having the babies or not, she decided to not kill any more lives and have the babies. Billy had tried multiple times to reach out to Sidney, trying to explain himself. And she only went once to see Billy. She never told him about keeping the babies or that it had been two. She made a cut, telling him to leave her alone and he never saw her again.
Billy worked hard on himself the next years, making sure he saw psychiatrist every day to deal with his trauma and pain. And only fifteen years later he was released from prison for good behaviour. Billy knew it may be a bad idea to go see Sidney but he was in a better place now and he wanted to at least tell her how sorry he was for what he did. Sidney wasn’t home to that point, she had been on tour promoting her book. And that’s where he met his children. Hayley had opened the door, when she told him her mother wasn’t home. And Billy was quick to collect the pieces together, knowing Sidney had kept the baby. Hayley found the situation rather weird before her brother Riley appeared behind her. And Billy knew there had been two of them. Shocked by the news, he didn’t tell them his name or anything, just leaving them back in confusion.
Sidney returned a few days later, her final stop of the tour being in Woodsboro and Billy went to see her. He had lots of questions but before Sidney had even the chance to tell him to leave her alone, the police interrupted them by revealing the bloody knife in the trunk of Sidney’s car. The killing started again and Billy was immediately framed the number one suspect and brought to the sheriff station. Of course, he declared his innocence but no one believed him and so he was kept inside. The killing continued and Billy was kept away until the killers were revealed. Sidney felt a little sorry for blaming Billy again and agreed on giving him at least a chance to get to know his children. He did try his best and Hayley seemed to be okay by getting to know her father while Riley had a rather tough start with him. He didn't want to spend his time with a framed killer and he did everything to go against him. But only two years later, Hayley suddenly turned out to be the trouble child while Riley slowly came to peace with his father. He was giving him a chance, seeing the way he tried his best every day. During this time, a few little sparks came up between Sidney and Billy again but they quickly faded after it came out that Sam was his daughter and that Billy had cheated back then on Sidney. The trust was gone and Sidney decided it was time for a change. She had offered her kids to come along but both denied her offer. Riley felt better sticking with his father and watching out he stood out of trouble, and Hayley didn’t want to leave her brother. But as soon as Hayley turned 18, she left Woodsboro along with Sam. She had offered Riley to go with her but he decided to stay with his father once again.
In 2022 the murders started again, kicking it off by hurting Tara and Riley. Billy was once again the first suspect but after a few questions he was free to leave and he was actively helping to find the killers. Though, he had proven more than once that he had been staying on the right path, it seemed like people were still lacking trust in him and so he was still the number one murder for the group of teens. He decided to keep himself more in the background until he was dragged into the game when he got attacked too. The final showdown at Stu’s former house brought them all back together, even Sam and Tara who were trying to leave again. Billy got knocked out, kept in a little chamber until Richie and Amber had their finale. He was found by Hayley, who freed him after Richie and Amber died.
After these events, Billy decided it was better to finally leave Woodsboro, and start somewhere knew. And so he moved along with Hayley and Riley, just as Sam and Tara and her group of friends to New York City. That’s where the story continues...
Verse Four - ghost ( inspired by the ahs murder house )
In this verse, Billy is a ghost. After he dies, his spirit remains in Stu’s house along with the rest of the people he and Stu killed there. He can be seen by those he want to be seen and inside the walls of the Woodsboro Murder House he’s able to kill everyone who’s trying to buy the house. On Halloween nights, his spirit is allowed to be seen by everyone and he’s able to continue living his life as a 16 year old teen and leave the house for the entire night. During this special night, he does let out his anger on innocent people, killing them and continuing the legacy he wanted to built as a living person.
